Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rent Control Acts
  • Section 24(5) of the H.P. Urban Rent Control Act, 1987 (for short 'Act')
  • Section 2(e)
  • Rent Control Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rent Control Acts
  • Section 24(5) of the H.P. Urban Rent Control Act, 1987 (for short 'Act')
  • Section 2(e)
  • Rent Control Act
Smart Summary

High Court of Himachal Pradesh — Civil Revisions Nos. 4 & 39 of 2008 (Judgment dated 20 Aug 2016)

Factual and Procedural Background

The matter arises from eviction proceedings under Section 14 of the H.P. Urban Rent Control Act, 1987 ("the Act"). The landlord (Shri Abhijit Rai) filed an eviction petition before the Rent Controller (Court No.3, Shimla) seeking eviction of the tenant (originally Dr. Kharak Singh, later substituted by Brig. (Retd.) R.S. Verma) on multiple grounds: (i) that the premises had been rented out as a shop but were being used for residential purposes (including cessation of medical practice by the tenant), (ii) that the tenant had acquired vacant possession of other premises (No.23, Boileauganj) post-termination of lease and let them out to another (Bhag Singh), and (iii) that alternative accommodation ("Glue Moon Cottage") was available and sufficient for the tenant's needs.

The Rent Controller framed issues on 08.11.2005 and decided issues Nos.1 to 3 in favour of the landlord, allowing eviction. The tenant appealed to the first Appellate Authority which reversed the Rent Controller on issues Nos.1 and 2 (user and impairment of utility/value) but affirmed the finding on issue No.3 (acquisition of vacant possession of property No.23) and maintained the eviction order. Both parties filed separate civil revisions under Section 24(5) of the Act: Civil Revision No.4 (Brig. R.S. Verma v. Abhijit Rai) challenging the finding on issue No.3, and Civil Revision No.39 (Abhijit Rai v. Brig. R.S. Verma) challenging the reversal on issues Nos.1 and 2. The High Court heard both petitions together and reserved judgment on 27.07.2016; judgment was delivered on 20.08.2016.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent (tenant) changed the user of the demised premises without the permission of the landlord (i.e., whether the premises were non-residential as rented or were being used residentially)?
  2. Whether the acts of the respondent impaired the utility and commercial value of the premises?
  3. Whether the respondent had acquired vacant possession of property No.23, Boileauganj, Shimla and thereby had alternative accommodation sufficient for his requirement?
  4. Are the petition and the landlord's claim maintainable in present form, including questions of lack of material particulars, locus standi of the landlord, and non-joinder of legal heirs?
  5. What relief (eviction and incidental reliefs) should follow if the landlord's grounds are established?

Arguments of the Parties

Contestant Tenant's (Brig. R.S. Verma) Arguments

  • The Appellate Authority erred in affirming the eviction order as regards issue No.3 by concluding the tenant-petitioner had acquired vacant possession of residential accommodation; that affirmation was said to be legally unsound ( Civil Revision No.4).
  • Preliminary objections raised at the Rent Controller stage: petition allegedly not maintainable in current form, lacking material particulars, landlord had no locus standi, non-joinder/mis-joinder of parties, petition malafide, and absence of cause of action.
  • On merits, the tenant contended the premises were used for residential purposes from the inception; only the front room facing the road was used to attend patients occasionally (with landlord's knowledge/consent), and therefore there was no change of user or impairment of utility.
  • The tenant denied acquisition of vacant possession of No.23, Boileauganj and denied letting it out as alleged; claimed Glue Moon Cottage was not fit for habitation (and thus unavailable as alternative accommodation).

Landlord's (Shri Abhijit Rai) Arguments

  • The premises had been given as a shop/commercial unit and were converted to residential use by the tenant; the landlord sought eviction on that ground.
  • The tenant had, after termination of an earlier lease, acquired vacant possession of part of property No.23, Boileauganj on 01.09.1997 and had let that accommodation out (to Bhag Singh), indicating availability of alternative accommodation.
  • The landlord maintained the tenant was not occupying available alternative accommodation and therefore eviction was justified under Section 14(3)(a)(iv) of the Act.
  • In Civil Revision No.39 the landlord argued the Appellate Authority's reversal of the Rent Controller's findings on issues Nos.1 and 2 was perverse and should be set aside.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Joginder Pal v. Naval Kishore Behal (2002) 5 SCC 397 Rent control legislation should be interpreted balancing tenants' protection with landlords' rights; courts may lean in favour of landlords when interpreting provisions that protect landlords; reasonable and balanced approach required. The Court relied on this authority to stress that while rent laws historically favour tenants, the Act must be interpreted to give landlords their statutory reliefs and that provisions protecting landlords should be meaningfully construed. This supported dismissal of the revisions and affirmed that landlords' entitlement to possession where grounds are made out should not be unduly curtailed.
Sidhharth Viyas & another v. Ravi Nath Misra & others (2015) 2 SCC 701 The object of rent law is to balance competing claims; a tenant who has already acquired alternative accommodation is not intended to be protected by the Rent Act. The Court cited this decision to support the proposition that a tenant with alternative accommodation need not be shielded from eviction; it applied the principle to facts showing the tenant had alternative accommodation and therefore eviction could be sustained.
Prabhakaran Nair v. State of T.N. (1987) 4 SCC 238 Contextual background for rent control laws: acute housing shortage and need for rational and humane laws balancing owners' and tenants' interests. Cited as part of the jurisprudential backdrop emphasizing the need for balanced construction of rent legislation; used to reinforce the Court's balanced interpretative approach.
Malpe Vishwanath Acharya v. State of Maharashtra (1998) 2 SCC 1 Social legislation like Rent Control Acts must strike a balance between rival interests so laws are just; avoid disproportionate benefits to one section. Referred to when explaining that the Act protects both tenants and landlords and that a balanced approach should guide interpretation and relief.
Arjun Khiamal Makhijani v. Jamnadas C. Tuliani (1989) 4 SCC 612 Provisions in rent control laws can be categorized into those beneficial to tenants and those to landlords; a provision beneficial to landlords need not be strained in favour of tenants. Used to justify that provisions favorable to landlords should be given their due effect and not artificially read down to favour tenants inappropriately.
Bega Begum v. Abdul Ahad Khan (1979) 1 SCC 273 Guard against artificial extension or strained construction of landlord-favourable provisions; ensure landlord reliefs remain meaningful. Applied to caution against interpretations that would make it impracticable for landlords to obtain eviction on recognized statutory grounds.
Kewal Singh v. Smt Lajwanti (1980) 1 SCC 290 Rent control legislation should not be construed to destroy limited reliefs granted to landlords; the intent is to balance. Invoked to support the view that landlord reliefs under the Act must be preserved and properly construed to be effective.
Shiv Sarup Gupta v. Mahesh Chand Gupta (1999) 6 SCC 222 Concept of bona fide need/genuine requirement requires a practical approach informed by realities of life; guard against overly pedantic constructions. Referred to when assessing the genuineness of claimed requirement and whether acquisition of alternative accommodation negates tenant protection; supported the Court's practical assessment of facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by addressing each ground of eviction separately (referred to as Point Nos.1, 2 and 3 in the judgment), applying statutory definitions, factual findings and settled principles from precedent.

Point No.1 (Change of user / Residential vs Non-residential):

  • The Court examined statutory definitions in the Act: "residential building" defined negatively as any building not non-residential; "non-residential building" defined as a building used "mainly for the purpose of business or trade" (i.e., dominant user). The Court emphasised that the dominant/primary user determines the character.
  • On the evidence, the Court found credible testimony (RW-1 Prem Singh, RW-2 Brig. R.S. Verma, RW-3 K.C. Bhagra) that only the front room facing the road was used as a clinic while the rest of the premises were used for residence. The landlord's case rested largely on a bald statement by PW-1 and lacked supporting documentary proof that the entire premises had been given as a shop.
  • Accordingly, the Court concurred with the Appellate Authority's reversal of the Rent Controller on the question of change of user: the premises were predominantly residential.

Point No.2 (Impairment of value and utility):

  • The Court observed the landlord had not led evidence to show that the acts of the tenant impaired the value and utility of the premises. The Appellate Authority's findings on this point were held to be free from interference.

Point No.3 (Acquisition of alternative accommodation / vacant possession of No.23 and Glue Moon Cottage):

  • The Court accepted that the tenant (through admissions and evidence) had acquired vacant possession of part of property No.23, Boileauganj and had let out accommodation to Bhag Singh; this fact was admitted by the tenant as RW-2.
  • The Court compiled the accommodation in the tenant's possession as of the record: the disputed premises (third floor portion), an equivalent accommodation on the second floor taken on rent since 1950, six rooms in "Glue Moon Cottage", a building at Faridabad, and ownership of four-storeyed Building No.23 receiving rent. The Court noted the tenant mainly resided at Faridabad.
  • The Court rejected the tenant's assertion that Glue Moon Cottage was uninhabitable: the earlier tenant (PW-2 P.M. Pardeshi) testified Glue Moon Cottage was not dilapidated at vacation. Even if it had been in disrepair later, the Court held that failure to occupy the alternative accommodation promptly (and the tenant's financial ability as a retired Brigadier) undermined the tenant's defence.
  • The Court emphasised that letting out the vacated premises (No.23) and not occupying available alternative accommodation, particularly when the tenant was mainly resident in Faridabad and received rents from properties including No.23, supported the finding that the tenant's requirement in Shimla was not genuine.
  • On this basis the Court found that the eviction order as maintained on issue No.3 was warranted.

Use of Precedents and Interpretative Approach:

  • The Court applied authoritative principles from Supreme Court decisions (notably Joginder Pal; Sidhharth Viyas) emphasising that rent legislation must be interpreted in a balanced manner — protecting tenants but not at the cost of rendering landlord remedies nugatory.
  • The Court observed that where a tenant has alternative accommodation, he is not intended to be protected by the Act; this principle informed the Court's conclusion that eviction was permissible when the tenant had other accommodation.

Credibility and Motive:

  • The Court found aspects of the tenant's case false or self-serving: admission of letting out vacated premises, claim of Glue Moon Cottage being uninhabitable contradicted by prior tenant's evidence, and indications that the tenant sought to retain a low-rent palatial premises while receiving higher rents from other properties and attempting to negotiate purchase of the building.
  • These findings led the Court to conclude the tenant pursued a strategy inconsistent with a bona fide requirement to continue occupation of the disputed premises.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Both civil revision petitions (Civil Revision Nos. 4 & 39 of 2008) were dismissed by the High Court. The Court affirmed the eviction order insofar as it rested on the tenant's acquisition of alternative accommodation and the related findings sustaining eviction.

Consequences and Orders:

  • The tenant (contestant tenant / Brig. R.S. Verma) was directed to pay costs of litigation assessed at Rs.30,000/- to the landlord; the Court clarified that this cost order would not prevent the landlord from seeking mesne profits, in accordance with rates the competent authority may determine.
  • All pending applications, if any, were disposed of. The Registry was directed to place a copy of this judgment on the file of Civil Revision No.39 of 2008.

Implications for Law:

The decision applies settled principles from higher courts regarding a balanced approach to rent legislation and reaffirms that a tenant's acquisition of alternative accommodation and non-occupation of available premises can justify eviction. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal proposition; it applies established precedents to the facts and enforces the landlord's statutory remedies where grounds are satisfactorily proved.

Judgment delivered by: Tarlok Singh Chauhan, Judge — dated 20th August 2016.

    Brig (Retd.) R.S. Verma-Tenant v. Abhijit Rai

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA

    Civil Revision Nos. 4 & 39 of 2008 . Judgment reserved on: 27.07 . .20 P 16. Date of decision: August 20 th , 2016.

    1. Civil Revision No.4 of 2008. H Brig (Retd.) R.S.Verma o f …..Tenant-Petitioner. Versus

    Abhijit Rai r t …..Respondent. For the Petitioner : u Mr.Bhupender Gupta, Senior Advocate with Mr.Neeraj Gupta, Advocate. For the Respondent: o

    Mr.Vinay Kuthiala, Senior Advocate with Mr.Suneet Goel, Advocate.

    2. Civil Revis io C n No.39 of 2008. Abhijit R h ai …..Petitioner/Landlord. g Versus B i rig (Retd.) R.S. Verma ……Respondent/Tenant. H For the Petitioner : Mr.Vinay Kuthiala, Senior Advocate with Mr.Suneet Goel, Advocate. For the Respondent: Mr.Bhupender Gupta, Senior Advocate with Mr.Neeraj Gupta, Advocate. Coram The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Tarlok Singh Chauhan, Judge.

    Whether approved for reporting?1Yes

    Tarlok Singh Chauhan, Judge.

    These revision petitions under Section 24(5) of the H.P. Urban Rent Control Act, 1987 (for short 'Act') have been filed against the order passed by the learned Appellate Authority, Shimla, on 04.12.2007 whereby it partly reversed the findings recorded by the learned Rent Controller, Court No.3, Shimla and ordered eviction of the

    Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?Yes

    1

    2

    tenant on the ground that the predecessor-in-interest of the tenant/respondent had acquired vacant possession of part of hi . s property No.23, Boileauganj, Shimla, on 01.09.1997 within the P same urban area and sufficient for his requirement and s H ince h.e did not occupy the same, he rendered himself liable to b f e evicted under the provisions of Section 14(3) (a) (iv) of the Act. The facts, in brief, can be sum m o ed up thus. 2. The respondent-landlo r rd t (hereinafter referred to as the landlord) filed an application under Section 14 of the Act for eviction of the petitioner on the follo o wing u grounds:- "(i) The premises were rented out as a shop to the

    re sp C ondent/tenant. It is submitted that the respondent was using premises for his medical practice. It may be further h submitted that respondent is now more than 100 years old g

    and has stopped his medical practice more than 10 years i

    back. Since the shop was lying vacant for more than a year, a case No.62-202/98-97 was filed and is being

    H

    adjudicated upon before the Hon'ble Rent Controller III. In his pleadings the respondent has stated that he and his family members are using the premises for residential purposes. As such the respondent has used the premises for a purpose other than that for which it was leased. This

    act of the respondent has impaired the utility and

    commercial value of the premises. The act of using the

    premises for residential purposes has been done without

    the consent of the landlord, as such this petition.

    (ii) That tenant/respondent whenever in Shimla, lives in the IInd floor which is below shop floor which is a residential flat and has been rented by him for residential use. The tenant/respondent has after the termination of this lease in 1995 acquired vacant possession of a part of his property No.23, Boileauganj, Shimla on 1.9.97 and premises have been let out by him to one Shri Bhag Singh at a rent of

    3

    Rs.800/- per month. As shop flat is being also used for residential purpose as stated by him in his reply referred t . o above, his requirement in addition to IInd floor could be met by the accommodation which he has rented to S . hr P i Bhag Singh.

    (iii) The tenant/respondent has admitted in his H written reply in case 62-2 of 98/97 before Rent Co f ntroller No.3, Shimla, that in winter he goes to Faridabad and stays there with his son. His son, Brig. R.S.Verm a w o ith whom respondent lives in Faridabad, has acquired from two tenants vacant

    possession of Building t No.12, Glue Moon Cottage,

    Boileauganj, Shim u la urnder the orders of Rent Controller IV, Shimla o , dated 20.4.1992 (copy enclosed) for his personal use. As his son Dr.R.S.Verma is residing with him when C he is in Shimla, there is no reason why respondent an d his son cannot live in Glue Moon Cottage and vacate h the premises under consideration. The two properties available to the tenant and his son are adequate for

    ig

    meeting their requirements." H 3. The tenant Dr.Kharak Singh Atrishi was though served but before filing written reply he unfortunately died and was substituted by Brigadier R.S.Verma (who hereinafter shall be referred as the contesting tenant).

    4. In the reply filed by the contesting tenant, a number of preliminary objections regarding petition being not maintainable in its present form, lacking material particular, landlord having no locus- standi, non-joinder and mis-joinder of parties, petition being malafide, there being no cause of action in favour of the landlord etc. etc. were raised.

    5. On merits, it was averred that the premises were not non- residential as is claimed but were being used for residence since the father of the contesting tenant was a doctor, who used to attend his

    4

    patients as and when required in the front room of the premises facing the road. While, the user of the premises right from the inception of th . e tenancy had remained unchanged and whatever the c . on P testing respondent was doing in the premises was with the consent and knowledge of the landlord. It was averred that the pre H mises were not

    taken for medical practice alone and that the origin f al tenant till his death

    was living in the premises in question alo ng o with his family consisting of two sons, daughter-in-laws, daugh r ters t and grand children. It was only when he grew old (about 100 years) that he on account of old age and poor health was not in a o posit u ion to attend any of his patients. 6. It was denied that the tenant had used the premises for a

    purpose other tha C n that for which it was leased. 7. h It was further denied that the utility or the commercial value of g the premises had been impaired and the user of the premises r i emained residential one which was never changed. H 8. Similarly, the averments regarding the tenant having acquired vacant possession of property No.23, Boileauganj and having let out the same to one Bhag Singh at the rent of `800/- per month were denied and it was averred that the tenant as well as his family members

    have been using both the floors as both the floors form one compact

    single unit and it was denied that the respondent had acquired any such

    possession of the said premises.

    9. As regards "Glue Moon Cottage", it was averred that the respondent had not acquired any such accommodation which was sufficient for his family needs. Though, Glue Moon Cottage had been got vacated, but it was not fit for habitation and being an old building had out-lived its life and required reconstruction involving heavy

    5

    amount of expenses and at present tenant was not in a position to carry out the same on account of paucity of funds being a retired person. .

    10. On 08.11.2005, the learned Rent Controller fram P ed the following issues:- .

    "1) Whether the respondent has changed the user of the premises without permission of landlo f rd, asH alleged? …OPP. 2) Whether the respondent has committed such acts which have impaired the value an d o utility of the premises as alleged? …OPP.

    3) Whether the responde r nt t has acquired vacant possession of his property No.23 at Boileauganj, Shimla, as alleged?

    …OPP.

    4) Whether th o e petiution is not maintainable in present form as alleged? …OPR.

    5) W he C ther the petition lacks material particulars, as alleged? h …OPR. 6) Whether the petitioner has no locus standi to file the g

    present petition as alleged? …OPR. i

    7) Whether the petition is bad for non-joinder of the legal heirs of Dr.Kharak Singh, as alleged? …OPR. H

    8) Relief." 11. The learned Rent Controller decided issues No.1 to 3 in favour of the landlord and allowed the petition and ordered the eviction of the contesting tenant.

    12. Aggrieved by the order of eviction passed by the learned Rent Controller, the contesting tenant filed an appeal before the learned first Appellate Authority, who reversed the findings recorded by the learned Rent Controller qua issues No.1 and 2, however, the findings recorded on issue No.3 were affirmed. Consequently, the orders of eviction of the tenant were maintained.

    13. The contesting tenant has assailed the findings of the learned first Appellate Authority qua issue No.3 by filing Civil Revision

    6

    No.4 of 2008, titled "Brig (Retd.) R.S.Verma versus Shri Abhijit Rai", whereas, landlord has filed Civil Revision No.39 of 2008, title . d

    "Sh.Abhijit Rai versus Brig (Retd.) R.S.Verma" and assailed ther P ein the findings rendered by the learned first Appellate Authority H on iss.ues No.1 and 2. I have heard the learned couns o el for f the

    parties and gone

    through the records of the case.

    14. It is vehemently argue r d b t y S hri Bhupender Gupta, Senior Advocate assisted by Shri u Neeraj Gupta, Advocate, for the current tenant that though the learned Appellate Authority has rightly reversed the findings of the learn o ed Rent Controller on issues No.1 and 2, but

    has gravely er red C in law by affirming the eviction order on issue No.3 concludin h g thereby that the tenant-petitioner had acquired vacant possession of residential accommodation. 1 i 5. g On the other hand, Shri Vinay Kuthiala, Senior Advocate H assisted by Shri Suneet Goel, Advocate, for the landlord has argued that the findings recorded by the learned lower appellate Court reversing the findings recorded by the learned Rent Controller on issues No.1 and 2 are perverse and are, therefore, required to be set

    aside.

    16. Having considered the rival contentions, it would be necessary to have a glance over the evidence led by the parties.

    17. PW-1, V.R.Vaish, is the Special Power of Attorney of the landlord and stated that property No.25, Boileauganj, Shimla was given to him and his brother Dr.Tara Chand in family settlement mark P-1. He stated that demised premises were given to Dr.Kharak Singh in 1935 vide lease agreement Mark P-2. He stated that tenancy was terminated

    7

    in the year 1995 vide letter Mark P-3 sent on the address of Boileaugan . j and Faridabad address of the current tenant. He stated that letters were sent through registered AD covers Mark P-4, Mark P-5 and P postal

    receipt is Mark P-6. He stated that the demised premise H s were. given to the tenant as shop. He further stated that a case had been filed against the tenant before the learned Rent Controll o er (3) f , S

    himla and in reply

    the tenant had stated that the premises is being used for residential

    purposes, copy of the reply is Ma r rk P t -7 . He further deposed that the tenant was having his own u house at Boileauganj known as "Moon House" (should be 'Glu o e Moon") and after his retirement had got two sets vacated from two tenants.

    18. In cr C oss-examination, the witness stated that the tenancy was term h inated by him in the capacity of 'Karta' in the year 1995. He den g ied the suggestion that original tenant Kharak Singh had been r i esiding alongwith his family in the demised premises comprised of four H rooms, one glazed verandah, kitchen and toilet in the third floor. He admitted that lateron Kharak Singh had taken on rent a floor of the demised premises in the year 1950. The rental of the building `1958/- was not disputed, however, it was denied that the "Moon House" was in

    a dilapidated condition.

    19. PW-2, P.M.Pardeshi, is the erstwhile tenant of "Glue Moon Cottage" and stated that he had been tenant under Dr. Kharak Singh from April 13, 1961 to March 31, 1996 and further stated that he had vacated the premises in the year 1996 after the eviction orders had been passed against him in a petition filed by Dr.Kharak Singh on the ground of personal requirement.

    8

    20. In cross-examination, the witness denied that the premises vacated by him were dilapidated and not in an habitable condition. .

    21. The current tenant, on the other hand, examined P Prem Singh as RW-1, who stated that he was a frequent visitor to t.he house of Dr.Kharak Singh, who was having two f storey H ed building in Boileauganj known as "25, Tara Niwas". o He state d that Dr. Kharak

    Singh was using first room of shop floo r as clinic and the remaining accommodation was being used for re t sidential purpose. He stated that after the death of Kharak Sing u h, his r two sons and three daughters were residing in the demised o premises. He further stated that he had seen "Glue Moon Cottage" which was in a dilapidated condition. He also stated that Br iga C dier R.S.Verma son of Dr. Kharak Singh is also a doctor by h profession and is using the clinic for attending patients. 22. g In cross-examination, the witness stated that all the c i hildren of Kharak Singh are married. However, he feigned ignorance H regarding the number of tenants in the building owned by Dr. Kharak Singh in House No.23, Boileauganj, but stated that the building was four storeyed and its rent was being received by Brigadier R.S.Verma. He further stated that Dr. Kharak Singh stopped his medical practice

    1-2 years before his death. He denied that the demised premises were

    rented out only for medical practice. He further denied that except

    Brigadier R.S.Verma, no other family member was residing in the

    demised premises.

    23. RW-2 is Brigadier R.S.Verma, current tenant, who has stated that House No.25 is a five storeyed building and known as "Tara Niwas". The third floor of this building was taken on rent by his father in and around 1930 and stated that first room was being used as a clinic

    9

    while the remaining was being used for residential purpose. The building was taken on rent from the father of V.S.Vaish. Thereafter, in .

    the year 1950 on account of increase in the family, they had P taken second floor below the floor in question on rent and the en.trance of both the floors was common from the main gate. He H stated that his father had died at the age of 100 years and at tha f t ti me his brother and sisters were residing with him in the demise o d premises and there was no change of user and addition in the t de mised premises and the same was put to use for the purpos u e to w r hich it had been taken on rent. He admitted in his cross- o examination that his father had let out the premises to Bhag Singh, but then tried to explain that it was with the consent of oth er C co-owners. He further stated that the landlord had not carried o h ut the repairs. He also stated that the landlord intended to sell the g entire building and had approached him for purchasing the same a i nd he had offered `17 lacs, but the landlord had not reverted back to H him. He also stated that the property No.23 was their ancestral property in which there were 20-25 co-sharers. He stated that "Glue Moon Cottage" was got vacated from P.M.Pardeshi (PW-2) but the condition of the same at the time of its vacation was not habitable.

    24. In cross-examination, the witness admitted that the agreement Mark P-2 was executed in between late Mithan Lal and late Dr. Kharak Singh. He did not dispute that the demised premises falls within the jurisdiction of Municipal Corporation. No records could be produced by the witness in support of his claim that except him, his family is also residing with him in the demised premises. He acknowledged that building No.23 Boileauganj was four storeyed building and he was not having any litigation with any of the tenants

    10

    residing therein. He further admitted that he was not a professional doctor, but had been attending to "old cases". He admitted that hi . s sisters were married but would claim that younger sister was ma P rried at Shimla itself. He further denied that the accommoda H tion in. building No.23 was sufficient for his family members. He admitted that during the illness of his father, he shifted to F o aridab f ad

    where his father

    ultimately died. He further stated that ex cept for the shop portion, the demised premises was being used r for t residential purpose. 25. RW-3, K.C.Bhag u ra, has stated that he knows Dr.R.S. Verma for the last 20 years and his father had been running a clinic in the front room while rem o aining portion of the premises was being used

    for residence, th C e user of which has not been changed till date. He

    further st h ated that he had seen "Glue Moon Cottage", which according to h g im, was in a dilapidated condition. 2 i 6. In cross-examination, he admitted that contesting tenant H alongwith his family members was residing in the demised premises which was 50-60 years old. He further reiterated that "Glue Moon" building was not in a habitable condition. This in entirety is the oral and documentary evidence led

    by the parties.

    27. As noticed above, the landlord has sought eviction of the contesting tenant on three distinct grounds as reproduced in para-2 (supra) and for each ground, distinct issues came to be framed by the learned Rent Controller on 08.11.2005. For the sake of convenience and clarity, each one of the grounds is taken separately and referred to as point No.1, 2 and 3.

    11

    Point No.1.

    28. This point is essentially required to be decided by falling .

    back to the provisions of the Act so as to find out whether the pr P emises in dispute are "non-residential" as averred by the H landlor.d or are "residential" as is sought to be established by the f con testing tenant. 29. Residential building has been d o efined under Section 2 (h) of the Act in the following terms:-

    "2(h) "Residential buildi r ng" t me ans any building which is not non-residential building;" Whereas, "non-resident o ial" bu u ilding has been defined in Section 2(e) in the following terms:-

    "2 (e) C "Non-residential building" means a building being used- h (i) mainly for the purpose of business or trade; or (ii) partly for the purpose of business or trade and partly for g

    the purpose of residence, subject to the condition that the i

    person who carried on business or trade in the building resides therein;

    H

    Provided that if a building is let out for residential and non-residential purposes, separately to more than one person, the portion thereof let out for the purpose of residence shall not be treated as non-residential building."

    Explanation.-Where a building is used mainly for the purpose of business or trade, it shall be deemed to be a non-residential building even though a small portion thereof is used for the purpose of residence;"

    30. It would be noticed that the word used to define non- residential building is "mainly for the purpose of business or trade"

    which means 'substantially' in contradiction to the word 'solely' which means exclusively. Therefore, in such circumstances, it is the dominant user of the building which will serve as a guiding factor to determine the

    12

    nature of the building. If the dominant user remains running of trade and business, then even if small portion is used as residence, it would .

    remain non-residential building. Likewise, if the dominant user P of the building is residential, then the mere fact that a small p H ortion .thereof is being used for non-residential purposes, the same would still remain residential. f

    31. Now, in case the pleadings a re o evaluated, then it would be seen that the landlord in para-4 of t the petition has described the premises as non-residential u and h r ad rented out the premises to the tenant for commercial o purpose to run his clinic whereas he had converted the same into residential premises. Whereas, in reply thereto, the co nte C sting tenant has submitted that since his father was a doctor, h h e used to attend the patients as and when required in front roo g m of the premises facing the road and the premises were never t i aken for medical practice alone. Apart from one room, the other rooms H were being used as residence. 32. Adverting to the evidence led by the parties, it would be noticed that overwhelming evidence led by the respondent to prove that out of the entire premises, it was only the room alone facing the road

    that was being used as a clinic while the rest of the premises were

    being used only for residential purpose. This is so stated by RW-1

    Prem Singh, RW-2 the current tenant himself and RW-3 K.C.Bhagra, as

    would be evident from the testimonies discussed in paras 21 to 26

    (supra). On the other hand, save and except for the bald statement of

    PW-1, the petitioner has virtually led no evidence to show much less to

    prove that the entire premises had been given to the tenant as 'shop'.

    13

    Point No.2.

    33. As regards point No.2 regarding the value and utility of the .

    building being impaired, the learned Appellate Authority has P rightly observed that the landlord has led no evidence to this e.ffect and, therefore, these findings call for no interference. H Point No.3. f

    34. Insofar as the third ground for o eviction is concerned, it is not in dispute that the landlord had r ac t qui red vacant possession of one of the flat No.23, Boileauganj, u Shimla, as this fact has been admitted by the current tenant whil o e appearing as RW-2 though he qualified his statement that the same had been let out to Bhag Singh with the consent of othe r C co-owners. 35. h However, the larger question which arises for consideration is w g hether the accommodation in possession of current tenant can be s i aid to be insufficient or does he only have a quest and insatiable H desire to possess properties. These observations are being made on the basis of the proved facts on record which clearly establish that as of today the current tenant is possessed of the following properties:-

    i) The disputed premises comprising of three rooms, one glazed verandah, one kitchen, one bathroom, W.C. and store in the third floor in 25, Boileauganj;

    ii) Similar or equivalent accommodation in the second floor taken on rent by father of the current tenant in the year 1950 in 25, Boileauganj;

    iii) Six rooms in "Glue Moon Cottage";

    iv) One building at Faridabad and;

    v) At the same time he is also owner of the four storeyed Building No.23, Boileauganj, Shimla and is even receiving rent therefrom.

    14

    36. Though, the current tenant would claim that the property No.23, Boileauganj, is owned by various other co-owners, but there i . s not an iota of evidence led by him to prove this fact. In additio . n P to this, it has been clearly established on record that the current tenant is mainly residing at Faridabad in the State of Haryana an H d not at Shimla

    and, therefore, if at all he requires any residence f at S himla i.e. only for

    his casual visits, he could have convenien o tly occupied the premises

    vacated by Laxmi Ram in property r No t .23 , Boileauganj, Shimla. In such circumstances, the act of letti u ng out these premises even after vacation to Bhag Singh and not o occupying the same has rightly been taken into account by the learned authorities below while ordering the eviction of the tenant. C

    37. h Th e learned lower Appellate Authority has erred in not taki g ng into account the acquisition of vacant possession of "Glue Moon C i ottage" which admittedly consists of six rooms only on the ground that H it was father of the current tenant, who had obtained eviction orders against the tenant P.M.Pardeshi. The learned lower Appellate Authority appears to be totally oblivious of the grounds on which eviction order was sought by the tenant in those proceedings. It is borne out from the

    record that the eviction of the tenant was sought only on the ground of

    personal requirement of the landlord (tenant herein) and not on any

    other ground like the premises being in a dilapidated condition or being

    inhabitable or unsafe etc. which were otherwise available to him under

    the relevant statute prevailing at that time. Therefore, it is too late in the

    day for the tenant to say that he could not shift to the premises known

    as "Glue Moon Cottage" as they were dilapidated and were not fit for

    human habitation. Even otherwise, this stand of the current tenant

    15

    stands completely demolished by the statement of erstwhile tenant P.M.Pardeshi, who has categorically stated that the condition of th . e premises is not at all dilapidated or not fit for human habitation. P

    38. Apart from this, the current tenant appears to h.ave been caught in his own web when he categorically admitte H d that the "Glue Moon Cottage" and the premises in dispute are f rou ghly of the same age i.e. having been constructed at the same o time.

    39. Even if, it is assumed that t the premises comprised in "Glue Moon Cottage" were in a dila u pidate r d condition, even then the same in itself could not be a gro o und for the current tenant to have not occupied the same, if not promptly, then within a reasonable time and it was no excuse to cla im C that he has no resources for the same, more particular h ly, when it has come on record that the current tenant has reti g red from Army that too from the post of Brigadier. The plea raised b i y the current tenant, to say the least, is not at all bonafide. H 40. The reason for sticking on to the premises is but obvious as the current tenant is barely paying a sum of `1958/- per annum for the palatial premises in his occupation. Whereas, he is receiving rental of `800/- per month from Bhag Singh alone, apart from the other rentals

    which he is receiving from the tenants of the four storeyed building

    owned by him i.e. building No.23, Boileauganj, Shimla.

    41. It would further be noticed that the current tenant has categorically stated in his examination before the Court that the landlord intended to sell the entire building and had approached him for purchasing the same and he had offered `17 lacs, but the landlord had not reverted back. This clearly indicates that the current tenant made all

    16

    out efforts to tire out the landlord, so that he would ultimately settle with him by paying a meagre amount of `17 lacs for the entire premise P s. .42. The learned lower Appellate Authority has erred in not taking into consideration that the rent legislature could. not be

    interpreted in a manner so as to lean only in favour of H the tenants and

    while being fair to the tenants, go to the extent o f f ac o

    tually being unfair to the landlord. The learned lower Appellate Authority further erred in not taking into consideration that t wh ile interpreting such of the provisions as take care of the inte r rest of the landlord, the same were required to be interpre o ted in u a manner which lean in favour of the landlord.

    43. He re C , it would be apt to take note of the judgment rendered by the H h on'ble Supreme Court in Joginder Pal versus Naval Kishore Beh g al (2002) 5 SCC 397 wherein it was held:- i

    "9. The Rent Control Legislations are heavily loaded in favour of H

    the tenants treating them as weaker sections of the society requiring legislative protection against exploitation and unscrupulous devices of greedy landlords. The Legislative intent has to be respected by the Courts while interpreting the laws. But it is being uncharitable to Legislatures if they are attributed with an intention that they lean only in favour of the

    tenants and while being fair to the tenants go to the extent of

    being unfair to the landlords. The Legislature is fair to the

    tenants and to the landlords- both. The Courts have to adopt a

    reasonable and balanced approach while interpreting Rent

    Control Legislations starting with an assumption that an equal

    treatment has been meted out to both the sections of the

    society. In spite of the overall balance tilting in favour of the

    tenants, while interpreting such of the provisions as take care of

    the interest of landlord the Court should not hesitate in leaning

    in favour of the landlords. Such provisions are engrafted in rent

    control legislations to take care of those situations where the

    landlord too are weak and feeble and feel humble.

    17

    32. We have already noticed that the purpose of the Act is to restrict increase of rent and the eviction of tenants in urban .

    areas. Still the legislature has taken care to provide grounds for eviction, one of them being the requirement of the landloPrd. We have to strike a balance between the need of prot.ecting the tenants from unjustified evictions and the n H eed for eviction when ground for eviction is one such as the requirement of the landlord. If we do not meaningfully co f nstrue the concept of requirement the provision may s o uffer from the risk of being branded as unreasonable, a t rbitrary or as placing uncalled for and unreasonable restric r tions on the right of the owner to hold and use his property. We cannot place a construction on the expression 'for his own use' in such a way as to deny the

    landlord a o right uto evict his tenant when he needs the accommodation for his own son to settle himself well in his life.

    W e h C ave to give colour and content to the expression and provide the skin of a living thought to the skeleton of the words h which the Legislature has not itself chosen to define. The Indian g

    society, its customs and requirements and the context where i

    the provision is set in the legislation are the guides leading to acceptance of the meaning which we have chosen to assign to H

    the words 'for his own use' in Section 13(3)(a)(ii) of the Act."

    44. It cannot be disputed that the initial view of the Hon'ble Supreme Court on rent legislation leaned entirely in favour of the tenants, but of late, it has been made clear that the object of the rent law is to balance the competing claims of the landlords on the one hand to recover possession of building let out to the tenant and of the tenant to be protected against the arbitrary increase of rent or arbitrary eviction, when there is acute shortage of accommodation.

    45. This was so observed by the Hon'ble three Judges' Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sidhharth Viyas and another versus

    Ravi Nath Misra and others (2015) 2 SCC 701 wherein it has been held as follows:-

    18

    "10. The object of rent law is to balance the competing claims of the landlord on the one hand to recover possession of building let out to the tenant and of the tenant to be protected agains.t arbitrary increase of rent or arbitrary eviction, when . t P here is acute shortage of accommodation. Though, it is for the legislature to resolve such competing claims in terms of

    statutory provisions, while interpreting the prov H isions the object

    of the Act has to be kept in view by the C f ou rt. Unless otherwise provided, a tenant who has a o lready acquired alternative accommodation is not intend t ed to be protected by the Rent Act. 11. In Joginder Pal vs. N r aval Kishore Behal (2002) 5 SCC 397 this Court observe u d : (SCC pp. 402-05, paras 5-9) "5. It o will be useful to state the principles relevant for interpretation of a provision contained in a rent control C law like the one with which we are dealing. The spurt of provincial rent control legislations is a necessary h

    consequence of population explosion. In Prabhakaran Nair v. State of T.N. (1987) 4 SCC 238 the Court noticed

    ig

    craving for a home - a natural human instinct, intensified by post-war migration of human beings en bloc place to H

    place, the partition of the country and uprooting of the people from their hearth and home as vital factors leading to acute housing shortage persuading the legislatures to act and enact rent control laws. The Court emphasized the need of making the landlord and tenant laws rational, humane, certain and capable of being

    quickly implemented. Benefit of society at large needs an

    equalistic balance being maintained between apparently

    conflicting interests of the owners of the property and the

    tenant by inducing and encouraging the landlords to part

    with available accommodation for reasonable length of

    time to accommodate tenants without unreasonably

    restricting their right to have the property being restored

    to them, more so, wh en they genuinely require it. Such

    limited safeguarding of landlords' interest ensures a

    boost to construction activity which in turn results in

    availability of more houses to accommodate more human

    souls with a roof on their heads. Sabyasachi Mukharji, J.,

    19

    as His Lordship then was, articulated the empty truism in such words as have become an oft-quoted quotation (SCC p. 262, para 36)- .

    "36….Tenants are in all cases not th . e Pweaker sections. There are those who H are weak both among the landlords as we f ll as the tenants." 6. In Malpe Vishwanath Ach o arya v. State of Maharashtra (1998) 2 SCC 1 this Court emphasized the need of social legislations like the Rent Control Act striking a balance between rival inte r rest t s s o as to be just to law. 'The law ought not to be unjust to one and give a disproportionate

    benefit or protection to another section of the society.'

    (SCC o p. u 22, para 29) While the shortage of accommodation makes it necessary to protect the C tenants to save them from exploitation but at the same time the need to protect tenants is coupled with an h

    obligation to ensure that the tenants are not conferred with a benefit disproportionately larger than the one

    ig

    needed. Socially progressive legislation must have a holistic perception and not a short-sighted parochial H

    approach. Power to legislate socially progressive legislations is coupled with a responsibility to avoid arbitrariness and unreasonability. A legislation impregnated with tendency to give undue preference to one section, at the cost of constraints by placing shackles on the other section, not only entails

    miscarriage of justice but may also result in constitutional

    invalidity.

    7. In Arjun Khiamal Makhijani v. Jamnadas C. Tuliani (1989) 4 SCC 612 this Court dealing with rent control legislation observed that provisions contained in such legislations are capable of being categorized into two:

    those beneficial to the tenants and those beneficial to the landlord. As to a legislative provision beneficial to the landlord, an assertion that even with regard to such provision an effort should be made to interpret it in favour

    20

    of the tenant, is a negation of the very principle of interpretation of a beneficial legislation. .

    8. The need for reasonable interpretation of re . nt P control legislations was emphasized by this Court in Bega Begum v. Abdul Ahad Khan. (1979) 1 SCC 273 Speaking

    in the context of reasonable requi f rem en H t of landlord as a ground for eviction, the Court guarded against any artificial extension entailin o g stretching or straining of language so as to ma ke it impossible or extremely difficult for the landlo t rd to get a decree for eviction. The Court warned tha r t such a course would defeat the very purpose of u the Act which affords the facility of eviction of the tenant to the landlord on certain specified grounds. In Kewa o l Kewal Singh v. Smt Lajwanti . (1980) 1 SCC 290 this Court has C observed, while the rent control legislation has given a number of facilities to the tenants, it should not be construed so as to destroy the limited relief which it h

    seeks to give to the landlord also. For instance, one of g

    the grounds for eviction which is contained in almost all i

    the Rent Control Acts in the country is the question of landlord's bona fide personal necessity. The concept of H

    bona fide necessity should be meaningfully construed so as to make the relief granted to the landlord real and practical. Recently in Shiv Sarup Gupta v. Mahesh Chand Gupta (1999) 6 SCC 222 the Court has held that the concept of bona fide need or genuine requirement needs a practical approach instructed by the realities of

    life. An approach either too liberal or too conservative or

    pedantic must be guarded against.

    9. The rent control legislations are heavily loaded in favour of the tenants treating them as weaker sections of the society requiring legislative protection against exploitation and unscrupulous devices of greedy landlords. The legislative intent has to be respected by the courts while interpreting the laws. But it is being uncharitable to legislatures if they are attributed with an intention that they lean only in favour of the tenants and while being fair to the tenants, go to the extent of being

    21

    unfair to the landlords. The legislature is fair to the tenants and to the landlords - both. The courts have to adopt a reasonable and balanced approach P while. interpreting rent control legislations starting . with an assumption that an equal treatment has been meted out to both the sections of the society. In sp H ite of the overall balance tilting in favour of the tenants, while interpreting such of the provisions as take care of the interest of the landlord the court should no o t hesiftate in leaning in favour of the landlords. Such provisions are engrafted in rent

    control legislations to tak e care of those situations where

    the landlords too a r re wteak and feeble and feel humble."

    46. As is clear from t u he above, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has categorically held that o the rent Acts have been enacted not only to protect the ten ants' unjust eviction but have been enacted to clearly enforce t h he right

    Cs of the landlord to obtain possession of their own property in the event of their satisfying the grounds prescribed for e i vic g tion. To say the least, the defence set up by the current tenant in H this case was not only false but is also cantankerous, more particularly, taking into consideration his stature and rank. 47. In view of the above discussion, both the revision petitions are dismissed. However, as observed earlier, the current tenant has illegally deprived the landlord of the possession of the property for all

    these years. Therefore, it is the duty of the Court to see that such

    wrong doers are discouraged at every step and even if the current

    tenant has succeeded in prolonging the litigation, then he must suffer the cost of the litigation and also bear the expenses of such unwarranted and otherwise avoidable litigation. Therefore, the current tenant is burdened with costs which are assessed at `30,000/- to be paid to the landlord. However, it is clarified that this cost shall not

    22

    prevent the landlord from seeking mesne profits on such rates as the competent authority may determine in this case. .

    48. Having said so, the petitions are disposed o . f P in the aforesaid terms. All pending applications, if any, stand dispose of. The Registry is directed to place a copy of this ju f dgmeHnt on the file of Civil Revision No.39 of 2008. o August 20th, 2016. r t (Tarlok Singh Chauhan), (krt) Judge. u

    C

    o

    h Hi g

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Brig (Retd.) R.S. Verma-Tenant v. Abhijit Rai
    (Aug 20, 2016)