Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Petitioner, Quippo Oil and Gas Infrastructure Limited, a public limited company engaged in oil and gas drilling services, challenged certain conditions in tenders floated by the Respondent No.1, Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Limited (ONGC Ltd.). The Petitioner sought quashing or waiving of clauses B.2.6(v) and B.2.7(v) of the tender conditions which required the bidder to be a 100% subsidiary of its parent/ultimate parent/holding company for financial eligibility. The Petitioner contended that this condition was arbitrary, discriminatory, and unreasonable, particularly as the Petitioner was 99.90% owned by SREI Infrastructure Finance Limited, effectively amounting to full control. The Petitioner filed two writ petitions: W.P.(C) No.12331/2015 seeking quashing of the conditions, and W.P.(C) No.791/2016 seeking a mandamus directing ONGC to consider its bids against the subject tenders.

The Respondent admitted to relaxing the 100% subsidiary condition in the case of a foreign consortium involving Russian companies due to legal restrictions under Russian law. The Petitioner’s holding company later acquired the remaining 0.10% shares, making it a 100% subsidiary.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the condition requiring a bidder to be a 100% subsidiary of its parent/ultimate parent/holding company for financial eligibility in ONGC’s tenders is an essential condition of eligibility or merely ancillary/subsidiary.
  2. Whether the impugned condition is discriminatory, arbitrary, and unreasonable in light of the Petitioner’s near-complete shareholding and control by its parent company.
  3. Whether the Respondent can insist on strict literal compliance of the 100% subsidiary condition given its own relaxation of this condition in the case of foreign companies due to statutory reasons.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The 100% subsidiary condition is discriminatory and arbitrary as the Petitioner is effectively fully controlled by its parent company holding 99.90% shares.
  • The condition is not essential to ensure successful execution of the work and thus unreasonable and opposed to public policy.
  • The Respondent’s own practice of relaxing the condition for foreign companies on legal grounds demonstrates that the condition is not essential.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The 100% subsidiary condition is necessary to prevent anomalies or difficulties caused by minority shareholders which could hamper the tender process.
  • The condition has never been relaxed for Indian companies, only for foreign companies due to statutory/legal restrictions under their laws.
  • Even a 0.10% shareholding by others can affect or hamper the tender process, justifying strict compliance.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Poddar Steel Corpn. v. Ganesh Engineering Works, (1991) 3 SCC 273 Distinction between essential conditions of eligibility and ancillary/subsidiary conditions in tenders; courts may waive technical irregularities if conditions are ancillary. The Court applied this principle to hold that the 100% subsidiary condition is ancillary and not essential, thus not requiring strict literal compliance.
C.J. Fernandez v. State of Karnataka, (1990) 2 SCC 488 Supportive authority on classification of tender conditions into essential and ancillary categories. Used to reinforce the distinction between essential and ancillary conditions in tender evaluation.
Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India, (1979) 3 SCC 489 Strict compliance required only for essential eligibility conditions; relaxing essential conditions amounts to illegal discrimination. Distinguished from the present case as it concerned essential conditions; here the condition was ancillary.
Michigan Rubber (India) Limited v. State of Karnataka and Others, (2012) 8 SCC 216 Judicial review of tender conditions requires fairness and non-arbitrariness; interference only if decision is mala fide, arbitrary, or affects public interest adversely. The Court found the Respondent’s selective application of the 100% subsidiary condition arbitrary and violative of fairness under Article 14.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by examining the distinction established by the Supreme Court in Poddar Steel Corpn. between essential tender conditions, which require strict compliance, and ancillary or subsidiary conditions, which may be waived or relaxed. The Court analyzed the impugned financial criteria clauses B.2.6(iv) and B.2.6(v), noting that while newly formed companies may rely on the financial strength of their promoter without 100% shareholding, subsidiary companies are required to be 100% owned by their parent for the same benefit.

The Court found no rational basis for this difference, since in both scenarios a corporate guarantee is provided by the parent or promoter company to financially support the bidder. The Court rejected the Respondent’s contention that even a single minority shareholder could cause difficulties, pointing out that standalone companies with multiple shareholders face similar risks without such a requirement.

The Court further noted that the Respondent had itself relaxed the 100% subsidiary condition in the case of a foreign consortium due to legal restrictions under Russian law, thereby conceding that the condition is not an essential eligibility criterion. This selective application was deemed arbitrary and discriminatory.

Applying the principles of fairness and non-arbitrariness under Article 14 as expounded in Michigan Rubber (India) Ltd., the Court held that the impugned condition is ancillary and subsidiary to the main eligibility criteria and thus cannot be enforced rigidly or selectively.

Holding and Implications

The writ petitions are allowed. The Court held that the condition requiring a bidder to be a 100% subsidiary of its parent/ultimate parent/holding company for financial eligibility is not an essential condition but ancillary and subsidiary. Consequently, the Respondent is prohibited from rejecting the Petitioner’s bid on this ground.

The direct effect of this decision is that the Petitioner’s bids must be considered by ONGC without insisting on strict compliance with the 100% subsidiary condition. No costs were imposed. The judgment does not set a new precedent altering tender law but reinforces established principles of fairness, non-arbitrariness, and judicial scrutiny of tender conditions.

    Quippo Oil And Gas Infrastructure Limited Petitioner v. Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Limited And Anr. S

    * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

    % Judgment Reserved on: 17thMarch, 2016 Judgment Delivered on: 11thMay, 2016

    + W.P.(C) 12331/2015

    QUIPPO OIL AND GAS INFRASTRUCTURE

    LIMITED .... Petitioner versus

    OIL & NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED AND ANR .... Respondents

    Advocates who appeared in this case:

    For the Petitioner : Mr P.Chidambaram, Senior Advocate and Mr Rajiv Nayar, Senior Advocate with Mr Abhimanyu Bhandari and Ms Kartika Sharma.

    For the Respondents: Mr Sanjay Jain, ASG with Mr Sunil K.Jain, Mr Kaushik Choudhury, Mr T.N.Durga Prasad, Ms Reeta Chaudhary, Mr Shaantanu Jain, Ms Rhea Vorma and Ms Ruchi Jain.

    + W.P.(C) 791/2016

    QUIPPO OIL AND GAS INFRASTRUCTURE

    LIMITED .... Petitioner versus

    OIL & NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED AND ANR .... Respondents

    Advocates who appeared in this case:

    For the Petitioner : Mr P.Chidambaram, Senior Advocate and Mr Rajiv Nayar, Senior Advocate with Mr Abhimanyu Bhandari and Ms Kartika Sharma.

    1

    For the Respondents: Mr Sanjay Jain, ASG with Mr Sunil K.Jain, Mr Kaushik Choudhury, Mr T.N.Durga Prasad, Ms Reeta Chaudhary, Mr Shaantanu Jain, Ms Rhea Vorma and Ms Ruchi Jain.

    CORAM:-

    HON'BLE MR JUSTICE BADAR DURREZ AHMED HON'BLE MR JUSTICE SANJEEV SACHDEVA

    JUDGMENT

    SANJEEV SACHDEVA, J

    1. The Petitioner filed W.P.(C) No.12331/2015 seeking quashing/waiving off the arbitrary and discriminatory conditions encapsulated in clauses B.2.6(v) and B.2.7(v) and B.2.6(v) of the tender Nos.1, 2 & 3 respectively. W.P(C) No.791/2016 has been filed seeking a mandamus to the Respondent No. 1 to consider the bid of the Petitioner against the five subject tenders.

    2. The Petitioner is a Public Limited Company engaged in the business of oil and gas drilling, providing drilling services to E& P Operators in India and overseas. It is stated to have over ten years of drilling experience across the industry and claims to be India's leading and fastest growing drilling company.

    3. The Petitioner is a wholly owned subsidiary of SREI Infrastructure Finance Limited, which owns 99.90% of the shares. The share-holding pattern of the Petitioner, as on the date of the filing

    2

    of the petition, was as under:-

    Name of the Shareholder No. of shares Share capital Share Holding in %
    SREI 29,968,000 299,680,000 99.90
    Mr Hemant Kanoria (Beneficial Holder for SREI) 500 5,000/- 0.00
    Mr Sandeep Lakhotia (Beneficial Holder for SREI) 500 5,000/- 0.00

    Mr Sanjeev Sancheti 100 1,000/- 0.00

    (Beneficial Holder for SREI)

    Mr Sandeep Bedi 30,000 300,000/- 0.10

    TOTAL 30,000,000 300,000,000 100.00

    4. It is contended that SREI is in full and complete control of the Petitioner Company and has full control on the operations and affairs of the Company of the Petitioner.

    5. It is contended that the Respondent No.1/Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited (ONGC Ltd.) floated the subject tenders for deployment of drilling rigs and carrying out of 3-D seismic survey. The Petitioner is aggrieved by the financial criteria of the subject tenders, whereby the subsidiary Company is required to be a 100%

    3

    subsidiary of the parent/ultimate parent/holding Company. It is contended that since the holding Company owns 99.90% shares of the Petitioner Company, it virtually amounts to 100% shareholding and the holding Company exercises complete control in the management and the decision making of the Petitioner. It is contended that such a condition is discriminatory and aimed at excluding prospective bidders and preventing healthy competition. It is contended that the said condition of owning 100% shareholding in the subsidiary is not relevant to ensure successful execution of the work and the said condition is unreasonable, discriminatory, opposed to public policy, arbitrary and irrational. It is contended that the said condition is not an essential condition of eligibility and is merely ancillary or subsidiary with the main object to be achieved by the condition. It is contended that even the Respondent No.1/ONGC has applied the same liberally. The Respondent No.1, in its counter-affidavit filed to C.M. No. 2081/2016, has conceded that it has awarded a tender to a consortium of M/s Bumi Armada Offshore Contractor Limited (BAOCL), Marshall Island and M/s Afcons Infrastructure Limited, Mumbai wherein the BAOCL has 99% stake in its subsidiary company M/s Bumi Armada Caspian LLC (BACLLC), Russia. BAOCL has 99% of shareholding in BACLLC and the rest 1 % is with M/s Bumi Armada Russia Holdings Limited, Marshall Islands

    (BARHL).

    4

    6. M/s Bumi Armada Russia Holdings Limited (BARHL), Marshall Islands and M/s Afcons Infrastructure Limited, Mumbai, wherein BARHL has 90% stake in its subsidiary Company.

    7. It is contended in the counter affidavit, that the same has been done because as per Russian Law, holding Company cannot hold 100% share of its subsidiary Company and, as such, 10% share was allotted to another entity. It is contended in the counter that the Respondent No.1 has never relaxed the tender condition of 100% ownership by parent/subsidiary Company in its tenders except in the case of Russian Company, which was due to valid/legal/statutory reasons, as stated above. It is contended that the said condition has never been relaxed in respect of any Indian Company, as under Indian Law, 100% subsidiary is permissible. It is contended that several anomalies or difficulties can be caused by even a single shareholder, reference is made as per Section 241 read with 244 and Section 188 of the Companies Act, 2013. It is contended that 0.10% shareholding can affect/hamper the tender process of the Respondent No.1 to a great extent.

    8. It may be noted, that during pendency of the present petition, the holding Company of the Petitioner i.e. the Respondent No. 2 has acquired even the said 0.10% shareholding and now holds 100% share in the subsidiary company, i.e. the Petitioner.

    5

    9. To settle the controversy that arises in the present writ petitions, we need to examine as to whether the impugned condition is an essential condition of eligibility or is merely ancillary or subsidiary to the main object to be achieved by the condition.

    10. The Supreme Court of India in Poddar Steel Corpn. v. Ganesh Engineering Works, (1991) 3 SCC 273 has held as under:

    "6. It is true that in submitting its tender accompanied by a cheque of the Union Bank of India and not of the State Bank clause 6 of the tender notice was not obeyed literally, but the question is as to whether the said non- compliance deprived the Diesel Locomotive Works of the authority to accept the bid. As a matter of general proposition it cannot be held that an authority inviting tenders is bound to give effect to every term mentioned in the notice in meticulous detail, and is not entitled to waive even a technical irregularity of little or no significance. The requirements in a tender notice can be classified into two categories — those which lay down the essential conditions of eligibility and the others which are merely ancillary or subsidiary with the main object to be achieved by the condition. In the first case the authority issuing the tender may be required to enforce them rigidly. In the other cases it must be open to the authority to deviate from and not to insist upon the strict literal compliance of the condition in appropriate cases. This aspect was examined by this Court in C.J. Fernandez v. State of Karnataka [(1990) 2 SCC 488] a case dealing with tenders. Although not in an entirely identical situation as the present one, the observations in the judgment support our view. The High Court has, in

    6

    the impugned decision, relied upon Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India [(1979)

    3 SCC 489] but has failed to appreciate that the reported case belonged to the first category where the strict compliance of the condition could be insisted upon. The authority in that case, by not insisting upon the requirement in the tender notice which was an essential condition of eligibility, bestowed a favour on one of the bidders, which amounted to illegal discrimination. The judgment indicates that the court closely examined the nature of the condition which had been relaxed and its impact before answering the question whether it could have validly condoned the shortcoming in the tender in question. This part of the judgment demonstrates the difference between the two categories of the conditions discussed above. However it remains to be seen as to which of the two clauses, the present case belongs." (underlining supplied)

    11. The impugned financial criteria of the 'bid evaluation criteria' of the said tenders reads as under:-

    "B.2.6 FINANCIAL CRITERIA FOR TURNKEY / SERVICE CONTRACTS / SUPPLY OF GOODS

    1. Turnover of Bidders : 30% of annualized bid value or more;'

    2. Net worth of Bidder : Positive (as per latest audited annual accounts)

    Note:

    7

    ***** ***** ***** iv). In case the bidder is a newly formed company (i.e. one which has been incorporated in the last 5 years from the date of un-priced bid opening of the tender) who does not meet financial criteria (i.e. Turnover for 30% annualized bid value) by itself and submits his bid based on the financial strength of his promoter company, then following documents need to be submitted;

    i. Turnover of the promoter company/ Joint venture partner should be more than 30% of the annualized bid value.

    ii. Net worth of the promoter / Joint venture partner company should be positive.

    iii. Corporate Guarantee on promoter / Joint venture partner company's company letter head signed by an authorized official undertaking that they would financially support the newly formed company for executing the project/job in case the same is awarded to them, and

    iv. The bidder is a newly formed company i.e. one which has been incorporated in the last 5 years from the date of un-priced bid opening of the tender

    v) In case the bidder is a subsidiary company (should be a 100% subsidiary of the parent/ultimate parent/holding company) who does not meet financial criteria (i.e. Turnover for 30% annualized bid value) by itself and submits his bid

    8

    based on the financial strength of his parent/ultimate parent/holding company, then following documents need to be submitted:

    i. Turnover of the parent/ultimate parent/holding company should be more than 30% of the annualized bid value.

    ii. Net worth of the parent company should be positive.

    iii. Corporate Guarantee on parent/ultimate parent/holding company's letter head signed by an authorized official undertaking that they would financially support their 100% subsidiary company for executing the project/job in case the same is awarded to them, and

    iv. The bidder is a 100% subsidiary company of the parent/ultimate parent/holding parent company.

    ***** ***** *****"

    12. As per the financial criteria, the bidder should have a turnover of at least 30% of annualized bid value. In case a bidder does not meet the financial criteria by itself, then under para (v) of clause B.2.6 it can submit its bid based on the financial strength of his parent/ultimate parent/holding company. In case such a bidder wishes to take advantage of the financial strength of his parent/ultimate parent/holding company, then it must be a 100% subsidiary of his

    9

    parent/ultimate parent/holding company. The parent/ultimate parent/holding company of such a bidder should have a turnover of at least 30% of annualized bid value, its net worth must be positive and the bidder should submit a Corporate Guarantee on parent/ultimate parent/holding company's letter head signed by an authorized official undertaking that they would financially support their 100% subsidiary company for executing the project/job in case the same is awarded to them.

    13. In contrast, if we examine para (iv) of clause B.2.6, it provides that in case a bidder does not meet the financial criteria by itself and it is a newly formed company (i.e. one which has been incorporated in the last 5 years from the date of un-priced bid opening of the tender) then it can submit its bid based on the financial strength of its promoter company. In case such a bidder wishes to take advantage of the financial strength of its promoter company, then the promoter company/joint venture partner should have a turnover of at least 30% of annualized bid value, its net worth must be positive and the bidder should submit a Corporate Guarantee on promoter company/joint venture partner company's letter head signed by an authorized official undertaking that they would financially support the newly formed company for executing the project/job in case the same is awarded to them.

    10

    14. In the case of a newly formed company, there is no requirement that the promoter company should have a 100% shareholding in the bidder. All that is required is that the promoter company should give a corporate guarantee/undertaking that it would financially support the newly formed company for executing the project/job in case the same is awarded to them. The pleas in the counter affidavit seeking to justify the requirement of a 100% shareholding by a parent company, on the ground that several anomalies or difficulties can be caused by even a single shareholder who can affect/hamper the tender process of the Respondent No.1 to a great extent, are without any basis. No such fear or apprehension is expressed in respect of a newly formed company. One cannot comprehend as to how a subsidiary would be different from a newly formed company when in both cases a corporate guarantee/undertaking is submitted from the parent/ultimate parent/holding company or the promoter company/joint venture partner that it would financially support the subsidiary company or the newly formed company (as the case may be) for executing the project/job in case the same is awarded to them.

    15. We may also note that the purpose of the financial condition is that the bidder should have the wherewithal to execute the project and in case it does not have the same, then there is a corporate guarantee/undertaking by its parent/ultimate parent/holding company

    11

    or the promoter company/joint venture partner (as the case may be), which has the financial wherewithal, that it would financially support the subsidiary company or the newly formed company. One fails to understand as to how holding 100% share in the subsidiary company would make the corporate guarantee/undertaking any better than in a case where the parent/ultimate parent/holding company does not hold 100% shares of the subsidiary company. In case of default of the bidder, the corporate guarantee/undertaking of the parent/ultimate parent/holding company would be enforced, in which case, it would be immaterial whether it holds 100% share in the subsidiary company or not.

    16. The hollowness of the plea of the Respondent No.1, that several anomalies or difficulties can be caused by even a single shareholder who can affect/hamper the tender process of the Respondent No.1 to a great extent, is further exposed when one considers the case of a standalone bidder which is able to meet the financial criteria on its own. A standalone company could be controlled by a simple majority of shareholders. In such a situation, the minority shareholders could still challenge the decisions of the majority and affect/hamper the tender process. How would the Respondent No.1, in such a situation, avoid the possibility of a dissent or a petition of mismanagement being filed? If in such a case there is no requirement of a 100%

    12

    shareholding then how can the Respondent No.1 insist upon such a condition in the case of a subsidiary company bidder when the bid is backed by a corporate guarantee/undertaking of the parent/ultimate parent/holding company? The ratio of the decision of the Supreme Court in Poddar Steel Corpn (Supra) is thus squarely applicable in the facts of the present case.

    17. Further we may note that Respondent No. 1 has itself not considered the said condition as an essential condition of eligibility and has admittedly not applied the principal of holding 100% shareholding of the bidder subsidiary company in the case of the consortium Russian Company M/s Bumi Armada Offshore Contractor Limited (BAOCL), Marshall Island and M/s Afcons Infrastructure Limited, Mumbai on the ground that as per legal advice received, under Russian Law a 100% subsidiary company cannot hold 100% shares of its subsidiary company. When the Respondent No. 1 has itself not treated the impugned condition as an essential condition of eligibility in the case of the Russian Company, then how can it be permitted to contend that in the case of the Petitioner, it is an essential condition of eligibility and not ancillary or subsidiary to the main condition.

    18. The Judgment of the Supreme Court of India in the case of

    Michigan Rubber (India) Limited v. State of Karnataka and Others

    13

    (2012) 8 SCC 216, relied upon by the Respondent No. 1, to contend that in the matter of formulating conditions of a tender document and awarding a contract, greater latitude is required to be conceded to the State authorities unless the action of the tendering authority is found to be malicious and a misuse of its statutory powers, interference by courts is not warranted, does not further its case in as much as in the said judgment the Supreme Court has held that the basic requirement of Article 14 is fairness in action by the State, and non-arbitrariness in essence and substance is the heartbeat of fair play. These actions are amenable to the judicial review only to the extent that the State must act validly for a discernible reason and not whimsically for any ulterior purpose. If the State acts within the bounds of reasonableness, it would be legitimate to take into consideration the national priorities. It has also laid down that a court before interfering in tender or contractual matters, in exercise of power of judicial review, should pose to itself the following questions:(i) Whether the process adopted or decision made by the authority is mala fide or intended to favour someone; or whether the process adopted or decision made is so arbitrary and irrational that the court can say: "the decision is such that no responsible authority acting reasonably and in accordance with relevant law could have reached"? and (ii) Whether the public interest is affected. If the answers to the above questions are in the negative, then there should be no interference under Article

    14

    226.

    19. In the present case, clearly the decision of the Respondent No. 1 to selectively apply the impugned condition in the case of the Petitioner and not the Russian company, smacks of arbitrariness. Further, as discussed hereinabove, the applicability of the impugned condition in the case of a subsidiary company bidder and not in the case of a newly formed company bidder or any other bidder company is clearly arbitrary and irrational.

    20. In view of the above discussion, we are of the view that the impugned condition is not an essential condition of eligibility but merely ancillary and subsidiary with the main object to be achieved by the said condition and thus the Respondent No. 1 cannot insist upon the strict literal compliance of the said condition. The writ petitions are allowed. The Respondent No. 1 is prohibited from rejecting the bid of the Petitioner on this ground. There shall be no order as to costs.

    SANJEEV SACHDEVA, J

    BADAR DURREZ AHMED, J

    MAY 11 , 2016/'sn'

    15

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Quippo Oil And Gas I... v. Oil & Natural Gas Co...
    (May 11, 2016)