AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, who was the plaintiff in the trial court, filed Suit No. 44/09 seeking permanent injunction to restrain respondent No. 1 (since deceased through legal representatives) and others from dispossessing her and/or demolishing the boundary wall of a specified plot in Village Bijwasan, New Delhi. The petitioner claimed to have purchased the plot from respondents No. 3 to 5. Prior to this, respondent No. 1 had filed Suit No. 43/09 seeking declaration of ownership of a 1/6th share of part of the plot and restraining respondents No. 3 to 5 and their mother. Due to common parties and subject matter, the two suits were consolidated by the trial court for common trial and evidence. Suit No. 43/09 was initially the main suit but was dismissed against the petitioner and her husband, after which Suit No. 44/09 was treated as the main suit.

During the pendency of these suits, the legal representatives of deceased respondent No. 1 filed an application under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC to recall a witness, Chhotu Ram PW1, whose cross-examination had concluded before consolidation. They argued that since evidence from one suit was to be read in the other, they had been deprived of an opportunity to cross-examine the witness in Suit No. 43/09. The petitioner opposed this application as an abuse of process and lacking grounds under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC. The trial court partly allowed the application, ordering that the witness be recalled, if available, for elaboration on left out points.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the application under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC to recall a witness whose cross-examination was completed prior to consolidation of suits can be allowed to afford an opportunity to the legal representatives of a deceased party to cross-examine the witness in the consolidated suit.
  2. Whether the power under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC should be exercised routinely or only when it assists the court in clarifying the case.
  3. Whether the delay in making the application (not at the time of consolidation) is a valid ground for rejecting the application.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The application under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC was not made bona fide but to fill lacunas in the evidence.
  • The power under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC should not be exercised routinely but only when it helps clarify the case.
  • The application should have been made at the time of consolidation; delay is a ground to reject it.
  • The application is an abuse of the process of law.
  • The Supreme Court judgment relied upon (Bagai Construction v. Gupta Building Material Store) is not applicable to the present facts.

Respondent No. 1's Legal Representatives' Arguments

  • The evidence of PW1 was recorded before consolidation and is to be read in both suits, thus they were deprived of cross-examination opportunity in Suit No. 43/09.
  • Allowing recall is necessary to prevent great prejudice to their case.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bagai Construction Thr. Its Proprietor Mr. Lalit Bagai v. Gupta Building Material Store (Civil Appeal No. 1787/2013) Limitations on the exercise of power under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC to prevent routine recall of witnesses Court found this precedent not applicable to the facts of the present case and did not rely on it to set aside the impugned order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged that the evidence of PW1 was recorded before consolidation of the two suits, and that the consolidation order mandated that evidence recorded in one suit be read in the other. Consequently, the legal representatives of the deceased respondent No. 1 were deprived of the opportunity to cross-examine PW1 in Suit No. 43/09. The court found this circumstance justified the request to recall the witness despite the delay in making the application. The court rejected the contention that the application was an abuse of process or an attempt to fill lacunas in the evidence, noting that the petitioner’s counsel failed to substantiate this claim. The court also distinguished the cited Supreme Court precedent, holding it inapplicable to the facts at hand. The impugned order allowing recall of PW1 for further elaboration on left out points to both parties was found to be lawful and not warranting interference.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the petition challenging the order allowing recall of the witness under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC.

The decision upholds the trial court’s discretion to permit recall of a witness to ensure fair trial, especially where consolidation of suits affects parties’ ability to cross-examine. The ruling directly affects the parties by permitting the legal representatives of the deceased respondent No. 1 to recall the witness for further examination, but does not establish a new precedent or broader legal principle beyond the case facts.

    Ram Rati Petitioner v. Mange Ram Since Deceased Through Lrs And Ors. S

    Veena Birbal, J.:— By way of this petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenge has been made to order dated 18.12.2010 by which application of the respondent No. 1, since deceased through LRs under Order 18 Rule 17 CPC has been partly allowed by the learned ADJ, Delhi.

    2. The background of the case is as under:-

    The petitioner herein i.e plaintiff before the learned trial court has filed a suit for permanent injunction i.e Suit No. 44/09 against the respondent No. 1 since deceased through LRs and four others for restraining them from dispossessing her and/or demolishing the boundary wall of suit property i.e bounded plot No. 636, Khatauni No. 487, measuring 5? biswas out of total 11 biswas situated in extended Lal Dora of Village Bijwasan, New Delhi. As per allegation in the said plaint the petitioner had purchased the said plot from respondent No. 3 to 5 herein. Prior to that, the respondent No. 1 i.e Sh. Mange Ram (since deceased) had filed a Suit No. 43/09 for being declared owner of 1/6th share of 5? biswas of aforesaid plot and for restraining the defendants of said suit i.e respondents No. 3 to 5 herein and their mother Smt. Chandrakanta. Since the parties and the subject matter in two cases was common, with the consent of the parties the aforesaid two suits were consolidated before the learned trial court for the purposes of trial on 8.12.2007 and it was ordered that there would be common trial and evidence led in either case be read as evidence in both the cases. Initially Suit No. 43/09 was treated as the main suit. The said suit was dismissed on 15.4.2008 by learned ADJ, Delhi qua the present petitioner and her husband who were impleaded in the said suit on 26.3.2003 Thereafter, Suit No. 44/09 was treated as the main suit by the order of learned ADJ dated 7.7.2008

    3. During the pendency of aforesaid cases, an application was moved by the LRs of Mange Ram i.e respondent No. 1 through LRs (a) to (f) herein for recalling of Chhotu Ram PW1 whose cross-examination was concluded on 16.4.2005 i.e prior to consolidation, in Suit No. 44/09. The stand of the LRs of respondent No. 1 was that as the evidence of Chhotu Ram PW1 in Suit No. 44/09 was recorded prior to consolidation and it has also been ordered that evidence in one case may be read as evidence in other case, the LRs of deceased respondent No. 1 would be deprived of opportunity of cross-examining of PW1 which was concluded prior to consolidation. It was therefore prayed that either the evidence of PW1 be recorded fresh or opportunity to cross-examine PW1 be given to the LRs of Mange Ram who are plaintiffs in Suit No. 43/09. The request was opposed by the learned counsel for petitioner/plaintiff by filing reply to the said application contending therein that the application was an abuse of the process of law. No grounds have been pleaded for invocation of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC and the same has been filed to fill lacunas. It was further contended that no submission or prayer in this regard was made on 8.12.2007 when the consolidation order was passed. The request of the LRs of deceased respondent No. 1 to discard the evidence of PW1 recorded in Suit No. 44/09 prior to the consolidation order has been dismissed. However, it has been ordered that Chhotu Ram PW1, if available, shall be recalled for further elaboration on the left out points to the parties.

    4. Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner has contended that the application has not been made bona fidely. It is submitted that the same has been moved by the LRs of deceased respondent No. 1 to fill up lacunas in the evidence. It is contended that the power under Order 18 Rule 17 is not to be exercised in a routine manner but has to be exercised where it will assist the court in clarifying the stand in the case. It is contended that there was no reason why such a request was not made at the time of consolidation as such the impugned order is liable to be set aside.

    5. On the other hand, learned counsel for LRs of deceased respondent No. 1 has contended that evidence of PW1 was recorded prior to consolidation and the same will be read in Suit No. 43/09 as per the order of consolidation as such great prejudice shall be caused to them.

    6. It is not disputed that the evidence of Chhotu Ram PW1 in Suit No. 44/09 was recorded prior to consolidation of two suits. There is also order of the learned ADJ at the time of passing of the consolidation order that evidence recorded in one case shall be read in the other case. In these circumstances, the stand of the respondent No. 1 i.e LRs of deceased Mange Ram is justified that they could not cross-examine the said witness as regards their suit is concerned. The evidence of the petitioner has not yet concluded. In these circumstances, even if the request was not made earlier the same is no ground to reject the application. Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner has failed to justify as to how it is an attempt to fill up the lacunas. The judgment relied upon by learned counsel for petitioner in Civil Appeal No. 1787/2013 decided on 22.2.2013 by Supreme Court titled “Bagai Construction Thr. Its Proprietor Mr. Lalit Bagai v. Gupta Building Material Store” is not applicable to the facts of the present case. Further, reading the impugned order shows that the witness has been recalled, if available, for further elaboration on the left out points to both the parties.

    7. In view of above discussion, no illegality is seen in the impugned order which calls for interference of this court. The petition is dismissed.

    CM No. 8497/2011

    8. In view of the order on the main petition, no orders are required on this application.

    9. The same stands disposed of accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Rati Petitioner v. Mange Ram Since Deceased Through Lrs And Ors. S
    (Apr 9, 2013)