AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 15A(b) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 (for short the Act).
  • section 15A(b) of 5 the Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 15A(b) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 (for short the Act).
  • section 15A(b) of 5 the Act.
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary: Securities Appellate Tribunal — Appeal No.195 of 2011

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Mr. Jagdish Mansukhani, a member of the Mansukhani family and the managing director of M/s. MAN Industries (India) Limited until 30 September 2011, appealed an adjudicating officer's order of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) imposing a penalty of ₹24 lakhs under section 15A(b) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 for alleged violation of Regulation 13 of the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 1992.

SEBI's investigation covered transactions in the company's shares from 1 June 2010 to 30 September 2010 and found that the appellant acquired 47,402 shares on 17 June 2010 and 43,000 shares on 18 June 2010. Regulation 13 required timely disclosure of such acquisitions.

The adjudicating officer found that the appellant did not make the required disclosure within the prescribed period. The appellant claimed he handed Form D to the company's Secretarial department (stating it was filed on 19 June 2010) but produced no acknowledgement; the company denied receipt. The appellant later re-submitted the intimation on 15 July 2010 after an e-mail from the secretarial department dated 14 July 2010.

A show cause notice was issued on 11 May 2011; the appellant replied on 24 May 2011 and gave personal hearing. The adjudicating officer imposed a penalty of ₹24 lakhs. The appeal was decided by the Securities Appellate Tribunal on 26 June 2012.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant failed to make the requisite timely disclosure of share acquisitions as required by Regulation 13 of the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 1992.
  2. Whether the penalty imposed under section 15A(b) of the SEBI Act (₹24 lakhs) was appropriate, and if not, whether the Tribunal should reduce the quantum of penalty in the circumstances of the case.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant acted in good faith and delivered Form D (disclosure) to the company's Secretarial department; the company customarily did not provide acknowledgements for documents handed over by officers.
  • The appellant had previously filed similar disclosures in time following identical practice and there had been no prior complaint.
  • There was a rift among the company's directors; the appellant's loss of position as managing director (powers withdrawn on 19 May 2011) suggested internal discord that might explain the present issue.
  • The adjudicating officer should have further investigated the matter by verifying with company officials and examining other relevant parties to corroborate the appellant's statement; the appellant could not produce documentary proof due to his circumstances.
  • As a mitigating alternative, the appellant requested reduction of the penalty considering previous conduct, strained relations in the company, and the fact that the disclosure was ultimately made (albeit belatedly on 15 July 2010).

Respondent's (SEBI's) Arguments

  • The appellant failed to discharge his onus to prove that the disclosure was made on time; no acknowledgement or affidavit from recipients was produced.
  • There was no evidence of compliance with the requirement to disclose to the stock exchange as envisaged in the Regulations.
  • The adjudicating officer's approach was correct: the appellant's unproven assertions could not be accepted without supporting evidence, and no request for cross-examination of involved parties was made.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal proceeded by applying the regulatory duty and basic evidential principles set out in the opinion:

  1. The factual basis that the appellant acquired 47,402 shares on 17 June 2010 and 43,000 shares on 18 June 2010 was undisputed; as a director/officer he was obliged to disclose the acquisitions under Regulation 13.
  2. The appellant asserted having handed the requisite Form D to the company's Secretarial department in time, but he could not produce any acknowledgement or documentary evidence of having done so; the company denied receipt of the disclosure on the stated date.
  3. The Tribunal emphasized the foundational evidentiary principle that a person who makes a factual assertion bears the onus to prove it. The appellant had not discharged that burden by affidavit, acknowledgement, or other corroborative proof.
  4. The Tribunal rejected the appellant's contention that the adjudicating officer should have obtained corroborative evidence from the company or other parties. The opinion states that a regulator cannot be expected to verify or investigate statements made by a noticee on the noticee's behalf; it is incumbent on the noticee to produce supporting proof.
  5. The absence of any evidence of disclosure to the stock exchange (as required by the Regulations) was an additional shortcoming in the appellant's case, correctly pointed out by SEBI's counsel and considered by the Tribunal.
  6. On the question of penalty quantum, the Tribunal noted that the adjudicating officer appeared to have levied the maximum permissible penalty under section 15A(b) — computed as ₹1 lakh per day for 24 days (total ₹24 lakhs). The Tribunal accepted that the appellant had a prior practice of handing over documents without acknowledgement and that the disclosure was eventually made belatedly (15 July 2010).
  7. Balancing these mitigating factual features (previous conduct of timely disclosures on earlier occasions, the appellant's asserted practice, the belated filing, and strained relations within the company), the Tribunal concluded that the maximum penalty was not warranted and that a reduced penalty would be just and reasonable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Tribunal upheld the adjudicating officer's finding that the appellant violated Regulation 13 of the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 1992 by failing to make the requisite disclosure within the prescribed time.

Core decision on penalty: The Tribunal reduced the penalty imposed under section 15A(b) of the SEBI Act from ₹24 lakhs to ₹5 lakhs, taking into account the specific facts and mitigating circumstances of the case. The appeal was disposed of on that basis with no order as to costs.

Implications: The direct consequence is that the adjudicating officer's finding of violation remains in place but the monetary liability of the appellant is reduced to ₹5 lakhs. The opinion does not state or establish any broader legal precedent or new principle; it resolves the penalty quantum on the particular facts before the Tribunal.

Decision rendered by Members P. K. Malhotra (Presiding Officer, Offg.) and S.S.N. Moorthy on 26 June 2012.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Jagdish Mansukhani v. Securities And Exchange Board Of India

    BEFORE THE SECURITIES APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI Appeal No.195 of 2011 Date of decision: 26.6.2012 Mr. Jagdish Mansukhani Plot No.43, Aadhya, 2 Floor, Road, Lamikant Pyarelal Chowk, JVPD, Juhu, Mumbai 400 056. Appellant Versus Securities and Exchange Board of India SEBI Bhavan, Plot No.C4A, G Block, Bandra Kurla Complex, Bandra (East), Mumbai 400 051. Respondent Mr. Zal Andhyarujina, Advocate with Mr. Adarsh Saxena, Advocate for the Appellant. Mr. Shiraz Rustomjee, Senior Advocate with Mr. Mihir Mody and Mr. Akhilesh Singh, Advocates for the Respondent. CORAM : P. K. Malhotra, Member & Presiding Officer (Offg.) S.S.N. Moorthy, Member Per : S.S.N. Moorthy The appellant belongs to the Mansukhani family which has promoted M/s. MAN Industries (India) Limited (hereinafter referred to as the company) which is engaged in the manufacture of carbon steel line pipe. The appellant was the managing director of the company till September 30, 2011. The present appeal is directed against an order passed by the adjudicating officer of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (for short the Board) imposing a penalty of ` 24 lacs under section 15A(b) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 (for short the Act). The appellant was found to have violated Regulations 13 of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 1992 (referred to hereinafter as the PIT Regulations).

    2. The Board conducted investigation in the transactions in the shares of the company for the period June 01, 2010 to September 30, 2010. The investigation revealed that the appellant had purchased/acquired 47,402 shares on June 17, 2010 and 43,000 shares on June 18, 2010. The provisions of regulation 13 of the PIT Regulations cast a duty on the appellant to make a disclosure of the acquisition within the prescribed time limit. The adjudicating officer found that the required disclosure was not made by the appellant within the prescribed period and so there was violation of regulation 13 of the PIT Regulations. It was contended before the adjudicating officer that the relevant disclosure in form no.D was filed with the company on June 19, 2010. However, the appellant failed to produce any acknowledgement to the above effect while the company denied having received the disclosure details on the said date. The appellant explained to the adjudicating officer that being a director of the company there was no practice of obtaining acknowledgement of documents filed and, therefore, he had passed on the information through his secretary to the Company Secretarial department. With reference to the acquisitions made by the appellant on earlier occasions it was contended that he had followed identical practices on all occasions and he had acted in good faith in handing over the documents of disclosure to the company. According to the appellant, he received an e- mail on July 14, 2010 from the Secretarial department of the company asking for details of the acquisitions made on June 17, 2010 and June 18, 2010. It is stated by the appellant that he resubmitted the intimation regarding acquisition of 90,402 shares to the company on July 15, 2010. A show cause notice was issued on May 11, 2011 calling upon the appellant to show cause as to why enquiry should not be held against him in respect of violation of Regulation 13 of the PIT Regulations. The appellant submitted a written reply on May 24, 2011 which was followed by personal hearing. After due consideration of the submissions made by the appellant the adjudicating officer concluded that the appellant failed to establish that the requisite disclosure was made in time as per the Regulations and consequently penalty of ` 24 lacs was imposed.

    3. Shri Zal Andhyarujina, learned counsel for the appellant, reiterated the contentions raised before the adjudicating officer. According to him, the appellant had acted in good faith in handing over the documents showing the requisite disclosure to the Secretarial department of the company and there was no default on his part. It is submitted that the prevailing practice in the company with regard to furnishing of documents by the officers of the company should be given due regard. There was no practice of obtaining acknowledgement for documents filed and the appellant had followed the same practice in this respect also. The appellants learned counsel stated that the appellant had acquired shares in open market transactions in May, 2010 on various days and there is no complaint from any quarters regarding failure to file the required documents with the company. It is pointed out that there is a rift among the directors of the company and the Board of Directors of the company had withdrawn the appellants powers as a managing director on May 19, 2011 and the present development is a fall out of the aforesaid rift in the company. According to him, the adjudicating officer should have enquired with the company after verifying with the concerned officials in view of the circumstances in which the appellant has been placed. The adjudicating officer should have appreciated the peculiar circumstances of the case and tried to shift the burden to the Board by verifying relevant details and examining relevant parties concerning the truth of the statement made by the appellant. The appellant is placed in a position where he cannot adduce necessary proof in support of his statement and so the adjudicating officer should have gone a step further in examining the truth behind the statements and action of the appellant. According to the appellant, as stated in the grounds of appeal, there is no evidence on record which would establish that the appellant did not make the requisite disclosure to the company.

    4. Learned senior counsel, Shri Shiraz Rustomjee appearing for the Board, submitted that the approach of the appellant is against established principles of law and he failed to provide necessary proof regarding the disclosure by way of affidavit or otherwise from the persons to whom the documents were allegedly handed over. He laid great emphasis on the fact that the appellant has not discharged his onus in proving the statement made by him. In addition, there was no evidence of providing the requisite disclosure to the stock exchange as contained in the provisions of the Regulations. He supported the stand taken by the adjudicating officer holding that the appellant failed in his duty to prove his statement that requisite disclosures were handed over to the company and that there was no request for cross examination of any of the parties involved in the transaction.

    5. We have considered the rival submissions. The fact regarding acquisition of 47,402 shares on June 17, 2010 and 43,000 shares on June 18, 2010 remains undisputed. As a director/officer of the company the appellant was obliged to make the requisite disclosure regarding the acquisition of shares as per regulation 13 of the Regulations. It is the case of the appellant that the relevant disclosure was made in time by handing over the disclosure documents in form D to the Secretarial department of the company. However, the fact remains that he is not in a position to prove the same with the help of acknowledgment or other documentary evidence. The company has denied having received any such disclosure on the said date. It is the fundamental principle of law of evidence that a person making a statement has the onus to prove the same. In the present case, the appellant has failed to discharge this onus. The appellants learned counsel argued at length stating that the adjudicating officer should have examined the statement of the appellant with other corroborating evidence gathered by him. A regulator cannot be expected to examine or verify details from other parties in order to establish a statement made by the noticee before him. The argument of the appellants learned counsel is farfetched and cannot be accepted. It may be true that the appellant had followed the identical practice with regard to submission of documents on earlier occasions also. However, he should have been alert in the present situation, more so, when the relationship among the directors had become sour. Or else, he should have taken steps to file supporting evidence through affidavit or other means. The learned senior counsel for the Board has correctly pointed out that there is no evidence in this case regarding a disclosure to the stock exchange by the appellant as envisaged in the regulations. Since the appellant has failed in the primary duty of proving the case the stand taken by the adjudicating officer cannot be faulted.

    6. During the appeal proceedings, the appellants learned counsel advanced an alternative argument for reducing the quantum of penalty considering the facts and circumstances of the case. According to him, the previous conduct of the appellant, the strained relations in the company and the present predicament of the appellant should be duly considered together and the quantum of penalty should be substantially reduced.

    7. We have considered the arguments advanced by the learned counsel. The issue to be considered is whether a penalty of ` 24 lacs is called for in the circumstances of the case. The penalty appears to have been calculated at the rate of one lakh rupees for each day of delay for a period of 24 days. This is the maximum penalty under section 15A(b) of the Act. Admittedly, the appellant had made disclosures regarding his earlier acquisitions in time. He was said to be in the habit of handing over relevant documents to the Secretarial department of the company without taking acknowledgement. In the present case also it is stated to be the practice followed by him. When he learnt about the failure to make the disclosure the same was made on July 15, 2010 though belatedly. Having regard to the circumstances of the case and to set the matter at rest we hold that a penalty of ` 5 lacs would be just and reasonable in the present case. It is to be observed that the quantum of penalty is reduced having regard to the peculiar facts of the present case. In the result, while upholding the findings recorded by the adjudicating officer, we reduce the penalty to ` 5 lacs. The appeal stands disposed of accordingly with no order as to costs. Sd/- P.K. Malhotra Member & Presiding Officer (Offg.) Sd/- S.S.N. Moorthy Member 26.6.2012 Prepared and compared by

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jagdish Mansukhani v. Securities And Exchange Board Of India
    (Jun 26, 2012)