Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980
  • Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2003
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980
  • Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2003
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The order deals with multiple Interim Applications (IAs) filed in the long-running writ petition concerning forest conservation measures (WP(C) No. 202 of 1995). The immediate controversy centres on the constitution and composition of the Forest Advisory Committee (FAC) under Rule 4 of the Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2003.

On 15-09-2006 the Court discovered that the FAC then in existence had been constituted under amended rules that had already been stayed in 2004. It therefore directed the Ministry of Environment & Forests (MoEF) to explain why the FAC had not been formed strictly under the 2003 Rules. During the same hearing the Court also noted that numerous Temporary Working Permit (TWP) matters required examination by a duly constituted FAC.

MoEF filed an affidavit on 14-12-2006 stating that it had reconstituted the FAC on 12-12-2006. According to that affidavit the names suggested by the Central Empowered Committee (CEC) did not qualify for appointment, generating a dispute over eligibility criteria and membership of the FAC. Meanwhile roughly 200 project proposals had accumulated, some already cleared by the (contested) FAC, some pending initial scrutiny, and others awaiting only the Court’s final approval.

The present order issues interim directions to keep forest-clearance work moving while postponing the larger question about the legality of the FAC’s composition to a future hearing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reconstituted Forest Advisory Committee (FAC) formed by MoEF on 12-12-2006 satisfies the eligibility requirements of Rule 4 of the Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2003, particularly in light of objections raised by the CEC.
  2. How pending and future forest-clearance proposals should be processed while the legality of the FAC’s constitution remains unresolved and prior stay orders are in force.

Arguments of the Parties

MoEF / Union of India

  • Filed an affidavit (14-12-2006) asserting that the individuals suggested by the CEC “did not qualify for appointments as experts” and were therefore ineligible for inclusion in the FAC.
  • Through the learned Additional Solicitor General (ASG), contended that once FAC members are appointed they cannot be removed except by following the procedure laid down by law.

Central Empowered Committee (CEC)

  • Had earlier suggested names of experts for inclusion in the FAC; objects to MoEF’s refusal to include them.
  • Continues to file individual responses to each project clearance so the Court can decide whether to approve or withhold final clearance.

Amicus Curiae

  • Consulted in selecting three experts in forestry and allied disciplines to assist the Court.
  • Drew the Court’s attention to additional CEC reports requiring responses from MoEF.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Order dated 15-12-2006 in the same writ petition (2011) 15 SCC 668 Stayed the reconstitution of the FAC effected on 12-12-2006. The present order partially modifies that stay by allowing the existing FAC to function, subject to the Court’s approval of every clearance.
Order dated 23-02-2007 in the same writ petition (2011) 15 SCC 677 Set conditions for permitting mining activities upon payment of 50% of Net Present Value (NPV). Reiterated: where 50% NPV has been deposited, authorities may grant permission for mining in various coalfields.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court recognised that deciding the “larger question” of the FAC’s legality requires a detailed examination of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and the 2003 Rules, which could not be completed at this stage. Nonetheless, the backlog of approximately 200 projects necessitated interim measures. Accordingly, the Court:

  • Allowed the presently constituted FAC to function but confined its role to issuing project-wise clearances for fresh cases, each of which must be forwarded immediately to the CEC and then brought before the Court for final approval.
  • Clarified that projects already cleared by the previous FAC after 15-09-2006 need not be revisited by the new FAC; instead, the CEC must submit its response, after which the Court will decide on approval.
  • Permitted FAC and the Central Government to pass orders, without Court or CEC reference, in matters where the Court had earlier relaxed conditions for projects within parks and sanctuaries.
  • Scheduled projects that have both FAC clearance and CEC response for listing in the second week of July 2007.
  • Extended its interim order of 30-11-2006, with modifications, so that every clearance remains subject to judicial scrutiny until the broader issue of FAC composition is resolved.

In ancillary directions, the Court issued notices to MoEF, CEC and various State governments to respond to separate CEC reports and individual IAs, fixing uniform timelines (mostly four weeks) for filing responses.

Holding and Implications

INTERIM DIRECTIONS ISSUED; STAY ORDER EXTENDED WITH MODIFICATIONS

Direct Consequences: The existing FAC may continue to process forest-clearance proposals, but no clearance takes effect unless and until the Supreme Court, after considering the CEC’s response, grants express approval. Mining companies that have already deposited 50% of the Net Present Value may obtain operational permissions in accordance with earlier Court orders.

Broader Implications: The order maintains judicial supervision over forest clearances and keeps the question of FAC’s lawful constitution open for a future, merits-based adjudication. No new precedent on the substantive legality of FAC appointments is set at this stage.

    T.N Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union Of India And Others

    Order

    IAs Nos. 1413-14, 1426, 1428, 1440-41, 1454, 1459-60, 1662-63 and 1675, 1717-18 in No. 1413 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995

    1. The above IAs cover several aspects, one such aspect being the constitution and composition of the Forest Advisory Committee (FAC) under Rule 4 of the Forest (Conservation) Rules, 2003 (the 2003 Rules). In this regard, the facts are as under: when the above IAs came for hearing on 15-9-2006, one of the items which this Court had to consider was concerning constitution of FAC under the said 2003 Rules. On that date, this Court found that FAC was constituted in terms of the amended Rules which were stayed by this Court in 2004. Therefore, it was directed to file affidavit explaining the circumstances under which FAC was not constituted under the 2003 Rules. Therefore, the matter had to be adjourned.

    2. On that date, however, this Court was told that there were several matters concerning the temporary working permit (TWP) which were required to be examined by a duly constituted committee under the said 2003 Rules. Accordingly, the matter was adjourned by two weeks to enable MoEF to file its affidavit. On that date, this Court directed three experts in the forestry and allied disciplines to be appointed in consultation with the learned amicus curiae and the Chairperson of CEC.

    3. On 14-12-2006 an affidavit was filed by the Assistant Inspector General of Forests, MoEF stating that on 12-12-2006 FAC has been reconstituted. In that affidavit it was stated that the names suggested by the Chairperson of CEC did not qualify for appointments as experts and therefore, they were not eligible to be members of FAC. This has given rise to the question regarding the eligibility of the members appointed by MoEF in FAC as well as the objection to the inclusion of the names suggested by CEC in FAC.

    4. We have made certain suggestions for incorporation of some names out of the names suggested by CEC. However, the learned ASG submitted that members once appointed cannot be removed except under the procedure prescribed by law. Today, it is not possible to decide this larger question. This question is to be decided at a later date as indicated hereinbelow. It will require detailed arguments in the light of the provisions of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 with the Rules framed thereunder.

    5. Unfortunately, in the process, a large number of projects (200) have accumulated for clearance. Broadly, we find that post-15-9-2006 FAC has given clearance to certain projects; there are cases which have not been vetted at all till today (fresh cases). Lastly, there are cases where post-15-9-2006 the projects have been cleared by FAC and the response has also been filed by CEC but they are pending approval by this Court. List of such cases be filed in the Registry before the next date of hearing.

    6. In the circumstances, we hereby give the following directions, pending our decision on the larger question indicated hereinabove:

    (a) FAC as it stands today will give priority to projects which need immediate clearances. In this regard, it may be stated that fresh cases may be cleared projectwise by FAC and thereafter such clearances shall be placed before this Court for approval. We make it clear that pending the decision of the larger question, all clearances by FAC of fresh cases shall be subject to approval by this Court. Before giving approval, we would like to have responses from CEC in respect of each clearance. In order to avoid delay, we direct the Ministry concerned to give a copy of the clearance to CEC so that CEC would give its response expeditiously. We will examine each clearance and decide whether to grant or not to grant the approval thereto. Once the approval is granted by this Court, the matter may be placed before the Central Government for disposal in accordance with law.
    (b) Post-15-9-2006, the former FAC has given clearances to projects and, therefore, in such cases it would not be necessary to place those clearances before the existing FAC once again. In such cases, CEC is required to file its response at the earliest. Such cases may be placed before this Court along with the response from CEC so that the approval of this Court could be obtained expeditiously.
    (c) There are certain projects on lands in parks and sanctuaries where this Court has passed orders relaxing certain conditions. In such cases, FAC and the Central Government may pass appropriate orders without reference to CEC or to this Court.
    (d) In respect of certain projects, FAC has given their clearance after 15-9-2006, CEC has also given its response. Such matters may be posted in the second week of July 2007 for approval of this Court.
    (e) Pending the decision of this Court on the abovementioned larger issue regarding constitution of FAC, our order dated 30-11-2006 stands extended till the decision, as we have decided to examine each clearance by FAC and the response of CEC. In that regard, our order dated 15-12-2006 (2011) 15 SCC 668 staying reconstitution of FAC (vide order dated 12-12-2006 annexed to the affidavit dated 14-12-2006 filed by MoEF) shall stand modified to the extent indicated hereinabove.

    IA No. 826 in No. 566 with No. 955 in Nos. 566, 958, 985, 1001-1001-A, 1013-14, 1016-18, 1019, 1046-47, 1135-64, 1180-83, 1196, 1208-09, 1222-25, 1229, 1233 in 1135-36, 1248-49, 1253, 1301-04, 1312-14, 1318-19 in Nos. 1137, 1325, 1364, 1365-66, 1371, 1384, 1385-87, 1434-38, 1441 with 1635, 1475-76, 1513, 1573, 1639 in Nos. 1135-36, 1664-65, 1671, 1676-80, 1707, 1785-86 in IAs Nos. 1441, 1779 in No. 1164 in Nos. 566, 1721 in No. 1597 in No. 566 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995 (NPV Matters)

    IA No. 826 in No. 566

    7. Pursuant to the report submitted by Prof. Kanchan Chopra Committee, the CEC has filed a supplementary report. Issue notice to MoEF. MoEF shall file its response within four weeks to the same. The matter may be placed for argument in the third week of July 2007. The parties, who wish to file any objections to the supplementary report, may also file their response within three weeks.

    8. We are told by the learned amicus curiae that there is another report of CEC in IA No. 955 and connected IAs. As regards this report also issue notice to MoEF and MoEF shall file its response within four weeks. The respective parties may also file their responses within three weeks. List in the third week of July 2007.

    All the matters covered by the CEC report up to 20-11-2006

    9. Issue notice to MoEF. MoEF and the parties concerned may file their response within four weeks. List in the third week of July 2007.

    IA No. 1137

    10. The State of Kerala may file its response to the report of CEC within three weeks.

    IA No. 1164

    11. No further orders are necessary for the present.

    IAs Nos. 1180-81 and 1435-37

    12. CEC has given its report. The parties may file their response, if any, within four weeks.

    IA No. 1441

    13. No further orders are necessary for the present.

    IA No. 1438

    14. Issue notice to MoEF. MoEF shall file its response within four weeks.

    IAs Nos. 1475-76 and 1513

    15. CEC's report has been filed. The parties may file their response within four weeks.

    IA No. 1573

    16. Issue notice. MoEF shall file its response within four weeks.

    IAs Nos. 1639 & 1671 in No. 1639 in Nos. 1135-36

    17. Issue notice. MoEF and the parties may file their response within four weeks.

    IAs Nos. 1664, 1665 and 1676

    18. Issue notice. MoEF and the parties may file their response within four weeks.

    IAs Nos. 1707 and 1721 in Nos. 1597, 1779 in Nos. 1664 and 1785-86

    19. Issue notice to CEC. CEC shall file its response within four weeks.

    As regards coalfields

    20. We are told that the mining companies have paid 50% of the NPV and in cases where 50% of the NPV has already been paid, appropriate authorities may give necessary permission/approval for carrying on the mining activities in the various coalfields in terms of the orders passed by this Court on 15-12-2006 (2011) 15 SCC 668 and 23-2-2007 (2011) 15 SCC 677.

    IAs Nos. 1798, 1789, 1788, 1787 and 1791-92

    21. Issue notice to CEC. CEC may file its response within four weeks.

    Court Masters

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    T.N Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union Of India And Others
    (Apr 27, 2007)