Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Order 39 Rule 3 proviso as also Order 39 Rule 3(a) of the CPC.
  • parties.5. Order 39 Rule 1 of the CPC
  • parte.9. Order 39 Rule 3 of the CPC
  • Order 39, Rule 3(a)(b) of the CPC.2.
  • Order 39 Rule 1 of the CPC
  • Order 39 Rule 3(a)(i
  • Order 39, Rule 3-A,
  • Order 3 Rule 3(a)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Order 39 Rule 3 proviso as also Order 39 Rule 3(a) of the CPC.
  • parties.5. Order 39 Rule 1 of the CPC
  • parte.9. Order 39 Rule 3 of the CPC
  • Order 39, Rule 3(a)(b) of the CPC.2.
  • Order 39 Rule 1 of the CPC
  • Order 39 Rule 3(a)(i
  • Order 39, Rule 3-A,
  • Order 3 Rule 3(a)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

On 21-1-2007 the petitioner instituted a civil suit in the Court of Sub Judge, Udhampur, seeking recovery of Rs. 3,000 as damages for alleged illegal dismantling of a compound wall (details were in the plaint) and a permanent injunction restraining the respondents from interfering with the suit compound or any construction “of his choice” by the petitioner on the suit land. Along with the suit, the petitioner sought an ad-interim (temporary/ex parte) injunction.

On the same date the Trial Court granted an ad-interim injunction temporarily restraining the respondents from interfering with construction of the compound wall raised by the petitioner; the operative part of that order is quoted in the record and directed service of the plaint and documents in terms of Order 39, Rule 3(a)(b) CPC.

By order dated 29-1-2007 the Trial Court directed police officers (Additional S.P. Udhampur and Officer In-charge, Police Station Rehambal) to implement the ad-interim injunction on the spot and to submit compliance reports.

Respondents entered appearance and filed objections on 6-2-2007. The respondents filed a civil miscellaneous appeal on 8-3-2007 before the Principal District Judge, Udhampur. The Appellate Court, by its order dated 30-8-2007, set aside the Trial Court order dated 22-1-2007, remanded the matter to the Trial Court for fresh orders, and directed restoration of the on-spot position to what existed prior to commencement of the suit.

The petitioner challenged the Appellate Court order dated 30-8-2007 by filing the present Civil Revision Petition. The matter was heard and the opinion under summary was rendered.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Court acted within jurisdiction and in accordance with law in granting an ex parte ad-interim injunction on 22-1-2007 and in directing police to implement that order on 29-1-2007.
  2. Whether the Trial Court complied with the procedural requirements of Order 39, Rules 1, 3 and 3-A (and the duty to decide an ex parte injunction application within one month) of the Civil Procedure Code when it granted the injunction without notice.
  3. Whether the Appellate Court was justified in setting aside the Trial Court's ex parte interim injunction order and remanding the matter for fresh consideration.
  4. Whether the Appellate Court had competence to direct restoration of the physical position on spot to the state prior to institution of the suit (including reference to the applicability or scope of Section 144 CPC in that context).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Trial Court's order dated 22-1-2007 was within its jurisdiction and the Trial Court lawfully exercised its discretion under Order 39 CPC.
  • Given the emergent nature of the matter, the Trial Court properly dispensed with notice before granting the ad-interim injunction.
  • Because the Trial Court's order was made "subject to objections" the Appellate Court should have refrained from interfering and allowed the Trial Court to decide the temporary injunction application on merits.
  • The Trial Court was justified in issuing the 29-1-2007 order directing police to implement the ad-interim injunction due to alleged disobedience of its earlier order.
  • The Appellate Court lacked competence to direct restitution of the position as it existed prior to commencement of the suit; Section 144 CPC, the petitioner contended, did not apply to an order on a temporary injunction application and, in any event, the power under Section 144 is restricted to reversal of a decree and is to be exercised by the court which passed the decree or the order varied or reversed in appeal.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the statutory framework governing temporary injunctions, principally Order 39 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC). The court summarized the purpose of Order 39 Rule 1 as being to preserve the subject-matter of the suit so that the successful party at trial can reap the fruits of litigation and the trial does not become infructuous if the property is wasted, damaged or alienated.

The court analyzed whether the Trial Court's ad-interim injunction served the preservation purpose or in fact granted final relief at the threshold. The court observed that the Trial Court, by permitting the petitioner to raise constructions (including the compound wall) on the suit land, effectively granted final relief at the outset. Once construction is permitted, the court found, there remained little substantive controversy to be litigated at trial.

The court emphasized procedural requirements of Order 39: Rule 3 generally prohibits grant of an injunction without notice; the exception for urgency requires recorded reasons; the applicant must serve copies and file an affidavit proving compliance with the provisions (including Order 39 Rule 3(a)(i)–(iii)). The court also noted an obligation under Order 39 Rule 3(a) (and related provisions) that an ex parte injunction must be decided within 30 days.

Applying those principles to the present facts, the court concluded that the Trial Court failed to follow the proviso to Order 39 Rule 3 and Order 39 Rule 3(a). In particular the Trial Court granted an ex parte injunction without securing an undertaking from the petitioner to demolish construction if the petitioner failed at trial, and it also failed to decide the injunction application within the one-month/30-day period mandated for ex parte grants despite the respondents having filed objections on 6-2-2007.

On that basis the court held that the Appellate Court was right to set aside the Trial Court's ex parte injunction order dated 22-1-2007 and to remand the matter for fresh consideration; the setting aside did not amount to irregular exercise of jurisdiction nor to failure of justice.

The court then turned to the Appellate Court's direction to restore the on-spot position to what existed prior to commencement of the suit. The court found that this direction was inappropriate. First, when a matter is remanded for fresh disposal of an injunction application, it is for the Trial Court to decide whether restoration is necessary (for example if the petitioner materially changed the position on spot relying on the ex parte order). Second, the court reasoned that powers under Section 144 CPC (to order restitution) are to be exercised at the instance of a party entitled to restitution and, importantly, by the court which passed the decree or the order varied or reversed in appeal. Consequently, the Appellate Court lacked jurisdiction or lawful justification for directing restoration of the physical position as it was prior to institution of the suit.

For these reasons the court held that the Appellate Court's direction for restoration was an irregular exercise of jurisdiction and that portion of the Appellate Court's order was set aside.

The court concluded by disposing of the Civil Revision petition "accordingly," directing the parties to appear before the Trial Court on 2-8-2010 and instructing the Trial Court to take all possible steps to dispose of the temporary injunction application within 30 days from that date.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Civil Revision petition was disposed of. The Court upheld the Appellate Court's setting aside of the Trial Court's ex parte ad-interim injunction and remand for fresh consideration, but set aside the Appellate Court's direction that the Trial Court restore the on-spot position to what existed prior to commencement of the suit.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The Trial Court's ex parte injunction order dated 22-1-2007 was correctly set aside by the Appellate Court to the extent that it had been granted without compliance with the safeguards in Order 39 (Rule 3 proviso and Rule 3(a)) and without timely adjudication within the statutory 30-day period; that part of the Appellate Court's order stands.
  • The Appellate Court's direction to restore the physical position on spot to the state existing before institution of the suit was irregular and has been set aside. Restoration, if appropriate, is a matter for the Trial Court to consider on remand and may involve application of Section 144 CPC only in the circumstances and by the court entitled to exercise that power.
  • The Trial Court was directed to hear and decide the temporary injunction application afresh and to take all possible steps to dispose of it within 30 days from 2-8-2010; the parties were directed to appear on that date.
  • No new precedent was created by this decision; the court applied and interpreted existing provisions of Order 39 CPC and Section 144 CPC as they applied to the facts of the case.

Order accordingly. Disposed of.

    Anant Ram v. Isher Dass & Ors.

    1. The petitioner on 21-1-2007 commenced a Civil Suit against the respondents in the Court of Sub Judge Udhampur for recovery of an amount of Rs. 3000/- from the respondents as damages for illegal dismantling of the compound wall, details whereof were given in the plaint. The petitioner also asked for permanent injunction decree perpetually restraining the respondents from interfering with the suit compound or any construction “of his choice” raised by the petitioner on the suit land. Alongside the suit the petitioner filed an application for grant of ad-interim injunction. The Trial Court on the date of institution of the suit and temporary injunction application, granted temporary injunction in favour of the petitioner and temporarily restrained the respondents from causing any interference in construction of the compound wall raised by the petitioner to fence the suit property. The operative part of the interim injunction dated 22-1-2007 reads as under:

    “……… In the meantime defendants/nonapplicants are temporarily restrained from causing any interference in the construction of compound walling being raised by the plaintiff/applicant in the suit property referred above. This order is however subject to objections from the other side. Plaintiff applicant is directed to supply copy of the plaint and documents annexed herewith to the defendants/non applicants along with the copy of order and file a service affidavit to this effect forthwith in terms of Order 39, Rule 3(a)(b) of the CPC.”

    2. The ad-interim injunction order dated 22-1-2007 was followed by an order dated 29-1-2007 directing Additional S.P Udhampur, and officer Incharge Police Station Rehambal, to implement the ad-interim injunction on spot, without fail and submit compliance report. Copy of the order was directed to be forwarded to the aforementioned Police officers for strict compliance. However, the Trial Court did not take any steps to finally dispose of the temporary injunction application within one month after ex parte injunction was passed as is mandated by Order 39, Rule 3-A, though the respondents entered appearance and even filed their objections on 6-2-2007. The respondents aggrieved of ex parte ad-interim injunction order dated 22-1-2007 filed a civil miscellaneous appeal on 8-3-2007 in the Court of Pr. District Judge, Udhampur. The Appellate Court vide order dated 30-8-2007 set aside the Trial Court order dated 22-1-2007 remanded the matter and asked the Trial Court to pass fresh orders and also restore the position on spot, to the position as it existed prior to commencement of the suit.

    3. The Appellate Court order dated 30-8-2007 is assailed in the present Civil Revision Petition on the grounds that the order is against law and facts and liable to be set aside. It is insisted that the order of the Trial Court dated 22-1-2007 fell within jurisdiction of the Trial Court and that the Trial Court while passing the order set aside in appeal, exercised discretion in a lawful manner warranting no interference from the Appellate Court. The Trial Court, it is pleaded, was alive to the fundamental principles that govera Page: 111exercise of discretion under Order 39 of the CPC. The matter being of emergent nature, it is averred, the Trial Court rightly dispensed requirement of notice prior to grant of ad-interim injunction. It is pleaded that the order of the Trial Court being subject to objections, the Appellate Court ought to have taken its hands off the matter and permitted the Trial Court to decide the temporary injunction application. The order dated 29-1-2007 is being justified on the ground that the Trial Court confronted with disobedience of the order dated 22-1-2007, was left with no option but to direct the police to ensure compliance of the adinterim injunction order on the spot. The petitioner also questions competence of the Appellate Court to direct restitution of the position as on the date of commencement of the suit on the ground that section 144 was not applicable to an order made on a temporary injunction application and the provision was restricted in scope, to the reversal of a decree and that only the Court that passes decree is clothed with the powers to press into service Section 144 of the CPC.

    4. I have gone through the revision petition as also the order impugned and have heard Ld. Counsel for the parties.

    5. Order 39 Rule 1 of the CPC enumerates the cases in which temporary injunction may be granted. It reads as under:

    “Cases in which temporary injunction may be granted

    Where in any suit it is proved by affidavit or otherwise.

    (a) that any property in dispute in a suit is in danger of being wasted, damaged or alienated by any party to the suit, or wrongfully sold in execution of a decree, or

    (b) that the defendant threatens, or intends, to remove or dispose of his property with a view to defrauding his creditors, the Court may by order grant a temporary injunction to restraint such act, or make such other order for the purpose of staying and preventing the wasting, damaging, alienation, sale removal or disposition of the property (or dispossession of the plaintiff, or otherwise causing injury to the plaintiff in relation to any property in dispute in the suit) as the Court thinks fit, until the disposal of the suit or until further orders,

    (c) that the defendant threatens to dispossess the plaintiff or otherwise causes injury to the plaintiff in relation to any property in dispute in the suit.

    6. A bare look at Order 39 Rule 1 of the CPC makes it clear that a purpose and object of the provision, is to preserve the subject matter of the suit so that the parties claiming their rights over the subject matter have an opportunity to substantiate their respective stand and the party at the end of trial found entitled to the relief, is in a position to reap the fruits of litigation. In case the suit property is allowed to be wasted, damaged or alienated the trial itself shall become infructuous and purposeless.

    7. Let us see whether the threshold order made by Ld. Trial Court was in the nature of preservation of the suit property and aimed at projecting against any damage or waste.

    8. The petitioner's case before the Trial Court was that the petitioner was in possession of suit property, that the petitioner proposed to raise construction on and around the suit property including a fencing wall and that the respondents were interfering in petitioner's possession over the suit property as also in the proposed construction. The Trial Court on the very date the temporary injunction application was filed, granted the temporary injunction in favour of the petitioner and against the respondents inter alia restraining the respondents from causing any interference in the construction of compound wall being raised by the petitioner. The Trial Court did not realize that the Trial Court was in effect granting final relief claimed in the suit at the very threshold. Once the petitioner was allowed to raise construction on the suit land, nothing substantial was left in the suit that was yet to be taken to the take off stage. The trial Court did not find it necessary to at-least ask the respondents to undertake to demolish the construction raised in the event the petitioner failed to succeed in the suit. This apart once the Trial Court decided to grant an injunction without giving notice to the opposite party, it was incumbent upon the Trial Court to decide the temporary injunction Page: 112application within one month from the date the temporary injunction was granted in ex parte.

    9. Order 39 Rule 3 of the CPC prohibits grant of an injunction without notice to the opposite party. In other words once a temporary injunction application is filed, the Court is required to direct notice of the application for grant of injunction to be given to the opposite party. The only exception to the general rule is the case where in the opinion of the Court the object of granting injunction would be defeated by delay in which case the Court may grant an injunction without giving notice to the opposite party. However, the power is to be exercised subject to the rider that the reasons are recorded in support of the opinion that the object of granting the injunction would be defeated by delay. The Court is further duty bound to ask the applicant to deliver/send by registered post to the opposite party copy of the application for injunction and copies of other material detailed in Order 39 Rule 3(a)(i to iii) and file an affidavit that the mandate of aforementioned provision has been followed. It is in addition to said duty that Order 3 Rule 3(a) enjoins upon the Court to decided the application for injunction within 30 days from the date on which the injunction was granted.

    10. In the instant case the Trial Court after granting injunction in ex parte, failed to follow mandate of Order 39 Rule 3 proviso as also Order 39 Rule 3(a) of the CPC. The 1st, Appellate Court has rightly set aside order dated 30-08-2007 remanded the matter and asked the Trial Court to dispose of the matter afresh. The order of the Appellate Court to the extent it set aside the order of the Trial Court dated 22-1-2007 granting injunction in ex parte, is in accordance with the law and neither amounts to irregular exercise of jurisdiction nor results in failure of justice. The Civil Revision petition to the said extent deserves to be dismissed.

    11. The 1st Appellate Court, however, was not right in asking the Trial Court to order restoration of position on spot, as it existed prior to the commencement of the suit. In the first place once the Trial Court is asked to dispose of temporary injunction application afresh, it is to be left to the Trial Court to order restoration of the position on spot to the position prior to institution of the suit, in the event the Trial Court does not find merit in the temporary injunction application and it is further established that the petitioner taking cover of ex parte injunction order has materially changed the position on spot. It was not appropriate for the Appellate Court to make room for fresh consideration of the matter and at the same time ask restoration of the position presuming that the petitioner had no case and further that position on spot was changed by the petitioner. Secondly the powers under Section 144 of the CPC are to be exercised at the instance of the party entitled to any benefit by way of restitution so as to place the parties in the position which they would have occupied but for the order set aside and lastly such power is to be exercised by the Court which passed the decree or the order varied or reversed in an appeal. In the present case the Appellate Court had neither jurisdiction nor any lawful justification for directing the Trial Court to order restoration of the position as it existed prior to commencement of the suit. The Appellate Court thus has made irregular exercise of jurisdiction while asking the Trial Court to restore the position on spot. The order of the Trial Court in the said extant is set aside. The Civil Revision is disposed of accordingly. The parties shall appear before the Trial Court on 2-8-2010. The Trial Court shall take all possible steps to dispose of the temporary injunction application within 30 days from the aforesaid date.

    12. Disposed of.

    13. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Anant Ram v. Isher Dass & Ors.
    (Jul 23, 2010)