AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India
  • Articles 14, 16 of the Constitution
  • Article 14, Article 21
  • The Societies Registration Act, 1860
  • 154th Report of the Department Related Parliamentary Committee on the functioning of JNVS
  • 198th Report of the Department Related Parliamentary Committee submitted on 17-8-2007
  • Article 14 of the Constitution
  • Article 311 of the Constitution
  • Road Transport Corporations Act, 1950
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the Societies Registration Act, 1860
  • Article 31 of the Constitution of India
  • Article 12 of the Constitution
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India
  • Articles 14, 16 of the Constitution
  • Article 14, Article 21
  • The Societies Registration Act, 1860
  • 154th Report of the Department Related Parliamentary Committee on the functioning of JNVS
  • 198th Report of the Department Related Parliamentary Committee submitted on 17-8-2007
  • Article 14 of the Constitution
  • Article 311 of the Constitution
  • Road Transport Corporations Act, 1950
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the Societies Registration Act, 1860
  • Article 31 of the Constitution of India
  • Article 12 of the Constitution
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The judgment disposes of two clusters of matters:

  • NWDA Cluster (Civil Appeals arising out of SLPs(C) Nos. 3106-07 of 2012 & 20425-26 of 2011)
    National Water Development Agency (NWDA), an autonomous society fully funded by the Union Ministry of Water Resources, adopted Central Government pay-scales and followed a Contributory Provident Fund (CPF) Scheme framed in 1982. Relying on an Office Memorandum (OM) dated 1-5-1987—which allowed Central Government CPF beneficiaries in service on 1-1-1986 to be “deemed” to have switched to the pension scheme—the employees sought similar benefit. The Governing Body rejected the request on 30-3-2000 after the Ministry of Finance advised against extending government-pattern pension to autonomous bodies (letter dated 16-3-2000). OA No. 2037/2008 before the Central Administrative Tribunal succeeded; the Tribunal directed implementation of the OM and grant of pension. The Delhi High Court, on writ petitions by the Union of India and NWDA, set aside the Tribunal’s order. Aggrieved employees approached the Supreme Court.
  • NVS Cluster (W.P.(C) Nos. 556 & 518 of 2012; Civil Appeal arising out of SLP(C) No. 19102 of 2012)
    Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti (NVS), registered on 28-2-1986 under the Societies Registration Act, runs fully residential schools. Its staff remained under the CPF Scheme until introduction of a New Pension Scheme (NPS) in 2004 (notified in 2008) with a cut-off date of 1-1-2004. Employees and their associations sought application of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972, citing parity with Kendriya Vidyalaya and other government-aided institutions. The Jharkhand High Court dismissed a writ petition challenging the NPS; similar writ petitions were filed directly before the Supreme Court. All matters were heard together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Office Memorandum dated 1-5-1987, permitting switch-over from CPF to the Pension Scheme, applies to employees of NWDA—an autonomous body with its own CPF Rules, 1982.
  2. Whether employees of NWDA and NVS can claim pensionary parity with Central Government employees or with staff of other autonomous educational bodies such as Kendriya Vidyalaya Samiti.
  3. Whether financial implications constitute a valid ground for the Government to withhold extension of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 to employees of autonomous bodies.
  4. In the NVS matters, whether the New Pension Scheme, 2004 (notified 2008) with a cut-off date of 1-1-2004 is arbitrary or discriminatory.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants/ Petitioners (Employees of NWDA & NVS)

  • The OM 1-5-1987 was held applicable to autonomous-body staff in Union of India v. S.L. Verma; by operation of Bye-law 28 (NWDA) and analogous resolutions (NVS) Central Government service rules apply mutatis mutandis.
  • NWDA never validly framed CPF Rules, 1982; appointment letters continued to cite CPF Rules, 1962, showing employees were always under the Central pattern.
  • Financial constraints cannot override fundamental rights under Articles 14, 16 & 21; denial of pension amounts to denial of livelihood post-retirement.
  • Parity with Kendriya Vidyalaya, IITs, etc., is justified because NVS and NWDA are wholly funded by Government and perform public functions.
  • The New Pension Scheme lacks family pension, gratuity and employer contribution for pre-2004 employees, making it arbitrary.

Respondents (Union of India, NWDA, NVS)

  • NWDA adopted its own CPF Rules in 1982 (retrospectively from 15-7-1982); once an autonomous body frames separate rules, Bye-law 28 ceases to import Central rules automatically.
  • Clause 6.1 of OM 1-5-1987 applies only to “civilian Central Government employees” under CPF Rules, 1962. Clause 7.2 requires separate orders for autonomous bodies; none were issued for NWDA or NVS.
  • Pension is not a fundamental right; entitlement flows only from governing rules. Financial viability is a legitimate consideration (A.K. Bindal, Associate Banks Officers’ Assn.).
  • Employees of different autonomous bodies do not constitute a homogenous class; doctrine of equal pay/pension requires complete identity of service conditions, which is absent.
  • New Pension Scheme, 2004 is a distinct, prospective scheme; choosing a cut-off date is a policy matter immune from judicial interference unless manifestly arbitrary, which is not demonstrated.

Table of Precedents Cited

PrecedentRule or Principle Cited ForApplication by the Court
Union of India v. S.L. Verma (2006) 12 SCC 53 OM 1-5-1987 applied to certain autonomous-body staff Held distinguishable; OM applicability in that case was admitted & employer had accepted IV CPC recommendation, unlike NWDA/NVS.
Kerala SRTC v. K.O. Varghese (2007) 8 SCC 231 Court’s minimal interference with rules of autonomous bodies Cited to emphasise autonomy of NWDA/NVS in framing service rules.
Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India (2005) 4 SCC 649 Tests for treating an entity as “State” under Article 12 Used to hold that mere government funding does not render NWDA a “State” for parity claims.
UT, Chandigarh v. Krishan Bhandari (1996) 11 SCC 348 Equality claim arises only among similarly situated persons Reinforced rejection of parity between NWDA staff and Central Government employees.
Sudhir Chandra Sarkar v. TISCO Ltd. (1984) 3 SCC 369 Arbitrary discretion in pension matters violates Article 14 Relied upon by employees; Court found no arbitrary discretion exercised.
Accountant General v. N. Bakshi AIR 1962 SC 505 Service conditions must satisfy constitutional norms Cited by employees; Court held facts distinguishable.
SAIL v. Dibyendu Bhattacharya (2011) 11 SCC 122 Limitation & maintainability of service claims Invoked by respondents to contest cause of action; not decisive of final outcome.
All India Reserve Bank Retired Officers Assn. v. Union of India 1992 Supp (1) SCC 664 Cut-off dates in wholly new schemes are permissible Supported validity of 2004 NPS cut-off for NVS.
Associate Banks Officers' Assn. v. SBI (1998) 1 SCC 428 Financial capacity is relevant in wage fixation Used to justify Government’s refusal on fiscal grounds.
A.K. Bindal v. Union of India (2003) 5 SCC 163 Economic capability integral to pay/pension decisions Relied on to uphold Government’s stance.
Municipal Council, Ratlam v. Vardichan (1980) 4 SCC 162 Financial incapacity no defence to statutory duty Cited by employees; Court found it inapposite to pension entitlements.
All India Imam Organisation v. Union of India (1993) 3 SCC 584 State obligations despite fiscal constraints Cited by employees; distinguished on facts.
Kapila Hingorani v. State of Bihar (2003) 6 SCC 1 Non-payment of salary violates Article 21 Cited by employees; held not directly relevant to pension scheme extension.
All India Sainik Schools Employees’ Assn. v. Sainik Schools Society 1989 Supp (1) SCC 205 Employees of one autonomous body not automatically comparable with another Applied to deny parity between NVS and KVS staff.
S.C. Chandra v. State of Jharkhand (2007) 8 SCC 279 “Equal pay for equal work” requires total identity Used to reject parity claim.
State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair (1985) 1 SCC 429 Pension a deferred component of salary Cited by employees; Court held principle inapplicable where no pension promise existed.
Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar (1971) 2 SCC 330 Pension cannot be withheld contrary to rules Reiterated limited to cases where pension is otherwise payable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court affirmed the Delhi High Court (NWDA) and Jharkhand High Court (NVS) by adopting the following analytical steps:

  1. Existence of Autonomous-Body Rules: NWDA had framed CPF Rules, 1982, duly approved by its Governing Body. Where an autonomous institution has its own rules governing service conditions, Bye-law 28 (which imports Central rules in the absence of internal rules) is inoperative. A similar autonomy exists for NVS.
  2. Textual Construction of OM 1-5-1987: Clause 6.1 confines automatic switch-over to “civilian Central Government employees” under CPF Rules, 1962; Clause 7.2 expressly contemplates separate orders for autonomous bodies following other provident-fund regimes. No such order was issued for NWDA or NVS.
  3. Distinction from S.L. Verma: In S.L. Verma the OM’s applicability was admitted and the employer had accepted the IV CPC recommendation. NWDA’s Governing Body expressly rejected the change-over in 2000; NVS did not exist on the OM’s cut-off date.
  4. Article 12 & Parity Claims: Mere 100% government funding does not automatically render an autonomous body “State” for all purposes (Zee Telefilms). Even assuming Article 12 status, parity requires identity of circumstances (Krishan Bhandari; S.C. Chandra), which is lacking between NWDA/NVS and Central Government departments.
  5. Financial Viability: The Court accepted that fiscal capability is a relevant factor in designing pensionary benefits (A.K. Bindal; Associate Banks Officers’ Assn.). Government apprehension of cascading liability across autonomous bodies was held legitimate.
  6. New Pension Scheme: The 2004 NPS for NVS is a fresh scheme with its own financial architecture; fixation of a cut-off date lies within executive discretion and is not per se arbitrary (All India RBI Retired Officers Assn.). No gross unreasonableness was demonstrated.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS AND WRIT PETITIONS DISMISSED.

Consequently:

  • Employees of NWDA remain governed by the NWDA CPF Rules, 1982; the OM 1-5-1987 and CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 are inapplicable.
  • Employees of NVS cannot claim pensionary parity with Kendriya Vidyalaya or other bodies; the 2004 New Pension Scheme stands undisturbed.
  • The judgment re-affirms judicial deference to autonomous-body regulations and recognises fiscal considerations as a valid basis for differential pension frameworks. No new precedent is set beyond application of established principles.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    T.M. Sampath And Others v. Secretary, Ministry Of Water Resources And Others

    Pinaki Chandra Ghose, J.— Leave granted in all the SLPs.

    Civil appeals arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 3106-107 of 2012 and SLPs (C) Nos. 20425-26 of 2011

    2. These appeals, by special leave, have been filed against the judgment and order dated 6-1-2011 passed by the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in Union of India v. T.M Sampath 2011 SCC OnLine Del 40 and order dated 18-3-2011 in Review Petition No. 90 of 2011, by which the High Court set aside the order dated 8-2-2010 OA No. 2037 of 2008, order dated 8-2-2010 (Tri) passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal in Original Application No. 2037 of 2008 filed by the appellants herein.

    3. The facts of these appeals are briefly stated hereinafter. The appellants herein are the employees of National Water Development Agency (“NWDA”) which was established as a society in July 1982 and was registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. The Society NWDA, which falls under the aegis and control, both administrative and financial, of the Ministry of Water Resources, is fully funded by the Government of India, headed by the Union Minister for Water Resources as the President. NWDA framed rules and regulations for its smooth functioning. Whatever emoluments have been prescribed for the government servants by the Central Government Office Memorandum (“the OM”, for short) the same apply mutatis mutandis to the employees of NWDA. Bye-law 28 of NWDA also mandates that the rules and orders applicable to the Central Government employees shall apply mutatis mutandis to the employees of NWDA subject to modification by the Governing Body concerning service conditions and only in case of any doubt, the matter has to be referred to the Governing Body for a decision. Bye-law 26(a) provides for the emoluments structure for all employees that will be adopted by NWDA, with the approval of the Ministry of Finance (Department of Expenditure). Bye-law 28 provides that till such time NWDA frames its rules governing service conditions of the employees, rules and orders applicable to the Central Government employees shall apply mutatis mutandis, subject to such modifications as made by NWDA from time to time.

    4. As per the appellants, NWDA had implemented all the recommendations of the Fourth Central Pay Commission from 22-10-1986. The pay scales of the employees of NWDA were revised as made applicable to the Central Government employees. Pursuant to the recommendation of the Fourth Central Pay Commission, the Office Memorandum dated 1-5-1987 was issued by the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Department of Pensions and Pensioners' Welfare, for switch-over of employees from Contributory Provident Fund Scheme to Pension Scheme, according to which all Contributory Provident Fund (CPF) Scheme beneficiaries, who were in service of the Central Government on 1-1-1986, were deemed to have come over to the Pension Scheme unless they specifically opted out to continue under CPF Scheme. This Pension Scheme was formulated by the Government under the 1972 Pension Rules.

    5. The Office Memorandum dated 1-5-1987 reads as under:

    “Change-over of employees from Contributory Provident Fund Scheme to Pension Scheme (G.I, Department of Pensions and Pensioners' Welfare, OM No. 4/1/87-P.I.C.I, dated 1-5-1987.)
    The Central Government employees who are governed by the Contributory Provident Fund Scheme (CPF Scheme) have been given repeated options in the past to come over to the Pension Scheme. The last such option was given in the Department of Personnel and Training OM No. F. 3(1)-Pension Unit/85, dated 6-6-1985. However, some Central Government employees still continue under the CPF Scheme. The Fourth Central Pay Commission has recommended that all CPF beneficiaries in service on 1-1-1986, should be deemed to have come over to the Pension Scheme on that date unless they specifically opt out to continue under the CPF Scheme.
    2. After careful consideration, it has been decided that the said recommendation shall be accepted and implemented in the manner hereinafter indicated.
    3.1 All CPF beneficiaries, who were in service on 1-1-1986, and who are still in service on the date of issue of these orders (viz. 1-5-1987) will be deemed to have come over to the Pension Scheme.
    3.2 The employees of the category mentioned above will, however, have an option to continue under the CPF Scheme, if they so desire. The option will have to be exercised and conveyed to the Head of Office by 30-9-1987, in the form enclosed if the employees wish to continue under the CPF Scheme. If no option is received by the Head of Office by the above date the employees will be deemed to have come over to the Pension Scheme.
    3.3 The CPF beneficiaries, who were in service on 1-1-1986, but have since retired and in whose case retirement benefits have also been paid under the CPF Scheme, will have an option to have their retirement benefits calculated under the Pension Scheme provided they refund to the Government, the government contribution to the Contributory Provident Fund and the interest thereon, drawn by them at the time of settlement of the CPF account. Such option shall be exercised latest by 30-9-1987.
    3.4 In the case of CPF beneficiaries, who were in service on 1-1-1986, but have been since retired, and in whose case the CPF account has not already been paid, will be allowed retirement benefits as if they were borne on pensionable establishments unless benefits settled under the CPF Scheme.
    3.5 In the case of CPF beneficiaries, who were in service on 1-1-1986, but have since died either before retirement or after retirement, the case will be settled in accordance with Para 3.3 or 3.4 above, as the case may be. Options in such cases will be exercised latest by 30-9-1987, by the widow/widower and in the absence of widow/widower by the eldest surviving member of the family who would have otherwise been eligible to family pension under the Family Pension Scheme if such scheme were applicable.
    3.6 The option once exercised shall be final.
    3.7 In the types of cases covered by Paras 3.3 and 3.5 involving refund of Government's contribution to the Contributory Provident Fund together with interest drawn at the time of retirement, the amount will have to be refunded latest by 30-9-1987. If the amount is not refunded by the said date, simple interest thereon will be payable at 10% per annum for period of delay beyond 30-9-1987.
    4.1 In the case of employees who are deemed to come over or who opt to come over to the Pension Scheme in terms of Paras 3.3, 3.4 and 3.5, the retirement and death benefits will be regulated in the same manner as in case of temporary/quasi-permanent or permanent government servants, as the case may be, borne on pensionable establishment.
    4.2 In the case of employees referred to above, who come over or are deemed to come over to the Pension Scheme, the Government's contribution to the CPF account of the employees will be resumed by the Government. The employee's contribution together with the interest thereon at his credit in the CPF account will be transferred to the CPF account to be allotted to him on his coming over to the Pension Scheme.
    4.3 Action to discontinue subscriptions/contributions to the CPF account may be taken only after the last date specified for exercise of option viz. 30-9-1987.
    5. A proposal to grant ex gratia payment to the CPF beneficiaries, who retired prior to 1-1-1986, and to the families of CPF beneficiaries who died prior to 1-1-1986, on the basis of the recommendations of the Fourth Central Pay Commission is separately under consideration of the Government. The said ex gratia payment, if and when sanctioned, will not be admissible to the employees or their families who opt to continue under the CPF Scheme from 1-1-1986 onward. [See Order (4) in this Appendix.]
    6.1 These orders apply to all civilian Central Government employees who are subscribing to the Contributory Provident Fund under the Contributory Provident Fund Rules (India), 1962. In the case of other contributory provident funds, such as Special Railway Provident Fund or Indian Ordinance Factory Workers Provident Fund or Indian Naval Dockyard Workers Provident Fund, etc. necessary orders will be issued by the respective administrative authorities.
    6.2 These orders do not apply to the Central Government employees who, on re-employment are allowed to subscribe to Contributory Provident Fund. These orders also do not apply to the Central Government employees appointed on contract basis where the contribution to the Contributory Provident Fund is regulated in accordance with the terms of contract.
    6.3 These orders do not also apply to scientific and technical personnel of the Department of Atomic Energy, Department of Space, Department of Electronics and such other Scientific Department as have adopted the system prevailing in the Department of Atomic Energy. Separate orders will be issued in their respect in due course [See Order (3) in this Appendix.]
    7.1 Ministry of Agriculture, etc. are requested to bring these orders to the notice of CPF beneficiaries under them, including those who have retired since 1-1-1986, and to the families covered by Para 3.5 of these orders.
    7.2 Administrative ministries administering any of the Contributory Provident Fund Rules, other than the Contributory Provident Fund (India) Rules, 1962, are also advised to issue similar orders in respect of CPF beneficiaries covered by those Rules in consultation with the Department of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare.
    8. These orders issue with the concurrence of the Ministry of Finance, Department of Expenditure, vide their UO No. 2038.IS (Pres)/97 dated 13-4-1987.”

    The above switch-over was applicable to all the Central Government employees who were subscribing to the Contributory Provident Fund under the Contributory Provident Fund Rules, 1962. As stated in Para 7.2 of the said OM, this switch-over was not applicable ipso facto to autonomous bodies under the Ministries of the Central Government who were subscribing to any other scheme other than the CPF Rules, 1962, and therefore, it directed the administrative bodies to issue similar orders for CPF beneficiaries, in consultation with Department of Pensions and Pensioners' Welfare. Subsequently, the employees of NWDA made representations to NWDA and the Ministry of Water Resources in view of the directions in the OM, pursuant to which the Ministry of Water Resources sought advice from the Ministry of Finance (Department of Expenditure). The Finance Ministry vide its Letter dated 16-3-2000, advised autonomous bodies to continue to follow the CPF Scheme or work out an annuity scheme. Under Para 3 of the said letter it stated that introduction of pension scheme on the Government of India pattern should not be agreed as a rule, and any exception in this regard would be referred to the Department. The Governing Body of NWDA in its 3rd meeting held on 31-3-1983 approved introduction of Contributory Provident Fund Scheme for the employees of NWDA on the lines of the Contributory Provident Fund Rules (India), 1962, as was clear in the appointment orders and CPF settlement cases of deceased employees of NWDA issued belatedly on 19-9-2007 and 23-12-2009. NWDA did not make any distinct CPF rules. As stated by the respondents, in the year 1982 NWDA had framed Contributory Provident Fund Rules, which were duly approved by the Governing Body of NWDA. It rejected the proposal for introduction of Pension-cum-GPF-DCRG Scheme in NWDA. The appellants sought right to information (“RTI”) on 18-7-2000 whereupon the decision of the Ministry of Finance dated 16-3-2000 and the decision taken by the Governing Body on 30-3-2000 that the implementation of the OM was rejected by the Governing Body, was apprised to them.

    6. The appellants filed OA No. 2037 of 2008 before the Central Administrative Tribunal assailing the decision of the Governing Body dated 30-3-2000 rejecting their request to switch over to the Pension Scheme and the Letter dated 16-3-2000 issued by the Finance Ministry whereby the request of the appellants to switch over to the Pension Scheme pursuant to the OM dated 1-5-1987, had been turned down.

    7. Before the Central Administrative Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”), when the case came up for hearing, the respondents took a preliminary objection as to the cause of action being barred by limitation on the ground that though the OM is dated 1-5-1987, yet few members were associated in the 30th meeting of the Governing Body having knowledge of the resolution passed by the respondents on 30-3-2000 and that they cannot resort to a cause of action on the basis of RTI after 8 years, to file the above OA. The Tribunal overruled the objection raised by the respondents and after referring to various authorities, observed that fundamental right of grant of pension does not attract limitation. Moreover, on inaction the Government is precluded from raising the hypertechnical plea to defeat the rightful claim of the applicants. The order passed in 2000 was reiterated to the applicants in 2007 thus the case of the applicants was good on merits. The Tribunal after referring to the OM, Bye-laws 26(a) and 28 and the decision of this Court in Union of India v. S.L Verma (2006) 12 SCC 53 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 312, held that there was nothing in the language of Clause 6.1 of the OM dated 1-5-1987, to suggest that the said OM does not apply to the employees of autonomous bodies controlled by the Central Government and the said view finds no support from Clause 7.2 of the OM. The advice dated 16-3-2000 of the Ministry of Finance to the Ministry of Water Resources, at best, can be treated as an executive order and as the same does not have retrospective effect, it has no application to overrule the OM. The Tribunal further held that NWDA/Ministry of Water Resources committed an error in seeking advice from the Ministry of Finance regarding implementation of the OM for the reason that Bye-law 26(a) provides that no approval of the Central Government is required to adopt scales of pay or allowances identical to those adopted for corresponding posts as per order issued by the Central Government. As per Bye-law 28, since no rules were framed by NWDA regarding switch-over of its employees, the OM squarely applied to NWDA employees and the question of applicability of the OM to the employees of the autonomous bodies is no longer res integra by the decision of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. S.L Verma (2006) 12 SCC 53 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 312. Accordingly, the Tribunal vide its order dated 8-2-2010 OA No. 2037 of 2008, order dated 8-2-2010 (Tri), set aside the orders dated 16-3-2000 and 30-3-2000 impugned before it, allowed OA No. 2037 of 2008 and directed the respondents to implement the OM dated 1-5-1987 and treat the employees of NWDA as covered under the Pension Scheme in terms of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 (“the CCS Pension Rules”, for short) w.e.f 1-1-1986 with all benefits.

    8. Aggrieved by the decision of the Tribunal, the respondents filed writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, challenging the order dated 8-2-2010 OA No. 2037 of 2008, order dated 8-2-2010 (Tri) passed by the Tribunal. The respondents did not urge the issue of limitation before the High Court. The question that arose for consideration before the High Court was as to the applicability of the OM dated 1-5-1987 to the employees of NWDA and whether reliance placed by the Tribunal upon the decision in S.L Verma case (2006) 12 SCC 53 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 312 was correct. The High Court after referring to Clauses 6.1 and 7.2 of the OM, held that the employees of NWDA are not “civilian Central Government employees” as NWDA is an autonomous body working under administrative control of the Ministry of Water Resources; the employees of NWDA are governed by the National Water Development Agency Contributory Fund Rules, 1982 and not Contributory Provident Fund (India) Rules, 1962, and in that view of the matter, they are covered under third situation envisaged under Clause 7.2 of the OM dated 1-5-1987 and not under the two situations under Clause 6.1 and Clause 7.2 thereof. The High Court was of the opinion that the Ministry of Water Resources ideally should have consulted the Department of Pensions and Pensioners' Welfare for issuance of similar orders as OM dated 1-5-1987. However, the Ministry of Water Resources consulted the Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance in respect of the said matter instead of consulting the Department of Pensions and Pensioners' Welfare. As regards the reason given by the Tribunal on Bye-law 28 of NWDA is concerned, the High Court opined that a bare reading of the provision makes it clear that rules and orders applicable to the Central Government employees shall apply mutatis mutandis to the employees of NWDA only in cases where NWDA has not framed its own rules and regulations. NWDA had framed its own CPF Rules in 1982 and thus, Bye-law 28 has no role to play in the instant case. On careful comparison of facts of S.L Verma case (2006) 12 SCC 53 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 312 with the facts of the case at hand, the High Court observed that there are two material facts which entirely distinguish S.L Verma case (2006) 12 SCC 53 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 312 from the case at hand. First being that the OM dated 1-5-1987 was fully applicable to the employees in S.L Verma case (2006) 12 SCC 53 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 312 while this is disputed in the present case. The second fact being that S.L Verma case (2006) 12 SCC 53 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 312 proceeds on the premise that the recommendation of the Fourth Central Pay Commission pertaining to switching over of the employees from the Contributory Provident Fund Scheme to Pension Scheme was accepted by the employer in that case. However, in the present case, it was specifically pleaded by the appellants that the said recommendations of the Fourth Central Pay Commission were not accepted by the Governing Body of NWDA.

    9. The learned counsel for the appellants claimed that the OM dated 1-5-1987 was scrutinised by the Supreme Court in S.L Verma (2006) 12 SCC 53 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 312 and the present case is fully covered by the ratio of said case. NWDA has not framed CPF Rules in 1982. There was no reason for not placing on record the CPF Rules, 1982 as approved by the Governing Body before the courts along with their pleadings. Only at the final stage they were included. NWDA has not brought the said Rules to the knowledge of the appellants. The Rules have not been approved by the Governing Body and are not in operation. The specific case of respondent T.M Sampath in the review petition was that the respondents had not framed any CPF Rules, 1982. No copy of the said Rules was ever provided. As is evident from the appointment letters, at least 100 appointments on record proved that the petitioners were governed by the CPF Rules of 1962. It was clearly mentioned under Item 6 that they would be compulsorily required to contribute to the CPF Rules, 1962. These appointments were made after the decision taken by the Governing Body on 31-3-1983. If the NWDA Rules, 1982 were in operation, there was no reason for the respondent Authority not to mention in the offer of appointments that the employees would be governed by the NWDA Rules, 1982. All orders of the Government of India in respect of the 1962 Rules were adopted by NWDA from time to time. Under the Bye-laws, the Governing Body is empowered to make and amend any rules of NWDA. But no separate CPF Rules, 1982 have ever been put up in prescribed format like those of medical attendance, earned leave and recruitment rules except introduction of CPF Scheme on lines of the CPF Rules, 1962. Going by the above facts the employees should get all the benefits which the Central Government civilian employees are entitled to. Under Bye-law 28, only in case of doubt the matter is referred to the Governing Body for a decision, there is no provision to switch over or application of the Pension Rules as envisaged through OM. Thus when there was no working rules and regulations as to conversion from CPF to Pension Scheme the order by the Pension Department passed on 1-5-1987 would be applicable. The petitioners are covered under Clause 6.1 of the OM read in conjunction with Clause 7.2 and in view of Bye-law 28 the OM will be applicable mutatis mutandis. NWDA had also not circulated the OM amongst the employees. Thus they never submitted their option for switch-over. Accordingly they are deemed to have opted by implication of not giving option.

    10. The respondents acted mala fide in implementing the second OM for introduction of Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity Scheme which was meant for civilian Central Government employees who wanted to continue under the CPF Rules, 1962. It is submitted that six to seven employees who were in a position to implement all the order had been absorbed by taking pro rata pension. The OM was equally applicable to autonomous bodies. The Government had failed to show that it had refused to finance autonomous bodies. It had acted arbitrarily by rejecting the claim of the petitioners. The petitioners' fundamental rights under Articles 14 and 16 had been violated by not treating them on a par with their similar counterparts in the Central Government, when NWDA falls within the meaning of “State” as defined in Article 12 of the Constitution. The petitioners were in regular service of the respondents after confirmation and thus they are entitled to protection under Article 311 of the Constitution. The respondents have acted wrongly by the fact that NWDA implemented all the recommendations of the Fourth Central Pay Commission except the change-over of CPF beneficiaries to Pension Scheme, as all top officers who were responsible for implementing were on deputation and were already covered under the Pension Scheme.

    11. The respondents have not pursued the change-over of CPF to Pension Scheme in a proper way. NWDA had never informed either the Governing Body or Ministry of Finance that they are obligated to bring in effect the change-over. Their contention that they placed the issue on 30-3-2000 is per se illegal and arbitrary. The letter of the Department of Expenditure of 16-3-2000 only provided advice that introduction to autonomous organisation should not be made in routine way. The Governing Body of NWDA is bound by legal fictions for providing pension scheme. The legal fictions are created by reason of the OM of 1-5-1987, acceptance of the Fourth Central Pay Commission recommendations, Bye-law 28 and sub-rule (6)(iv) of Rule 209 of the General Financial Rules that service conditions of autonomous organisation receiving more than 50% of recurring expenditure by way of grant-in-aid from the Central Government should be treated on a par with their counterparts in the Central Government. In view of the decision in Sudhir Chandra Sarkar v. Tisco Ltd. (1984) 3 SCC 369 , 1984 SCC (L&S) 540 , (1984) UJ SC 986, any rule which places absolute discretion of an administrative authority the power to grant or refuse pension or gratuity is arbitrary and violative of Article 14. The petitioners are performing duties in the interest of State, and they should be provided conditions and benefits of service in view of the decision of the Court in Accountant General v. N. Bakshi AIR 1962 SC 505. The denial of retiral benefits is denial of livelihood after superannuation which is violative of Article 21.

    12. The respondents submitted that the same is wrong and that there are two material facts which entirely distinguish S.L Verma case (2006) 12 SCC 53 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 312 from the present case. They dismissed the contention stating the same to be wrong and submitted that the organisation had framed its own CPF Rules, 1982 which were duly approved by NWDA Governing Body in its meeting held on 31-3-1983. The CPF Rules were made effective retrospectively from 15-7-1982. The respondents submitted that when the CPF Rules, 1982 were framed on the lines of the 1962 Rules, then mere mentioning of the wrong year does not confer any constitutional right that the employees would be governed by the CPF Rules, 1962. It is also noteworthy that NWDA came into existence in 1982. Posts in different grades were filled either by direct recruitment or by deputation. For this reason, even after the NWDA CPF Rules were formulated, orders were issued mentioning compulsory contribution to CPF under the CPF Rules, 1962. Rule 10(2) of the NWDA CPF Rules, 1982 says that contribution shall be a percentage of the subscriber's contribution or may be prescribed by the Government. Rule 11 provides that the Agency will pay interest at such rate as the Central Government prescribes on subscriptions to CPF. It is submitted that all orders of the Central Government were not automatically made applicable to the employees of NWDA. After acceptance of the Fourth Central Pay Commission recommendations the OM was issued extending benefits to employees governed by CPF Scheme. As NWDA was following its own CPF Rules, the benefits were extended by framing its own rules in consultation with nodal ministry. These Rules were approved by the Governing Body in the 21st meeting. Since the rules and regulation governing service conditions had been framed by NWDA, Bye-law 28 has no application.

    13. As NWDA is a temporary organisation all the officers are also temporary employees. No employees have been declared as permanent. The service rendered in NWDA by its employees is non-pensionable. The establishment expenditure of NWDA and for implementing the mandate of NWDA, grant-in-aid is provided by the Government. Without any specific approval of the Ministry of Finance, the Department of Pensions and Pensioners' Welfare and the Ministry of Water Resources, NWDA cannot introduce the pension scheme on the lines of the CCS (Pension) Rules. The petitioners have misled the Court that the government orders are adopted by the respondents where rules are not framed. The petitioners are covered under Clause 7.2 in view of the OM, it was examined by the Department of Pensions and Pensioners' Welfare and the Ministry of Finance. Both after examining the proposal did not agree to the contention of the petitioners. The allegation, that NWDA had intentionally not circulated the OM is wrong. The change-over to Pension Scheme was not automatic as NWDA was following its own CPF Rules, 1982. The rules and regulations in different autonomous bodies are different so the petitioners cannot be equated on a par with their counterparts working in the government departments and autonomous bodies as contended in Union of India v. Jai Dev Wig (2015) 5 SCC 353.

    14. Based on the provisions in the OM proposal for framing of DCRG Rules for employees of NWDA was processed by the officers on deputation from pensionable departments with the help from officers/employees. The officer and employees were fully involved and they cannot claim that they were totally ignorant of the orders. The change-over of employees cannot be suo motu made applicable for NWDA employees. The petitioners have failed to prove arbitrary action of the respondents and hence Sudhir Chandra Sarkar v. Tisco Ltd. (1984) 3 SCC 369 , 1984 SCC (L&S) 540 , (1984) UJ SC 986 and Accountant General v. N. Bakshi AIR 1962 SC 505 has no application. In view of the law laid down in SAIL v. Dibyendu Bhattacharya (2011) 11 SCC 122 , (2011) 2 SCC (L&S) 192 , (2011) 2 SLR 243, the petitioners have no cause of action.

    15. In light of the facts and circumstances of this case and the submissions made by the learned counsel on both sides, it can be concluded that NWDA had framed its regulation: the CPF Rules, 1982 and they were duly approved by the Governing Body of NWDA. As NWDA is an autonomous body under the Ministry of Water Resources, it has framed its own bye-laws governing the employees. It has been time and again reiterated that the court must adopt an attitude of total non-interference or minimal interference in the matter of interpretation of rules framed by autonomous institutions. In Kerala SRTC v. K.O Varghese (2007) 8 SCC 231 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 862, this Court held:

    “18. … Ksrtc is an autonomous corporation established under the Road Transport Corporations Act, 1950. It can regulate the services of its employees by making appropriate regulations in that behalf.
    ***
    21. The High Court … is not correct in thinking that there is any compulsion on Ksrtc on the mere adoption of Part III of KSR to automatically give all enhancements in pension and other benefits given by the State Government to its employees.”

    Thus, as the appellants are governed by the CPF Rules, 1982, the OM applicable to the Central Government employees is not applicable to them.

    16. On the issue of parity between the employees of NWDA and Central Government employees, even if it is assumed that the 1982 Rules did not exist or were not applicable on the date of the OM i.e 1-5-1987, the relevant date of parity, the principle of parity cannot be applicable to the employees of NWDA. NWDA cannot be treated as an instrumentality of the State under Article 12 of the Constitution merely on the basis that its funds are granted by the Central Government. In Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India (2005) 4 SCC 649, it was held by this Court that the autonomous bodies having some nexus with the Government by itself would not bring them within the sweep of the expression “State” and each case must be determined on its own merits. Thus, the plea of the employees of NWDA to be treated on a par with their counterparts in the Central Government under sub-rule (6)(iv) of Rule 209 of the General Financial Rules, merely on the basis of funding is not applicable.

    17. Even if it is presumed that NWDA is “State” under Article 12 of the Constitution, the appellants have failed to prove that they are on a par with their counterparts, with whom they claim parity. As held by this Court in UT, Chandigarh v. Krishan Bhandari (1996) 11 SCC 348 , 1997 SCC (L&S) 391, the claim to equality can be claimed when there is discrimination by the State between two persons who are similarly situated. The said discrimination cannot be invoked in cases where discrimination sought to be shown is between acts of two different authorities functioning as State under Article 12. Thus, the employees of NWDA cannot be said to be “Central Government employees” as stated in the OM for its applicability.

    18. Thus, by reason that the employees are governed by the NWDA CPF Rules, 1982, the OM dated 1-5-1987 is not applicable to the appellant employees. Further, as they have not established that they are the Central Government employees, on a par with their counterparts, their claim of parity with the Central Government employees is also defeated.

    19. In view of the discussion in the foregoing paragraphs, we do not find any merit in these appeals which are accordingly dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Writ Petitions (Civil) Nos. 556 and 518 of 2012 and civil appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 19102 of 2012

    20. Writ Petitions (Civil) Nos. 556 and 518 of 2012 and Special Leave Petition (C) No. 19102 of 2012 are other group of matters arising out of same factual matrix and the point of contention in all three matters is same. Writ Petition (Civil) No. 556 of 2012 has been filed by All India Navodaya Vidyalaya Staff Association and Writ Petition (Civil) No. 518 of 2012 has been filed by the Principals and other officials of Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya and the employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti, for issuance of an appropriate writ in the nature of mandamus or any other direction(s) to the respondents to introduce and implement the CCS Pension Scheme, 1972 to all the employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti. SLP (C) No. 19102 of 2012 has been filed by Shri P.N Mishra against the order dated 2-3-2012 2012 SCC OnLine Jhar 273 passed by the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi dismissing the writ petition filed by him.

    21. The facts necessary for disposal of these cases, stated briefly, are that the idea of Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya was conceptualised in 1985 and two model schools were started, one each at Jajjhar in Haryana and Amravati in Maharashtra. However, the Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti was established under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 on 28-2-1986. It is stated that Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya schools have been established under the aegis of the Ministry of Human Resource Development, Government of India. The employees of Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti (“JNVS”) demanded that they be brought under the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme like their counterparts in other educational institutions, like Kendriya Vidyalaya Samity (“KVS”), IITs, Sainik Schools, Ncert, etc. However, they have continued to be governed only by the CPF Scheme and were excluded from the Pension Scheme till 2004. It has been submitted on behalf of the petitioners/appellants that the Executive Committee of JNVS had adopted a resolution which proposed the application of the Central Government Service Rules to its employees mutatis mutandis till the Samiti framed its own rules. But the resolution has not been shown to have been approved by the Government or District Inspector of Schools. In any case, the demands of the employees of JNVS have been supported as well as voiced by various government functionaries including the Ministry of Human Resource and Development through its letter to the Finance Ministry in 1998 seeking approval of the Finance Ministry to introduce the Pension Scheme to JNVS, Y.N Chaturvedi Committee Report on Review of Management Structure and Operating Mechanism of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti, Parliamentary Committee on Functioning of Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti through its 154th, 184th and 198th Reports. All these committees have strongly recommended that the employees of JNVS be brought on a par with the employees of Kendriya Vidyalaya and be given similar service benefits, including pension under the 1972 Rules. However, the major hurdle in implementation of Pension Scheme to the employees of JNVS has been the financial constraints as the Finance Ministry never gave a go-ahead for such implementation. To substantiate their claim, JNVS engaged an actuary to determine the financial feasibility of implementing the Pension Scheme to JNVS employees and it was found that if the employees' contribution up to 31-3-2005 is transferred to the Pension Fund by 31-3-2005 and annual contribution @18% of salary on monthly basis from 1-4-2006, the implementation of the scheme is financially viable.

    22. The Central Government formulated New Pension Scheme, 2004 for the employees of JNVS in response to their repeated demands. This New Pension Scheme was implemented from 1-1-2009. All the employees who had joined prior to the date of implementation were given an option to either continue under the CPF Scheme or to switch-over to the New Pension Scheme. The cut-off date for this New Pension Scheme was 1-1-2004; therefore, it was not available to the employees who had joined the service prior to cut-off date. However, the employees claim that New Pension Scheme was also discriminatory as it is not on a par with the Pension Scheme under the 1972 Rules. The existing employees were put under Tier II of the New Pension Scheme and the employer's contribution was not available to them. Further, the New Pension Scheme did not include any family pension, medical benefits and death gratuity.

    23. The present appellant in SLP No. 19102 of 2012, Shri P.N Mishra had filed a writ petition in the Jharkhand High Court seeking writ of mandamus against the Government to implement the Pension Scheme under the 1972 Rules for the employees of the Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya on the grounds of arbitrary discrimination against them vis-à-vis employees of the Kendriya Vidyalaya and other educational institution although run by autonomous bodies but very much under the aegis of the HRD Ministry whose employees are benefited by the Pension Scheme. The petitioner therein also challenged the New Pension Scheme notified in 2008 being discriminatory and ultra vires of Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India.

    24. The High Court found that there existed no pension scheme for the employees of JNVS till the 2004 Scheme which was notified in 2008. It noted that the New Pension Scheme which was formulated by the Government in 2004 and notified in 2008 was in response to the demands of the employees of JNVS and that cut-off date was the domain of the employer. It relied on the judgment in All India Reserve Bank Retired Officers Assn. v. Union of India 1992 Supp (1) SCC 664 , 1992 SCC (L&S) 517 , (1992) 19 ATC 865, wherein the Supreme Court had held that when an existing scheme is liberalised, the employer cannot ordinarily grant the benefit to one class of employees and deny it to others by choosing arbitrary cut-off date. However, when a completely new scheme is introduced, whole new set of considerations are involved primarily being the financial implications. On these grounds the High Court dismissed 2012 SCC OnLine Jhar 273 the writ petition stating that the petitioner could not prove that NPS was arbitrary or discriminatory.

    25. Following issues are involved in these matters for our consideration:

    (i) Whether OM dated 1-5-1987 applies to the employees of the NVS?
    (ii) Whether the financial implication can be valid consideration for denying pension?
    (iii) Whether the employees of the Navodaya Vidyalaya are entitled to parity in pension with the employees of other autonomous institutions like Kendriya Vidyalaya, Ncert, National Open Schools and Tibetan Schools Association?
    (iv) Whether the New Pension Scheme, 2004 is arbitrary or discriminatory?

    26. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners/appellants have emphasised on the applicability of the Office Memorandum of the Department of Public Grievances and Pensions, Department of Pensions and Pensioners' Welfare dated 1-5-1987 to the employees of JNVS just like it was applied to KVS. However, the learned Additional Solicitor General has lucidly brought out the difference between the position of employees of the organisation with respect to said OM. She has pointed out that for application of the said OM, following three prerequisites were to be fulfilled by the employees:

    (i) they must be Central Government employees;
    (ii) they must be in service on 1-1-1986; and
    (iii) they must be CPF beneficiaries as on 1-1-1986.

    27. The respondents have contended that JNVS was not in existence at the time of cut-off date applicable under the OM dated 1-5-1987 and also that the employees of JNVS cannot claim as of right to be governed by the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 as they are not employees of the Central Government.

    28. It is undisputed fact that the Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti was established and registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 only on 28-2-1986, so its employees cannot be in service as on 1-1-1986. Thus, while first condition is disputed, the second condition is clearly not fulfilled. In contrast, KVS was established in 1965. Therefore, we find merit in the argument of the learned Additional Solicitor General that the said OM cannot apply to the NVS employees.

    29. Further, it was submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioners/appellants that the only reason for not providing pension as per the 1972 Rules has been the financial implications which becomes apparent from the Letter of the Finance Ministry dated 5-2-1999 to the HRD Ministry in which the Finance Minister has clearly pointed out the excessive liability that the Government would have to incur in case it extends pension scheme to JNVS employees and suggested that an annuity scheme may be formulated with LIC by employees contribution alone without any liability of the Government. Also the Finance Ministry has expressed its concern that extending such pension benefit on the grounds of parity would mean that all the autonomous bodies under the Government of India would make similar demands and that would be financially infeasible.

    30. In support of these submissions, the learned counsel for the petitioners/appellants has cited plethora of judgments wherein it was held that fundamental rights cannot be violated on the grounds of financial constraints and that the right to education is a fundamental right which cannot be jeopardised by compromising with quality of teachers in schools due to poor post-service benefits. Reliance was also placed on Municipal Council, Ratlam v. Vardichan (1980) 4 SCC 162 , 1980 SCC (Cri) 933, All India Imam Organization v. Union of India (1993) 3 SCC 584 and Kapila Hingorani (1) v. State of Bihar (2003) 6 SCC 1 , 2004 SCC (L&S) 586.

    31. The learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the respondents argued that none of the cases relied upon by the petitioners/appellants involves right to pension and that pension is not a fundamental right. She cited Associate Banks Officers' Assn. v. SBI (1998) 1 SCC 428 , 1998 SCC (L&S) 293, wherein this Court observed that many ingredients go into shaping of the wage structure of any organisation, including the economic capability of the employer. Taking simplistic approach of granting higher remuneration to workers of one organisation because another organisation had granted its employees, may lead to undesirable results and the application of the doctrine would be fraught with danger and may seriously affect the efficiency and functioning of the organisation. She also relied on A.K Bindal v. Union of India (2003) 5 SCC 163 , 2003 SCC (L&S) 620, which also states that the financial capacity is a relevant consideration in deciding revision of pay scales. Therefore, the learned Additional Solicitor General concluded that financial capacity of the employer is an important factor which cannot be ignored while fixing the wage structure and thus, the demands of the employees of NVS are not founded on sound principle of law.

    32. The learned counsel for the petitioners/appellants have argued that right to equality is guaranteed under Article 14 of the Constitution which incorporates the principle of equal pay for equal work and same has been violated in the present case by granting pension under the 1972 Pension Rules to the employees of some autonomous educational institutions like KVS, Ncert, etc. and denying that benefit to the employees of NVS. The learned counsel pointed out that parity in pay and pension be granted, particularly, between the employees of NVS and the employees of KVS as both these institutions are run by autonomous bodies registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 under the aegis of the Ministry of Human Resource Development, Government of India and are fully funded by the Government of India. Also, that the working hours of the teachers in NVS are more as compared to KVS and JNVS being fully residential schools, the burden on teaching and non-teaching staff is much more than Kendriya Vidyalayas which are only day schools. The learned counsel has brought to the fore recommendations of various committees and authorities which have supported the cause of the petitioners, namely, the Review Committee set up by the Ministry of HRD under the chairmanship of Shri Y.N Chaturvedi to review the Management Structure and Operating Mechanism of JNVS, 154th Report of the Department Related Parliamentary Committee on the functioning of JNVS which was laid before the Lok Sabha on 2-3-2005, the Cabinet Note prepared by the Ministry of HRD in March 2006 which specifically pointed out the need to extend the Pension Scheme under the 1972 Rules to the employees of JNVS, the 198th Report of the Department Related Parliamentary Committee submitted on 17-8-2007 which strongly recommended for implementing the Pension Scheme to the employees of JNVS. Even the Ministry of Labour and Employment by its OM dated 7-9-2006 to the Ministry of HRD, recommended extension of Pension Scheme to NVS.

    33. The learned Additional Solicitor General, appearing on behalf of the respondents submitted that the issue of extending Pension Scheme of 1972 to the NVS employees is an administrative decision which is made keeping in mind various determining factors and that it cannot be said all schools and educational institutions constitute one class. She cited All India Sainik Schools Employees' Assn. v. Sainik Schools Society 1989 Supp (1) SCC 205 , 1989 SCC (L&S) 264 , (1989) 9 ATC 827 wherein the Sainik School employees had sought writ of mandamus to extend all service benefits and advantages to them as are applicable to the employees of KVS. In the said case the Supreme Court dismissed the petition on the ground that the employees of Sainik Schools cannot be considered employees of the Central Government nor can they be treated on a par with KVS employees.

    34. The respondent also relied on S.C Chandra v. State of Jharkhand (2007) 8 SCC 279 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 897, wherein this Court held that the doctrine of “equal pay for equal work” is applicable only when there is total identity in two groups of employees. Further, in A.K Bindal (2003) 5 SCC 163 , 2003 SCC (L&S) 620, this Court has held that employees of the government companies are not government servants. It is, therefore, submitted on behalf of the respondents that the petitioners/appellants are employees of the autonomous body, that is, Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti which has all the control on the organisation.

    35. It may be expedient to note what this Court observed in S.C Chandra (2007) 8 SCC 279 , (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 897:

    “35. … fixing [of] pay scales by [the] courts by applying the principle of equal pay for equal work upsets the high constitutional principle of separation of powers between the three organs of the State. Realising this, this Court has in recent years avoided applying the principle of equal pay for equal work, unless there is complete and wholesome identity between the two groups (and there too the matter should be sent for examination by an Expert Committee appointed by the Government instead of the court itself granting higher pay).”
    (emphasis in original)

    36. Further, the learned counsel appearing for the appellants have contended that the pension is not a bounty given to the employee at the will of the Government but a valuable right vested in the employee and a right to receive pension is a “property” under Article 31 of the Constitution of India as was held in State of Kerala v. M. Padmanabhan Nair (1985) 1 SCC 429 , 1985 SCC (L&S) 278. Further, the learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the pension is that part of the salary which was not given to the employee during his/her service but was kept for payment as pension, so now the employer cannot deny the employees what is rightfully employees' because, if there was no pension to be paid, employees would have had higher salary.

    37. The learned Additional Solicitor General has submitted that the right to pension is not an inherent right of every employee but it flows from the rules of the Government. If the employee is entitled to pension as per the rules of the Government, his/her pension cannot be withheld by a simple executive order (Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar (1971) 2 SCC 330). Similarly, it is submitted that if the employee is not entitled to the pension as per the rules governing his/her service conditions, he/she cannot claim it as of right inherent to the employment.

    38. Further, the counsel for the appellants' argument regarding the pension being part of the salary is accepted as the principle governing pension but it cannot be applied to the present case as the employees in the present case were not promised any pension at the time of their appointment and no deductions were made during their service towards any pension fund. Thus, it cannot be said that the employees have been denied what was rightfully theirs.

    39. The appellants had raised the issue of the New Pension Scheme which was notified in 2008 and whose cut-off date was 1-1-2004 in the writ petition and the SLP, however, it was not pressed during the arguments. In any case, they have claimed that the New Pension Scheme, is also discriminatory and that the said cut-off date is arbitrary. The learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the New Pension Scheme is not on a par with the Pension Scheme under the 1972 Rules as it does not have provisions for death gratuity, family pension and medical benefits. Also, the two-tier system of the New Pension Scheme was challenged.

    40. We have carefully perused the judgment of the High Court of Jharkhand in P.N Mishra v. Union of India 2012 SCC OnLine Jhar 273 against which SLP (C) No. 19102 of 2012 has been filed and we concur with the view of the High Court. The cut-off date is a domain of the employer and so the introduction of new scheme of pension will be done considering all the relevant factors including financial viability of the same. No interference is warranted unless there is gross injustice perpetrated. The appellants have failed to prove any arbitrariness and discrimination with respect to the New Pension Scheme.

    41. In the light of the discussion in the foregoing paragraphs, the writ petitions and the appeal are also dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    T.M. Sampath And Others v. Secretary, Ministry Of Water Resources And Others
    (Jan 20, 2015)