AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • dismissed.20. Rule discharged.21.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • dismissed.20. Rule discharged.21.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an order dated 20 April 1985 terminating her services as a lecturer and seeks reinstatement with continuity of service and back-wages.

The fourth respondent, Bhandup Education Society, opened a college in the 1982–83 academic year and advertised in March 1983 for principal and lecturer posts. The petitioner applied and, per the selection committee report dated 10 June 1983, was recommended at serial No. 1 for the post of lecturer in Business Communication. She received a letter of appointment (part-time, temporary to the end of the academic year and subject to university approval) dated 29 June 1983 and the university approved the appointment on 30 September 1983 subject to conditions including that certain recommended candidates would have to acquire revised qualifications within five years and that appointments were temporary.

The petitioner's temporary engagement for 1983–84 ended in April 1984. A fresh advertisement was issued in February 1984; the petitioner applied and on 25 June 1984 received a letter appointing her as a full-time lecturer, again described as purely temporary up to the end of the current academic year. The university approved this appointment on 25 October 1985 (the opinion records the approval and the period from 25 June 1984 to 20 April 1985).

On 20 April 1985 the petitioner was informed that her services were terminated and she was not continued for the next academic year. She appealed to the College Tribunal which dismissed the appeal on 9 February 1986. The petitioner then filed the present petition impugning termination and seeking reinstatement.

Subsequent events noted in the opinion: after the College Tribunal appeal was pending, Smt. Meenakshi Balasubramaniam (initially selected for the 1985 appointment) resigned; a later appointment was made of Smt. Anuradha V. Sherikar on or about 7 November 1985, who continues in the post.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the termination of the petitioner's services dated 20 April 1985 was illegal and whether she is entitled to reinstatement with continuity of service and back-wages.
  2. Whether the petitioner possessed the requisite qualifications for appointment as a college lecturer under the Government resolution dated 31 January 1983 and the Vice-Chancellor's circular (Cl. 1(iii), its proviso and explanations).
  3. Whether a temporary appointment, renewed year-to-year, can confer a right to continue in post as a permanent appointment (i.e., whether "artificial breaks" at academic year end can be used to defeat permanency).
  4. Whether the petition is maintainable in the absence of necessary parties (in particular the present incumbent, Miss Anuradha V. Sherikar, and the University of Bombay).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Petitioner's) Arguments — as advanced by Sri Cama

  • The petitioner was validly selected by the selection committee and her appointment should be treated as permanent in substance despite being described as temporary in appointment letters; the respondent used artificial year-end breaks to avoid recognizing permanency.
  • The initial part-time appointment was converted to a full-time appointment in June 1984 and was approved by the university; therefore re-advertisement and termination for 1985–86 was unjustified.
  • Even if she lacked certain qualifications at the date of appointment, the relevant circular allowed eight years to acquire the requisite qualification (M.Phil or equivalent), and the petitioner eventually passed her M.Phil within that period; at worst the sanction for failing to obtain the qualification would be loss of future increments, not termination of service.
  • The petitioner relied on several authorities (listed in the opinion) to support her contentions and argued that non-joinder should not be fatal to her petition.

Respondents' Arguments — as advanced by Sri R.J. Kochar

  • The petitioner did not possess the requisite qualifications for appointment under the Government resolution and the Vice-Chancellor's circular; the college had to appoint a temporary, stop-gap lecturer because qualified candidates did not apply when the college newly opened.
  • Seats reserved for backward classes could not be filled for lack of eligible candidates and were carried forward; petitioner cannot claim a substantive entitlement on grounds of lacking qualifications and not being from the reserved community for the reserved post.
  • The petitioner failed to implead the University of Bombay and the then-current incumbent (Miss Anuradha V. Sherikar), who are necessary parties: reinstatement would displace the present incumbent and cannot be ordered without joining her and giving her an opportunity to be heard.
  • The petitioner was aware that her appointment was temporary and accepted it; the respondents were therefore justified in re-advertising the post and appointing candidates who met the prescribed qualifications.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Anant S. Dodwad v. Sonapant Dandekar Arts College (Pendse & Sugla, JJ.) The opinion quotes the case for the principle that lecturers without requisite qualifications in 1983 could not continue after the specified grace period and that failure to obtain qualifications did not merely result in loss of increments but could lead to cessation of entitlement to hold the post after the prescribed date. The court relied on and applied this precedent to reject the petitioner's contention that lack of qualifications would only deprive her of increments; the court held the precedent supports that unqualified lecturers could not continue beyond the allowed period and used it to find the petitioner ineligible for relief.
Manager, Government Branch Press v. D.B. Belliappa [1979 — II L.L.N 324] The opinion records that this decision was relied upon by Sri Cama; the specific rule invoked by counsel is not detailed in the provided text. The court noted the decision was cited by counsel but stated it would not dwell on certain decisions; no specific application of this precedent is described in the opinion.
Smt. R. Venkutaraman v. Union of India [1978 — II L.L.N 479] Listed among authorities relied upon by the petitioner; the opinion does not set out the principle from this case. The court acknowledged the reliance but did not discuss or apply any specific principle from this case in the written analysis.
Rattanlal v. State of Haryana [1985 — II L.L.N 828] Listed by petitioner’s counsel; the opinion does not state the specific rule cited from this decision. The court mentioned the citation but did not elaborate on its application and did not rely on it expressly in the reasoning laid out.
Swadesamitran, Ltd. v. Their Workmen [1960-1 L.L.J 504] Listed as a case relied upon by counsel; the opinion does not record the legal principle taken from it in the text provided. The court noted the citation but indicated it would not dwell on certain decisions; no direct application is described.
Baleshwar Dass v. State of Uttar Pradesh [(1980) 4 SCC 226] Included in the list of cases relied upon by the petitioner; the opinion does not summarise the principle from this case within the text. The case was referenced by counsel but the court did not rely upon it expressly in the rationale recorded in the opinion.
General Manager, South Central Railway v. A.V.R. Siddhanti [(1974) 4 SCC 335 : AIR 1974 SC 1755] Relied upon by petitioner to argue non-joinder was not fatal in certain seniority-list challenges; the opinion records the nature of that authority. The court drew a distinction: those authorities dealt with seniority-list challenges where relief did not directly operate to displace an individual; the court held they were not analogous because here reinstatement would directly affect a presently employed person not joined in proceedings.
A. Janardhana v. Union of India [1983 II L.L.N 310] Also relied upon by petitioner on non-joinder issues; the opinion records the citation without detailing the rule beyond context. The court treated the authority as inapposite to the present facts for reasons noted in the previous row: the present petition, if granted, would adversely affect a specific incumbent who was not impleaded.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a fact-based and textual analysis of the appointment history and the qualification requirements in the Government resolution dated 31 January 1983 and the Vice-Chancellor's circular (Cl. 1(iii), its proviso and explanations).

  1. Qualification analysis:
    • The court set out the qualification requirement for a Lecturer in English from the circular: either (a) a good academic record with at least Second Class Master's Degree, or (b) an M.Phil or a recognised degree/diploma beyond the Master's or published work showing research capacity.
    • The proviso permits appointment, on selection committee recommendation, of a person without (b) provided the person has a "good academic record" and undertakes to acquire the higher qualification within a specified period (eight years for certain groupings), failing which increments may be withheld.
    • Explanations define "good academic record": a candidate without M.Phil must have either (i) a high Second Class Master's and a Second Class Bachelor's, or (ii) a Second Class Master's and a First Class Bachelor's. The court computed the "high Second Class" midpoint and compared the petitioner's marks.
    • The petitioner's marks: H.Sc. 54%, B.A. 46% (Second Class), M.A. 50% (Second Class). The midpoint between Second and First Class (45% and 60%) is 52.5%; the petitioner’s M.A. at 50% is below that high Second threshold, and her B.A. at 46% is not First Class. Thus she failed both alternative tests in the explanation and did not have the M.Phil or published work at the time of appointment.
    • Consequently, the court concluded the petitioner did not possess a "good academic record" and therefore did not meet the basic qualifications required by Cl. 1(iii).
  2. Nature of appointment and intent:
    • The court observed that the petitioner was repeatedly appointed on letters explicitly stating the appointment was "temporary" up to the end of the academic year, and that the college re-advertised for each academic year.
    • When the college initially opened, it did not receive adequately qualified applicants; the petitioner was therefore appointed as a stop-gap/temporary measure. The court emphasized that the petitioner was aware of the temporary character of her appointment and did not object when her services ended after the academic year.
  3. Contentions about the eight-year concession:
    • The petitioner argued the eight-year concession (to acquire qualifications) meant that non-possession of qualifications could not lead to termination, only to withholding of increments. The court rejected this reading, relying on an earlier decision (Anant S. Dodwad v. Sonapant Dandekar Arts College) which the court quoted as holding that lecturers without the requisite qualifications in 1983 could not continue after the permitted period and that the concession did not mean indefinite continuation without qualifications.
    • The court held that the proviso presupposes appointment of a person who already possesses a "good academic record"; since the petitioner lacked that foundational requirement, the eight-year concession could not be used to validate her appointment to the substantive post.
  4. Selection of other candidates and current incumbency:
    • The court noted that subsequently selected candidates (Meenakshi Balasubramaniam and Anuradha V. Sherikar) had qualifications meeting Cl. 1(iii)(a) (first-class or high marks noted in the opinion), and their appointments were approved by the University. That fact underpinned the conclusion that qualified candidates were available and could be appointed in preference to the petitioner.
  5. Non-joinder of necessary parties:
    • The court addressed the respondents' contention that the petitioner failed to implead the University and the current incumbent (Miss Anuradha V. Sherikar). The court concluded that an order of reinstatement would directly affect the present incumbent and therefore she was a necessary party; non-joinder was an independent ground to refuse relief.
    • The court distinguished authorities cited by the petitioner on non-joinder, noting those concerned different factual contexts (seniority list challenges) and were not analogous to a situation where relief would directly displace a specific employed person.
  6. Final synthesis:
    • Because the petitioner did not meet the prescribed basic qualifications at the time of appointment, her appointments were only temporary stop-gap measures and she had no right or lien to the post. Given both the qualification deficiency and the non-joinder of the present incumbent, she was not entitled to the reliefs claimed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court found the petition to be without merit and held that the petition is liable to be dismissed. (The opinion states: "I Find the present petition is devoid of merit and the same is liable to be dismissed." The rule was discharged and there was no order as to costs.)

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The petitioner's termination dated 20 April 1985 is upheld by the court's reasoning; she is not entitled to reinstatement, continuity of service, or back-wages under the facts and law as analyzed in the opinion.
  • The court held the petitioner did not possess the requisite qualifications at the time of appointment and therefore had no proprietary right or lien to the post; subsequent qualified appointments by the college were validly made and approved by the university.
  • The petition also failed on the independent ground of non-joinder of necessary parties (notably the current incumbent), meaning relief that would adversely affect a non-joined incumbent cannot be granted.
  • The opinion does not announce any novel legal principle; it applies existing qualification rules and precedent to the facts and does not purport to set new precedent beyond its application to the case at hand.

Rule discharged. There shall, however, be no order as to costs.

    Lalita P. Kolharkar v. College Tribunal, (D.M Naik, Presiding Officer), Bombay, And Others

    1. By the present petition, the petitioner seeks to impugn the order, dated 20 April, 1985, terminating her services as a lecturer. She has prayed for an order of reinstatement with continuity of service along with back-wages.

    2. Respondent 4 Bhandup Education Society, opened its College of Commerce and Economics in the academic year 1982–83. On 30 March, 1983, the Chairman of the said society issued an advertisement in the Times of India inviting applications for the post of Principal and lecturers in its college. The said advertisement is annexed at exhibit B to the petition. The petitioner in response to the aforesaid advertisement sent her application, dated 13 May, 1983, exhibit C, to the petition. On 10 June, 1983, the selection committee of the college issued its report in regard to the selection of lecturers, exhibit D to the petition. By the said report, the committee recommended the petitioner at serial No. 1 in the order of merit for the post of lecturer in Business Communication. On 22 June, 1983, the Chairman of the college wrote to the Registrar of the University of Bombay for grant of approval of the selections exhibit E to the petition. On 29 June, 1983, the Chairman of the society issued a letter of appointment to the petitioner for the post of part-time lecturer of Business Communication with effect from 1 July, 1983. The said letter is annexed at page 50 of the affidavit-in-reply. It recites that the petitioner's appointment is purely temporary up to the end of the current academic year. It further recites that her appointment is subject to the approval by the university. On 18 August, 1983, the Principal of the college addressed his letter exhibit G to the petition to the Registrar, University of Bombay, forwarding the details of the new appointments in the college for the academic year 1983–84. The particulars of the petitioner, which were furnished to the Registrar, mentioned that she was being appointed as a part-time lecturer on temporary basis. The particulars further show that the petitioner had secured 54 per cent marks in her H. Sc. Examination, 45 per cent marks in her Bachelor's Degree and 50 per cent marks in her Master's Degree. It further provides that the petitioner did not possess consistently good academic record and did not obtain high Second Class or B grade in seven point scale at the Master's examination as required. It further recites that she had no professional experience. On 30 September, 1983, the university accorded its approval for exhibit H to the petition for appointment of the petitioner as a lecturer in Business Communications. Paragraph 2(iii) of the aforesaid letter provided as under:

    “(iii) that the recommendations of the selection committee in respect of candidates at serial Nos. 1, 5 and 6 have been approved by the Vice-Chancellor subject to the condition that they will have to acquire the revised qualifications within five years from the dates of their appointments, failing which they will not be allowed to earn any future increments and their services will be liable to be replaced by recruiting persons possessing the revised qualifications, and that their appointments are made on a temporary basis.”

    3. The petitioner's services being on temporary basis for the academic year 1983–84 came to an end in April 1984. On 20 February, 1984, a fresh advertisement, exhibit M, to the petition was published in the Times of India inviting applications for the post of lecturers for the subject Business Communications and other allied subjects. The petitioner, in response to the aforesaid advertisement sent her application, dated 25 March, 1984 (exhibit N to the petition). On 25 June, 1984, the Chairman of the fourth respondent issued a letter of appointment to the petitioner, exhibit P to the petition, to the post of full-time lecturer in the subject of Business Communications. The letter clarified that the petitioner's appointment was purely temporary up to the end of the current academic year. On 21 September, 1984, the Principal of the college, by a letter, exhibit O to the petition, forwarded the names of the lecturers, who were proposed to be appointed, for the approval of the university. The university by its communication, dated 25 October, 1985, exhibit R, approved the appointment of the petitioner as a full-time temporary lecturer for the period from 25 June, 1984 to 20 April, 1985. On 20 April, 1985, it is the case of the petitioner that she was informed that her services were terminated and that she was not continued as a lecturer for the next academic year.

    4. Like in the previous years, the fourth respondent again invited applications for fresh appointment and the petitioner vide her application, dated 8 February, 1985, applied for being selected. However, the selection committee selected one Smt. Meenakshi Balasubramaniam who had I class in B.A, M.A as also B.Ed She was placed at serial No. 1 and the petitioner at serial No. 2 in the merit list. Consequent upon the said selection, the aforesaid Meenakshi Balasubramaniam came to be appointed in preference to the petitioner. The petitioner being aggrieved by the termination of her services preferred an appeal to the College Tribunal wherein by judgment and order, dated 9 February, 1986, the appeal was dismissed with no order as to costs. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the petitioner has preferred the present petition.

    Dated 9 September, 1991.

    5. Pending the appeal before the College Tribunal, it appears that Smt. Meenakshi Balasubramaniam resigned and hence the fourth respondent on 7 November, 1985 issued an advertisement for fresh appointment for a lecturer in English to teach Business Communications and one Smt. Anuradha V. Sherikar came to be appointed. The said Anuradha V. Sherikar is continuing on the said post till date.

    6. Sri Cama, the learned counsel appearing in support of the petition, strenuously urged that the petitioner's appointment as a lecturer had been made after she was validly selected by the selection committee. Though the appointment letter styled her appointment as a purely temporary appointment, her services for all practical purposes, was of a permanent nature. He submitted that the fourth respondent was not justified in appointing the petitioner only for an academic year and giving artificial breaks at the end of each academic year so as to avoid the link of permanency to the petitioner's appointment. The initial appointment of the petitioner, as part-time lecturer, was made full-time lecturer in June 1984. The appointment was duly approved by the university. The fourth respondent was, therefore, not justified in re-advertising the post for the academic year 1985–86. The termination of the services of the petitioner was illegal and the appointments of the candidates such as Smt. Meenakshi Balasubramaniam and Smt. Anuradha V. Sherikar are illegal. Sri Cama submitted that the impugned order of College Tribunal is liable to be set aside and back-wages.

    7. Sri R.J Kochar, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondents 2 to 4, submitted that the petitioner did not possess the requisite qualifications for being appointed as a lecturer. Since the college had been recently opened, it was necessary to commence the classes. The fourth respondent, therefore, issued an advertisement in March 1983 inviting applications for the post of lecturer. The said advertisement did not receive the desired response and no candidate possessing the requisite qualifications applied for the post. It was, in these circumstances, that the petitioner was appointed temporarily as a stop-gap arrangement till such time a candidate possessing requisite qualifications was found. Sri Kochar pointed out that though certain seats were required to be reserved for the backward class candidates, the said reservations could not be filled up for want of requisite candidates. The reserved posts were, therefore, carried forward. The petitioner, therefore, cannot claim to be validly appointed to a substantive post on both the grounds namely, that—

    (i) she did not possess the requisite qualifications; and

    (ii) she did not belong to the backward community for which the post was reserved.

    Sri Kochar further submitted that the petitioner is not entitled to any reliefs in the present petition on the ground that the petitioner has not impleaded the University of Bombay as also Smt. Anuradha V. Sherikar, who are necessary parties to the petition. The post of lecturer in English is a one man post and hence an order of reinstatement of the petitioner would amount to displacing Smt. Anuradha V. Sherikar who is the present incumbent to the said post. The petitioner having failed to implead her both before the College Tribunal as also in the persent petition is not entitled to the reliefs prayed for in the petition. The first controversy raised by the contending parties is regarding the qualification of the petitioner. The petitioner having been initially appointed in the academic year commencing from June 1983 is governed by the Government resolutions, dated 31 January, 1983, which is annexed at exhibit 5, to the affidavit-in-reply. The said resolution, inter alia prescribes for grant of modified scales as prescribed by the university. It also provides for the revised qualifications prescribed by the University Grants Commission and accepted by the Government of India and which are applicable as condition precedent to the lecturers becoming eligible for the revised scales. The lecturers were demanding revised scale for a considerably long time and the University Grants Commission decided to revise the pay-scales but at the same time prescribed better qualifications for appointment to the post of teachers. The relevant qualification for lecturer in English is found in Cl. 1(i)(iii) of the circular which provides as under:

    “Lecturer in English:

    (a) Good academic record with at least Second Class (C in the seven point scale) Master's Degree from an Indian University or an equivalent degree from foreign university;

    (b) An M.Phil Degree or a recognised degree or diploma in the teaching of English/English studies beyond the Master's level or published work indicating the capacity of a candidate for independent research work.”

    The aforesaid clause contains proviso in the following terms:

    “Provided further that if a candidate possessing the qualifications as at (b) above is not available or not considered suitable, the college, on the recommendation of the selection committee may appoint a person possessing a good academic record on the condition that he will have to obtain an M.Phil Degree or a recognised degree or diploma in the teaching of English/English studies beyond the Master's level within eight years of his appointment, failing which he will not be able to earn future increments till he obtains that degree, diploma or gives evidence of equivalent published work of high standard.”

    The aforesaid proviso is followed by an explanation, which is in the following terms:

    “Explanations:— (1) For the purpose of determining good academic record one of the following criteria may be adopted:

    (i) A candidate holding an M.Phil Degree should possess at least a Second Class Masters Degree; or

    (ii) A candidate not holding a M.Phil Degree should possess either—

    (a) a high Second Class Master's Degree and a Second Class Bachelor's Degree; or

    (b) a Second Class Master's Degree and a First Class Bachelor's Degree.

    2. For the purpose of determining high Second Class, the raid-point between the minimum percentage of marks fixed by university for award of Second Class and First Class may be taken.

    Note: The qualifications prescribed above for different categories of teachers are the minimum qualifications only to determine the eligibility for applying for the post.”

    8. The qualifications of the petitioner are as under:

    Higher Secondary, Second Class with 54 per cent marks Bachelor's Degree, Second Class 46 per cent marks Master's Degree, Second Class with 50 per cent marks.

    9. It is not in dispute that the petitioner neither held a M.Phil Degree or recognised degree beyond the Master's level nor had she published any work indicating her capacity for independent research work at the time when she applied in 1983 or 1984 as required by Cl. 1(iii)(b). It may be, as pointed out by Sri Cama that the petitioner there after, after passing of the impugned order of termination of her services, has passed her M.Phil Degree. That, however, will not be relevant for determining her qualifications at the time of her appointment in the year 1983–84 as also at the time of termination of her services. The petitioner can not in the circumstances be held to possess the requisite qualifications under Cl. 1(iii)(b). The next question which is to be considered is whether the petitioner satisfies the requirement under Cl. 1(iii)(a), i.e, whether she possesses good academic record with at least a Second Class Master's Degree. Explanations 1 provides that for determining “good academic record” a candidate holding an M.Phil Degree should possess at least a Second Class Master's Degree and a candidate not holding an M.Phil Degree should possess either:

    (a) a high Second Class Bachelor's Degree; or

    (b) a Second Class Master's Degree and a First Class Bachelor's Degree.

    Since the petitioner did not hold a M.Phil Degree she would be governed by Cl. (ii) and before she can be considered to possess “good academic record” she has to possess a high Second Class-Masters Degree. High Second Class Degree, under explanation II is the mid-point between the minimum percentage of marks fixed by a university for award of Second Class and First Class. The mid-point between 45 per cent and 60 per cent would be 52.5 per cent, the petitioner, however, has obtained only 50 per cent mark for her Master's Degree. It cannot, therefore, be held that the petitioner possesses a high Second Class Master's Degree. Similarly the petitioner has obtained only 46 per cent marks in her Bachelor's Degree. She has not obtained a First Class Bachelor's Degree and hence she cannot qualify within explanation I (ii)(b).

    10. In view of the above facts, it is not possible to accept the contention of Sri Cama that the petitioner has a good academic record and, there fore, qualified under Cl. 1(iii)(a) of the circular. The petitioner, in the circumstances, was not entitled to be appointed to the post of college lecturere in accordance with the Government resolution, dated 31 January, 1983.

    11. Sri Cama, however, submitted that even though the petitioner was not initially eligible for appointment to the post of lecturer, the Government circular allowed a period of eight years for the petitioner to acquire the requisite qualification. It is common ground that a candidate possessing qualifications as required in Cl. 1(iii)(b) namely a candidate holding a M.Phil Degree was not available and hence the petitioner was appointed on the recommendations of the selection committee. Such appointee, according to Sri Cama, had been granted a period of eight years for passing the M.Phil Degree. According to Sri Cama the petitioner has, in fact, passed her M.Phil, within the requisite period of 8 years. Even had she not passed M.Phil within the aforesaid period, the petitioner could not be visited with an order of termination of her services. The petitioner, at best, could be deprived of her future increment till she obtains a M.Phil Degree.

    12. In my judgment, there is no merit in the aforesaid contention as it overlooks the requirements contained in the proviso namely that the person, who could be appointed, should be a person possessing a good academic record. I have already held that the petitioner docs not qualify the test laid down for possessing good academic record. Hence the petitioner lacks the basic qualifications required for being appointed a lecturer. The fourth respondent had started the college in the year 1982–83 and was required to commence the requisite classes. It, therefore, issued its advertisement but did not receive the applications from qualified lecturers. The petitioner was, therefore, appointed as a part-time lecturer and her appointment was made specifically “temporary” for the academic year 1983–84. The fourth respondent again on 20 February, 1984, issued a fresh advertisement inviting applications for the post for the academic year 1984–85. The petitioner by her application, dated 25 March, 1984, applied in response to the said advertisement. The facts show that the petitioner was conscious and aware of the nature of her appointment. She, therefore, did not raise any objection when her services came to an end by the end of 20 April, 1984. The petitioner was appointed as a full-time lecturer vide appointment letter, dated 25 June, 1984, which clearly recites that the petitioner's appointment was purely temporary up to the end of the current academic year.

    13. After the fourth respondent once again issued an advertisement for appointment of lecturer for the academic year 1985–86 like on the earlier occasions the petitioner on 8 February, 1985, sent her application. The Staff Selection Committee, however, this time, recommended Smt. Meenakshi Balasubramaniam as she was found possessing the requisite qualifications. She had B.A Degree in First Class, M.A Degree in First Class and B.Ed in First Class. The said appointment was duly approved by the university. Similarly, the Staff Selection Committee on 25 January, 1986 recommended Miss Anuradha V. Sherikar, who had secured 64 per cent for her B.A and 55 per cent marks for her M.A Hence it would be seen that both Smt. Meenakshi Balasubramaniam and Miss Anuradha V. Sherikar possessed the requisite qualifications re quired under Cl. 1(iii)(a) of the circular read with explanations (i)(ii).

    14. In view of the aforesaid facts, I am inclined to hold that the petitioner did not hold the requisite qualifications for being appointed a lecturer as provided in the Government resolution, dated 31 January, 1983. Her appointment was only made because no applicants possessing requisite qualifications were available. The petitioner, in the circumstances, cannot claim any right or lien over the said post. The petitioner is, therefore, not entitled to any of the reliefs claimed in the petition.

    15. Sri Cama further reiterated that the circular in question merely requires the obtaining of the requisite qualifications within a period of eight years. It further provides that in case such qualifications are not secured then the lecturer would not be entitled to get any future increments till the requisite qualifications are obtained. He contended that even if a lecturer fails to obtain the requisite qualifications within the stipulated period that would only deprive him of the future increments and not the post. In my judgment, there is no merit in the above contention. It has been held by this Court, in Writ Petition No. 456 of 1984, in the case of Anant S. Dodwad v. Sonapant Dandekar Arts College decided by Pendse and Sugla, JJ., on 9 January, 1989/17 March, 1989, as follows:

    “The plain reading of the Government resolution and the circular issued by the Vice-Chancellor leaves no manner of doubt that those lecturers who did not possess the requisite qualifications in the year 1983 could not continue in the post, but a concession was given for those lecturers who were appointed between October 1975 and January 1983 to secure the requisite qualifications within a period of eight years from October 1977. This concession was given with a view to avoid hardships to those lecturers who were recruited prior to 1983 and when the qualifications required were not so stringent as prescribed in 1983. The contention that in spite of the failure to obtain qualifications such lecturers could continue to hold the office but only are deprived of future increments is incorrect. The circular prescribes that as a grace the lecturers not having the qualifications were permitted to remain on the post till 25 October, 1985 but such continuance would not enable them to earn any increments till they acquire the qualifications. It is futile to suggest that the lecturers could continue without the requisite qualifications even after October 1985 but would not earn future increments.”

    It is to be noted that the petitioner in the instant case does not qualify either under Sub-cl. (a) or (b) of Cl. (1)(iii) of the circular. She neither possessed a M.Phil Degree nor did she possess a good academic record. The petitioner, therefore, did not possess the requisite qualifications for being appointed a lecturer. The contention of Sri Cama, therefore, is liable to be rejected.

    16. Sri Cama next submitted that I would not be justified in disturbing the finding of the College Tribunal to the effect that the petitioner possessed the requisite qualifications for appointment as lecturer. The respondents have not challenged the said findings by filing a separate petition. The College Tribunal on the material placed before it has held that the petitioner did hold the requisite qualifications. I would not, therefore, be justified in arriving at a contrary finding in the absence of proper challenge on the part of the respondents. In my judgment, there is no merit in the above contention. The petitioner has filed the present petition seeking a declaration that she was entitled to be appointed as a full-time permanent lecturer. She has prayed for a writ of certiorari for quashing the impugned order of the Tribunal. She has prayed for a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to withdraw the order of termination of her services, dated 20 April, 1985. She had prayed for direction to the respondents to reinstate her with full back-wages and continuity of service. The petitioner is, therefore, bound to establish her requisite qualifications before the aforesaid prayers can be granted. It is, therefore, futile to seek the aforesaid prayer on the finding arrived at by the Tribunal to the effect that the petitioner did possess the requisite qualifications which findings on merits I have found to be unsustainable. The respondents were justified in appointing the petitioner purely on temporary basis, as a stop-gap arrangement till such time that a candidate possessing the requisite qualifications or a candidate belonging to the backward class was forthcoming. Once it is found that the petitioner lacks the basic qualifications, the petitioner will not be entitled to any of the reliefs claimed in the petition. (See (1991) 3 SCC 246), Ayurvidya Prasarak Mandal v. Geeta Bhaskar Pendse (Smt.). The petitioner in my judgment is not entitled to any of the reliefs claimed in this petition on an additional ground namely non-joinder of necessary parties, more particularly, the present incumbent Miss Anurad-ha V. Sherikar. She as also her predecessor Smt. Meenakshi Balasubramaniam had not been impleaded before the College Tribunal either. Post of lecturer in English a one man post in the college of the fourth respondent. Grant of reliefs would necessarily adversely affect the appointment of Miss Anuradha V. Sherikar. The petitioner not having pleaded the said Anuradha V. Sherikar, no reliefs can be granted to the petitioner.

    17. In view of my aforesaid findings, I do not propose to dwell on certain decisions which were sought to be relied upon by Sri Cama. I may only mention that he relied upon the decisions in the following cases:

    (i) Manager, Government Branch Press v. D.B Belliappa, [1979 — II L.L.N 324].

    (ii) Smt. R. Venkutaraman v. Union of India, [1978 — II L.L.N 479].

    (iii) Rattanlal v. State of Haryana, [1985 — II L.L.N 828].

    (iv) In the case between Swadesamitran, Ltd. v. Their workmen, [1960-1 L.L.J 504].

    (v) Baleshwar Dass v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [(1980) 4 SCC 226].

    18. In support of his contention that the petition is not liable to be dismissed for non-joinder of parties, Sri Cama relied upon two decisions reported in the case of General Manager, South Central Railway v. A.V.R Siddhanti, [(1974) 4 SCC 335 : A.I.R 1974 S.C 1755], in the case of A. Janardhana v. Union of India, [1983 II L.L.N 310]. Both the aforesaid cases pertain to the challenge to the seniority list wherein there was no claim directed against the individual workers. However, the grant of reliefs in the present petition is bound to bring about the termination of the services of Miss Anuradha V. Sherikar. Such an order cannot be passed behind her back and without affording her an opportunity of being heard. This petition is, therefore, liable to fail also on ground of non-joinder of necessary parties.

    19. For the foregoing reasons, I Find the present petition is devoid of merit and the same is liable to be dismissed.

    20. Rule discharged.

    21. There shall, however, be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lalita P. Kolharkar v. College Tribunal, (D.M Naik, Presiding Officer), Bombay, And Others
    (Sep 10, 1991)