Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 323/149 IPC
  • Section 304 Part II IPC
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
  • Sections 302/149 IPC
  • Section 323 IPC
  • Section 149 IPC
  • Section 302 IPC
  • Section 148 IPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 323/149 IPC
  • Section 304 Part II IPC
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
  • Sections 302/149 IPC
  • Section 323 IPC
  • Section 149 IPC
  • Section 302 IPC
  • Section 148 IPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Abbas Khan and Shabbir Khan had filed Civil Suit No. 110 of 1974 against Abdul Waheed alleging that he was raising construction on village Panchayat land. The Munsif Court ordered maintenance of status quo, yet Abdul Waheed allegedly continued the construction, leading to contempt proceedings listed for 6 November 1974.

On the evening of 5 November 1974, while Abbas, Razzaq (complainant) and others were sitting on the chhabutra of a well near Abbas’s house, Abdul Waheed and several relatives arrived—some armed with licensed guns, others with lathis. After an exchange of threats, lathi-blows were dealt and guns were fired. Abbas sustained a gunshot wound to his arm and died of shock and haemorrhage; Israr Khan was wounded by pellets, later developed septic peritonitis and died on 18 December 1974. Several others on the complainant side were injured; two members of the accused party received simple injuries.

An FIR was registered (Crime Case No. 313 of 1974) under multiple sections of the IPC. After investigation a charge-sheet was filed on 7 January 1975. The Second Additional District & Sessions Judge, Farrukhabad convicted eight accused on 31 March 1981, awarding Abdul Waheed life imprisonment under Section 302 IPC for Abbas’s murder and concurrent sentences for allied offences. On appeal, the Allahabad High Court (17 December 2004) upheld Abdul Waheed’s conviction but partially allowed the appeal of co-accused. Abdul Waheed alone pursued the present criminal appeal before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether discrepancies regarding the exact place of occurrence and absence of bloodstains at the alleged spot created reasonable doubt about the prosecution version.
  2. Whether the complainant party, and not the accused, were the aggressors, thereby affecting criminal liability and any right of private defence.
  3. Whether Abdul Waheed’s act amounted to murder under Section 302 IPC or the lesser offence of culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part II IPC.
  4. Whether the passage of time since 1974 and the appellant’s advanced age warranted interference with sentence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Alleged discrepancies about the scene of crime: the incident occurred near Shafiq’s chhabutra, not Abbas’s, and no blood was found where the prosecution placed the occurrence.
  • The complainant side were the aggressors; Abbas and Israr were armed with gun and pistol, respectively, and the accused acted in self-defence.
  • Recovery of a third, unexplained gun cartridge casts doubt; non-recovery of Abdul Waheed’s own gun undermines the prosecution case.
  • Since the shot hit Abbas’s arm—a non-vital part—the offence, if any, falls under Section 304 Part II, not Section 302.
  • Given the appellant’s age (about ninety) and the lapse of nearly four decades, custodial sentence would now be unduly harsh.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • Eyewitness testimony of Razzaq (injured), Yasin and Ali Daraj is consistent and corroborated; their credibility remained intact after cross-examination.
  • Motive is clearly established by the pending civil and contempt proceedings.
  • Minor injuries on two accused were trivial and satisfactorily explained; the pattern of injuries and two deaths prove the accused were the aggressors.
  • Non-recovery of the appellant’s gun is immaterial; ballistic evidence linked other recovered cartridges to a co-accused’s weapon, and eyewitnesses confirmed Abdul Waheed fired.
  • Use of a firearm, coupled with prior enmity and arrival in an armed group, demonstrates intention sufficient for murder under Section 302 IPC; sentence requires no reduction.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by affirming motive: documentary evidence (orders in Civil Suit No. 110/1974 and contempt application scheduled for hearing the next day) underscored animosity between the parties. It then evaluated eyewitness testimony:

  • PWs 1, 3 and 4 spoke consistently about the accused arriving armed at Abbas’s chhabutra; Razzaq’s status as an injured witness lent additional credibility.
  • Lengthy cross-examination failed to shake their versions, and their presence at the scene was natural given proximity of their houses.

On the alleged discrepancy in the place of occurrence, the Court noted absence of blood near Shafiq’s chhabutra and found the defence version improbable. Addressing the “aggressor” contention, it held that two minor blunt-force injuries on accused Hafeez and Vakil were adequately explained: they were sustained when complainant witnesses used lathis defensively. The accused, armed with guns and lathis and causing two deaths, were clearly the aggressors.

Regarding ballistic evidence, non-recovery of Abdul Waheed’s gun did not create reasonable doubt; eyewitnesses saw him fire and a cartridge unlinked to recovered weapons could plausibly have come from his gun.

On the nature of the offence, the Court reasoned that use of a gun, deliberate arrival in an armed group, and prior enmity demonstrated requisite intention or knowledge for murder. A gunshot is inherently lethal; the fact that it struck the arm yet proved fatal through haemorrhage did not reduce culpability.

The plea for leniency on account of age and passage of time was rejected. The Court stressed that undue sympathy would undermine public confidence; concurrent findings of fact by two courts below merited no interference under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Holding and Implications

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirmed Abdul Waheed’s conviction under Section 302 IPC and allied offences, cancelled his bail bonds, and directed that he be taken into custody to serve the remaining sentence.

Immediate consequence: Abdul Waheed must undergo the life sentence originally imposed. The decision leaves intact the concurrent factual findings of the trial court and High Court and sets no new legal precedent beyond reaffirming settled principles on evaluation of eyewitness testimony, motive, and intent where firearms are used.

    Abdul Waheed v. State Of Uttar Pradesh .

    R. Banumathi, J.— This appeal is preferred against the judgment dated 17-12-2004 passed by the Allahabad High Court in Abdul Waheed v. State of U.P. Criminal Appeal No. 796 of 1981 whereby the High Court affirmed the conviction of the appellant Abdul Waheed under Sections 302, 148 and 323 IPC read with Section 149 IPC and sentence of life imprisonment and one year's rigorous imprisonment respectively awarded to him. The High Court partly allowed the appeal qua accused Babu Khan, Mukhtiyar, Javed Khan and Mohd. Hafeez Khan. The appeal before the High Court abated qua accused Vakil Khan, Abdul Hai and Shafiq Khan.

    2. The case of the prosecution is that complainant Razzaq Khan's brother Abbas and Shabbir instituted a suit in the Court of Munsif, Farrukhabad and an injunction order was issued by the court. Despite the court order, appellant Abdul Waheed did not stop construction and continued the construction on the Panchayat Ghar. Due to the continuing unlawful act of the appellant, contempt proceedings were initiated against him and the case was listed for hearing on 6-11-1974. One day before the hearing date i.e. 5-11-1974, at about 8.00 p.m., the complainant was sitting near the chhabutra of the well along with Abbas, Shubrati and Israr discussing about the court hearing. At that time, Abdul Hai, appellant Abdul Waheed, Vakil Khan, Babu, Shafiq, Mukhtiar, Javed and Hafeez came there and abused them giving a warning that they would be killed if they proceeded to the court next day. Abbas replied back saying that he has instituted the suit and he will pursue the matter. Appellant Abdul Waheed, Abdul Hai and Shafiq were armed with licensed guns, while the rest had lathis and dandas. On hearing the altercations, Ashfaq, Ishtiyaq, Yasim Khan, Ali Daraj and Mohd. Yaseen came to the spot and intervened saying that the court would decide the issue. Abdul Waheed and Shafiq exhorted others to break the bones, whereupon Babu, Vakil, Mukhtiyar, Javed and Hafeez started inflicting injuries by giving lathi-blows. Ishtiyaq and Ashfaq used lathis in defence. The accused Abdul Hai, Abdul Waheed and Shafiq opened fire on the complainant party. Abdul Waheed's gunshot directly hit Abbas in his arm and Abbas sustained fracture injuries and he died little thereafter. Israr was also hit by pellets and sustained gunshot injuries.

    3. On the complaint lodged by Razzaq Khan (PW 1), a case was registered in Crime Case No. 313 of 1974 at Police Station Kamalganj under Sections 147, 148, 302, 302/149 and 302/149 IPC and Bisheshwar Singh, Sub-Inspector of Police (PW 7) had taken up the investigation. Injured Ashfaq Khan, Ishtiyaq Khan, Razzaq Khan and Shubrati were admitted in Primary Health Centre Kamalganj and after first aid they were referred to District Hospital, Fatehgarh where they were treated. Dr H.D. Gupta conducted post-mortem on the body of Abbas on 6-11-1974 and issued post-mortem certificate (Ext. Ka-25) opining that Abbas died of shock and haemorrhage due to injuries sustained by him.

    4. Injured Israr Khan was admitted as indoor patient in District Hospital, Fatehgarh and he was discharged from the hospital on 18-11-1974. Thereafter Israr was again admitted in the hospital on 14-12-1974 complaining of intestinal obstruction. On 16-12-1974, dying declaration of Israr Khan (Ext. Ka-28) was recorded in the District Hospital by Shri Vinai Kumar (PW 13), the then SDM Sadar. Dr Sabir Hussain has given a certificate (Ext. Ka-17) that Israr Khan was in a fit state of mind to give dying declaration. Despite treatment Israr Khan died on 18-12-1974. Dr S. Tandon (PW 10) conducted the autopsy on the body of deceased Israr Khan and issued post-mortem certificate (Ext. Ka-24) opining that the death was due to shock as septic peritonitis which according to the doctor, Israr could have developed for want of proper treatment of injuries. After due investigation charge-sheet was filed against the accused on 7-1-1975 under Sections 147, 148, 302 IPC read with Section 149 IPC (two counts).

    5. To bring home the guilt of the accused, the prosecution has examined thirteen witnesses. On behalf of the accused, defence has examined two witnesses. Upon consideration of the evidence, the Second Additional District and Sessions Judge, Farrukhabad vide judgment dated 31-3-1981 convicted the appellant Abdul Waheed under Section 302 IPC for murder of Abbas Khan and sentenced him to undergo life imprisonment. Other seven accused persons were convicted for murder of Abbas Khan under Section 302 IPC read with Section 149 IPC and each of them were sentenced to undergo life imprisonment. All the eight persons were convicted under Sections 302/149 IPC for the murder of Israr Khan and each of them were sentenced to undergo life imprisonment. Accused Abdul Hai, Abdul Waheed and Shafiq were also convicted under Section 148 IPC. All the eight accused persons were also convicted under Sections 323/149 IPC. Aggrieved by the verdict of conviction, the accused persons preferred appeal before the Allahabad High Court which vide impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 796 of 1981 confirmed the conviction of the appellant Abdul Waheed as awarded by the trial court and partly allowed the appeal qua other accused as aforesaid. This appeal assails the correctness of the impugned judgment.

    6. Taking us through the evidence and the material on record, Mr Salman Khurshid, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant assailed the conviction inter alia on the grounds: (i) the discrepancy as to the place of occurrence; (ii) complainant party were the aggressors; and (iii) conviction of the appellant could only be under Section 304 Part II IPC and not under Section 302 IPC. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that the incident took place near the chhabutra of Shafiq where Shafiq and co-accused Vakil and Hafeez were sitting and not in the place and manner as put forth by the prosecution. It was further submitted that the investigating officer did not find any blood spot at the alleged place of occurrence i.e. in front of door of Abbas. It was further submitted that the accused party were not the aggressors and only deceased Abbas Khan and Israr were armed with gun and pistol, respectively and the investigating officer recovered a gun belonging to the deceased Abbas Khan from the place of occurrence but the prosecution has failed to explain as to how the gun was found there and the material lapses in the prosecution case were not properly appreciated by the High Court.

    7. Per contra, Mr Ratnakar Dash, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent submitted that the prosecution has established the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt and the trial court rightly convicted the appellant for committing the murder of Abbas Khan and the High Court rightly dismissed the appeal.

    8. We have carefully considered the rival contentions and perused the impugned judgment and material on record.

    9. Shabbir Khan and Abbas filed Civil Suit No. 110 of 1974 (Ext. Ka-40) alleging that the appellant Abdul Waheed has started construction of his house over the site of Panchayat Ghar. On the application of Abbas Khan, the Munsif Court vide order dated 17-4-1974 passed the order of status quo. Ext. Ka-41 is the copy of the Commissioner's Report and map in the aforesaid suit. Ext. Ka-42 is the application moved by Shabir Khan in the aforesaid Suit No. 110 of 1974 for taking action against the appellant Abdul Waheed under Order 39 Rule 2 CPC which was registered as Miscellaneous Case No. 65 of 1974 and the same was scheduled to be heard on the next date of the incident i.e. 6-11-1974. By the evidence of PW 1 and by the aforesaid documents prosecution has established the motive of the accused. Admittedly, the accused persons were close relations of the appellant-accused hence they also rendered a helping hand in the commission of the crime and all of them formed an unlawful assembly with common intention of inflicting injuries to the complainant party. There is plausible and cogent evidence establishing motive of the accused person for committing the alleged crime. Proof of motive of the accused towards the deceased heightens the possibility of the crime. Proof of motive adds weight and value to the evidence of the eyewitnesses.

    10. Prosecution has mainly relied on the testimony of three eyewitnesses Razzaq Khan (PW 1), Yasin Khan (PW 3) and Ali Daraj (PW 4). PWs 1, 3 and 4 have spoken in one voice about the overt acts of the accused. PW 1 Razzaq Khan being injured witness, his evidence stands on a higher footing. Unless there are cogent and convincing grounds, evidence of PW 1 injured witness cannot be doubted. PW 3's house is at a distance of 30 to 35 paces towards the west of the house of Abbas Khan and his presence on the spot is quite natural. At the time of occurrence PWs 3 and 4 were present in the house of PW 3 and on hearing the hues and cries of the occurrence, both of them rushed to the spot and their evidence is fully corroborated by the evidence of PW 1. The courts below recorded concurrent findings of fact that the evidence of PWs 1, 3 and 4 remains unshaken and in spite of lengthy cross-examination of these witnesses, the accused were not able to bring any point shaking credibility of PWs 1, 3 and 4.

    11. The learned Senior Counsel for the appellant contended that the appellant Abdul Waheed and the accused party were not the aggressors and that the fateful incident took place near the chhabutra of Shafiq where co-accused Vakil Khan, Hafeez were sitting and discussing the strategy of the contempt case listed on 6-11-1974 and at that moment deceased Abbas and Israr armed with gun and pistol, respectively along with other accused armed with lathis came there hurling abuses and an altercation took place between both the parties and Razzaq Khan had given lathi-blows to Vakil Khan and Hafeez and Abbas fired from his gun and only to show that the accused party were the aggressors, the scene of occurrence was shifted as chhabutra of Abbas. As per prosecution version, in the evening of 5-11-1974, PW 1 was sitting on the chhabutra of the well situated in front of the house of Abbas Khan and the accused party came and fired gunshot injuries and attacked them with lathis. The controversy between the parties is about the exact location of the place of occurrence. Admittedly, both parties have stated that after the wordy altercation on account of civil dispute, the fight ensued between them. PW 1 and other witnesses have spoken consistently about the place of occurrence being chhabutra of Abbas. If the occurrence had taken place at the chhabutra of Shafiq Khan as alleged by the defence, then it was expected that some blood would have been found near the chhabutra of the house of Shafiq; the fact that no blood was found at the chhabutra of Shafiq Khan improbabilises the defence version.

    12. On behalf of the accused it was contended that the complainant party were the aggressors and deceased Abbas Khan and Israr armed with gun and pistol respectively along with other persons armed with lathis came to chhabutra of Shafiq Khan hurling abuses and the complainant gave lathi-blows to Vakil Khan and Hafeez and Abbas Khan opened fire from his gun as a result of which accused viz. Vakil Khan and Hafeez sustained injuries and the prosecution has suppressed genesis of the occurrence. Evidence of PW 2 Dr G.M. Solanki, of course shows that the accused persons, namely, Mohd. Hafeez and Vakil Khan sustained simple injuries (Exts. Ka-6 and Ka-43). Prosecution is obliged to explain injuries sustained by the accused, if it is not trivial in nature. The injuries sustained by Mohd. Hafeez and Vakil Khan were simple injuries. However, the prosecution has sufficiently explained the injuries sustained by the accused even at the time of registration of the FIR as in defence Ishtiyaq and Ashfaq inflicted blows with lathis on the accused party. As discussed earlier, the accused party were armed with guns, pistols and lathis, the injuries sustained by the complainant party and that there were two deaths on the side of the complainant party and the injuries sustained by them would clearly prove that the accused party were the aggressors. The truth of the matter is that the accused were the aggressors and the accused Vakil Khan and Hafeez Khan received minor simple injuries of blunt weapons at the hands of Ishtiyaq and Ashfaq Khan who wielded lathis in lawful exercise of their right of private defence.

    13. The prosecution version is assailed contending that the prosecution has not explained the recovery of third gun from the scene of occurrence. The learned Senior Counsel for the appellant contended that three allegedly recovered empty cartridges were sent to ballistic expert, PW 8 who has given a certificate (Ext. Ka-23) that two of the said cartridges were fired from Gun No. 3696-69 i.e. the gun allegedly recovered from co-accused Abdul Hai and the third cartridge was not fired from either of the two guns and in the absence of the recovery of third gun, the version of the prosecution becomes highly doubtful. Be it noted that although it is proved that two cartridges were fired from the gun recovered from the accused, from the statement adduced by the three eyewitnesses it is evident that Abdul Waheed had a gun and he fired one shot from his gun. The said cartridges could have been fired possibly from the gun of appellant Abdul Waheed which was not recovered. Non-recovery of gun from the appellant nor opinion of ballistic expert regarding three cartridges does not in any way raise doubts about the prosecution case and the involvement of the appellant.

    14. The learned Senior Counsel Mr Salman Khurshid further urged that gunshot fired by the appellant hit Abbas on his arm which is not a vital part of the body and the appellant cannot be held guilty of the murder. By perusal of the post-mortem certificate (Ext. Ka-25), it is seen that Abbas sustained following injuries:

    (i) Gunshot wound 1½″ × ½″ × bone-deep on the front and inner side of right upper arm. 3½″ above elbow with fracture of the shaft of humerus bone.
    (ii) Multiple gunshot wound of exit of varying dimensions from 1/8″ × 1/8″ × 1/10″ × 1/10″ in middle part of right upper arm with everted margins.
    (iii) Abrasion 1/2″ × 1/2″ on the right side of tip of nose.

    The doctor recovered twelve shots from the wounds and Dr H.D. Gupta opined that the death of the deceased Abbas was due to shock and haemorrhage as a result of injuries sustained by him.

    15. The appellant and the accused party were having enmity against the deceased Abbas Khan on account of civil suit and filing of contempt petition. The appellant and the accused party went to chhabutra of Abbas Khan armed with pistol, guns and lathis which shows the intention of the appellant to commit the murder. An ordinary person is not presumed to know the precise location of the arteries in the human limbs. Therefore, if a stab with a knife or dagger, aimed at an arm or a leg, severs an artery and the injured man dies as a result, it may be reasonable to argue that the offence is not one of culpable homicide and that the assailant can only be presumed to have intended to cause hurt or grievous hurt with a dangerous weapon. The case in hand is quite different. When gun is used and the person who fires the gun must be presumed to have knowledge and intention that he is inflicting an injury which in the ordinary course of nature is sufficient to cause death and the offence is clearly murder. Having regard to the enmity and the weapon used, the courts below rightly held that the appellant-accused was guilty of committing the murder of Abbas Khan.

    16. On behalf of the appellant it was stated that the occurrence was of the year 1974 and the appellant is aged about ninety years and sending him to prison at this distant point of time would be harsh. We are not impressed with this submission. In the occurrence when two persons died and number of others were injured, in our view, age of the accused is of no relevance. Undue sympathy would do more harm to the criminal justice system undermining the public confidence in the efficacy of the system. It is therefore the duty of every court to award proper sentence having regard to the manner in which the offence was committed. The trial court and the High Court have recorded concurrent findings and the findings are based upon evidence warranting no interference in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution of India.

    17. The appeal is dismissed. The appellant is on bail. His bail bonds are cancelled. He shall be taken into custody forthwith to serve the remaining sentence.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Abdul Waheed v. State Of Uttar Pradesh .
    (Sep 1, 2015)