AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This order is part of the continuing proceedings in Malik Mazhar Sultan & Ors. v. U.P. Public Service Commission & Ors., in which the Supreme Court has been monitoring the timely recruitment of subordinate judicial officers across the States. An earlier direction dated 4-1-2007 (reported in (2008) 17 SCC 703) required High Courts/Public Service Commissions (PSCs) to notify, in addition to current and anticipated vacancies, “ten per cent of unforeseen vacancies” calculated with reference to the total sanctioned strength.

Several interlocutory applications (IAs) came up for consideration. IA No. 56 sought modification of the 4-1-2007 direction; IA Nos. 57, 59, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67 and 68 concerned State-specific compliance reports or ancillary reliefs regarding the filling up of vacant posts of District Judges, Civil Judges (Senior Division) and Munsifs in Jharkhand, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Bihar. The present order disposes of or adjourns each IA as indicated below.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the directive in paragraph 15 of the 4-1-2007 order—mandating notification of ten per cent of unforeseen vacancies with reference to sanctioned posts—should be continued or modified.
  2. What consequential directions should be issued to the States of Jharkhand, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Bihar for filling existing vacancies in their subordinate judiciary.

Arguments of the Parties

Counsel for Various High Courts

  • Explained that notifying ten per cent of all sanctioned posts, irrespective of actual or foreseeable vacancies, results in the advertisement of a very large number of posts for which no vacancies may ultimately arise.
  • Such enlarged notifications create unrealistic expectations among candidates placed on the select list, leading to avoidable litigation when appointments do not materialise.
  • Requested that only (a) existing vacancies, (b) vacancies anticipated in the following one year, and (c) a limited wait-list be notified.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Malik Mazhar Sultan & Ors. v. U.P. Public Service Commission & Ors., (2008) 17 SCC 703 Paragraph 15 directed that “ten per cent of unforeseen vacancies would be in respect of sanctioned posts and not vacancies occurring in a particular year.” The Court modified this very directive, limiting future notifications to existing and one-year-anticipated vacancies, with a wait list, thereby superseding the earlier rule.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court accepted the practical difficulties highlighted by the High Courts. It observed that the earlier mandate to notify ten per cent of the entire sanctioned strength had led to the advertisement of posts for which no actual vacancies might emerge, fuelling unwarranted litigation by disappointed candidates. Balancing administrative efficiency with fairness to aspirants, the Court held that recruitment notices should realistically reflect:

  • Current vacancies;
  • Vacancies anticipated within the next twelve months; and
  • A limited number of candidates in a wait list.

Accordingly, the directive in paragraph 15 of the 4-1-2007 order was expressly modified. For the State-specific IAs, the Court recorded compliance steps, granted time for replies, or issued directions—such as instructing Bihar to take urgent action on 101 recommended candidates for 109 Civil Judge (Senior Division) vacancies.

Holding and Implications

IA No. 56 is DISPOSED OF with the modification that henceforth High Courts/PSCs shall notify only the existing vacancies, vacancies anticipated in the next one year, and maintain a wait list; the earlier order dated 4-1-2007 stands modified to that extent.

IA No. 67 is DISMISSED as withdrawn with liberty to pursue the matter in a pending special leave petition.

IA No. 57 is DISPOSED OF after recording the status of recruitment in Jharkhand.

Other IAs (59, 63, 64, 65, 66, 68) were either adjourned, granted time for replies, or issued directions (e.g., notice to the State of Bihar; directions to Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Jharkhand to proceed with recruitment).

Implications: The modification standardises a more pragmatic vacancy-notification practice nationwide, likely reducing candidate litigation and streamlining judicial appointments. No new substantive precedent was set beyond clarifying and updating the Court’s own supervisory directions.

    Malik Mazhar Sultan And Another v. Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission And Others

    Order

    IA No. 56

    1. On 4-1-2007 (2008) 17 SCC 703, this Court had given certain directions regarding the selection and appointment of members of the subordinate judicial officers in various courts. In the tabular form, the number of vacancies are notified by the High Court/Public Service Commission. It was directed that the further vacancies that may arise due to elevation or death or otherwise, 10% of the posts shall be notified and this is referred at para 15 of the order; it is further stated: (Malik Mazhar case (2008) 17 SCC 703)

    “15. We further direct that ten per cent of unforeseen vacancies would be in respect of sanctioned posts and not vacancies occurring in a particular year.”

    2. It has been pointed out by the counsel appearing for the various High Courts that 10% of the sanctioned posts are notified in some States. A large number of posts are to be notified whereas there was corresponding number of vacancies to be filled if the candidates are selected in the select list. There may be an expectation for such candidates to get appointment and this creates unwanted litigation by the candidates and it is prayed that the existing vacancies alone be notified along with the anticipated vacancies that may arise in the next one year and some candidates also be included in the wait list prepared by the High Courts/PSCs.

    3. In supersession of the order passed by this Court on 4-1-2007 (2008) 17 SCC 703, this Court directs that in future the High Courts/PSCs shall notify the existing number of vacancies plus the anticipated vacancies for the next one year and some candidates also be included in the wait list. To this extent earlier order is modified.

    4. IA is disposed of accordingly.

    IA No. 67

    5. IA is dismissed as withdrawn with liberty to pursue the matter in the special leave petition filed by the petitioner.

    IA No. 57

    6. There were 42 vacancies in the cadre of District Judge in the State of Jharkhand and the examination was proposed to be held on 31-8-2008, but the same was not held and the clarification was sought from the High Court.

    7. Learned counsel appearing for the High Court of Jharkhand stated that there was Writ Petition (S) No. 4159 of 2008 before the High Court and it was finally disposed of by the judgment dated 29-8-2008 and certain directions have been given to fill up these 42 posts.

    8. We are told that the judgment of the High Court is challenged before this Court in a special leave petition and they are to be dealt with separately.

    9. There were 22 posts of Sub-Judge (Civil Judge, Senior Division) and 66 candidates have been put in the zone of consideration and interview is proposed to be held and it is submitted by the learned counsel for the Jharkhand that these posts will be filled up. There were 65 vacancies of Munsiffs and the main examination and interview are to be held shortly. This is recorded.

    10. IA is disposed of accordingly.

    11. The presence of the Registrar is recorded. His presence is dispensed with.

    IA No. 59 and SLP (C) No. 28488 of 2008

    12. The Registrar General seeks further time. Adjourned.

    IAs Nos. 63 and 64

    13. The Registrar General and the Registrar (Vigilance) of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh are present.

    14. Learned counsel for the High Court submits that there were 10 vacancies of Civil Judge (Senior Division) and the same have been filled up by promoting the Civil Judges (Junior Division) and the High Court has also prepared a list of eligible candidates for promotion to Civil Judge (Senior Division).

    15. List on 5-5-2009.

    16. Meanwhile reply, if any, be filed.

    IAs Nos. 65 and 68

    17. The Registrar, Kerala High Court is present.

    18. Two weeks' time, as requested, is granted for filing a reply.

    19. List on 5-5-2009.

    IA No. 66

    20. Issue notice returnable on 5-5-2009.

    21. The Secretary (Legal) of the State of Bihar is directed to be present on the next date of hearing.

    22. We are told by the learned counsel appearing for the High Court of Bihar that 109 vacancies of the Civil Judge (Senior Division) are to be filled up and it has recommended the names of 101 candidates to the State Government and the State Government has not taken any further steps to appoint them. The State of Bihar is directed to take urgent steps to fill up these vacancies.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Malik Mazhar Sultan And Another v. Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission And Others
    (Mar 24, 2009)