REKHA MITTAL, J.
The present appeal lays challenge to order dated 27.8.2013 passed by the Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Gurgaon whereby the complaint filed under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (in short “the Act”) was ordered to be dismissed for non-prosecution and the accused/respondent is acquitted of the offence.
M/s Alliance Steels, Gurgaon through its proprietor Ashu Aggarwal filed complaint under the Act in respect of dishonour of cheque No. 779163 dated 3.1.2013 for Rs. 12 Lakhs with the remarks “exceeds arrangement”. The respondent-accused failed to pay the cheque amount despite receipt of legal notice. Counsel for the petitioner would submit that after recording evidence during preliminary enquiry, the respondent/accused was ordered to be summoned to face proceedings for offence punishable under Section 138 of the Act. On the previous date i.e 8.8.2013, the Presiding Officer was on leave and Clerk to counsel for the complainant forgot to carry forward the next date (27.8.2013) fixed in the case in the dairy maintained by him. Counsel neither appeared in person nor informed the complainant about the date fixed and as a result, the complaint was dismissed for non-prosecution. It is argued that on 27.8.2013, the case was pending for securing presence of the accused and the accused had actually put in appearance and was released on bail. The learned trial court did not advert to the question if personal appearance of the complainant was necessary or could be dispensed with on 27.8.2013 but proceeded to dismiss the complaint for want of prosecution causing a serious prejudice to the petitioner and a wrongful gain to the accused. It is further argued that in case the impugned order is not set aside, the petitioner would be condemned unheard and the accused would be exonerated of his liability to face prosecution legitimately lodged by the petitioner.
Counsel for the respondent has submitted that as neither the petitioner nor his counsel was present before the Court on 27.8.2013, there was no option with the Court except to dismiss the proceedings for non-prosecution.
I have heard counsel for the parties and perused the records.
The petitioner lodged the criminal proceedings in February 2013 wherein the respondent-accused was ordered to be summoned to face trial for commission of offence punishable under Section 138 of the Act. On 27.8.2013, the case was pending for securing presence of the accused and the accused had put in appearance before the trial court and was released on bail. Perusal of the order dated 27.8.2013 would make it evident that the trial court did not bother to examine if personal appearance of the complainant was necessary or could be dispensed with on 27.8.2013 in the light of ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in The Associated Cement Company Limited v. Keshvanand 1998 (1) R.C.R (Criminal) 309 There is nothing on record suggestive of the fact that the petitioner on an earlier occasion absented from the proceedings or his conduct was found to be lacking bona fide.
In view of settled principle of natural justice, no one should be condemned unheard and every endeavour should be made to dispose of disputed claims of the parties after giving them an opportunity of being heard. In case the impugned order is allowed to sustain, it would deprive the petitioner of his valuable right of being heard in the matter and bringing the criminal proceedings to its logical end. Conversely, dismissal of the criminal proceedings for want of prosecution would enure to benefit of the accused without his being asked to face the criminal trial despite the fact that the Court has found a prima facie case against him to face the criminal proceedings.
In view of the facts and circumstance discussed hereinbefore, I am of the considered opinion that it is expedient in the interest of justice that the application filed by the petitioner for grant of leave to appeal is allowed and the appeal being meritorious also warrants acceptance.
For the reasons aforesaid, the appeal is allowed, order dated 27.8.2013 is set aside and the criminal proceedings are restored at Board of the trial court from the stage at which the same were terminated.