Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion by Sardar Ali Khan, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter concerns a review petition filed against the judgment of this Court in Writ Appeal No. 1438 of 1988 dated 5-12-1990. That judgment was delivered by a division bench consisting of Justice Ramanujulu Naidu and Justice Lyyapu Panduranga Rao. After the judgment was delivered, Justice Ramanujulu Naidu retired from service, leaving Justice Lyyapu Panduranga Rao as the only remaining member of the original bench.

When the review petition was placed before a division bench composed of Sardar Ali Khan, J. and Lyyapu Panduranga Rao, J., the second respondent's counsel objected that the review could only be heard by the remaining judge of the earlier bench (Justice Lyyapu Panduranga Rao) sitting singly. The Court considered the applicable statutory provision (Order 47 Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure) and several authorities interpreting that rule, then directed that the review application be posted before the remaining single judge (Justice Lyyapu Panduranga Rao) for hearing and disposal.

The review petition sought review of the writ appeal judgment dated 5-12-1990 arising from earlier proceedings concerning a petitioner who had joined APSRTC as a junior clerk, tendered resignation which was accepted, later sought to withdraw the resignation, and litigated before the labour court and the high court. The original single judge had awarded compensation (Rs.15,000) but not reinstatement; on appeal the compensation was enhanced to Rs.25,000 while reinstatement was again refused. The review petitioner challenged that outcome.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Order 47 Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, a review petition against a judgment of a division bench that originally consisted of two judges (one of whom has since retired or otherwise cannot sit) must be heard only by the remaining original judge sitting singly, and not by any other judge or by a differently constituted division bench.
  2. Whether decisions or local rules from other High Courts (specifically the Madhya Pradesh decision in Manoharlal) can permit a differently constituted bench to hear a review despite Order 47 Rule 5, and whether such ratio is applicable in the present High Court where no similar local rules were framed.
  3. On the merits of the petitioner's request for reinstatement and back wages, whether the conditions for review under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC (discovery of new evidence, mistake apparent on the face of the record, or other sufficient reason) are satisfied.

Arguments of the Parties

Second Respondent's Arguments

  • Learned counsel for the second respondent (Sri D. Reddappa Reddy) argued that the review petition could not be heard by the division bench as constituted (Sardar Ali Khan, J. and Lyyapu Panduranga Rao, J.), and must be heard only by the remaining judge of the earlier bench (Justice Lyyapu Panduranga Rao) sitting single.
  • To support this contention, the counsel relied upon four decisions which, taken together, were said to establish that when one member of an original bench is unavailable (e.g., retired or elevated), the remaining judge alone must hear the review and any order passed by that single remaining judge is deemed to be the order of the original bench.

Petitioner's Arguments (Procedural)

  • Learned counsel for the petitioner (Sri Mirza Nisar Ahmed Baig) relied upon the decision in Manoharlal v. State (AIR 1970 Madhya Pradesh 131) to contend that the matter could be heard by the division bench as constituted before whom the matter was listed.
  • It was further submitted that since the bench had been constituted by the Chief Justice, the division bench should hear the matter and it need not be sent to the remaining judge to hear the review application.

Petitioner's Arguments (Merits)

  • On the substantive relief (reinstatement and back wages) the petitioner's counsel relied on decisions such as Sri Om Prakash Goel v. Himachal Pradesh Tourism Development Corporation Ltd. (1991 (3) S.C. 6) and Mohanlal v. Management, Bharat Electronics Ltd. (AIR 1981 SC 1253) to argue for reinstatement with back wages, on the basis that the court had found the resignation to be involuntary.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Order 47 Rule 5, Code of Civil Procedure (text reproduced in opinion) Specifies that where a judge who passed the decree or order remains attached to the court and is not precluded for six months after presentation of the review application, that judge shall hear the review and no other judge shall hear it. The Court interpreted and applied the rule to conclude that if one member of an original division bench has retired or is otherwise unable to sit, the remaining judge alone must hear the review and no other judge or differently constituted bench may hear it. The review was directed to be posted before the remaining single judge (Justice Lyyapu Panduranga Rao).
Achyuiam v. Annapurnamma, AIR 1903 Andhra Pradesh 277 (division bench decision) Interpreted Order 47 Rule 5 to hold that if one member of a bench is appointed to the Supreme Court (or otherwise unavailable), the remaining judge alone may hear the review and any order he passes is deemed to be on behalf of the original bench. The Court relied on this authority as supporting the proposition that the remaining judge alone should hear the review and that such single-judge decision is deemed to be the decision of the original bench.
Sitarama Sastry v. Sundaramma, AIR 1966 Andhra Pradesh 173 Affirmed that the remaining judge sitting single has jurisdiction to hear a review under Order 47 Rule 5 where other judges who formed the original bench are unavailable. The Court cited this case as additional support for the rule that the remaining original judge may alone hear the review application.
Maji Mohan Kanwar v. State, AIR 1967 Rajasthan 264 Held that where one judge of a division bench is unable to be part of the bench, the remaining judge alone must hear the review and it cannot be heard by other judges or by the remaining judge sitting with another judge who was not a party to the original bench. The Court used this decision to reinforce the view that the remaining judge must hear the review alone and should not sit with other judges who were not part of the original bench.
Bhera v. Board of Revenue, AIR 1975 Rajasthan 55 Affirmed the principle from Maji Mohan Kanwar that if one member of a bench is available, the review application should be heard by that member alone. The opinion cited this case as confirming the consistent judicial position that the remaining member alone should hear the review petition.
Manoharlal v. State, AIR 1970 Madhya Pradesh 131 Interpreted local rules (rules 3 and 4 of Chapter I of rules framed by the Madhya Pradesh High Court under Article 226) to hold that in cases not covered by Order 47 Rule 5, a review may be heard by a bench constituted differently (including another division bench). The Court examined this authority and distinguished it: Manoharlal was based on local rules framed by the Madhya Pradesh High Court (rules 3 & 4). Since no similar rules exist in the present High Court, the ratio was held inapplicable and Order 47 Rule 5 remains controlling here.
Sri Om Prakash Goel v. H.P. Tourism Dev. Corporation Ltd., 1991 (3) S.C. 6 Authorities cited by the petitioner for the proposition that reinstatement and back wages may be appropriate where resignation was not voluntary. The Court examined this Supreme Court authority and concluded that it was not applicable to the review before it because review jurisdiction is governed by Order 47 Rule 1 CPC and the statutory conditions for review were not met.
Mohanlal v. Management, Bharat Electronics Ltd., AIR 1981 SC 1253 Also cited by petitioner in support of reinstatement and back wages where resignation was involuntary. The Court considered this authority but found it inapplicable for the same reason: review under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC requires satisfaction of statutory grounds which were not shown in the present petition.
Order 47 Rule 1, Code of Civil Procedure (text reproduced in opinion) Sets out the grounds and conditions under which a review of judgment may be sought (new evidence, mistake apparent on face of record, or other sufficient reason). The Court applied Order 47 Rule 1 to the substantive review request and held that the petitioner did not meet the statutory conditions for review; the bench had considered reinstatement but declined it for reasons stated in the judgment, and no grounds for review under Rule 1 were established.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two main analytical tracks: (A) the procedural question of which judge or bench may hear the review under Order 47 Rule 5 CPC; and (B) the substantive merits of the review petition under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC.

(A) Procedural Analysis — Interpretation of Order 47 Rule 5 CPC

  • The Court reproduced the text of Order 47 Rule 5 CPC and emphasized its plain language: if a judge who passed the decree or order continues attached to the court when the review application is presented and is not precluded for six months from considering the matter, that judge shall hear the application and no other judge shall hear it.
  • The Court surveyed a consistent line of authorities (from Andhra Pradesh and Rajasthan High Courts) holding that where a division bench judgment was rendered by two judges and one judge is subsequently unavailable (retired or elevated), the remaining judge alone must hear the review and his decision is deemed to be the order of the original bench.
  • The Court considered and distinguished Manoharlal (M.P.) where the Madhya Pradesh High Court had framed local rules (rules 3 & 4) that permitted a differently constituted bench to hear reviews in certain circumstances. The present High Court had no such local rules; therefore Manoharlal was not applicable.
  • The Court rejected the argument that a bench constituted by the Chief Justice should nevertheless decide the review; the Court held that Order 47 Rule 5 and the cited authorities require the remaining original judge to hear the review alone, so the review had to be posted to Justice Lyyapu Panduranga Rao to hear singly.

(B) Substantive Analysis — Application of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC to the Merits

  • The Court set out the statutory grounds for review under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC: discovery of new and important matter/evidence (despite due diligence), mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or other sufficient reason.
  • The Court noted that the bench (including the single judge) had considered reinstatement but declined it, giving reasons: the petitioner was a practising advocate and later appointed Assistant Government Pleader; the single judge had observed that the petitioner "will do well to reconcile herself as an advocate than seeking reinstatement" and thus refrained from ordering reinstatement or back wages despite acknowledging the circumstances normally meriting such relief.
  • Because the issue of reinstatement had been considered on the merits by the single judge and by the bench, and because the petitioner had not brought forward new evidence or shown a mistake apparent on the face of the record, the conditions for review under Order 47 Rule 1 were not satisfied.
  • Additional factual conduct by the petitioner was noted: the petitioner had accepted and withdrawn awarded compensation (first Rs.15,000 then the difference when enhanced to Rs.25,000), and thus her conduct disentitled her from further relief.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that the review application must be heard by the remaining original judge alone and directed that the review be posted before Justice Lyyapu Panduranga Rao for hearing and disposal. On the merits, finding that the statutory conditions for review under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC were not met and that the petitioner's conduct disentitled her from relief, the Court DISMISSED the review petition.

Implications:

  • Direct procedural consequence: the review application was to be heard by the remaining judge of the original bench (Justice Lyyapu Panduranga Rao) sitting singly; a differently constituted division bench should not hear the review in the absence of a local rule to the contrary.
  • Direct substantive consequence: the petitioner was denied reinstatement and back wages; the review petition was dismissed for failure to satisfy the statutory grounds for review and in view of the petitioner's conduct regarding acceptance/withdrawal of awarded compensation.
  • No broader new legal precedent was declared by this opinion beyond reaffirming the consistent line of authority interpreting Order 47 Rule 5 CPC; the Court distinguished Manoharlal (M.P.) on the factual ground that no analogous local rules exist in the present High Court.

This summary is based exclusively on the text of the provided opinion. No information beyond that opinion has been added.

    K. Pushpa Leela v. Labour Court Guntur

    Sardar Ali Khan, J.:-

    (1) An interesting question of considerable importance has arisen in this case. The facts of the matter lie within a narrow field.

    (2) The review petition has been filed for the review of the judgment of this court in w a no. 1438 of 1988 dated 5 - 12 - 90. That judgment was passed by a division bsnch of this court consisting of m/s g ramanujulu naidu j and lyyapu panduranga rao j. After passing the judgment mr ramanujulu naidu j has retired as a judge of this high court. The only remaining member of that bench which heard the case and passed the judgment in w a no. 1438 of 1988 dated 5 - 12 - 90 is mr. Lyyapu panduranga rao j.

    (3) When the application for review was filed the matter was placed before this division bench consisting of mr sardar ah khan j and mr lyyapu panduranga rao j.

    (4) Sri d reddappa reddy learned counsel appearing on behalf of the 2nd respondent in this case raised a legal issue that the review petition cannot be heard by this division bench and that it should be heard only by the remaining judge of the earlier bsnch (viz mr lyyapu panduranga rao j) sitting single. The iearned counsel relied upon four decisions in this regard to substantiate his contention that it is the remaining judge alone who has to hear the review petition in case the other judge has retired from service.

    (5) Before considering the case law relied upon by the learned counsel it would be appropriate to re produce hereunder the provisions of Order 47 rule 5 of the code of civil procedure which deals with the question of application for review in court consisting of two or more judges. Order 47 rule 5.

    "where the judge or judges or any one of the judges who passed the decree or made the order a review of which is applied for continues or continue attached to the court at the time when the application for a review is presented and is not or are not precluded by absence or other cause for a period of six months next after the application from considering the decree or order to which the application refers such judge or judges or any of them shall hear the application and no other judge or judges of the court shall hear the same".

    The rule is clear to the effect that if a judge or judges who passed the decree or made the order a review of which is applied for continues or continue attached to the court at the time when the application for a review is presented and is not or are not precluded by absence or other cause for a period of six months next after the application is presented then such judge or judges alone shall hear the application and no other judge or judges can hear the same. It is pertinent to note that the final words occurring in this rule are that "no other judge or judges of the court shall hear the same". The inteipretatioa of the rule has been the subject matter of a decision of a division bench of this court reported in achyuiam vs. Annapurnamma air 1903 andhra pradesh 277. It may suffice to state that the division bench in this matter held that where a judgment and decree is passed by two judges and one of the judges having been appointed to the supreme court the review application against the judgment and decree is posted under order 47 rule 5 of the code of civil procedure before the other judge and he dismisses it the order passed by the judge sitting alone is deemed to be on behalf of the bench that originally heard the appeal. As against the judgment of the bench of the court, there can be no further appeal to another division bench. This judicial dictum has been laid down by the division bench in the light of the provisions of Order 47 rule 5 of the code of civil procedure which obviously means that in case one of the judges of the division bench has retired from service or has been elevated to the supreme court and therefore cannot form a party to the bench before whom the review application is filed then the remaining judge alone shall hear the application for review and the decision of the single judge passed on that review application is deemed to be the order of the division bench.

    (6) Another decision reported in sitarama sastry vs. Sundaramma air 1966 andhra pradesh 173 is also to the same effect where a single judge held that the contention that the remaining judge sitting single has jurisdiction to pass orders on review petition is well founded in law. The single judge in that case assumed jurisdiction under order 47 rule 5 of the code of civil procedure and heard the review application in the absence of the other judges who had retired from service.

    (7) In yet another decision reported in maji mohan kanwar vs. State air 1967 rajasthan 264 a division bench has taken the view under order 47 rule 5 of the code of civil procedure that if a review is sought of an order or decree passed by a division bench and if one of the judges of that bench is unable for the causes stated above to form a party to that division bench then the matter is to be heard by the remaining judge alone and cannot be heard by other judges or by the remaining judge sitting with another judge who was not a party to the original decree or order cought to be reviewed. This view of the rajasthan high court was affirmed in the decision reported in bhera vs. Board of revenue air 1975 rajasthan 55 wherein it was held relying upon the earlier authority of maji mohan's case (3 supra) that even if one member of the high court is available the review application should be heard by him alone.

    (8) It is therefore evident that the consistent judicial opinion as emerging from the above decided cases is that in a matter of this nature it is the remaining judge alone who has to hear the review petition and no other judge. More over, the remaining judge forming part of the division bench along with another judge who had not heard the matter earlier should not have the jurisdiction to hear the review application.

    (9) Sri mirza nisar ahmed baig. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in this matter, relied upon a decision reported in manoharlal vs. State air 1970 madhya pradesh 131 and contended that the matter can be heard by the division bench as constituted before whom the matter is listed. We would like to analise the judgment relied upon by the learned counsel to see whether the ratio of that case is applicable to the case on hand. In that case what happened was that certain rules were framed by the madhya pradesh high court providing for review of cases decided under article 226 of the constitution of india. rules 3 and 4 of chapter i of the rules framed by that high court provided that "in cases not provided for by order xlvii rule 5 of the code of civil procedure, an application for review of a decree or order shall be heard. (a) if the decree or order, review of which is applied for, is passed by a judge alone, by a bench of two judges: (b) if the said decree or order was passed by a bench of two or more judges, by a bench consisting of as many judges as the bench of whose decree or order review is applied for. " it is in the light of rules 3 and 4 the madhya pradesh high court held that the provisions of Order 47 rule 5 of the code of civil procedure are not applicable and the matter could heard by another division bench of by an equal number of judges who have decided the earlier matter of which the review is sought for by the parties. We are afraid that the ratio of this case is not applicable to the matter arising before us for the simple reason that no rule to the same effect has been framed by our high court as was done in the case of madhya pradesh high court. In other words the review application will have to be disposed of in accordance with the provisions of Order 47 rule 5 of the code of civil procedure. It has also been submitted by the learned counsel mr. Baig that since in any case the bench has been constituted by the hon'ble the chief justice the matter should be beard by the division bench itself and need not be sent to the remaining judge (viz mr lyyapu panduranga rao, j) to hear the review application. This matter no doubt has been posted before this division bench but in the light of the provisions of Order 47 rule 5 of the code of civil procedure and the decisions referred to earlier in this judgment it is obvious that the matter is to be heard only by the remaining single judge (mr. Lyyapu panduranga rao j) and not by any other judge as such. Therefore, we direct that this review application may be posted before the learned single judge mr. Lyyapu panduranga rao j for hearing and disposal of the same according to law. This review wamp coming on before the hon'ble sri justice lyyapu panduranga rao on this the 28th day of november, 1991 for final hearing pursuant to the order of this court dated 4 - 10 - 1991 and passed herein and upon perusing the petition and the order of this court dated 4 - 10 - 91 and made herein and upon hearing the arguments of the counsels appearing on behalf of the parties concerned, the court made the following : order

    (10) This review petition is directed to review the judgment of this court in writ appeal nos. 931 and 1438 of 1988 dated 5 - 12 - 90.

    (11) The said judgment was delivered by me and justice ramanujulu naidu. Since justice ramanujulu naidu retired from service, the matter is posted before me in view of the provisions of Order 47 rule 5 cpc. The brief facts of the case of the petitioners is that the petitioner joined the service of apsrtc as a junior clerk on 26 - 8 - 80. Since she could not get on well with her colleagues, she was transferred to retreading section of apsrtc at vijayawada as a junior clerk. Later she was again transferred to the office of the assistant engineer, apsrtc guntur. Since there also things did not improve she submitted a letter of resignation on 17 - 8 - 1983 which was accepted by the coneerned authorities on 26 - 8 - 83 and the acceptance was duly communicated to her. Later the review petitioner submitted a representation to the authorities coneerned permitting her to withdraw her letter of resignation. But, the same was not complied with. Consequently she filed i d no. 264/85 before the labour court, guntur which was dismissed as per orders dt. 20 - 5 - 86. Assailing the orders in i d no. 264/85, a writ petition no. 7492/87 was filed and the learned single judge allowed to the writ petition partly and awarded a compensation of rs. 15,000/ - while not granting relief of re - instatement as prayed for. Being aggrieved with the said judgment in w p no. 7492/87, while the review petitioner filed wa no. 1430/88, the apsrtc filed w a no. 938/88. Both the writ appeals were heard and disposed of as per the common judgment dated 5 - 12 - 90 wherein the compensation awarded by the learned single judge at rs. 15,000/ - was increased to rs. 25,000/ - while rejecting the reinstatement of the petitioner in service as prayed for. Aggrieved by the said judgment, the petitio - ner came up with the present petition.

    (12) The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that this court has categorically gave a finding that the resignation letter was not given by the petitioner voluntarily and hence this court should have ordered reinstatement of the petitioner with full back wages. To support his contention, the learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the decisions in sri om prakash goel vs. Hp tourism dev. Corporation limited and another it 1991 (3) sc 6. And mohanlal vs. Management bharat electronics ltd, air 1981 sc 1253. Having examined these cases, i find that these decisions have no application. Order 47 rule 1 cpc governs the case where review is asked for. Order 47 rule 1 cpc reads as follows :

    "o. 47 - r. 1. Application for review of judgment : - (1) any person considering himself aggrieved - (a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed, but from which no appeal has been preferred. (b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is allowed or (c) by a decision on a reference from a court or small causes, and who from the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which after the exercise of due deligence was not within his knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the decree was passed or order made or on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient reason desires to obtain a review of the decree passed or order made against him, may apply for a review of judgment of the court which passed the decree or made the order".

    (13) Review is permitted only in cases where (1) discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after exercise of due diligence was not within the knowledge or could not be produced by the party at the time when the decree was passed or order was made. (2) on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient reason. In this case having considered the request of the review petitioner for reinstatement into service the court considered the matter at length and observed as follows : "since she is a practising advocate it seems to me that the petitioner will do well to reconcile herself as an advocate than seeking reinstatement in the office of the corporation. Where she had been humiliated. Taking all these circumstances into account, i would refrain from directing the reinstatement of the petitioner and also the payment of backwages although in the normal circumstances, i would have given that direction in the present case.

    (14) In these circumstances, the learned single judge thought it fit to award compensation to the petitioner. Thus the question of reinstatement of the petitioner was considered but the said relief was not granted in view of the fact that the review petitioner was practising as an advocate in this court. It is also to be noted that as on today, the review petitioner is appointed as assistant government pleader in high court. Thus the learned single judge as well as the bench who heard the writ appeals considered the question of reinstatement of the review petitioner in the circumstances but the said relief was negatived for the reasons mentioned supra. In view of the said circumstances it is not now open for the review petitioner to ask for review of the judgment since the conditions laid down under Order 47 rule 1 cpc are not complied with.

    (15) The conduct of the petitioner disentitled her from claiming any relief. It is to be seen that when the learned single judge awarded a compensation of rs. 15,000/ - the said amount was withdrawn by the review petitioner. Similarly when the said compensation was enhanced to rs. 25,000/ - in the writ appeal the difference of rs. 10,000/ - was also deposited and the said amount was also withdrawn by her. Admittedly the review petition has already withdraw relevence benefits also. Under these circumstances, finding no merits the review petition is dismissed.

    Order 47 ruleOrder 47 ruleOrder 47 rule
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K. Pushpa Leela v. Labour Court Guntur
    (Dec 5, 1990)