Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT 1947
  • Section 7, 8, 13 (a) (b), 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 389 and 120-B I.P.C. Police Station Anti Corruption
  • Section 438 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 173(2) Cr.P.C.
  • Section 482 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 7, 8, 13 (1) (d), 13(2) Prevention of Corruption Act and Section 389, 120-B I.P.C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT 1947
  • Section 7, 8, 13 (a) (b), 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 389 and 120-B I.P.C. Police Station Anti Corruption
  • Section 438 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 173(2) Cr.P.C.
  • Section 482 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 7, 8, 13 (1) (d), 13(2) Prevention of Corruption Act and Section 389, 120-B I.P.C.

    JODHA RAM GURJAR v. STATE OF RAJASTHAN THROUGH PP

    S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition No. 1445/2016 Jodha Ram Gurjar S/o Shri Shyoji Ram, by caste Gurjar, R/o Village Roopaheli, P.S. Lamba Harisingh, Tehsil Malpura, Distt. Tonk, at present 425-A, Shrinathpuram, Kota.

    Accused- Petitioner...

    VERSUS State of Rajasthan through P.P.

    Respondent...

    DATE OF ORDER ::: 10th November, 2016 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BANWARI LAL SHARMA Mr. S.R. Surana, Sr. counsel with Mr. Rajeev Surana for the Petitioner.

    Mr. B.N. Sandhu, AAG, for the respondent.

    In the matter of State of Madhya Pradesh vs. Shri Ram Singh reported in AIR 2000 SC 870 whereby in the year 2000 Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that :-

    Corruption in a civilised society is a disease like cancer, which if not detected in time is sure to maliganise the polity of country leading to disastrous consequences. It is termed as plague which is not only contagious but if not controlled spreads like a fire in a jungle. Its virus is compared with HIV leading to AIDS, being incurable. It has also been 2termed as Royal thievery. The socio-political system exposed to such a dreaded communicable disease is likely to crumble under its own weight. Corruption is opposed to democracy and social order, being not only anti people, but aimed and targeted against them. It affects the economy and destroys the cultural heritage.

    Unless nipped in the bud at the earliest, it is likely to cause turbulence shaking of the socio-economic- political system in an otherwise healthy, wealthy, effective and vibrating society.

    The menace of corruption was found to have enormously increased by first and second world war conditions. The corruption, at the initial stages, was considered confined to the bureaucracy who had the opportunities to deal with a variety of State largesse in the form of contracts, licences and grants.

    Even after the war the opportunities for corruption continued as large amounts of Government surplus stores were required to be disposed of by the public servants. As consequence of the wars the shortage of various goods necessitated the imposition of controls and extensive schemes of post-war reconstruction involving the disbursement of huge sums of money which lay in the control of the public servants giving them wide discretion with the result of luring them to the glittering shine of the wealth and property. In order to consolidate and amend the laws relating to prevention of corruption and matters connected 3thereto, the Prevention of Corruption Act 1947 was enacted which was amended from time to time. In the year 1988 a new Act on the subject being Act No.49 of 1988 was enacted with the object of dealing with the circumstances, contingencies and shortcomings which were noticed in the working and implementation of 1947 Act. The law relating to prevention of corruption was essentially made to deal with the public servants, as understood in the common parlance but specifically defined in the Act.

    The Act was intended to make effective provision for the prevention of bribe and corruption rampant amongst the public servants. It is a social legislation defined to curb illegal activities of the public servants and is designed to be liberally construed so as to advance its object. Dealing with the object underlying the Act this Court in R.S Nayak v. A.R Antulay ., [1984 (2) SCC 183] held: The 1947 Act was enacted, as its long ltitle shows, to make more effective provision for the prevention of bribery and corruption.

    Indisputably, therefore, the provisions of the Act must receive such construction at the hands of the Court as would advance the object and purpose underlying the Act and at any rate not defeat it. If the words of the Statute are clear and unambiguous, it is the plainest duty of the court to give effect to the natural meaning of the words used in the provision. The question of construction arises only in the event of an ambiguity or 4the plain meaning of the words used in the statute would be self-defeating. The court is entitled to ascertain the intention of the Legislature to remove the ambiguity by construing the provision of the Statute as a whole keeping in view what was the mischief when the Statute was enacted and to remove which the Legislature enacted the Statute. The rule of construction is so universally accepted that it need not be supported by precedents. Adopting this rule of construction, whenever a question of construction arises upon ambiguity or where two views are possible of a provision, it would be the duty of the Court to adopt that construction which would advance the object underlying the Act, namely, to make effective provision for the prevention of bribery and corruption and at any rate not defeat it. Here in the case in hand this is third round of petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. initially petitioner Jodha Ram Gurjar the then SHO who was at a relevant time posted as SHO, P.S. Modak District Kota filed S.B. Criminal Misc.

    Petition No. 124/2015 before this court wherein it was prayed that F.I.R. No. 293/2014 registered at Principal Police Station Bureau of Anti Corruption, Jaipur, ACB, Choki Kota for offence under Section 7, 8, 13 (1) (d), 13(2) Prevention of Corruption Act and Section 389, 120-B I.P.C. and all consequences of investigation proceedings there off may be 5quashed. The same was dismissed as withdrawn by the Co- ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 13.05.2015.

    Thereafter another S.B. Criminal Writ Petition No.

    174/2015 was filed by the petitioner Jodha Ram Gurjar wherein it was prayed that Writ of certiorari or any other writ like nature declaring the FIR No. 293/2014 dated 23.08.2014, under Section 7, 8, 13 (a) (b), 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 389 and 120-B I.P.C. Police Station Anti Corruption Bureau, Jaipur, Chowki Kota Rajasthan as unconstitutional and amounting to depriving the right of liberty guaranteed under Article 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India and restraining the respondent-State for taking any coercive steps against the petitioner which was dismissed by the Coordinate bench of this Court vide order dated 31st July, 2015 with cost of Rs.

    2000/- to be deposited with Rajasthan State Legal Services Authority and anticipatory bail application was also filed by the petitioner under Section 438 Cr.P.C, which was also dismissed by the Coordinate Bench of this Court.

    Now this is third petition wherein petitioner- accused prayed that Investigation agency may be directed to investigate this matter in fair and unbiased manner and without any delay. Conclusion of the investigation be done in a fair, proper and unbiased manner within a period of 2 6months.

    It was also prayed that the progress report of the aforesaid matter be called from the Investigating Officer, Additional Superintendent of Police, Anti-Corruption Bureau, Chittorgarh Shri Chirangilal, and direction be given for fair, proper and unbiased investigation.

    During pendency of this petition, an application being I.A. No. 10399/2016 was also filed by the petitioner wherein it was prayed that public prosecutor be directed to produce progress report and conclusion of the Investigating Officer namely Sh. Bhupendra Singh Chudawat be placed before this Court for perusal and necessary direction after perusal be given for fair and proper investigation in the present FIR by an independent Agency.

    The another application being I.A. No.

    14363/2016 was also filed by the petitioner wherein it was prayed that additional documents may be considered as part and parcel of the petition and the same may be considered at the time of hearing of the petition.

    Though matter is listed on Interim application on orders but with the consent of Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner Mr. S.R. Surana and Learned Additional Advocate General Mr. BN Sandhu matter is heard finally.

    The brief facts of the case are that complainant 7Bhagwati Prasad @ Vikram submitted a written report on 21.08.2014 before Shri Devendra Kumar Sharma, Additional Superintendent of Police, Anti Corruption Bureau, Kota stating therein that :- ^^eS a Hkxorh izlkn mQZ fodze iq= Jh tk s jkjke mez 36 lky] tkfr fo'uk s b Z] fuoklh tk s /kiqj dk jgu s okyk g w a A ljdkjh Mk s Mk ik s LV d s ykbZl s a l /kkjh vjfoUn iq= Jh guqeku izlkn mik/;k; d s le w g Vk s a d ] HkhyokMk] dk s Vk] c w a n h] NhikcMkSn] ck a jk] >kykokM] Hkokuhe a Mh] jkex at e.Mh dk gSA mUgk s a u s eq> s bl le w g dh n s [kj s [k dh ftEe s nkjh dk dke lkS a i j[kk gSA bl le w g dk i w j k ftEek eS a gh n s [krk g w a o xk s nke Hkokuhe.Mh l s Vk s a d ] n s oyh tku s oky s Mk s Mk ik s Lr dk ifjogu dk ftEek Hkh eS a n s [krk g w a A fnuk a d 08-08- 2014 dk s Mk s Mk ik s Lr dh xkMh vkj-t s - 19&th-lh-&2955 tk s ijfeV'kqnk Hkokuhe.Mh xk s nke l s Vk s a d jk s M d s fy, jokuk dh Fkh] ftl xkMh dk s dk s Vk fty s d s Fkkuk ek s Md Fkkuk bykdk e s a

    Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that initially the matter was investigated by Sh. Bhupendra Singh Chudawat, Additional Superintendent of Police, Anti- Corruption Bureau, Chittorgarh who reached on the conclusion that no offence is made out against the present petitioner and he proposed negative final report in regard to the petitioner but now Investigating agency after concealing the material collected by Sh. Bhupendra Singh Chudawat during his investigation wants to file chargesheet against the present petitioner in false and fabricated case, therefore Investigating agency may be directed to conduct fair, impartial and unbiased investigation in this matter and submit their report under Section 173(2) Cr.P.C.

    expeditiously preferrably within 2 months.

    Learned Counsel relied on Pooja Pal Vs Union of 9India reported in 2016 CrI.L.J. 2038.

    Per contra Learned Additional Advocate General Mr. B.N. Sandhu submits that intially matter was investigated by Mr. Neeraj Gupta, Inspector from 28.08.2014 to 24.09.2014. After investigation he found that allegations against the petitioner and co-accused Vinod Pareta are proved. Thereafter due to transfer of Shri Gupta the investigation was handed over to Sh. Ramniwas who also endorsed the finding of previous Investigating officer Mr. Neeraj Gupta. The investigation remained with Mr.

    Ramniwas from 28.09.2014 to 28.07.2015.

    Thereafter investigation was handed over to Sh.

    Bhupendra Singh Chudawat, Additional Superintendent of Police, Anti-Corruption Bureau, Chittorgarh where the investigation remained from 28.07.2015 to 23.09.2015. He only verified the previous investigation, but did not investigate the matter. Thereafter from 05.11.2015, the matter is with Mr. Chirangilal Meena, Additional Superintendent of Police, Anti-Corruption Bureau, Chittorgarh.

    He submits that when the investigation was pending before Sh. Bhupendra Singh Chudawat, Additional Superintendent of Police, Anti-Corruption Bureau, Chittorgarh, he apprised to Additional Superintendent of Police, Anti-Corruption Bureau, (Crime Branch), ACD, Rajasthan, Jaipur vide his letter dated 02.09.2015 that accused of this case Mr. Jodha Ram Gurjar, Sub Inspector was in subordination with him at Kota (Rural) therefore it will be better to get the matter investigated by some another outpost on which Mr. V.K. Singh, the then Inspector General of Police, ACB noticed that petitioner/accused since very long had been trying to influence ACB to hand over this case to Sh. Bhupendra Singh Chudawat and this fact is in knowledge of other officers who are looking after this case, therefore irrespective of merit any action of his part will also be looked suspicious and thereafter investigation was withdrawn from Sh. Bhupendra Singh Chudawat and was transferred.

    He submits that in this matter complainant from beginning clearly alleged that he has paid a substantial amount to petitioner as bribe and again petitioner is demanding for the same and also wants monthly amount.

    He submits that still chargesheet has not been filed against the petitioner, two petitions have already been dismissed by this Court and his anticipatory bail application has also been dismissed. Petitioner again and again filing frivolous applications and petitions just to delay the matter. At the stage of investigation Court has no power to direct the Investigating Agency to investigate the matter in a particular manner, it is the preroragative of the Investigating Officer and statutory right of the police that how the matter should be investigated. If there is any lacuna in investigation then same can be pointed out or raised by the aggrieved person during trial before the Trial Court. During investigation accused cannot interfere in investigation and can't direct the Investigating agency for investigation in a particular manner as he wishes. Therefore this misc. petition may be dismissed with heavy cost.

    In rebuttal Learned Senior Counsel Mr. S.R.

    Surana submits that Investigating Officer is required to conduct fair, impartial and unbiased investigation. He submits that petitioner/accused is implicated in this matter on the basis of telephonic conversation and as per allegation incident took place on 08.08.2014 and report was submitted on 22.08.2014 and facts have already been verified on 08.08.2014 by Mr. Soni, Inspector of Narcotics and at that time the presence of complainant was missing. He has no nexus with Mr. Arvind Upadhyay, licencee holder he is also not employee of Mr. Arvind Upadhyay, licencee holder of contra-band and Bhagwati Prasad, complainant fabricated the documents and submitted false report with false allegations.

    It also reveals that at the time of talks the tap record was got off. The currency notes were found in the possession of Mr. Sachin Jain who has not been arrested in this matter and also evidence are manufactured and fabricated and petitioner was present at the place of incident or near by, the currency notes were not recovered from his possession and allegations of Learned AAG regarding pressurizing by the petitioner to hand over the investigation to Sh. Bhupendra Singh Chudawat or any other officer are false and baseless. Not only this petitioner never made any application for changing the Investigating Officer. Material witness Arvind Upadhyay and Narpat Singh licence holders and Gagan Narayan licence holder's Manager and Saiyad Bhai Mev who was present at Mev Transport Company, Dabok, Subhash driver have not been examined by the Investigating Agency. Not only this Investigating agency also didn't verify the location of mobile tower by which mobile talks could have been verified.

    He further submits that it is true that two petitions have already been dismissed by this Court but in this petition, petitioner prayed for fair, impartial and unbiased investigation which is his fundamental right. He also submits that since available material was not sufficient with the Investigating Agency therefore the investigation qua petitioner was kept pending. Now without collecting any material Investigating Agency wants to file chargesheet which is not permitted and the case law cited by the respondent State of Madhya Pradesh vs. Shri Ram Singh (supra) also doesn't say that petitioner cannot move for fair, impartial and unbiased investigation.

    He submits that even after filing charge sheet Court can order for re-investigation or for further investigation in appropriate case.

    I have considered the submissions made by Learned counsel for the petitioner and Learned AAG for the respondent and perused the available record.

    Since earlier two petitions have already been filed by the petitioner for quashing FIR, out of them one was withdrawn and second was dismissed with cost of Rs.

    2000/-. Now again without changed circumstances before filing chargesheet against the present petitioner, this third petition is filed.

    In Pooja Pal Vs Union of India (supra) Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that:- Criminal investigation is a lawful search for people and things useful in reconstructing the circumstances of an illegal act or omission and the mental state accompanying it. It is probing from the known to the unknown, backward in time, and its goal is to determine truth as far as it can be discovered in any post- factum inquiry.

    Successful investigations are based on fidelity, accuracy, and sincerity in lawfully searching for the true facts of an event under investigation and on an equal faithfulness, exactness, and probity in reporting the results of an investigation.

    Modern investigators are persons who stick to the truth and are absolutely clear about the time and place of an event and the measurable aspects of evidence. They work throughout their investigation fully recognizing that even a minor contradiction or error may destroy confidence in their investigation.

    which is not disputed.

    In the aforesaid case there was death of sitting MLA of Uttar Pradesh State Assembly wherein the widow of deceased MLA filed a petition before the Hon'ble Supreme Court questioning the investigation after filing chargesheet which was allowed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and investigation was handed over to CBI even after filing chargesheet, therefore the facts of that case are distinguishable from the case in hand. As in the case in hand no chargesheet is filed yet against the present petitioner.

    What material will be filed with the chargesheet against the present petitioner can be looked after filing of the chargesheet only.

    At the stage of investigation accused cannot direct the Investigating agency in what manner they have to get investigate the matter. From the arguments advanced by Learned Counsel for the petitioner, it reveals that there is not a single allegation against any of the Investigating officer or complainant regarding biasness. The allegations levelled are only that particular evidence which he suggests has not been recorded or taken on record. It has already been said that accused has no right to direct the Investigating Officer to record the particular evidence. It is exclusive domain of Investigating agency. Not only this in earlier petitions, petitioner has already raised these facts before this Court, therefore this third petition is nothing but mis-use of the procedure of the Court, as such there is no merit in this third misc. petition and the same is dismissed.

    Both applications also stand disposed of.

    [BANWARI LAL SHARMA], J.

    Simple Kumawat/114

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    JODHA RAM GURJAR v. STATE OF RAJASTHAN THROUGH PP
    (Nov 10, 2016)