Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion records an appeal to His Majesty in Council from a decree of the Sudder Adawlut of Bombay which had affirmed the dismissal by the Zillah Court of Kaira of a civil suit originally filed by the Appellant. The central factual dispute concerned whether a sub-partnership existed between the Appellant and the Respondent in respect of a certain share in a banking concern at Baroda (established in 1805 and wound up in 1818). The Appellant sued for the Respondent's share of debts and losses (stated at a principal sum of rupees 10,290.2.60, and with interest amounting in the whole to rupees 111,745.0.85).

The Appellant's plaint was filed in the Zillah Court of Kaira on 1 March 1821. The Appellant produced documentary evidence (an agreement dated 7th Assin-vud 1874 as rendered in the record), account books showing an alleged payment of 500 rupees by the Respondent, and witness depositions including confessions or admissions attributed to the Respondent made to an Ameen of Police (Pundit Huree Narain). The Zillah Court examined the documents, referred them to five Shroffs (bankers) for opinion, found signs of mutilation and differing handwriting on parts of the document, found erasures and recent-looking alterations in the account books, and considered witness testimony inconsistent and unreliable. On 6 September 1835 the Zillah Court dismissed the suit with costs. The Sudder Adawlut of Bombay, on appeal, affirmed the Zillah Court's decree on 21 March 1826 with costs. The Appellant then appealed to the Judicial Committee (His Majesty in Council).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a sub-partnership existed between the Appellant and the Respondent in respect of a share in the Baroda banking concern.
  2. Whether the alleged written instrument (agreement) and the account-book entries relied on by the Appellant were genuine and admissible as proof of the Respondent's interest.
  3. Whether the Judicial Committee should overturn the findings of fact and credibility reached by the two Indian courts below.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Appellant contended he had clearly proved that the Respondent held a share in the house established under the name Rursai-bhaee Petamber-das (i.e., that the sub-partnership existed).
  • The Appellant argued he should have been permitted an opportunity to prove that the Shroffs (bankers) to whom the courts referred the documents were biased or partial, or to make other legal objections to their nomination, which he was prepared to establish.
  • The Appellant maintained that any irregularity in the instrument's body (being written by another person) does not affect validity if the signing by the party intended to be bound is proved; and that irregularities in his books should not be a complete bar to his claim absent legal proof invalidating them.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Respondent relied on the confirmation of the lower courts' decrees on the ground that the Appellant had not, by the evidence adduced, proved that the Respondent had any share or interest in the banking house in question.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Judicial Committee framed its review by emphasising that the case depended entirely upon facts and credibility determinations made by two courts in India (the Zillah Court of Kaira and the Sudder Adawlut of Bombay). The Committee explained the general principle that, where factual findings have been made by two competent tribunals who heard witnesses and inspected the evidence, an appellate body should not disturb those findings unless it is very clearly satisfied the judgment below was wrong.

The Committee then examined the primary evidence relied upon by the Appellant:

  • Inspection of the written instrument (agreement) showed that part of the original paper appeared to have been cut off and that four lines written on the back, immediately above a signature, as well as the signature itself, were in a different handwriting from the first part of the document.
  • The Zillah Court had, to obtain technical opinion, referred the document and the Appellant's account books to five Shroffs (bankers), who reported that the first portion of the document was in one hand but the four lines and the signature on the back were in a different hand, and that certain book entries showed erasures and alterations and that some items appeared to have been recently made.
  • Only one subscribing witness (Pundit Huree Narain) asserted he had seen the Respondent sign the instrument; that witness later presented a written declaration which the Appellant relied on, but the surrounding witness testimony varied and several attesting witnesses gave inconsistent accounts of the execution. One attesting witness (Huree Narain) later petitioned that he had placed his signature at the Appellant's request.
  • The Committee noted it was open to conceive that the document had been mutilated (with vital lines cut away) and a separate sheet bearing lines and a genuine signature appended to create an apparent instrument; absent corroboration beyond the single subscribing witness, such a document could not be accepted as reliable.
  • The Zillah Court, having had the benefit of seeing the document and hearing the witnesses, found the paper to be spurious and fabricated; the Sudder Adawlut merely confirmed that finding. The Judicial Committee considered that the two courts' findings (including a finding of probable forgery and possibly perjury) were not shown to be wrong by the Appellant's submissions.

Based on these facts and the quality of the evidence, the Committee concluded it was not satisfied the lower courts' judgments should be reversed. The Committee emphasised the advantage the lower courts had in seeing witnesses and the instrument itself, which reinforced the deference that should be accorded to their factual conclusions.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Judicial Committee dismissed the appeal and affirmed the judgments below. The appeal was dismissed with costs (the Committee described the case as founded in forgery at the least, and most likely forgery supported by perjury).

Implications: The direct consequence is that the decree of the Zillah Court of Kaira and its confirmation by the Sudder Adawlut of Bombay were upheld, leaving the Appellant without recovery. The opinion does not set or state a broader legal precedent beyond applying established evidentiary principles (respect for lower courts' factual findings, caution in admitting instruments that appear altered or mutilated, and the need for satisfactory corroboration where a document suggests alteration). No new precedent was announced in the provided text; the decision operates to affirm the dismissal of the Appellant's suit and an award of costs to the Respondent.

    Petamber Manik-Jee v. Motee-Chund Manik-Jee (India)

    PET. ~ A ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ V. ~ O ~ ~ ~ - G ~ ~ N ~ ~ A ~ - ~ ~ ~ [ 18371 I MOORE IWD. APP, 420

    years, the period l~mited by sec. 13 of Reg. I. A.D. 1800. By that secxion, “The

    Judge i s p r o ~ ~ ~ ~ i t e d hearing, trying, or deterniin~ng the merits of any suit what-

    ever, against any person or persons, if the cause of action shall have arisen tn~elve

    years before any su i t shall have been coir~n~enced on account of it: unless the Corn-

    ~ ~ a i ~ i a n t c sbow, by clear positive proof, that he had d e ~ a ~ d e d iho ~ ~ o ~ i e y ,

    or that he directly preferred Isim within that period, for the matter in disp~xte,

    to a Court of c o ~ p e t e i ~ t urisdic~,ion, to try the d e ~ a n d , and assign ~ a t ~ s f a c ~ ~ ~

    reason to the Court why he did not proceed in the suit : or that either from ~ ~ ~ i ~ o r i ~ y

    or other good and sufficient cause, he had been precluded from obtaining redress.”

    This is U s u ~ c i e n t bar to the ~ppellant’s right, if t?iey ever had any, to recover.

    4 Of the two w~tnesses produced before the Sudder Adawlut, one only speaks to any

    payment being niade to the A ~ ~ e ~ l a n t s , and that Court, as we t h i ~ ~ very ~ r o p e r ~ ~ ,

    disc~edited his tes t i~ony. The jud~ment of the Court below must be a ~ r ~ ~ d wi th

    costs.

    [See now Indian Limitation Act (XY. of 18%”1).]

    [e(!] P ~ T A M ~ ~ R ~ ~ ~ 1 3 - ~ ~ ~ , - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Z a ~ ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - C ~ ~ ~ ~

    ~ ~ s ~ 1 2 . ~ e ? ~ ~ * [May XG, 18311.

    012. appeal from the Sudder D e w a m p Cow8 of Bombay,

    On a question whether a s u b - ~ a ~ t ~ ~ e r s ~ i p had been entered into j the ~ a l ~ d ~ t y

    of which ~epended on an ~ n ~ r ~ r i ~ e ~ ~ t ~ r o d u c d in e~iidence in the Court

    belom; and upon inspection, as well as the evidence in s u p ~ o r t of it, pro-

    nounced tc be invalid ; the Judicial Coniin~tte~, in confirming the judgment

    of both Courts beluw, were of o ~ ~ n ~ o ~ , that they were c o ~ ~ c ~ u d e d un er the cir-

    cumstances of tbe case, from entering upon the exaniination of the instru-

    ment itself, though they fully concurred in the opinion expressed by tho

    Judge of the ZilIah Court, and dismissed the appeal w i t h costs.

    ent of the Sudder Adawlut of ~ o i ~ i ~ a y , a ~ r ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~

    a decreB of the Zillah Court of Kaira, whereby *he suit of the present Appe~~aKit, who

    was the PlaintifE in the ZilIah Court, was ~ i ~ ~ i i s s e d with costs.

    The res1 issue in the suit was, whether a sub-partnership existed between the

    Respondent and the Appellant in respect of a certain share ~ c l o n g i ~ ~ g

    to the ~ppel lan t in a bank~ng ccncern a t Baroda, wlticli was estab

    l ~ s ~ e ~ in the year A.D. 1805, and closed its affairs in the year A.D.

    18%. The Appell~nt’s claim upon the R ~ p o r ~ d e n t founded on the

    alleged s u ~ p a r ~ n e r s h i ~ ~ was for the share of the debts and losses of the concern,

    which the Appellant had either paid, or for which he w a s responsiMe. The ftespon-

    dent denied the existence of the s u b - p a ~ t n e r ~ ~ i p , and the ZiIlah Court of Kaira; in

    the ~rst .~nstance, and [@I] a f t e r ~ a r d s the Sudder Adawlut of Bombay ~ p Q n appeal,

    decided that the Appe~lant had failed to establisb it by evidence.

    The Appel~ant’~ plaint was frled in the la^ Court of ICaira, on the 1st of March,

    1821, ; it set forth that the Appeilant and one R u t u n - ~ e ~ ~ a h a n ~ d a s establ~shed a

    Rank at Baroda on the 23rd of October, 1805, in which they had equal shar~s, the

    business of the concern being carried on in the name of Nursai Bhaee, the Appel-

    lant’s son; that from the day ths Bank was estab~~shed the Respondent took one-half

    of the Appellant’s share, and advanced five hundred rupeeg, which sum it, was alleged

    was entered in the Books of the ~ p p e ~ l a n t ’ ~ firm at the illa age Dakoor. It further

    ~ ~ 1 e ~ e ~ tfmt, in consequence of the ~ ~ s p o n d ~ ~ t ’ s refusd to c o n t r ~ ~ u t e his &are of

    losses s~i~tUined by the concern, tbe business of the Rank was sto~ped on the 2nd of

    * Present : ~ e y ~ ~ ~ e r s of the J u d ~ c ~ a ~ Con ~nittee,-Lord ~ y n f o r d , Lord Brougham,

    Mr. Justice ~ o s a ~ i ~ u e t ’ and the Chief Judge of the Court of ~ankruptcy.

    Privy Councillors,-~ssessoru, The Bight Hon. Sir Edward Eyde East, Bart.,

    and the Right Hon. Sir Alexander Johnston.

    This was an appeal from a jud

    -~

    R E . v&. 169 6U

    Novenl~er, 1823, The amount of the ~espor~der~t’s share of the total loss for which

    the ~ p p e ~ l a r ~ t epres~nted hiniself to be ~ r i ~ a r ~ ~ ~ li ble, was stated to be the

    principal sun1 of rupees 10,290. 2. 60,) for the recovery of which, with interest,

    a~nou~iting in the whole to rupees 111,745. 0. 85., the ~ p p e ~ l a I ~ t brought h i s suit.

    The ~espondent, by his ~ ~ ~ s ? ~ e r to the plaint, denied the partners~~ip, or that he

    had ever ~ d v a n ~ e d any ~noney on that a [ ~ c o ~ i n ~ .

    Both parties entered into evidence.

    The Appellant’s evidence, so f a r as it in any degree affected or could be used

    against the ~ ~ e s p o ~ ~ d e n t , co sisted first of an agre~n~ei i t alleged to have been signed

    by the ~ e s ~ o ~ l d e n t , which coi~ta~ned an a c k n o w ~ e d ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t that he had a fourth share

    aroda, and the deI?os~t~ons of ~~~itnesses in a up port [422] of that

    , the Ap~ellant’s accouIi~books, showing entries of, and relative

    to, the payment by the ~espondent of five hundred rupees as his share of the stock

    of the house of Naroda; and third, a letter alleged to have been written and serit by

    Huree Narain, an An~eeI~ ~ ~ o ~ ~ m ~ s s i o n e r ~ of Police, to the AppeK~ant at the Respon-

    dent’s request, c o ~ ~ t a i n i n ~ a confession that the ~ e s p o n d e ~ ~ t had a fourth share in

    the house a t Baroda j and the depositioRs of witnesses to prove that this letter lras,

    in fact, written and sent a t the ~espondent’s request.

    jee, pass this writing

    to you, ~ e t a ~ r ~ ~ ) e r ~anik- jee . 1x1 the money ~ r a n ~ a c t ~ o n s for the district of Ir’etlad

    with the Patel’s degbhaee, S a ~ ~ i ~ - b ~ a e e , and ~ e s ~ a b ~ ~ a e e , ~ s ~ ~ w a r ~ - d a s , the persona

    rnentioned below have shares, as follows : J31iut Tricurn-jee Wussun-jee have five and

    a half anas (5$>, of which J u ~ ~ ~ ~ a - d a s S ~ ~ n ~ i I r l a l aiid Bechur Joeta have sharea;

    ~ u t u i ~ - j e e ~ a ~ ~ a ~ ~ - d a s , ryho ha B s b p at, A ~ ) ~ ~ e d ~ ~ ~ a d , two alias (2) in the rupee j you

    have five and a half anas in the rupee, of which I have a fourth share with Junma-

    dtts ~ u n ~ u r l ~ l , and Beehur Joeta. Tkze r e ~ ~ a ~ n i n g three anas (3) in the r u p ~

    belongs to Nursai-bhaee, ~etaniBer~das’s house, in which Rutun-jee Rahan-das hits

    half (one ana and a half), and you ‘nave half of the remaining ana and a half, and

    I the other, being three-quarters of an ana each. In this house I have a fourt i~

    share, as i s d m v e stated, sixteen anas (161, o r one rupee among four persons.’>

    On the back of this agreement a paper was pasted, c o ~ ~ t a ~ n i n ~ the f o ~ l o ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

    end#rse~ent in the ~ i a ~ d - w r ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ of the ~ e s ~ o n d e n t :-

    ~ 4 2 3 ~ “ V a s divided whatever 8uni have been received, each partner taken his

    share ; besides this three Wloussnd five hundred rupees ( 3 ~ ~ 0 ~ i s due to you by the

    house a t Dakoor, which you can take when the money comes from h o n a ; but this

    money i s entered in another Book. Until the money arrives from Poona, I shall

    give you interest at the same rate as I usually do.-Dated 7th Assin-vud 1874.’’

    This docu~z~ei~t bore the sign re of the ~espondent, and was a~tested by

    Pundit;, Huree Narain, of tlre villa f Dakoor, and four other witnesses.

    These ~ ~ ~ t n e s s e s , with the e x c e ~ t ~ o n of Pundit, Buree Narain, were calied and

    examined by the Appel~ant. They all ackiiow~ed~ed their own s i g ~ ~ a t u ~ e s as

    attesting w~tnesses; but they varied from each other in the version they severally

    gave of the contents of the paper, and in the detail of circumstances attend in^ the

    alleged execution of it by the Respondent. A. s u ~ ~ t n o ~ i s was issued for his attendance ;

    but by the Nazir’s return upon the s u ~ ~ ~ ~ o n s , it appeared that he had then quitted

    , Pundit., Nuree Narain presented a petition to the

    Court, in which ha- d e ~ ~ a r e d ~ with reference to the d o c u ~ ~ e ~ ~ in ~ u e s t ~ o n , that in

    Sumvit year 1880, the Appe~~ant came to him at Kaira, and showed to him a

    written paper dated 7th Assin-vud, 1874, in the name, and with the s ignatu~e of the

    ~espondent, and re~uested that as the docunzent had not been attested by any one,

    he, Pundit, Nuree Xarain, would do so, and that by this means his signature had been

    obt~ined.

    Pundit, Huree Narain left K&ra ~ i t h ~ ~ u t being examined, and shortly a~terwards

    died. On the 1?th E&+&] of June, 1825, the A~pellant ~ r e s e ~ t e d to the Court

    another dec~aration in wr~ting, signed by ~ u n d ~ t ~ Huree R’arain, bearing date a t

    Dakoor, 2nd Katik-sood 1881 (October, I$%), and which was attested By two wit -

    nesses. By this declaration it was stated, that the paper or agreement before. referred

    to, was executed by the ~ e s p o n d e ~ ~ t on the day on which i t bears date, and was duly

    I70

    The a r ~ u ~ n e i ~ t nas 8s f o l ~ o ~ v ~ : - ~ ~ I, Mootee ~ h u i ~ d , Man

    ‘U. ~ i ~ T ~ E - C ~ U ~ ~ ~ A ~ I - J ~ ~ E18371 I EOORE IND. UP., 436

    attested by Pundit, Huree Warain, The witnesses to this decIaration deposed to

    its having been signed by Pundit, IIuree Narain, in their presence.

    The Zilhh Court considered that the evidence of the other attest~ng witnesses

    to the ResporIdei~t~s alleged agreen~ent, could not be relied upon as esta~)lishing the

    fact that the ~ e s p o n d ~ n t executed the paper to which their testimony referred ; and

    that the paper itself bore evident marks of being spurious and fabricated. The

    Court submit~ed the document to the e ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ a t i o n of five Shroffs, or Bankers, who

    were directed to give their opinion w h e ~ h ~ r the four last lines and the s ~ ~ n a t u r e on

    the back of it were written in the same handwriting as the first par t ; and i f there

    were anything else in the document which they should think i t necessary to mention,

    they were to do so. The answer of these five Bankers was, that they had carcfullp

    examined the d o c u ~ ~ e r ~ t referred to them, and they thought that a part of the paper

    haa been cut of?; that, in their opinion, the writing from the c o ~ ~ i i ~ e n c e ~ e n t of the

    docu~i~eRt down to the bottom of first page, was in the same h a n d w r ~ t i n ~ , but that

    the four lines on the back, and the signature were in a different handwriting.

    The -~ppellant also produced certain Books of account, which contained, among

    other entries, one E4251 relating to the payn~ent of five hundred rupees by the Re-

    spondent, on account of the stock or capital of the partne~ship concern.

    The Zillah Court, however, ieferred the Books to the e ~ a m i n ~ t i o n f the Shroffs,

    or Bankers, who reported that various crasurcs and alterations were apparent j

    that some of the entries affect in^ the ~ e s ~ o n d e n t appeared to have been recently

    made, and that, in their opinion, agree~bly to the custom of Bankers, tko item

    relied upon of five hundred rupees credited i n the nmie of the Respondent, could not

    be considered as a proper one.

    The Appellant endeavoured also to f i x upon the Respondent an adn~~asion or

    confession made by him to Huree Narain, an Ameen of Police, that he had a fourth

    share in the house at Baroda. Ne was examined on behalf of the ~ p p e ~ i & n t ; and

    stated t h t , on the 1st of Margasira-vud 7880 (February, 1824. A.D.), tun-jee, a t

    ten o’clock in the forenoon, sent for the witness to his house at Dakoor, whither the

    witness proceeded, and found there the Respondent, Kapoor ~ ~ ~ u n d ~ a i k ” j e e and

    Rutun-jee ; on which occasion the ~cspondent told the witness that he, the ~espondent,

    had a fourth share in the house at Barods, and was also indebted to the Appellant

    in the sum of 3500 rupees, being the a ~ o u n t of his share of the Petlad c o l l ~ ~ i o n s :

    for the recovering of both of which the Ap~)e~lant bad gone to Eaira, for the purpose

    of ~nst i tut i i~g a sui t against the ~espondent, and that the ~espondent hen requested

    the witness to call the Appellant back, as the Respondent wished to settle it; in

    coi~se~uence of which the witness wrote and desp~tched a letter to that eEect to the

    Appellant. This letter was produced by the Appellant, and was [426] verified by

    the witness, Kapoor-chund, who, together with one Vujeram, bearer of the letter,

    was represented to have been present on the occasion at which the conversation

    between Ameen, Efuree Nttrain and the ~espondent ook place, was also examined

    by the Appellant. Efis testimony varied from that of h e e n , fiuree Narain in some

    of the ~ncidents of the alleged meeting a t the house of Rutun-jee on the 1st of

    ~ a r ~ a s i r a - v u d , 1880.

    The only evidence produced by the ~espondent was wi th reference to the d~sputed

    document already noticed. The object of the Respondent’s evidence was to prove an

    alibi a t the time when i t was alleged he executed the d o c u ~ e n t in question. The

    Zilfah Court, however, placed no reliance upon this evidence,

    On the 6th of S e p t e ~ ~ ~ e r , 1835, the Zillalk Court of Aaira, after a full e x a ~ ~ n ~ t i o ~

    of the Appellant’s documents and the depositions of his witnesses, declared its opinion

    that the Appel~ant had totalIy failed to e s t a ~ ) l i s ~ ~ the ~espondent’s share in the

    banking concern at Baroda, and accordingly dismissed the suit with costs.

    From this decree of dismissal the Appellant appealed to the Sudder Adawlut

    of Bombay, by which Court the decree of the Rillah Court was, on the 21st of March,

    1626, a ~ r n ~ e d with costs.

    The Appellant appealed from the ~ a s ~ ~ ~ K ~ t i o ~ ~ e d decree to His ~ a ~ e s t y in Council,

    praying that the decision of the Sudder Adawlut of Bombay might be reversed,

    for the ~ o ~ l o ~ t i n ~ reasons :-

    I, Because the Appellant clearly proved that the ~espondent had a share ia

    the house established under the name of Rursai-bhaee Petamber-das.

    171

    I MOORE IND. APP., 427 PET. ~ A ~ ~ ~ - J ~ ~ V. ~ O ~ ~ ~ - C H ~ ~ ~ ~ A N I - J ~ ~ [1837]

    11. Because the Appellant ought to have had an [e71 opportunity of proving

    that the Shroffs, to whoni the examination of the agreement and of the Books of the

    Appellant was referred, were disposed to act with partiality towards the Appellant,

    or to make any other legal objection to those nomi~~ated which he was prepared to

    establish.

    111. Because it is no objection to the validity of an instrument that the body of

    it is written by another person, provided it be proved to have been signed by the

    party intended to be bound by it after i t has been so written ; and the irregularities

    (if any) in the Appellant's Books c o ~ ~ ~ ~ i t u t e d no bar to his claim, of which they

    could have found no legal proof.

    The Respondent, on the other hand, relied €or a confirmation of the decrees of

    the Courts below, on the following reason :-

    That, by the evidence adduced by the Appellant in the Zillah Court of Kaira, it

    was not proved that the Respondent had a.ny share or interest in the ban~ing-~~ouse

    in question in this appeal.

    Mr. PIPiller, K.C., and Mr. Wigram, K.C., for the Appellant. Mr. Serjeant

    Spankie, and Mr, E. J. Uoyd, for the Respondent.

    Lord ~ y n f o r d . - ~ h e i r Lordsl~~ps do not think it necessary to call upon the

    Respondent's Counsel. This is in fact an appeal against two judgments; the judg-

    ment of the Zillah Court of Kaira, confirmed by the Sudder Adawlut of Bornbay;

    the latter Court making no observations, but merely confirming the j udgment given

    by the Court below.

    E4281 The question depends entirely upon facts; and in a case c o ~ i n g before

    this Court, depending upon facta, which have received the judgment of two Courts in

    India, this Court ougkit not to set aside the last judgment, unless it can see very

    clearly that $kat judgment is wrong. It' must be most completely satisfied it was

    wrong and incon~istent with the justice of the case, and against the facts. So far

    from that being the case in the present case, their Lordships are of opinion t,hat, if

    those facts haa been presented to us in the first instance, we should have given the

    same judgment as pronounced by the two Courts in India. This case depends upon

    an instrument purporting to be an agreement entered into by the Respondent,

    ~ o t e ~ c h u n d ; and appears to be subscribed by the ~espondent, and to be witnessed

    by the Pundit, Buree Narain, who has alone given evidence to prove that the signature

    was formerly affixed to it, and four other parties ; but Huree Narain is the only one

    who says he saw the Respondent execute it. With respect to the validity of this

    i~~strument, i is enough for us to refer to the judgment of the Court below, without

    going through the circumstances of the case.

    Let us see, therefore, what the ZilIah Court says upon the subject : " On examining

    this paper, it appears that part of the original paper has been cut off, and four lines,

    just above the signature, written a t the back of it : these four lines, and the signature,

    are written in a differeiit handwr~tiiig from. the first part of the docun~ent. The

    Court, in order to have this point well ascertained, thinks it necessary to show it to

    some Bankers ; and a question is put to the following Bankers, who are therc named."

    Now here, it must be observed, that the Court itself found that [e93 instrument had

    been mutilated in the manner stated upon their own view of it, without the assistan~e

    of the Bankers; and that, in our opinion, gets rid of the objection made to these

    persons having been called in : for we get the fact here stated, by the Judge of the

    Zillah Court, that the instrument had been rnutiIated by a part of the document

    being cut off, and that the four lines on the back of it, and the signature, are written

    in a different handwriting from the first part of the instrument.

    It i s material that we should take notice that only one subscribing witness saw

    this instrument signed ; and, putting that witness out of the question, why rnay not

    mm0 very important lines have been cut off from the original document'l Cutting

    the paper off entirely, so that the signature, which was a t the bottom of the first

    paper, niight be added, by introducing another paper with those four lines upon

    it; and the genuine s~gnature, a p p l i c a b ~ ~ to a different transaction, is appe~ided to

    this paper, which i s in this state; and, bu t for the evidence of this one witness,

    there is no testimony in this eause, which goes the length of disproving that eirctrm-

    stance. Now, i s there any Court in the world that would receive such instrument,

    172

    MANIK-JEE 1'. ~ € I ~ o ~ ~ ~ ~ D - ~ J ~ ~ : [I8371 I "EOORE IND. APP., 430

    cut in the manner that this is, without more satisfactory evidence than has been

    produced? If a ~ l a i n t ~ f f produces a Bond in this country, or any other ~nstrL~i~~ent ,

    which appears to have been altered, thc Court will not receive it, or act upon it, till

    it is most satisfactorily proved by all the subscribing witnesses at the least and

    other evidence, that that alteration was made antecedently to the signature : there

    i s no such evidence here, and this is the whole of the case of the Plaintiff helow.

    14301 There is a circumstance which ought to be noticed : Huree Nai-ain, Atneen

    of Police, says the Defendant admitted he was a partner in the house: but v e

    cannot admit that that is sufficient to buoy up ail instrument that is krrciten down

    by all the facts that appear.

    Under these circumstances, the Court, so far from thinking they have that

    satisf~~ctory evidence that will enable them to reverse two jiidgments in India,

    where the Judges had an opportunity not only of hearing the witnesses, .vYhic+ is it

    great advantage they have over us in that respect, aed where they had an opportunity

    of seeing this i n s t r u ~ ~ e n t ; for though an English Judge might not have ~nderstooa

    the writing,. the manner in which these alterations were made, might have given us

    strong reasons for forniing a conclusion with respect to this rnatter ; but, wider

    these circumstances, the Court is of spinion &at the appeal must be dismissed ; a d

    as this case, on the view w e have taken of it, is founded in forgery at the least, and

    most likely forgery supported by perjury, we think it ought to be dismissed with

    costs."

    -_I-I ~.~

    14311 ~ ~ O O R S I ~ E D - J E ~ MANIIi-JEE,-ArJ~~f2%irnl; M E H ~ W ~ N - J ~ E KEOOR-

    S ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ and DAD^-^^^^^ ECEOORSHED-JEF,,-Be8l?oizJe12.Ls * [June

    2 2 and 23, 18371.

    On ~~p~~~ from the ~~1~~~~~ ~ e ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ o , ~ r ~ of ~ o ~ t ~ ~ ~ .

    The heirs of a Parsee Merchant having, upon his death, taken possession of his

    shop and continued to carry on his business for nearly tv-o years, the Courts

    below refused t o disturb their possession upon the production of a Will, by

    which the busitless was directed to be carried on by the Executor for their

    benefit, until he should think proper to admit them into possession: Held

    by the Judicial Committee of Privy Council, affirming the judgments of the

    Court below, that the abstaining from producing the Will for the above

    period was a consent on the part of the Appellants to the Respondents' posses-

    sion of their father's estate and business, and was, therefore, a virtual compli-

    anee with the terms of the Will [1 Moo. Ind. App. 4431.

    Semnbte-Where an instrument has beon admitted to probate, and acted upon in

    the Courts below, this Court will no% enter into the question whether the

    instrument i s sufficiently proved or not [ X Moo. Ind. App. 4.231.

    The Appel~ant efainied to be the acting Executor of Klioorshed-jee Komwur-jee,

    ~1 Parsee Mercliant, who resided and carried 011 business at Surat, and 'ct'as possessed

    of considerable property both there and at Bombay.

    Tipon h i s

    death, which happened on the 19th of September, 1815, they entered into possession

    of the shop, and rontinued the business of their deceased father, and in that character

    they paid and received money, engaged in various transactions, and sued and were

    sued in the Adawlut.

    [432j About $WO years after the death of Khoorshed-jee Koonwur-jee, his son-in-law,

    PeBhtun-jee Veer-jee, produce^ a Will and Codicil, which he alleged to have been

    * Present : Hembers of the Judicial Gommittee,-Lord Wynford, Lord Rrougham,

    Mr. Justice Bosanquet, Mr. Baron Parke, and the Right Hon. Thomas Erskine, Chief

    Judge of the Court of Bankruptcy,

    Privy C~unci~lors,-Assessors. the Right Won. Sir Edward Hyde East, Bar1 ,, arn&

    the Right Hon. Sir Alexander Johnston.

    The Respondents were sons and heirs of Koorshed-jee Iioonwur-jee.

    -- -___ -

    173

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Petamber Manik-Jee v. Motee-Chund Manik-Jee (India)
    (May 16, 1837)