Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Mohd. Rashid Alam, a constable in the District Police Force, was killed while on security duty, leaving behind an illiterate widow and four minor children. To support the family, the deceased’s younger brother, the present appellant, applied for compassionate appointment with the widow’s consent and an undertaking to maintain the family. The State appointed him as a constable on 2 May 1991. After fifteen years of unblemished service, the Senior Superintendent of Police issued a show-cause notice (4 June 2005) asserting that a brother was not a “dependent” under the prevailing policy and proposing termination. Despite the appellant’s explanation, his services were terminated on 23 June 2005. His departmental appeal remained undecided, prompting Writ Petition No. 5713 of 2006 before the Patna High Court, which a learned Single Judge dismissed on 8 November 2010. A Letters Patent Appeal also failed (20 December 2013). The appellant then approached the Supreme Court by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government was justified in terminating the appellant’s services after fifteen years on the ground that, as a brother of the deceased, he did not fall within the definition of “dependent” for compassionate appointment.
  2. Whether the lapse of time and the State’s own knowledge and conduct precluded it from rescinding the compassionate appointment granted in 1991.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found the termination unjustified for several inter-related reasons:

  • Full disclosure at the time of appointment: Both the widow and the appellant truthfully revealed their relationship and the family situation; no fraud or misrepresentation was involved.
  • Undertaking and actual maintenance of the family: The appellant formally undertook—and for over fifteen years fulfilled—the responsibility of supporting the widow and her children, even arranging the marriages of two daughters.
  • Absence of alternative dependents: No other eligible family member could have sought compassionate employment; the appellant was the only adult male relative capable of supporting the bereaved family.
  • State’s conscious decision and delay: The Government knowingly appointed the appellant despite the policy wording and allowed him to serve satisfactorily for fifteen years. By its own conduct, the State effectively condoned any technical irregularity, and could not later benefit from its “mistake.”
  • Welfare-State considerations: The Court emphasized the compassionate appointment’s purpose—to alleviate immediate financial hardship of a deceased employee’s family—and held that revoking such relief after long service defeats that objective.
  • Lack of culpability on the appellant’s part: Because no fraud, suppression, or misrepresentation was attributed to the appellant, the equitable doctrine against allowing a party to take advantage of its own wrongdoing applied to the State.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; Termination Order Quashed. The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s judgments and the termination order dated 23 June 2005. It directed:

  • Immediate reinstatement of the appellant within one month.
  • Payment of full back wages from the date of termination until reinstatement, along with consequential seniority and notional promotions.
  • Costs of Rs 5,000 to be paid to the appellant.

The ruling restores the appellant’s employment and financial benefits but does not announce any new legal precedent; its impact is confined to rectifying the State’s action in this particular case.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Md. Zamil Ahmed v. State Of Bihar And Others

    Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.— Leave granted. This appeal is filed against the final judgment and order dated 20-12-2013 of the High Court of Judicature at Patna in Mohd. Zamil Ahmad v. State of Bihar 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 778 whereby the Division Bench of the High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the appellant herein against the order dated 8-11-2010 of the learned Single Judge of the High Court in Mohd. Zamil Ahmad v. State of Bihar CWJC No. 5713 of 2006 in which it was held that the appellant being the brother of the deceased was not entitled to claim compassionate appointment. His services were, therefore, terminated on this ground.

    2. In order to appreciate the short issue involved in this appeal, it is necessary to state a few relevant facts.

    3. One Mohd. Rashid Alam, who was working as a constable in District Police Force, was killed while on security duty. He left behind his illiterate wife and four minor children. Since there was no one in the family to support the widow and the minor children, the widow of the deceased submitted a petition to the State (Police Department) enclosing an affidavit giving assurance by the appellant, who is the brother of the deceased, that he would support the widow and the minor children of the deceased constable if he is given appointment. Accordingly, Memo No. 1267/P-02 dated 29-2-1991 was issued by the Director General of Police to appoint the appellant. Vide D.O. No. 1248/91, the appellant was appointed as constable w.e.f. 2-5-1991 after being declared medically fit on the post of constable in the scale of Rs 950-20-1150-25-1400.

    4. Thereafter the appellant successfully completed his recruits' training course and since then he had been performing satisfactory duties in various districts and also taking care of the illiterate widow and four children of the deceased constable. The appellant also, in the meantime, got married two daughters of the deceased constable.

    5. After 15 years of service, on 4-6-2005, the appellant received a show-cause notice from the Senior Superintendent of Police, Patna. In the show-cause notice, it was stated that why the appellant's services be not terminated because he being a “devar (brother of the deceased)” was not included in the definition of dependant of the deceased and hence was not eligible to claim compassionate appointment in the State services.

    6. On 10-6-2005, the appellant gave his explanation and stated that ever since his appointment in February 1991, he has been looking after the widow and four children of the deceased constable. He gave them education and is still maintaining the family of the deceased as Head of the family. He also explained that his dismissal, after 15 years of satisfactory duty, would cause undue hardship to the widow and family of the deceased constable because even as on today, there is no earning member in the family.

    7. The Senior Superintendent of Police, Patna did not accept the explanation offered by the appellant and terminated the services of the appellant on 23-6-2005 holding his appointment on compassionate ground to be illegal and against the policy. Aggrieved by the said order, the appellant filed an appeal before the Inspector General of Police on 1-8-2005.

    8. Since the appeal was not decided by the Inspector General of Police, the appellant filed a petition being Writ Petition No. 5713 of 2006 before the High Court for quashing the order of termination passed by the Senior Superintendent of Police, Patna with a further prayer to reinstate him with all consequential benefits or in the alternative to direct the authorities to decide the appeal filed by him. By the order dated 8-11-2010 CWJC No. 5713 of 2006, the learned Single Judge dismissed the petition. It was held that it was a case of a mistake committed by the authorities while giving such benefit to the appellant and hence this is a fit case for termination of the appellant's services.

    9. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the appellant filed an appeal being LPA No. 758 of 2013. By order dated 20-12-2013 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 778, the Division Bench upheld the order of the learned Single Judge and dismissed the appeal. Against the said order, the appellant has filed this appeal by way of special leave before this Court.

    10. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties.

    11. Keeping in view the peculiar undisputed facts of the case and having regard to the totality of the circumstances, we are of the considered view that the State was not justified in terminating the appellant's services. In other words, the ground on which the appellant's services were terminated by the State after a period of 15 years of the appellant's appointment does not appear to be well founded. This we say for the following reasons:

    11.1. Firstly, the appellant and wife of the deceased at the time of seeking compassionate appointment did not conceal any fact nor filed any false or incorrect document/declaration. On the other hand, both of them disclosed their true family relations and conditions prevailing in the deceased's family on affidavit.

    11.2. Secondly, the appellant, who is the brother of the deceased, undertook to maintain the family of the deceased in the event of his securing the compassionate appointment and he accordingly also gave such undertaking to the State.

    11.3. Thirdly, there was no one in the family of the deceased to claim compassionate appointment except the appellant who, as mentioned above, was the close relative of the deceased i.e. real younger brother and used to live with the deceased. He was otherwise eligible to claim such appointment being major, educated and only male member in the family.

    11.4. Fourthly, the appellant after securing the employment throughout maintained the family of the deceased in all respects for the last more than 15 years and he is continuing to do so.

    12. In the light of aforementioned reasons, which rightly persuaded the State to grant compassionate appointment to the appellant, we do not find any justification on the part of the State to dig out the appellant's case after 15 years of his appointment and terminate his services on the ground that as per the State policy, the appellant did not fall within the definition of the expression “dependant of deceased” to claim compassionate appointment.

    13. The fact that the appellant was the younger brother of the deceased was within the knowledge of the State. Similarly, the State was aware that the brother does not fall within the definition of “dependant” at the relevant time and still the State authorities obtained the undertaking from the appellant that he would maintain the family of the deceased once given the appointment.

    14. In our considered view, the aforesaid facts would clearly show that it was a conscious decision taken by the State for giving an appointment to the appellant for the benefit of the family members of the deceased who were facing financial hardship due to sudden demise of their breadearner. The appellant being the only close relative of the deceased could be given the appointment in the circumstances prevailing in the family. In our view, it was a right decision taken by the State as a welfare State to help the family of the deceased at the time of need of the family.

    15. In these circumstances, we are of the view that there was no justification on the part of the State to wake up after the lapse of 15 years and terminate the services of the appellant on such ground. In any case, we are of the view that whether it was a conscious decision of the State to give appointment to the appellant as we have held above or a case of mistake on the part of the State in giving appointment to the appellant which now as per the State was contrary to the policy as held by the learned Single Judge, the State by their own conduct having condoned their lapse due to passage of time of 15 years, it was too late on the part of the State to have raised such ground for cancelling the appellant's appointment and terminating his services. It was more so because the appellant was not responsible for making any false declaration nor he suppressed any material fact for securing the appointment. The State was, therefore, not entitled to take advantage of their own mistake if they felt it to be so. The position would have been different if the appellant had committed some kind of fraud or manipulation or suppression of material fact for securing the appointment. As mentioned above such was not the case of the State.

    16. It is for this reason, we are of the view that action on the part of welfare State in terminating the appellant's service on such ground cannot be countenanced. We, therefore, disapprove the action taken by the State.

    17. In the light of foregoing discussion, we allow the appeal, set aside the impugned orders 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 778 CWJC No. 5713 of 2006 and in consequence allow the writ petition filed by the appellant (writ petitioner) and quash the appellant's termination order dated 23-6-2005 (Annexure P-4 of SLP).

    18. As a consequence thereof, the respondent State is directed to reinstate the appellant in service with all consequential benefits such as payment of full back wages payable from the date of termination (23-6-2005) till the date of reinstatement in service. The appellant is also entitled to claim his seniority and notional promotions as per the rules. It be fixed accordingly.

    19. Let the appellant be reinstated in service within a month as an outer limit and the arrears of back wages, as directed, be paid to the appellant within three months by the respondent State.

    20. Cost of this appeal is quantified at Rs 5000 and the same be paid to the appellant by the respondent State along with the arrears of back wages.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Md. Zamil Ahmed v. State Of Bihar And Others
    (May 5, 2016)