AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, born in 1961 in an Agarwal family, married Dr. Veer Singh of the Jatav Scheduled Caste community against her parents' wishes, resulting in severed family relations. The couple had two sons born in 1980 and 1982. The petitioner applied for and received a Scheduled Caste (Jatav) caste certificate from the District Collector, Bulandshahar in 1991, following her assimilation into the Jatav community. Subsequently, she was appointed as a Post-Graduate Teacher (Hindi) in Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan under the Scheduled Caste reservation category in 1993. After over 19 years of service, the caste certificate was challenged upon a complaint, leading the Deputy Commissioner to request verification. The District Magistrate directed cancellation of the caste certificate in June 2013, asserting caste is determined by birth, not marriage.

The petitioner sought recall of the cancellation order but was unsuccessful. She filed Writ-A No. 15682 of 2014, leading to a direction for the District Magistrate to decide her representation, which was rejected in September 2014. Subsequent writ petition (No. 52295 of 2014) led to the suggestion to appeal to the Commissioner of the Division, who dismissed the appeal in December 2014. The State Level Committee affirmed these decisions in May 2015. Following cancellation, the petitioner was removed from service in March 2015. The petitioner now challenges these orders and seeks restoration of her caste certificate.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a person belonging to an unreserved caste by birth, upon marriage to a person of a Scheduled Caste, is entitled to claim reservation benefits under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) of the Constitution of India.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contends that after assimilation and naturalization in the Jatav community, she was rightly issued a caste certificate and accepted as a member of the Scheduled Caste.
  • She argues the cancellation of the caste certificate was illegal and irregular, and the procedure as per Madhuri Patel v. Additional Commissioner Tribal Development was not followed.
  • It is urged that if a community accepts a woman by marriage, her caste status should be recognized accordingly, relying on N.E Horo v. Jahan Ara Jaipal Singh.
  • The petitioner asserts no fraud or misrepresentation was involved, citing Shalini v. New English High School and Kavita Solanke v. State of Maharashtra to support her entitlement to benefits already received.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent contends that granting reservation benefits based on marriage to a person belonging to a reserved category defeats the purpose of reservation.
  • Persons who have not undergone the social stigma attached to a Scheduled Caste cannot claim such benefits merely by marriage.
  • Reliance was placed on the Division Bench judgment in Smt. Sushma Singh v. State of U.P to support this position.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Madhuri Patel v. Additional Commissioner Tribal Development, 1994 6 SCC 241 Procedure to be followed for cancellation or verification of caste certificate. Petitioner claimed the procedure was not followed in cancelling her caste certificate.
N.E Horo v. Jahan Ara Jaipal Singh, 1972 1 SCC 771 Recognition of caste status upon marriage if community accepts the person. Petitioner relied on this to argue her assimilation into the Scheduled Caste community.
Shalini v. New English High School, 2013 16 SCC 526 Protection against deprivation of benefits without fraud or misrepresentation. Petitioner cited to argue she should not lose benefits already granted.
Kavita Solanke v. State of Maharashtra, 2012 8 SCC 430 Similar principle as Shalini regarding protection of benefits. Supported petitioner's claim against deprivation without fraud.
Smt. Sushma Singh v. State of U.P, 2005 4 AWC 3358 All Reservation benefits cannot be claimed by marrying into a reserved caste. Respondent relied on this to argue against petitioner's entitlement.
Murlidhar Dayandeo Kesekar v. Vishwanath Pandu, 1995 Supp 2 SCC 549 Reservation benefits must be based on birth, not voluntary mobility such as marriage. Cited to establish constitutional policy against granting reservation by adoption or marriage.
R. Chandevarappa v. State of Karnataka, 1995 6 SCC 309 Similar to Kesekar, emphasizing birth-based status for reservation. Supported court's reasoning rejecting caste status by marriage.
Valsamma Paul v. Kochin University, 1996 3 SCC 545 Forward caste person marrying into backward class not entitled to reservation. Applied to show petitioner’s claim is not tenable.
Sobha Hymavathi Devi v. Setti Gangadhara Swamy, 2005 2 SCC 244 Overruled N.E Horo partially; caste status cannot be acquired by marriage for reservation. Reinforced that reservation status is by birth alone.
Sandhya Thakur v. Vimla Devi Kushwaha, JT 2005 1 SC 556 Woman born to high caste cannot claim backward class reservation by marriage. Reinforced principle that caste status for reservation is by birth, not marriage.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the constitutional provisions under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) concerning reservation benefits, emphasizing that caste status for these benefits must be determined by birth and not by voluntary assimilation through marriage, adoption, or conversion. The court noted that a person born into a forward caste who marries into a Scheduled Caste or backward class does not undergo the social disadvantages or stigma that the reservation policy intends to ameliorate. The petitioner’s claim of assimilation into the Jatav community was insufficient to confer Scheduled Caste status for reservation purposes. The court analyzed relevant precedents, including partial overruling of N.E Horo in Sobha Hymavathi Devi, which clarified that reservation entitlement cannot be acquired by marriage. The court found the petitioner’s arguments and reliance on community acceptance inadequate to override constitutional principles and precedent. Consequently, the cancellation of the caste certificate was upheld, and the petitioner’s entitlement to reservation benefits was denied.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is the upholding of the cancellation of the petitioner’s Scheduled Caste certificate and denial of reservation benefits based on marriage. No new precedent was established; the court reaffirmed existing constitutional principles that caste status for reservation is determined by birth and cannot be acquired through marriage or voluntary assimilation. The petitioner’s removal from service pursuant to cancellation of the caste certificate stands affirmed.

    Smt. Sunita Singh Petitioner v. State Of U.P. And 5 Others S

    Suneet Kumar, J.:— The petitioner claims to have been born in 1961 in Agarwal family, she contracted marriage with Dr. Veer Singh who belongs to the Jatav community (Scheduled Caste)1. The marriage was contracted against the will of her parents, as such, the parents severed all relations with the petitioner. Out of their wedlock two sons were begotten in 1980 and 1982, respectively. It is contended that the petitioner on being assimilated and naturalized in Jatav community applied for caste certificate which was accordingly issued by the District Collector, Bulandshahar on 29 November 1991 certifying that the applicant belongs to Scheduled Caste (Jatav) community. The petitioner, thereafter, was appointed Post-Graduate Teacher (Hindi) in Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan on 16 December 1993 under the category reserved for Scheduled Caste, during service the petitioner obtained M.A Degree. Upon putting 19 years of service as teacher in Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan, upon complaint, the Deputy Commissioner, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan requested the District Magistrate to get the caste certificate verified. On the direction of the District Magistrate, the Tehsildar, Tehsil Sadar, Bulandshahar vide order dated 22/27 June 2013 cancelled the caste certificate and directed the petitioner to return the caste certificate.

    2. It appears that the petitioner made a request to the District Magistrate to recall the order of cancellation, upon no heed being paid, the petitioner approached this Court in a petition being Writ-A No. 15682 of 2014 which was disposed of on 7 April 2014 directing the District Magistrate to decide the representation of the petitioner. The District Magistrate rejected the representation by order dated 3 September 2014 with the reasoning that the caste of a person is determined by birth not by marriage to a person belonging to the reserved category. Aggrieved, petitioner again approached this Court in a petition being Writ Petition No. 52295 of 2014 which was also disposed of on 24 September 2014 with the observation that the petitioner may approach the Commissioner of the Division in appeal. In appeal, the Commissioner, Meerut Division, Meerut/Regional Level Committee dismissed the appeal by order dated 27 December 2014 upholding the order of the District Magistrate. Aggrieved, the petitioner approached the State Government/State Level Committee, which by order dated 15 May 2015 affirmed the orders passed by the Regional Level Committee and the District Level Committee. As a result of the cancellation of the caste certificate, the petitioner has since been removed from service of the Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangthan vide order dated 18 March 2015 passed by the Additional Commissioner (Administration) & Disciplinary Authority, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan.

    3. The petitioner is assailing the orders passed by the State Level Committee arising from the order passed by the District and Regional Level Committee, a further direction has been sought to restore the caste certificate issued to the petitioner in 1991.

    4. On the request of the parties, the petition is being decided at the admission stage without calling for counter affidavit as per the Rules of the Court.

    5. The facts, inter se, parties are not in dispute. It is admitted on behalf of the petitioner that she belongs to upper caste family which does not fall under any of the class/caste included in the category of SC as notified from time to time. It is admitted that the petitioner was married to a person belonging to the SC category. It is, however, contended that the marriage was against the wishes of the family and upon marriage the Jatav community have accepted her as a member of the community.

    6. After a lapse of 23 years and upon putting in more than 19 years of service, the petitioner was accepted and assimilated into the Jatav community, therefore, it is sought to be urged that the authorities committed illegality and irregularity in cancelling the caste certificate. Further, the procedure as laid down in Madhuri Patel v. Additional Commissioner Tribal Development 1994 6 SCC 241, was not followed. It is further sought to be urged that if the community of a particular caste as per their prevailing customs and usages approves and accepts the marriage of a lady of other caste with a male of a particular community, the lady would become a member of the particular community and her caste for all practical purposes will be caste of the community. In support of his submission, reliance has been placed on N.E Horo v. Jahan Ara Jaipal Singh 1972 1 SCC 771. Finally, it is urged that there being no fraud and misrepresentation practised on the part of the petitioner, as such, she cannot be deprived of the benefits already provided to the petitioner, reliance has been placed on Shalini v. New English High School 2013 16 SCC 526 and Kavita Solanke v. State of Maharashtra 2012 8 SCC 430.

    7. In rebuttal, learned Standing Counsel would submit that the provisions for reservation if granted to a person upon marrying a person belonging to the reserved category would defeat the very purpose of reservation, persons who have not undergone the social stigma attached to a community cannot be conferred such benefit merely upon marriage to a person belonging to SC. In support of his submission, reliance has been placed on a Division Bench judgment rendered in Smt. Sushma Singh v. State of U.P 2005 4 AWC 3358 All.

    8. The question for determination is as to whether a person belonging to an unreserved category upon marriage would be entitled to claim reservation under Article 15(4)/16(4) of the Constitution of India.

    9. When a member is transplanted into the Dalits, Tribes and OBCs, he/she must of necessity also undergo and have had some of the handicaps, and must have been subjected to the same disabilities, advantages, indignities or suffering so as to entitle the candidate to avail the facility of reservation. The candidate who had advantageous start in life being born in forward caste and had march of advantageous life but is transplanted in scheduled caste by adoption or marriage or conversion, does not become eligible to the benefit of reservation either under Articles 15(4) and 16(4), as the case may be. Acquisition of the status of scheduled caste etc. by voluntary mobility into these categories would play fraud on the Constitution, and would frustrate the benign constitutional policy under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) of the Constitution. (Vide Murlidhar Dayandeo Kesekar v. Vishwanath Pandu 1995 Supp 2 SCC 549 and R. Chandevarappa v. State of Karnataka 1995 6 SCC 309)

    10. In Valsamma Paul v. Kochin University 1996 3 SCC 545, the appellant claimed reservation under Article 16(4) which was refused being a member of the forward class, who had an advantageous start in life and after completing education and upon becoming major married Yesudas a Latin Catholic, she was therefore not entitled to the facility of reservation given the Latin Catholic (backward class).

    11. In Sobha Hymavathi Devi v. Setti Gangadhara Swamy 2005 2 SCC 244, the Supreme Court reconsidered the judgment of N.E Horo (supra) and partly overruled it holding that non-tribal person under the cover of marriage cannot be permitted to contest a seat reserved for tribes as it would disturb the very object of such a reservation. The status is varied by birth alone and not by adoption, conversion or marriage.

    12. In Sandhya Thakur v. Vimla Devi Kushwaha [JT 2005 1 SC 556, it was held that the claim of woman born to a high caste married to a man of Backward Class cannot be accepted as she was not born in a disadvantageous position which the community faces, therefore, would not be entitled to contest a seat reserved for Backward Class merely on the basis of her marriage to a person belonging to the Backward Class. (Reference may also be made to a judgment rendered in Smt. Sushma Singh v. State of U.P Through Secretary Harijan and Samaj Kalyan 2005 4 AWC 3358, 2005 2 ESC 1537)

    13. Having considered the facts and circumstances of the case, it is not in dispute that the petitioner belongs to the forward class of a prosperous hindu community, she married upon attaining the age of majority a person belonging to the Scheduled Caste, as such, it cannot be said that she acquired the status of that community, therefore, it cannot be said that she would be entitled to the constitutional protection and benefit conferred in terms of Article 15(4) and 16(4) of the Constitution.

    14. The writ petition being devoid of merit is accordingly dismissed.

    15. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Sunita Singh Petitioner v. State Of U.P. And 5 Others S
    (Dec 21, 2015)