Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The Respondent instituted a suit for possession against the petitioner, which was disposed of by consent terms. Under those terms the petitioner undertook to vacate the suit premises on or before 31-12-1983. The petitioner did not vacate the premises. The Respondent-decree holder initiated execution proceedings under Order XXI, Rule 22 of the Civil Procedure Code to enforce the consent decree.

The petitioner contended that the decree had become non-executable because, with effect from 1-1-1984, he had acquired fresh tenancy rights independent of the consent decree. The Small Causes Court, on 19-11-1998, allowed the petitioner to adduce evidence to establish those claimed tenancy rights. On 9-12-1998 the petitioner submitted draft issues to the Executing Court, but the Executing Court framed a single issue that day: “Does the defendant prove that he acquire tenancy rights after passing of the decree?”

On 16-12-1998 the petitioner applied for framing additional issues. The Executing Court disallowed that application and, by order dated 28-7-1999, held that it was not necessary for the Executing Court to frame issues and recalled the issue it had earlier framed. The petitioner challenged that order by way of the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether it is mandatory for the executing Court to frame an issue based on the rival stands of the parties in order to decide the question raised in execution proceedings.
  2. Whether the Executing Court was justified in suo motu recalling an issue which it had earlier framed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Executing Court is incumbent upon to frame issues whenever it has to determine any question arising between the parties.
  • Reliance was placed on Section 42 of the Civil Procedure Code and on provisions of Order 14 (Rule 1 and Rule 3) to contend that courts are duty bound to frame issues on the basis of the rival stands before proceeding to determine questions.
  • Reference was also made to Order XXI, Rule 101 and Rule 105 (Order 21, Rules 101 and 105) to contend that the Executing Court is empowered to decide all questions raised before it and therefore must frame proper issues and address them.

The opinion does not set out a detailed, separate account of the Respondent's arguments before this Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1956 Raj 1 — Ramjivan Ramnath v. Roopchand That issues are not necessarily framed when objections in execution proceedings are decided. The Court relied on this decision to hold that the Executing Court is not under an absolute obligation to frame issues in execution proceedings; framing issues is at best a matter of prudence and not a mandatory rule.
1999 (3) Mh. L.J. 779 : 1999 (3) All M.R. 45 — Manuel Coetans Gonsalves Partrico v. Antonio Broganza Interpretation of Order 14, Rule 5 (procedure for framing and recalling issues in suits). The Court noted that this decision concerned Order 14, Rule 5 and held that it is inapplicable to execution proceedings governed by Order XXI; thus reliance on it does not aid the petitioner in the present context.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court approached the matter in two stages: first addressing the manner and motive of the petitioner's challenge, and then examining the legal merits of the petitioner's contention regarding framing of issues.

As to motive and context, the Court found the writ petition to be an instance of abuse of judicial process. The petitioner had given an undertaking to vacate by 31-12-1983 but failed to do so and had repeatedly stalled execution proceedings by raising successive technical objections. The petitioner’s plea that the decree had become non-executable (by reason of acquiring fresh tenancy rights) was held to be unsupported by documentary evidence and characterised as frivolous. The Court observed that the petitioner used the present proceedings to agitate a purely procedural point concerning framing of issues with the purpose of delaying execution.

On the legal merits, the Court analysed the relevant procedural provisions. It held that provisions of Order 14 (which govern procedure for determination of suits) are inapplicable to execution proceedings, which are governed by Order XXI of the Civil Procedure Code. A plain reading of Order XXI, Rules 101 and 105 showed that the Executing Court is not under any imperative obligation to frame issues regarding questions raised in execution proceedings. Framing issues in execution proceedings is a matter of prudence and convenience rather than a statutory requirement.

The Court expressly relied on AIR 1956 Raj 1 (Ramjivan Ramnath v. Roopchand) to support the proposition that issues are not necessarily framed when objections in execution proceedings are decided. It also addressed the petitioner’s reliance on a decision interpreting Order 14 (the Manuel Coetans decision) and held that such authorities are not applicable to proceedings under Order XXI. Consistently, the Court found no error in the Executing Court recalling the single issue it had earlier framed when it concluded that framing issues was not obligatory.

The Court emphasised that procedure is a means to the end of disposing justice and should not be misused to prolong litigation. The Executing Court was directed to focus on deciding the main execution application with expedition rather than engaging in technical procedural disputes.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed. The Court's core ruling is: Writ petition dismissed.

Direct consequences and directions imposed by the Court:

  • The writ petition was dismissed with exemplary costs quantified at Rs. 10,000/-. The costs are to be deposited with the Legal Aid Committee, High Court, Bombay within two weeks.
  • The costs quantified do not preclude the Respondent from claiming appropriate damages or compensation against the petitioner as permissible in law.
  • The Executing Court was directed to decide the application under Order XXI, Rule 22 (which has been pending since 1994) within three months from receipt of this order. The parties were directed to appear before the Executing Court on 13-7-2000, and the Court was directed not to permit any adjournment; proceedings were to be conducted on a day-to-day basis to conclude within the three-month period.
  • A certified copy of the order was to be expedited, and parties were to act on the authenticated copy.

Broader implications: The Court reiterated that framing of issues in execution proceedings is discretionary and not mandatory; it cautioned against using procedural technicalities to delay enforcement of decrees. The opinion does not purport to set a new broad legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities (notably AIR 1956 Raj 1) to the facts; its principal effect is the dismissal of the petition and directions to expedite execution.

    C.V Joshi v. Elphinstone Spinning And Weaving Mills Co. Ltd.

    1. This writ petition by the Judgment-debtor takes exception to the order passed by the Judge of the Small Causes, Bombay dated 28th July, 1999 in Misc. Notice No. 20 of 1999 in Misc. Notice No. 716/1994 in L.E Suit No. 157/183 of 1983.

    2. The short question which arises for consideration in this case is whether it is mandatory for the executing Court to frame an issue on the basis of the stand taken by the rival parties for deciding the question raised before it. Secondly, whether the Court below was justified in suo motu recalling the issue, which was already framed earlier, by the impugned order.

    3. Briefly stated, the Respondent had instituted a suit for possession against the petitioner wherein consent terms came to be filed on the basis of which the said suit was disposed of. As per the consent terms the petitioner filed an undertaking before the Small Causes Court that he would vacate the suit premises on or before 31-12-1983. In spite of the said undertaking the petitioner did not vacate the suit property. Resultantly, the Respondent-decree holder was forced to move an application for execution of the consent decree, purporting to be an application under Order 21, Rule 22 of Civil Procedure Code. In the said proceedings the petitioner took a plea that the said decree has become non executable, as, with effect from 1-1-1984, the petitioner has acquired fresh tenancy rights, independent of the said consent decree. In view of the stand taken by the petitioner, the Small Causes Court on 19th November 1998, after hearing both the sides, ordered that the petitioner would be permitted to adduce evidence to establish his tenancy rights acquired after passing of the consent decree. Thereafter the petitioner submitted draft issues to the Executing Court on 9th December, 1998. Page: 196However, the Executing Court, on the same day, framed only one issue which reads thus:

    “Does the defendant prove that he acquire tenancy rights after passing of the decree?”

    4. The petitioner on 16-12-1998 made another application before the Executing Court to frame additional issues. The said application has been disallowed by the Executing Court on 28th July, 1999 on the ground that it is not necessary for the Executing Court to frame issues with regard to the stand taken by the parties and the execution proceedings can be finally decided without framing any issue. In the circumstances, the Executing Court thought it appropriate to recall the issue already framed on 9th December, 1998.

    5. The aforesaid order dated 28-7-1999 passed by the Executing Court is the subject matter of challenge before this Court. The learned Counsel for the petitioner contends that it is incumbent on the Executing Court to frame issue whenever it has to determine any question arising between the parties. Besides referring to section 42 of Civil Procedure Code he has also relied on Order 14, Rule 1 and Order 14, Rule 3 to contend that the Court is duty bound to frame issue on the basis of the rival stand taken before proceeding to determine the question raised before it. Reference is also made to Order 21, Rule 101 and Rule 105 regarding the power of the Executing Court in deciding the question which is raised before it. It is thus submitted that since the Executing Court is empowered to decide all questions raised before it, it is the duty of the Executing Court to frame proper issues and address itself to those issues.

    6. After having heard the rival contentions, I am of the view that the present writ petition is a classic instance of abuse of judicial process. Although, a consent decree has been passed and undertaking filed by the petitioner in the Court, that he would hand-over vacant and peaceful possession of the suit premises to the Respondent-plaintiff on or before December 31, 1983, the petitioner has succeeded in stalling the said decree so far on one pretext or the other. The petitioner has raised a plea of decree having become non executable which is not supported by any documentary evidence. Besides raising such frivolous plea, the petitioner has now taken recourse to the present proceedings to agitate that the Executing Court was bound to frame issues. This has been done with a definite purpose of protracting the execution of the decree. It is surprising that the Executing Court instead of deciding the main application has preferred to answer on the technical question as to the necessity of framing of issues. Undoubtedly, the execution proceedings in respect of a consent decree between the parties are pending since year 1994, although the petitioner was required to vacate the suit premises by 31-12-1983, as per his undertaking given to the Court. There can be no better instance than the present one to hold that this is a clear case of abuse of judicial process. On this count alone, I am inclined to dismiss the present writ petition. There can be no two opinions that the litigants are Page: 197primarily concerned with the final result of the case and not interested in getting locked up in procedural wrangles. Framing of issue would only enable the Court to focus its attention on the question raised before it between the parties and nothing more. Since no provision is made in the Code regarding the necessity of framing issues by the Executing Court, the Court would act with prudence. Procedure is evolved only to achieve the main object of dispensation of justice. It is only a means and not an end in itself. It may not be forgotten that it is on the Courts that citizens primarily repose trust. If they have respect for the work of the Courts, their respect for law will survive, but if they lose their respect for the work of the Courts, their respect for law and order will vanish with it to the great detriment of society. The approach of the Executing Court in the present case is bound to shatter the faith in the working of the Courts. There is no reason why the Courts should show any concession with regard to such technical plea at the instance of a party who seeks to ineffect resile from the consent decree and has disobeyed the undertaking given to the Court.

    7. Be that as it may, I shall now examine the merits of the contention advanced on behalf of the petitioner, lest the Courts do not get embroiled in such unstatable matters in future. Reliance has been placed by the petitioner on the provisions of Order 14, Civil Procedure Code which are inapplicable to the present case. We are concerned with the execution proceedings which are governed by the provisions of Order 21, Civil Procedure Code. In my view, Order 14 would apply only to the procedure regarding determination of the suit and not to the execution proceedings. Reference is also made to Order XXI, Rule 101 and Rule 105. On plain reading of the said provisions it would appear that the Executing Court is not under any obligation to frame issue regarding the question which has been raised before it. Framing of issue by the Executing Court would at best be a matter of prudence but not a rule. The Court below has rightly relied upon the decision reported in AIR 1956 Raj 1 (para 6) Ramjivan Ramnath v. Roopchand to hold that issues are not necessarily framed when objections in execution proceedings are decided. In the light of the said decision no further investigation on this question would survive. Instead of spending its precious time on adjudicating such trivial matters, the Executing Court would be well advised to decide the main execution proceedings with utmost despatch.

    8. Regarding the second grievance made by the petitioner that the Executing Court was not justified in recalling the issue which was already framed, I am of the view that the Executing Court by the impugned order has held that it was not obligatory for the Executing Court to frame any issue. I have already held that there is no error in this approach. Consistent with this view the Court has thought it appropriate to recall the issue which was framed. In the circumstances, this approach of the Executing Court cannot be assailed. The learned Counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on the decision of this Court reported in 1999 (3) Mh. L.J 779 : 1999 (3) All M.R 45 Page: 198Mr. Manuel Coetans Gonsalves Partrico v. Mr. Antonio Broganza. The said decision relates to Order 14, Rule 5, which has been held to be inapplicable to the present proceedings under Order 21. Civil Procedure Code. As already observed framing of issue would be matter of prudence, therefore, the Executing Court in the present case while deciding the question arising before it between the parties would nevertheless be guided by the issue framed earlier as to whether the petitioner herein has succeeded in establishing that he has acquired fresh tenancy rights after passing of the decree.

    9. For the aforesaid reasons, I am disposed of to dismiss the writ petition with exemplary costs. It is however made clear that the costs quantified in this order shall not preclude the Respondent from claiming appropriate damages/compensation against the petitioner as permissible in law. While dismissing this writ petition it would be in the interest of justice to direct the Executing Court to decide the application under Order XXI, Rule 22, which is pending before it since year 1994, within a period of 3 months from the receipt of this order. The parties shall appear before the Executing Court on 13-7-2000. The Court shall not permit any party to seek adjournment on any count and the proceedings be conducted on day to day basis, within 3 months from the receipt of this order.

    10. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed with exemplary costs quantified at Rs. 10,000/-. The costs to be deposited with the Legal Aid Committee, High Court, Bombay within a period of two weeks from today. The said Committee is requested to accept the said amount.

    11. Certified copy expedited.

    12. Parties to act on the copy of this order duly authenticated by Sheristedar of this Court.

    Writ petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    C.V Joshi v. Elphinstone Spinning And Weaving Mills Co. Ltd.
    (Jun 28, 2000)