Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • section 2(14) of the I.T. Act, 1961. 4
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • section 2(14) of the I.T. Act, 1961. 4

    Sandesh Ramrao Patil,, Satara v. Tax Recovery Officer,,

    IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL

    SMC BENCH, PUNE

    ी आर. के. पांडा, लेखा सदय के सम

    BEFORE SHRI R.K. PANDA, AM

    आयकर अपील सं. / ITA No.710/PN/2016 नधारण वष / Assessment Year : 2007-08

    Shri Sachin Ramrao Patil Saidapur, Karad

    Dist. Satara-415110

    PAN :AALHS5136M

    ………. अपीलाथ / Appellant

    बनाम v/s

    Tax Recovery Officer, Satara ………. यथ /

    Respondent

    आयकर अपील सं. / ITA No.711/PN/2016 नधारण वष / Assessment Year : 2007-08

    Shri Sanjay Ramrao Patil Saidapur, Karad

    Dist. Satara-415110

    PAN :AALHP5137L

    ………. अपीलाथ / Appellant

    बनाम v/s

    Tax Recovery Officer, Satara ………. यथ /

    Respondent

    आयकर अपील सं. / ITA No.712/PN/2016 नधारण वष / Assessment Year : 2007-08

    Shri Sandesh Ramrao Patil Saidapur, Karad

    Dist. Satara-415110

    PAN :AALHP5138F

    ………. अपीलाथ / Appellant

    बनाम v/s

    Tax Recovery Officer, Satara ………. यथ /

    Respondent

    अपीलाथ क ओर से / Appellant by : Shri M.K. Kulkarni यथ क ओर से / Respondent by : Shri Hitendra Ninawe सनुवाई क तार ख /

    Date of Hearing :20.09.2016 घोषणा क तार ख /

    Date of Pronouncement: 21 .09.2016

    1

    2

    आदेश / ORDER

    PER R.K.PANDA, AM :

    The above three appeals filed by the respective assessees are directed against the separate orders dated 04-01-2016 of the CIT(A)- 2, Pune relating to A.Y. 2007-08.

    2. Although a number of grounds have been taken by the respective assessees they all relate to the order of the CIT(A) in confirming the taxation of long term capital gain of Rs.12,35,688/-in each appeal.

    3. First we take up ITA No.710/PN/2016 in the case of Shri Sachin Ramrao Patil as the lead case. Facts of the case, in brief, are that the assessee belongs to an agriculturist family residing in the village Saidapur in Karad Taluq. The ancestral agricultural land in HUF capacity was cultivated by him jointly with his other two brothers namely Shri Sandesh R. Patil and Shri Sanjay R. Patil and mother Smt. Sharadabai R. Patil. There was no source of income other than agriculture. In this case, information was received from DIT (CIB) Pune that the assessee has deposited cash of Rs.13,95,500/- in his savings account maintained with the Karad Urban Cooperative Bank during F.Y. 2006-07. On enquiry it was revealed that assessee and his two brothers namely Shri Sandesh R. Patil and Shri Sanjay R. Patil had executed the development agreement in favour of M/s. Ashtabhuja Builders Pvt. Ltd. for development of land for a consideration of Rs. 52,55,000/-. This agreement was registered in the office of the Sub-Registrar, Karad at Sl.No.1065. It was also noticed that every brother is 1/3rdowner of the land under consideration. The land is situated at Saidapur

    3

    which is under the Gram Panchayar area. The total area of the land is 1H 55R. Initially this was an agricultural land but converted into non-agricultural land vide order No.NA/SR/19/2007 dated 14-07- 2006 passed by Sub Divisional Officer, Karad. As per 1/3rdshare each brother has received Rs.17,51,766/- out of the total sale consideration. Since the assessee has not filed return u/s.139(1) the AO had reason to believe that long term capital gain has escaped from assessment for A.Y. 2007-08. Accordingly, the AO issued notice u/s.148 on 23-11-2010 which was served on the assessee on 25-11- 2010. Subsequently, the AO completed the assessment u/s.143 r.w.s. 147 dated 29-12-2011 determining the total income of the assessee at Rs.7,02,355/-.

    4. Before CIT(A) the assessee submitted that no capital gain arose to the assessee since the agricultural land was converted into non-agricultural land vide statutory permission dated 10-07-2006. This otherwise means that the agricultural land was converted into capital asset only on 10-07-2006. Therefore, the cost of acquisition of the non-agricultural land/capital asset was the same as receivable on development agreement. Thus, there was no difference in the cost of acquisition and sale/transfer thereof. Referring to the decision of Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of CIT Vs. Gurucharan Singh reported in 292 ITR 387 and the decision in the case of CIT Vs. Hoshnak Singh reported in 292 ITR 390 it was argued that the cost of acquisition would have to be taken as the price of the land on the date on which the agricultural land was deemed to be a capital asset within the meaning of section 2(14) of the I.T. Act, 1961.

    4

    5. It was argued that in the instant case the cost of acquisition of the capital asset deemed to be so on the conversion of agricultural land into non-agricultural land/capital asset, the cost of acquisition would be deemed to be the price of the land that is Rs.78,75,000/-. Since this is the cost of acquisition therefore there is no difference between the value of the land transferred and the cost of acquisition deemed to be of the capital asset on conversion of agricultural land to non-agricultural land. No capital gain is taxable u/s.45 of the I.T. Act. The assessee accordingly argued before the CIT(A) challenging the validity of the reassessment proceedings as well as the computation of capital gain.

    6. In appeal the Ld.CIT(A) upheld the validity of reassessment proceedings. He also upheld the action of the AO in bringing to tax the long term capital gain of Rs.7,02,355/-. He, however, has not decided the issue as to whether the date on which cost of acquisition is to be calculated should be the cost on the date of acquisition of the land or the cost on the date from which the agricultural land has been deemed to be capital asset within the meaning of section 2(14) for the purpose of capital gain.

    7. Aggrieved with such order of the CIT(A) the assessee is in appeal before the Tribunal with the following grounds :

    (Without prejudice to each other)

    1. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law the Ld. CIT(A) was not justified in dismissing the appeal of the assessee which decision is contrary to the provisions of law. The order of the Ld. CIT(A) be set aside.

    2. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law the Ld. CIT(A) confirmed the taxation of the Long Term Capital Gain of Rs.12,35,688/- during the year under appeal. The order of the Ld. CIT(A) confirming the order of the A. O. as regards taxation of capital gain being contrary to law be set aside.

    5

    3. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law the Ld. CIT(A) was not justified in confirming the order of the A.O. wherein the capital gain was subjected to tax. The Ld. CIT(A) ought to have considered the legal position when the case of the assessee was covered by S. 45(2) of the Act. The order of the Ld. CIT(A) be set aside to this effect.

    4. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law the Ld. CIT(A) erred in confirming action taken by the A. O. of reopening the assessment under S. 147 of the Act. The facts and legal positions as pleaded the action invoked under S. 147 was illegal and without jurisdiction. The assessment being illegal be quashed.

    5. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law and in view of the fact that no capital gain arose for taxation during the year under appeal. In view of this the assessment of capital gain in the year under appeal was bad in law. The assessment be quashed.

    6. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law the assessment of capital gain as confirmed by CIT(A) in appeal is illegal as there was no difference between the cost of acquisition and the sale consideration. The order of the CIT(A), therefore, be set aside.

    7. The appellant craves to leave, add/amend or alter any of the above grounds of appeal."

    Identical grounds have been taken by the other assessees.

    8. The Ld. Counsel for the assessee submitted that the land in question was an agricultural land situated beyond 8 kms from the municipal limits and there is no dispute to the above fact. The land was converted into non-agricultural land vide statutory permission dated 10-07-2006. Thus, the agricultural land was converted into capital asset on 10-07-2006. Therefore, in view of the decision of Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of CIT Vs. Gurucharan Singh (Supra) the cost of acquisition would have to be taken as the price of the land on which date the agricultural land was deemed to be a capital asset. However, this plea was never raised before the AO. Although it was raised before the CIT(A) he has not dwelt upon this issue. He accordingly submitted that the

    6

    matter may be decided in favour of the assessee or alternatively it may be set aside to the file of the AO.

    9. The Ld. Departmental Representative on the other hand while supporting the order of the CIT(A) submitted that he has no objection if the matter is restored to the file of the AO since the assessee has never raised such plea before the AO and the CIT(A) has also not decided on this issue.

    10. After hearing both the sides, I find the assessee in the instant case has sold agricultural land along with his 2 brothers in the capacity of HUF for a consideration of Rs.52,55,000/-. The AO brought to tax an amount of Rs.7,02,355/- as long term capital gain in the hands of the assessee which has been upheld by the CIT(A). It is the submission of the Ld. Counsel for the assessee that since the agricultural land was converted into non-agricultural land on 10-07-2006, therefore, the cost of acquisition is to be calculated on the date from which the agricultural land has been deemed to be a capital asset within the meaning of section 2(14) of the I.T.Act for the purpose of computation of capital gain. For the above proposition, the assessee has relied upon the decision of Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of CIT Vs. Gurucharan Singh reported in 292 ITR 387. In the above mentioned case, the Tribunal relying upon the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT Vs. Shirinbai K. Kooka reported in 46 ITR 86 has held that the valuation of the agricultural land should be taken on the date when it became a capital asset. The relevant observation of the Hon'ble High court at para 4 and 5 of the order is as under :

    7

    "4. By rejecting the plea of the revenue, the Tribunal relied upon a judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT v. Bai Shirinbai K. Kooka [1962] 46 ITR 86, wherein it was held that where an assessee who held, by way of investment, certain shares in companies, commenced a business in shares converting the share into stock-in- trade of the business, and subsequently sold these shares at a profit, in that eventuality the assessee's assessable profits on sale of the shares was the difference between the sale price of the shares and the market price of the shares prevailing on the date when the shares were converted into stock-in-trade of the business in shares, and not the difference between the sale price and the price at which the shares were originally purchased by the assessee. No judgment taking a contrary view has been cited before us. In the present case also by amendment in the Act, agricultural land became a capital asset on the sale of which capital gain tax became exigible, so applying the principles of law laid down in Bai Shirinbai K. Kooka (supra), the date of valuation of the capital asset will be the date when the agricultural land became capital asset.

    5. In view of our above discussions we are of the view that the Tribunal was right in taking the view that valuation of land should be taken on the date when it became a capital asset."

    11. Although the above decision was cited before the CIT(A), I find the Ld.CIT(A) has not dwelt upon this issue and has not commented upon as to whether the valuation of the capital asset, i.e. the Agricultural land in the instant case, will be the date when the agricultural land became capital asset or the cost on the date of the acquisition of the land. Further, this plea was also not taken by the assessee before the AO during the assessment proceedings. Considering the totality of the facts of the case and in the interest of justice, I deem it proper to restore the issue to the file of the AO with a direction to decide the issue afresh and in accordance with law after giving due opportunity of being heard to the assessee. I hold and direct accordingly. Grounds raised by the assessee are accordingly allowed for statistical purposes.

    12. Identical grounds have been taken by Shri Sanjay R. Patil in ITA No.711/PN/2016 and Shri Sandesh R. Patil in ITA No.712/PN/2016. Since facts are identical, therefore, following the

    8

    reasonings given in ITA No.710/PN/2016 in the case of Shri Sachin R. Patil the grounds raised by the respective assessees are also allowed for statistical purposes.

    13. In the result, all the 3 appeals filed by the respective assessees are allowed for statistical purposes.

    Order pronounced in the open court on 21-09-2016. Sd/-

    (R.K. PANDA)

    ACCOUNTANT MEMBER

    पणेु Pune; दनांक Dated : 21stSeptember, 2016. सतीश

    आदेश क त"ल#प अ$े#षत/Copy of the Order forwarded to :

    आदेशानसुार/ BY ORDER, //स या$पत %त // True Copy // व&र'ठ %नजी स*चव / Sr. Private Secretary आयकर अपील य अ*धकरण, पुणे / ITAT, Pune

    1. अपीलाथ / The Appellant

    2. यथ / The Respondent

    3. The CIT(A)-2, Pune

    4. The CIT-2, Pune

    5. $वभागीय %त%न*ध, आयकर अपील य अ*धकरण, "SMC Bench" पणेु / DR, ITAT, "SMC Bench" Pune;

    6.

    गाड2 फाईल / Guard file.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sandesh Ramrao Patil,, Satara v. Tax Recovery Officer,,
    (Sep 21, 2016)