Gokal Chand Mital, J. (Oral) — The trial Court decreed the suit for pre-emption filed by the two plaintiffs against Chitru vendee and Snmer alleged lessee (sic). Against the aforesaid order, Chitru vendee and Sumer lessee have come to this Court in second appeal.
2. So far as Sumer is concerned, his case is that he is lessee on the land in dispute and whether suit for pre-emption is decreed or not he will continue in possession as lessee under the successful party, and, since he was not party to compromise the term of compromise that the possession can be taken after 31st October, 1988 cannot bind him. Obviously, since he is not party to the compromise and even if it were to be considered that compromise has been legally arrived at between Chitru vendee and the pre-emptors, his appeal before the lower Appellate Court had to be considered on merits to determine whether he was entitled to remain in possession in spite of the decree of pre-emption. To this extent the lower Appellate Court was in error in dismissing the entire appeal on the basis of statements to which Sumer was not party. Hence, the appeal of Sumer has to be decided. On merits by the lower Appellate Court.
3. As regards Chitru, he and his counsel had signed statement recorded by the Court containing terms of compromise. The question for determination would be whether statement made in writing before the Court would be sufficient compliance of order 23 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short ‘the Code’), or the compromise should be reduced into writing in the form of an instrument signed by the parties. This matter was considered by the Apex Court in Gurpreet Singh v. Chatur Bhuj Goel., AIR 1988 SC 400, and the relevant discussion is in para 10 of the reported judgment. The relevant observations are these:—
“When the parties enter into a compromise during the hearing of a suit or appeal, there is no reason how the requirement that the compromise should be reduced in writing in the form of an instrument signed by the parties should be dispensed with. The court must therefore insist upon the parties to reduce the terms into writing.”
In terms of the aforesaid decision, the compromise must be reduced into writing in the form of an instrument duly signed by the parties and mere recording of statements of the parties is Court even if they are signed by the parties and their counsel is not sufficient compliance of Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code. Since there was no compromise reduced into writing in the form of an instrument there was no compliance of Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code on behalf of Chitru. Therefore, he is also entitled to challenge the order of the lower appellate Court in dismissing the appeal as withdrawn
4. For the reasons recorded above, the appeal is allowed and after setting aside the order of the lower appellate Court dated 11th August, 1988, the matter is remitted to that Court for decision of the appeal on merits in accordance with law.
The parties through their counsel are directed to appear before the lower appellate Court on 4-12-1989.
Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code