Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 10(2) of the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Rules (hereinafter referred to as VAT Rules), read with Section 19
  • section 19(1) of the TNVAT Act, 2006
  • Section 19(15) of the VAT Act, 2006,
  • Section 39(15) of the VAT Act, 2006,
  • Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963,
  • Section 17 of the VAT Act, 2006,
  • Section 19(15) of the VAT Act,
  • Bombay Sales Tax Act, 1951,
  • Section 19(16) of Act, 2006,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 10(2) of the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Rules (hereinafter referred to as VAT Rules), read with Section 19
  • section 19(1) of the TNVAT Act, 2006
  • Section 19(15) of the VAT Act, 2006,
  • Section 39(15) of the VAT Act, 2006,
  • Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963,
  • Section 17 of the VAT Act, 2006,
  • Section 19(15) of the VAT Act,
  • Bombay Sales Tax Act, 1951,
  • Section 19(16) of Act, 2006,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by S. Manikumar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Revenue filed multiple writ appeals under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent against a common order dated 20.04.2015 in W.P. Nos. 11404 to 11407 of 2015 (and related matters). The common controversy in those appeals was the correctness of writ-court orders that set aside assessment orders which had reversed input tax credits availed by purchasing dealers. The reversal followed cancellation of the selling dealers' Registration Certificates with retrospective effect by the Commercial Tax Department. The purchasing dealers (respondents in most appeals) had purchased goods when the sellers' registration certificates were in force and had availed input tax credit; they challenged the reversal by filing writ petitions seeking certiorari.

The writ court, relying on the Supreme Court's decision in State of Maharashtra v. Suresh Trading Co. (1998) 109 STC 439 (SC) and a decision of this Court in Jinsasan Distributors v. Commercial Tax Officer (2013) 59 VST 256 (Mad), allowed the writ petitions and set aside the impugned proceedings. The Revenue appealed those orders by filing writ appeals (e.g., W.A. Nos. 946/2016 to 949/2016). One particular writ appeal, W.A. No. 753/2016, was argued separately; it related to W.P. No. 5173 of 2015 (order dated 03.03.2015) which quashed the cancellation of the Registration Certificate of M/s. Vijayshree Metals with retrospective effect and directed re-activation of the certificate. The Assistant Commissioner (CT) filed W.A. No. 753/2016 challenging that writ-court order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether cancellation of a selling dealer's Registration Certificate with retrospective effect entitles the Department to reverse input-tax credit already availed by purchasing dealers who purchased when the seller's registration was in force.
  2. Whether the appellate court should decide the separate question of whether the competent authority has the power to cancel, modify or amend a Registration Certificate retrospectively (the court in this opinion expressly declined to decide this broader question in these appeals).

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue (Appellant) — represented by the Additional Government Pleader (Taxes)

  • The VAT Act and Rules constitute a comprehensive scheme for tax collection and preventing evasion; input tax credit availed by a registered dealer is provisional (reliance on Section 19(16) of the TNVAT Act, 2006) and can be revoked by the Assessing Authority if it appears incorrect, incomplete or not in order.
  • Section 19(15) requires that where a selling dealer's registration certificate is cancelled, the purchasing dealer who had availed input tax credit shall pay the amount availed from the effective date of cancellation and will be liable for interest at two percent per month for the relevant period.
  • The authority granting registration has the power under Sections 39(14) and 39(15) to cancel, modify or amend registration certificates, subject to giving the dealer an opportunity to be heard.
  • The burden of proving a claim of input tax credit lies on the dealer (reliance on Section 17 of the VAT Act, 2006).
  • Assessment authorities acted within statutory provisions and in the interest of Revenue in reversing input credits when sellers' registrations were cancelled.

Respondents / Purchasing Dealers

  • Purchasing dealers contended that, having complied with Rule 10(2) of the TNVAT Rules read with Section 19 of the VAT Act, their claim to input credit should not be denied merely because the sellers' Registration Certificates were cancelled with retrospective effect.
  • They relied on the Supreme Court decision in State of Maharashtra v. Suresh Trading Co. (1998) 109 STC 439 (SC) and decisions of this Court (including Jinsasan Distributors) to assert that purchasing dealers who acted on a valid registration certificate cannot be prejudiced by retrospective cancellation of a seller's registration.
  • In at least one appeal (counsel for respondents in W.A. No. 1051/2016), reliance was also placed on a Kerala High Court decision (Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax v. Debi Prasad Shyam Sunder & Sons, 82 STC 305) that supports the principle that subsequent retrospective cancellation cannot adversely affect buyers who dealt when the sellers' certificates were valid.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Maharashtra Through The Secretary v. Suresh Trading Company, (1998) 109 STC 439 (SC) The principle that a purchasing dealer is entitled to rely upon the selling dealer's certificate of registration and that retrospective cancellation of the seller's registration cannot affect a person who acted on the strength of a valid registration certificate when it was current. The court applied this Supreme Court precedent as the principal authoritative rule determining that reversal of input-tax credit on the ground of retrospective cancellation of the seller's registration cannot be countenanced. It formed the basis for allowing writ petitions that had set aside reversals.
Jinsasan Distributors v. Commercial Tax Officer (CT), Chintadripet Assessment Circle, (2013) 59 VST 256 (Mad) This Court's decision was cited as covering the issue in favour of petitioners (i.e., supporting buyers who relied on sellers' registration certificates). The writ court relied on this decision in ordering relief to purchasing dealers; this court referred to it and treated it as squarely applicable to several matters before it.
Althaf Shoes (P) Ltd., reported in 50 VST 179 The opinion references this decision of this Court but does not specify in detail the exact rule or principle taken from it in the provided text. Referenced among decisions of this Court relied on by respondents; the opinion does not elaborate further on its application.
Sri. Vinayaga Agencies, reported in 60 VST 283 The opinion references this decision of this Court but does not specify the precise principle cited in the provided text. Referenced by respondents as among decisions supporting their position; the opinion does not elaborate further on how it was applied.
Aassan Global Trade (W.P. Nos. 25996 to 25998 of 2014) The opinion references this writ matter but does not state a distinct legal principle from it in the provided text. Listed among precedents/decisions relied on by respondents; no further detail on application is given in the text.
Infiniti Wholesale Limited (W.P. No. 9265 of 2013) The opinion references this writ matter but does not specify the rule or principle drawn from it in the provided text. Referenced by respondents; the opinion does not give further detail as to its application.
Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax (Law), Board of Revenue (Taxes), Ernakulam v. Debi Prasad Shyam Sunder & Sons, 82 STC 305 (Kerala High Court) The principle that subsequent retrospective cancellation of registration cannot adversely affect a purchasing dealer who had a valid certificate on the day the transaction occurred; the purchasing dealer is entitled to the exemption claimed. The court noted and relied on this decision as supporting the view taken in Suresh Trading Co. that buyers acting on valid registrations should not be prejudiced by later retrospective cancellations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by identifying the narrow legal scope of the appeals: they were confined to the correctness of reversal of input credits availed by purchasing dealers consequent to retrospective cancellation of sellers' Registration Certificates. The court extracted and considered relevant statutory provisions (as they appear in the opinion):

  • Section 19(15) and Section 19(16) of the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006 (on reversal of input credit and provisional nature of credit respectively).
  • Sections 39(14) and 39(15) (powers of authority granting registration to cancel/modify/amend registration and requirement to give opportunity to be heard).
  • Section 17 (burden of proof for assessment and for claim of input tax credit).

The court acknowledged the Revenue's argument that input tax credit is provisional and that statutory provisions empower revocation of such provisional credits and may require a purchasing dealer to repay credits (with interest) if the seller's registration is cancelled. The Revenue also emphasized that the authority to cancel registration exists and assessment actions were taken based on statutory powers.

However, rather than resolving the separate and broader question whether the registering authority may cancel a registration certificate retrospectively, the court limited itself to the specific issue before it: whether reversal of input credit on account of retrospective cancellation could be sustained against purchasing dealers who purchased while the seller's registration was valid.

Applying the Supreme Court's ruling in State of Maharashtra v. Suresh Trading Co. and this Court's decision in Jinsasan Distributors (and noting the Kerala High Court's decision in Debi Prasad Shyam Sunder & Sons), the court reasoned as follows:

  • The Supreme Court held that a purchasing dealer is entitled to rely on the seller's certificate of registration and that retrospective cancellation of the seller's registration cannot affect a person who acted upon the strength of that certificate when it was current.
  • The High Court and subsequent authorities had found that if the purchaser fulfilled the condition precedent (i.e., purchased from a registered dealer and obtained the necessary certificate), the purchaser's right to a tax-free re-sale accrues and cannot be taken away by later events (such as cancellation with retrospective effect) affecting the seller.
  • The court therefore concluded that reversal of input-tax credit on the ground that the seller's registration was cancelled retrospectively could not be countenanced under the law as explained in Suresh Trading Co. and related authorities.

On procedural fairness, in W.A. No. 753/2016 (challenging the writ-court order in W.P. No. 5173 of 2015), the court observed that the appellant (the department) had not been afforded an opportunity to file a counter-affidavit to the supporting affidavit before the writ court. The court therefore found that the writ-court order required interference on procedural grounds and remanded the matter to permit the department to file a counter-affidavit and for the writ court to reconsider the matter.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • All writ appeals challenging the reversal of input tax credit (those arising from W.P. Nos. 11404 to 11407 of 2015 and similar matters) were dismissed. In effect, the appellate court upheld the principle, as stated by the Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra v. Suresh Trading Co. and followed by this Court, that reversal of input credit on the ground of retrospective cancellation of a selling dealer's registration cannot be sustained against a purchasing dealer who purchased while the seller's registration certificate was in force.
  • W.A. No. 753 of 2016: The court set aside the writ-court order in W.P. No. 5173 of 2015 (dated 03.03.2015) on procedural grounds because the department was not given an opportunity to file a counter-affidavit, and remanded the matter to the writ court with liberty to the department to file a counter-affidavit. No costs were imposed in relation to this direction.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: Purchasing dealers who acted on the strength of a selling dealer's registration certificate while it was valid are protected from reversal of input-tax credit merely because the seller's registration certificate was later cancelled with retrospective effect. The Revenue's appeals against writ-court orders granting such protection were dismissed.
  • Procedural implication: Where a writ court sets aside a cancellation order (involving retrospective effect) without giving the department an opportunity to file a counter-affidavit, the appellate court may set aside that writ-court order and remit the matter for reconsideration after permitting the department to respond.
  • Precedential scope: The court applied existing authorities (notably State of Maharashtra v. Suresh Trading Co. and Jinsasan Distributors). The opinion explicitly refrained from deciding the separate substantive question of whether the registering authority may exercise retrospective cancellation power; therefore no new legal proposition on the retrospective cancellation power was laid down beyond the narrow ruling protecting purchasers' input-credit rights where they acted on a current certificate.

Note: Costs were generally not awarded in the matters described; connected miscellaneous petitions were closed in the dispositions recorded.

    Assistant Commissioner v. Bhairav Trading Company

    Prayer: Writ Appeal filed under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent, against the common order, dated 20.04.2015 made in W.P No. 11404 of 2015 etc.

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    S. Manikumar, J.:— Common issue in all the writ appeals filed by the Revenue is to the correctness of the orders passed by the writ court in setting aside the assessment orders passed by the competent authorities. As facts and law involved in all the writ appeals except W.A No. 753/2016, are common, they are being dispsoed of by this common judgment, and W.A No. 753/2016, is separately dealt with.

    2. In view of the above, suffice to incorporate the averments and grounds of challenge from one appeal. Respondents in all the appeals, except W.A No. 753/2016, are the buying dealers, who have purchased goods from the selling dealers, whose Registration Certificates, have been cancelled by the Commercial Tax Department with retrospective effect. Consequently, input tax credits availed by the buying dealers for the purchases made, during the period, when the Registration Certificates of the selling dealers were in force, were reversed, which resulted in filing of the writ petitions, by the assessees for a writ of certiorari, to call for the proceedings of the Assessing Officers, contending inter alia that the said proceedings, are contrary to the principles of natural justice and the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary v. Suresh Trading Company reported in 109 STC 439, decisions of this court in Jinsasan Distributors v. Commercial Tax Officer (CT), Chintadripet Assessment Circle reported in 59 VST 256, Althaf Shoes (P) Ltd. reported in 50 VST 179, Sri. Vinayaga Agencies reported in 60 VST 283, Aassan Global Trade in W.P Nos. 25996 to 25998 of 2014 and also in the case of Infiniti Wholesale Limited in W.P No. 9265 of 2013 respectively.

    3. Before the writ court, contention has also been made that, so long as the purchasing dealers have complied with the requirements of Rule 10(2) of the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Rules (hereinafter referred to as VAT Rules), read with Section 19 of the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax, 2006 (hereinafter referrred to as VAT Act), the claim of the purchasing dealers to avail input credit, should not be denied, and merely because, the Registration Certificates of the seller dealers, have been cancelled with retrospective effect, reversal of input tax credit of the buying dealers, is contrary to the law declared by the Hon'ble Apex Court in State of Maharatshtra v. Suresh Trading Co. reported in (1998) 109 STC 439 (SC). Thus, for the abovesaid reasons, and other grounds inter alia, made in the supporting affidavits, respondents/buying dealers, have sought for a writ of certiorari, to quash the proceedings, impugned in the writ petitions.

    4. Taking note of the law declared by the Hon'ble Apex Court in State of Maharatshtra v. Suresh Trading Co. reported in (1998) 109 STC 439 (SC) and a decision of this court in Jinsasan Distributors v. Commercial Tax Officer, reported in 2013 59 VST 256 (Mad), the writ court, in W.P Nos. 11404 to 11407 of 2015 dated 20.04.2015, ordered as hereunder:

    “2. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, drawing the attention of this court to the judgment of this court in JINSASAN DISTRIBUTORS v. CTO ((2013) 59 VST 256 (MAD)), pointed out that the issue raised in these writ petitions is covered in favour of the petitioner.

    3. Mr. S. Kanmani Annamalai, learned Additional Government Pleader, who takes notice for the respondent, in reply, fairly conceding to the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioner, submitted that as against the order passed, writ appeal has been filed and the same is also pending without any order of stay.

    4. In the decision reported in (2013) 59 VST 256 (MAD.), it has been held as under:—

    “8. The fact that the petitioners herein/assessees under the TNVAT Act have purchased goods from registered dealers on paying the input tax is not in dispute. the fact that they have availed of input-tax credit in terms of section 19(1) of the TNVAT Act, 2006 is also not in dispute and in all these cases the assessment orders have been passed based on documents furnished. The cause of action for issuing the notices for reversal of input tax credit or the order revising the assessment is based on the cancellation of the registration certificates of the selling dealers, who sold the goods to the petitioners herein. It is also not in dispute that the registration certificates of the selling dealers have been cancelled with retrospective effect. That appears to be the one and only ground for initiating the action and therefore the challenge.

    9. The question now to be considered is whether the cancellation of the registration certificates of the selling dealers with retrospective effect will entitle the Department to reverse the input-tax credit already availed of by the petitioners/assessees consequent to assessment orders passed by competent authority based on records….

    An almost identical issue was considered by the Supreme Court in State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary v. Suresh Trading Company (1998) 109 STC 439 (SC).

    The Supreme Court, while dismissing the appeals filed by the Revenue, held as follows: (page 441 in 109 STC):

    In our view, the High Court was right. A purchasing dealer is entitled by law to rely upon the certificate of registration of the selling dealer and to act upon it. Whatever may be the effect of a retrospective cancellation upon the selling dealer, it can have no effect upon any person who has acted upon the strength of registration certification when the registration was current. …

    In the present case, it is not in dispute that the registration certificates of the selling dealers have been cancelled with retrospective effect and, therefore, to reverse the input-tax credit on the plea that registration certificates have been cancelled with retrospective effect cannot be countenanced.”

    5. In view of the above decision, the respondent cannot deny the benefit of input-tax credit to the petitioner as it is contrary to the law laid down by the Apex Court in the above said judgment. Therefore, the writ petitions stand allowed in the light of the ratio laid down by this court as well as the Honourable Supreme Court in the decision cited above. No costs. The connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.

    6. W.A Nos. 946/2016 to 949/2016 are filed against the orders made in W.P Nos. 11404 to 11407 of 2015. Similar orders have been passed in other writ petitions, against which, appeals filed, are listed today.

    7. Assailing the correctness of the orders impugned before us, Mr. Kanmani Annamalai, learned Additional Government Pleader (Taxes), explained that Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax, 2006 and the Rules framed thereunder, provide for a comprehensive system, both for collection of tax and curbing tax evasion. Inviting attention of this court to Section 19(16) of Act, 2006, he submitted that the input credit availed by a registered dealer shall be only provisional and the Assessing Authority is empowered to revoke the same, if it appears to the Assessing Authority to be incorrect, incomplete or otherwise not in order. He further submitted that Section 19(16) of the Act has to be read along with Section 19(15) of the Act, 2006, which states, where a registered dealer has purchased any taxable goods from another dealer and has availed input tax credit in respect of the said goods and if the registration certificate of the selling dealer is cancelled by the appropriate registering authority, such registered dealer, who has availed by way of input tax credit, shall pay the amount availed on the date from which the order of cancellation of the registration certificate takes effect. Such dealer shall be liable to pay, in addition to the amount due, interest at the rate of two percent, per month, on the amount of tax so payable, for the period commencing from the date of claim of input tax credit by the dealer to the date of its payment.

    8. On the powers of the competent authority to revoke the certificate of registration, attention was invited to Sections 39(14) and 39(15) of the Act, which reads thus:

    Sec.39(14). The authority granting the certificate of registration may, by order, for good sufficient reasons to cancel, modify or amend any certificate of registration granted by it.

    Sec. 39(15). No application for registration or for a copy or duplicate of the certificate under this section shall be refused and no order under sub-section 14 shall be made, unless the dealer concerned has been given an opportunity of being heard.

    9. Inviting attention of this court to Section 17 of the VAT Act, 2006, learned Additional Government Pleader (Taxes) submitted that, for the purpose of assessment of tax under the Act, the burden of proving that any transaction or any turnover of a dealer is not liable to tax, shall lie on such dealer. In this context, Section 17 of the Act is extracted hereunder:

    Section 17. Burden of proof. - (1) For the purpose of assessment of tax under this Act, the burden of proving that any transaction or any turnover of a dealer is not liable to tax, shall lie on such dealer.

    Sec. 17(2) For the purpose of claim of input tax credit, the burden of proving such claim shall lie on such dealer.

    Sec.17(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or in any other law for the time being in force, a dealer in any of the goods specified in the Second Schedule liable to pay the tax in respect of the first sale in the State shall be the first seller of such goods and shall be liable to pay tax at the rate specified in the Second Schedule on his turnover of sale relating to such goods, uless he proves that the sale or purchase, as the case may be, of such goods had already been subjected to tax under this Act.

    10. In the backdrop of the above provisions, Mr. Kanmani Annamalai, learned Additional Government Pleader (Taxes) submitted that the authority granting certificate of registration, has powers to cancel, modify or amend any certificate of registration by him, and while doing so, he is mandated to give the dealer concerned, an opportunity of being heard. He also submitted that when input tax credit availed by the registered buying dealers is only provisional, the assessing authority is empowered to revoke the same, which in the case on hand, has been done. He further submitted that consequent to the cancellation of the Registration Certificates of the selling dealers with retrospective effect, reversal of input credits availed by the dealers has been made in terms of Section 19(15) of the VAT Act, which cannot be said as erroneous.

    11. He further submitted that assessment orders are passed, based on the documents furnished by the registered dealers. According to him, the competent authorities have acted, as per the statutory provisions, in the best interest of Revenue and accordingly, reversed the input credits availed by the dealers, which action, cannot be termed as illegal, warranting interference.

    12. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents in W.A Nos. 1051/2016 submitted that in Bombay Sales Tax Act, 1951, there is a provision for retrospective cancellation of Registration Certificate. The Selling dealer's Registration Certificate was cancelled retrospectively. Assessee's claim for deduction on the basis of purchase made at the time when the sellers Registration Certificate was alive, was disallowed. Although there is power to cancel the certificate of registration retrospectively, the Apex Court in State of Maharatshtra v. Suresh Trading Co. reported in (1998) 109 STC 439 (SC) held that as long as the buyers have purchased the goods, when the Registration Certificates were in force, disallowance by the Assessing Officer has been held, as bad in law. He also relied on a judgment of the Kerala High Court in Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax (Law), Board of Revenue (Taxes), Ernakulam v. Debi Prasad Shyam Sunder & Sons reported in 82 STC 305.

    13. Heard the learned Additional Government Pleader (Taxes) and perused the material available on record.

    14. In the light of the statutory provisions extracted supra, there cannot be any quarrel that input tax credit availed by any registered dealer is only provisional and that the Assessing Officers are empowered to revoke the same, if it appears to the assessing authority to be incorrect, incomplete or otherwise not in order. If Section 19(15) of the VAT Act, 2006, to be given effect, in letter and spirit, then, no sooner the Registration Certificate of the selling dealer is cancelled by the appropriate authority, such registered dealer, who had purchased any taxable goods from the selling dealer and availed input tax credit in respect of the said goods, has to pay the amount availed on the date from which the order of cancellation of the Registration Certificate takes effect. Added further, the buying dealer is also liable to pay, any addition to the amount due, interest at the rate of two percent per month on the amount of tax payable, for the period commencing from the date of claim of input tax from the dealer. Section 39(15) of the VAT Act, 2006, is silent, as to whether the competent authority is empowered to cancel, modify or amend any certificate of registration granted by him, retrospectively.

    15. As the issue considered by this court, in the instant writ appeals, is restricted only to the correctness of reversal of input credits availed, by the buying dealers, consequent to the cancellation of the Registration Certificates of the selling dealers with retrospective effect, we are not inclined to go into the aspect, as to whether the competent authority has power to cancel, modify or amend the Registration Certificate retrospectively.

    16. In the light of the above, we now consider the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary v. Suresh Trading Company reported in (1998) 109 STC 439, relied on by the writ court. In the above reported case, respondents therein were registered dealers, under the Bombay Sales Tax Act, 1951. During the period of 1st January 1967 to 31 December 1967, they have purchased goods from M/s. Sulekha Enterprises, who were also registered dealers under the said Act. Bills given to the respondents contained a certificate to the effect that the registration of Sulekha Enterprises was in force, on the date of sales. Respondent/buying dealers, thereafter, resold the goods purchased by them from Suleka Enterprises, within the State of Maharashtra. Purchasing dealers also claimed to deduct, from their turn over of sales, for the relevant accounting years, the re-sale of the goods purchased from Sulekha Enterprises. The Sales Tax Officer disallowed the respondent's claim for deduction, on the ground that the registration of Sulekha Enterprises had been cancelled on 20.08.1967, with effect from 01.01.1967 The Department contended that on the dates of purchase, Sulekha Enterprises was not a registered dealer. The Sales Tax Officer also imposed penalty upon the purchasing dealers/respondents. Being aggrieved, they filed an appeal to the Commissioner of Sales Tax, which was dismissed. Further appeal to the Maharashtra Sales Tax Tribunal, resulted in confirmation on disallowance, but the Tribunal ordered deletion of penalty.

    17. Being aggrieved, respondent/buying dealer, moved the High Court, for an answer, as to, “whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the said case, the Tribunal was correct in holding that the Sales Tax Authority was justified, in treating the purchase of the applicants made from Sulekha Enterprises, as purchasers from an unregistered dealer, on the ground that the Registration Certificate of Sulekha Enterprises was cancelled on August 25, 1967, and when the cancellation thereof, was operative with effect from January, 1967, insofar as the purchase of the applicants, effected from the said party, prior to August 25, 1967 were concerned?”

    18. The High Court answered the question in favour of the respondent/buying dealer. The High Court noted that the effect of disallowing deductions claimed by the respondent was in subsistence, to tax transactions, which were otherwise not taxable. High Court further held that the condition precedent for becoming entitled to make a tax free re-sale was the purchaser of the goods, which was re-sold from a registered dealer and obtaining from that registered dealer of a certificate in this behalf. Thus the condition having been fulfilled, the right of purchasing dealer to make a tax free sale accrued to him. Thereafter, the whole, by reason of something that had happened subsequent to the date of the purchaser, namely, the consummation of the selling dealers registration with retrospective effect, that a tax free re-sales had become liable to tax.

    19. Not satisfied with the aforesaid decision of the High Court, State of Maharashtra went on appeal. After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties, the Hon'ble Apex Court in Suresh Trading Company's case, at paragraphs 5 and 6, held as follows:

    “5. In our view, the High Court was right. A purchasing dealer is entitled by law to rely upon the certificate of registration of the selling dealer and to act upon it. Whatever may be the effect of a retrospective cancellation upon the selling dealer, it can have no effect upon any person who has acted upon the strength of a registration certificate when the registration was current. The argument on behalf of the department that it was the duty of persons dealing with registered dealers to find our whether a state of facts exists which would justify the cancellation of registration must be rejected. To accept it would be to notify the provisions of the statute which entitle persons dealing with registered dealers to act upon the strength of registration certificates.

    6. It must also be noted that the learned Advocate General, appearing for the department before the High Court, stated that the genuineness of the transactions between the registered dealer and the respondents was not in doubt and not disputed. This being so, it is difficult to see how there could have been a cancellation of registration with effect from a date that preceded the dates of the transactions and how, accordingly, the respondents could be made liable to pay tax.”

    20. Thus, the Hon'ble Apex Court, dismissed the appeal preferred by State of Maharashtra holding that, whatever be the effect of retrospective cancellation upon the selling dealer, it can have no effect upon any person, who has acted upon the strength of a registration certificate, when such certificate was alive.

    21. In Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax (Law), Board of Revenue (Taxes), Ernakulam v. Debi Prasad Shyam Sunder & Sons reported in 82 STC 305, the Hon'ble Division Bench of the Kerala High Court, has held as follows:

    “6. Admittedly, in this case, the purchasing dealers were having registration under the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, 1963, when the disputed transactions were effected; the subsequent cancellation of their registration, even if stated to be with retrospective effect, cannot in any manner visit the assessee with adverse consequences. The assessee is entitled to the exemption pleaded, on the basis of form 25 declarations, issued by the purchasing dealers, who had admittedly valid certificates, on the day when the declarations were issued.”

    22. We have already considered, what the Hon'ble Apex Court in Suresh Trading Company's case, has held. Revenue has not placed any contrary judgments, nor pleaded that the judgements, stated supra, are inappropriate to the facts on hand. In the light of the above, all the writ appeals dealing with reversal of input credit, are dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to cost. Consequently, the connected civil miscellaneous petitions are closed.

    23. Writ appeal No. 753 of 2016 is filed against the order made by the writ court in W.P No. 5173 of 2015 dated 03.03.2015, by which the writ court, issued a writ of certiorari, to quash the order of the Assistant Commissioner (CT), Braodway Assessment Circle, Chennai, respondent herein in RC. No/221/2014/Ac dated 12.01.2015

    24. Order impugned before the writ court was cancellation of the Registration Certificate of M/s. Vijayshree Metals, Chennai/respondent, with retrospective effect. Placing reliance on the decision of this court in Jinsasan Distributors v. Commercial Tax Officer (CT), Chintadripet Assessment Circle, Chennai, reported in 2013 59 VST 256 (Mad) and by observing that the said decision is squarely applicable to the facts to W.A No. 753/2016, the writ court, has set aside the order dated 12.01.2015 of the Assessing Officer, cancelling the Registration Certificate of the seller, with retrospective effect, with a further direction to the Assessing Officer, to activate the Registration Certificate, within one week from the date of receipt of a copy of the above said order.

    25. Being aggrieved, the Assistant Commissioner (CT), Broadway Assessment Circle, Chennai has filed the present appeal W.A No. 753 of 2016.

    26. Though the appellant has raised several grounds assailing the correctness of the order made in W.P No. 5173 of 2015 dated 03.03.2015, going through the same, and with due respect to the writ court, we are of the view that the decision rendered in a case pertains to the challenge against reversal of input credit and that, judgment has been applied, to set aside the retrospective cancellation of the Registration Certificate. From the perusal of the order, it would also be deduced that the appellant, was not provided with an opportunity to file any counter affidavit, on the grounds of challenge made in the supporting affidavit to the writ petition filed to quash the Registration Certificate, with retrospective effect.

    27. In the above circumstances, we are of the view that order made in W.P No. 5173 of 2015 dated 03.03.2015 requires interference. Mr. Kanmani Annamalai, learned Additional Government Pleader (Taxes) for the appellant submitted that a counter affidavit would be filed to the challenge. Mr. Adhitya Reddy, learned counsel for the respondent, has no objection for the impugned order before this court, being set aside, giving liberty to the department to file counter affidavit. He has also no objection for remanding the matter to the writ court. Submission is placed on record. In view of the above, order made in the writ petition is set aide. Writ court is requested to consider the same and decide accordingly. No cost. Consequently, the connected civil miscellaneous petition is closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Assistant Commissioner v. Bhairav Trading Company
    (Sep 1, 2016)