Westkopp, C.J:— It has been found by the District Judge on clear and satisfactory evidence that, at the time of the former suit brought by the first defendant Pandurang against the second defendant Anant, the latter was manager of the undivided family of which the plaintiffs and he are members, and that they all three resided together, and the plaintiffs assisted the second defendant in that suit. The plaintiffs do not allege that they were then minors, or give any other reason for not asking to have been made co-defendants in that suit. The second defendant is still manager of the family, and the allegation of the plaintiffs, that he colluded with the first defendant in the former suit, has altogether failed in proof. Under these circumstances, we act consistently with the view of the Privy Council, expressed in Jogendro Deb Roy Kut v. Funindro Deb Roy Kut and with Mayaram Sevaram v. Jayvantrao Pandurang in affirming the decrees of the Courts below with costs.
Decrees affirmed.
Both the lower Courts dismissed plaintiff's suit, holding that Govind and Mahadev were undivided in interest, and that the land had ceased to be their property at the time when the plaintiff purchased it at the Court sale.
The plaintiff specially appealed to the High Court.
Bhairavnath Mangesh for the appellant.
Pandurang Balibhadra for the respondent.
It was contended in special appeal that the plaintiff was entitled, at least, to the share of Mahadev, who was no party to the foreclosure suit brought by Jayvant.
The following is the judgment of the Court:—
West, J.:— The son, Mahadev, was effectively represented in the suit, brought by Jayvantrao by his father Govind for whom he had written the mortgage on which Jayvant proceeded. The foreclosure was binding, therefore, on him as well as on Govind, and the property had ceased to be his at the time when his interest was sold in execution to Mayaram. We confirm the decree of the District Court with costs (27th February, 1874).