Rangnekar, J.:—
This is an application to review ??? of the defendant-respondent's costs. The ??? five items objected to, are, in my opinion, items in ??? to which there is no principle involved. It is ??? established that a Court or a Judge will not in ??? interfere with the order of taxation to be ??? on a question that depends on the discretion of ??? Master, as, for instance, where the objection is to Page: 64the amount. As stated in Hill v. Peel, (1870) L.R 5 C.P 172 at p. 180 where a principle is involved, the Court will always interfere and entertain a review, but where it is a question of whether the Master exercised his discretion properly or it is only a question as to the amount to be allowed, the Court is generally unwilling to interfere with the judgment of its officer whose peculiar province it is to investigate and to judge of such matter, unless there are very strong grounds to show that the officer is wrong in the judgment which he has formed. In my opinion, no such case ??? made out as regards these items and as to these the application for review must fail.
The sixth item of objection is as to the disallow an by the Taxing Master of the amount claimed as expenses of the defendant's journey from and to Australia and boarding and lodging during the period of his stay ??? Bombay in connection with this suit.
[His Lordship then stated the facts and proceeded. The first point to consider is whether, as the defendant says, he is a resident of Australia. Mr. Coltman contends that there is no evidence to show that he is resident of Australia or any evidence to show that ??? has a home and family in Australia. In his affidavit dated February 7, 1927, made for the purpose of appealing to have the suit expedited, the defendant stated ??? he was a resident of Australia and he had left Bombay in or about May 1926 after winding up all his ??? in India. That statement remains uncontradicted ??? unchallenged. In his examination he stated that ??? father was a breeder and a racing man and President Albony Racing Club, Australia, and that he was ??? with his father's stables in Australia ??? came to India in 1914. In his cross-examination, swore that he had property in Australia. Mr. Coltman Page: 65relies upon the admission that when he was examined in 1923 in connection with his insolvency proceedings the had stated that he had no property in Australia. But that was at the time when he was examined in 1923. I cannot, therefore, accept the contention that the defendant is not a resident of Australia. Then it appears that he left this country immediately after he ??? his cross-objections in Appeal No. 30 of 1927 and admittedly has not returned to India since then.
The next question is: Did the defendant come back ??? Bombay in December in order to give evidence in his case, or, as contended by Mr. Coltman, to superintend ??? conduct of the suit? Mr. Coltman relies upon the statement of the defendant in his affidavit of February ??? where he says that he came back to Bombay in December for the purpose of the suit. Mr. Coltman further defendants that the evidence in this case was documentary, ??? the oral evidence of the defendant was not necessary ??? his case. He argues that a party is not entitled to ??? the expenses of subsistence as a witness if in fact he ??? as a party.
This was a suit for damages for defamation. The plaintiff's case was that the defendant in a letter written ??? him to the stewards of the Turf Club had falsely ??? that the plaintiff had given him instructions such ??? prevented the defendant from winning with the ??? of the plaintiff's horses at Poona races. The plaintiff complained that the letter was defamatory. The defendant's case inter alia was that the statements ??? the letter were true in substance and in fact. The plaintiff's case rested on certain innuendoes which were ??? by the defendant in his written statement. In ??? 11 of the written statement the defendant ??? in support of his plea of justification that the plaintiff had given him clear and definite instructions ??? training and running of each of the several Page: 66horses. These instructions, according to the defendant were orally given, were supplemented, and were confirmed by the plaintiff in the correspondence which passed between him whilst he was in England and the defendant. Then the defendant sets out the instructions which were according to him given by the plaintiff in detail. The defendant gave evidence as to these instruction and deposed to what the plaintiff had told him from time to time and how the plaintiff told him that he was to win with some horses only at Poona. Then in ??? evidence he explained the meaning and what he understood by the expressions used by the plaintiff in his letters. Thus, for instance, as to horse Oriental the expression used by the plaintiff was “I do not wanted to come to light on us” which the defendant explained to mean that “the horse was not to win and not to ??? exposed.” Another instance is as to the words “The stop” which the defendant explained as meaning “??? him in the second division.” I am only mentioning the two instances to show that it was necessary for the defendant to come into the box to explained the expressions which but for such explanation would be unintelligible to any outsider. He was cross-examined in ??? as to the oral instructions and as to the meaning ??? he put on several technical expressions used in the correspondence by the plaintiff. I am, therefore, satisfied that the defendant's evidence was material and entitled necessary for the purpose of his case.
As I have stated the defence was justification and my opinion it was necessary for the defendant to ??? in Bombay to give evidence in support of the plea. ??? expression “for the purpose of the suit” in the ??? davit of February 7 does not, in my opinion, necessary mean to supervise the conduct of the suit and is ??? consistent with the defendant's case that he had ??? here in order to give evidence on his behalf. There ??? Page: 67the defendant was a resident in Australia. This suit was filed against him for damages and he was served the same day. He had stayed in Bombay where his written statement was filed and then left for his native place. The suit was not likely to reach hearing for some time. He came to know in October that the suit was likely to be heard early and came back to Bombay for the purpose of the suit. Then finding that the suit would not be heard soon he applied to the Court with the ??? of the other side for expediting it. This was ??? serious case against him and if he had not defended he would have been liable to pay heavy damages and ??? career ruined. The defamation with which he was charged depended upon innuendoes. His defence was justification and depended on his evidence as to what ??? instructions were, oral as well as documentary. This letter required oral evidence to explain but for which ??? were unintelligible. In the end the plaintiff was awarded Re. 1 as damages against which the plaintiff appealed and the defendant filed cross-objections. Immediately after his filing the cross-objections he went ??? to Australia and has never returned here ???.
What then is the position? Under Order 65, rule 27 ??? 9, of the Rules of the Supreme Court, it is provided at:—
“As to evidence, such just and reasonable charges and expenses as appear ??? have been properly incurred in procuring evidence and the attendance of witnesses, are to be allowed.”
The result of the authorities is that the expenses of ??? attendance of a party at the trial in order to give evidence on his own behalf may be allowed if the evidence was material and necessary. It is a well established rule that a witness who is detained in England ??? the purpose of giving evidence at the trial is entitled ??? be paid the expenses of such detention. This is Page: 68called subsistence money. The amount to be allowed ant the period during which subsistence money is to be paid are matters for the discretion of the Master. Thus, for instance, in Howes v. Barber, (1852) 18 Q.B 588 the head-note says:—
“If a party to a cause be examined on his own behalf under stat. 14 & 1 Vict. c. 99, s. 2., the Master may allow, in taxation, for his maintenance during the time of his detention for the purpose of giving evidence, as in the case of any witness, if his testimony, in the Master's opinion, was material and necessary, and if he attended for the purpose of being examined ??? as witness and not merely to superintend the cause.”
Lord Campbell, C.J says as follows (p. 591):—
“We are of opinion that the Master's taxation of costs in this case was ??? No doubt, the practice of allowing costs to the successful party in ??? of his having been a witness for himself may lead to ??? consequences; but we do not think we can lay down a rule that such costs ??? never be allowed. The party is now by law admitted as a witness; he ??? be a material and necessary witness; and his attendance may not only ??? justice for himself, but may lessen the expense which would otherwise ??? upon the opposite party, by obviating the necessity for requiring the ??? of other witnesses, or for issuing a commission to examine witness abroad.
“The reasonable expenses to which the plaintiff is put by being obliged attend and be examined as a witness to enforce payment of a just demand, ??? to seek redress for an injury, should be thrown on the wrong doer. Again ??? an unfounded action is brought, and the evidence of the party improperly ??? is necessary for his defence, he is not indemnified if his own expenses as a witness are not allowed to him.
“Here the plaintiff, the captain of a ship, had a demand against the ??? for wages; and this he could make out only by his own evidence, or sending out a commission to a distant country. Remaining in England ??? the purpose of being examined at the trial, the Master has made him the ??? allowance for maintenance from the service of the writ till the day of ??? which would have been made to a third person as a witness under ??? circumstances. Berry v. Pratt (1823) 1 B. & C. 276 and other decisions shew that to a ??? person so remaining in this country as a witness such an allowance would ??? proper: and, the Legislature having been pleased to permit the parties to ??? examined in their own behalf, we cannot say that the expense of the successful party who has been so necessarily examined should not fall upon the party ??? a legal demand, or making an unlawful one, has caused ??? necessity.”
In Potter v. Rankin, (1870) L.R 5 C.P 518 where a captain of a ship ??? detained in England for a period of eighteen ??? viz., from the issuing of the writ until the trial of ??? Page: 69action upon a policy of insurance, the Court refused to interfere with the decision of the Master who had allowed subsistence money at the rate of ten shillings a day during that period. The conduct of the captain was impugned and it was therefore admitted that his personal attendance at the trial was necessary. In an ??? case, Lonergan v. The Royal Exchange Assurance, (1831) 7 Bing. 725 the Court ordered the Prothonotary to review is taxation where he had refused to make any allowance for the loss of time and the expenses of the captain of a vessel of his voyage to England from Havannah, is detention in England and return. Such expenses will certainly be allowed where the detention of the witnesses deprived him of the means of subsistence, providing that his evidence was material and that in order to give ??? the detention was necessary. That is the principle ??? to the decision in Dowdell v. Australian Royal Mail Company. (1854) 3 E. & B. 902
In Calvert v. The Scinde Railway Co. (1865) 18 C.B.N.S 306 the plaintiff, ??? in the defendants' employ in India, brought ??? against them for wrongful dismissal, and a ??? was taken by consent for £200, a quarter's salary, ??? £150 for his expenses in coming to England, the ??? refused to review the Master, who on taxation ??? allowed the plaintiff £450 for subsistence in England ??? awaiting for the trial which the defendants had ??? and £150 for expenses to enable the plaintiff to ??? to India. It will be seen that this is a much ??? case than the one before me. In this case the plaintiff was not a resident of England and had filed ??? in England. Again the plaintiff stayed in ??? for the purpose of giving evidence at the trial, ??? a year and a half. A very large sum for ??? money for that period and a further sum for Page: 70his voyage back to Lahore was allowed by the Master Erle, C.J stated that, although it was necessary ??? exercise great caution in order to prevent a party ??? abroad, who chose to bring an action in England from putting his opponent to such heavy expenses ??? those allowed by the Master, still, the Court came to the conclusion that the allowance which had been made in that case was within the principle of law which was applicable to that suit.
The case of Howes v. Barber (1852) 18 Q.B 588 was followed in Ansett v. Marshall. (1853) 22 L.J Q.B 118 In that case the plaintiff engaged passage to Australia in the defendants' vessel, but ??? turned out of it, and the ship having sailed without him, he sued the defendants for not carrying him ??? to their contract. The plaintiff could have ??? another passage in the course of a few days, but ??? remained until the trial of the cause, several month and gave evidence in his own favour. A verdict ??? found for him. On a motion to review the Master taxation of costs, it was held that if the plaintiff was detained bona fide for the purpose of giving evidence in the cause, and it was proper to call him as a witness at the trial, he ought to be allowed the expense of the maintenance while so remaining in his country as ??? against the defendants although he was not a ??? man. In giving judgment Crompton, J. pointed ??? that case that it was for the Master to consider, on whole matter, whether the plaintiff was bona fide ??? for the purpose of giving evidence in the cause, whether he was a proper witness to be kept. The ??? Judge said that he did not mean whether he was a necessary, but whether it was reasonable that should be so detained.
In my opinion, therefore, a witness, who ??? abroad, is entitled to the expenses of being brought ??? Page: 71to give evidence and also to subsistence money during the period of detention, and the same principle applies to the case of a party whose evidence is reasonably necessary and material for the purpose of his case and on his own behalf. It is true, as pointed out in ??? of the cases, that the question as to how far attendance of a witness was necessary and material is one for the Master to decide. But that discretion must be exercised in a fair and reasonable way according to the usual and established practice and allowance in respect of ??? matters. Otherwise, the Court or a Judge will interfere and review the discretion of the Master who was not so exercised it. If the Court is satisfied that the Master has so exercised his discretion as to produce ??? justice or thrown an unreasonable burden on a party, ??? think the Court is always disposed to interfere. In this case, as I have said, the defendant is a foreigner ??? had got his clearance from the Turf Club. Even ??? had continued here it is clear that he would have been ??? to earn his subsistence. In the absence of any evidence, the presumption would be that he had to go ??? from Bombay in order to find subsistence, and therefore if the evidence of the defendant was necessary and material for the purpose of his case, I think he was entitled to his expenses including his subsistence money, ??? Taxing Master has disallowed such expenses on the ??? that it was not “essential” that the defendant ??? go into the witness box. If by that he means at the evidence was not material or necessary, I am ??? to agree. He then proceeds on two grounds: ??? on what he had learnt himself from inquiries as ??? the habits of trainers and jockeys in general, and, ??? that the oral evidence of the defendant was ??? necessary. Mr. Coltman does not support the first ??? and wisely. In my opinion the propriety of a Page: 72finding based on an inquiry made outside the proceedings, is, to say the least, open to grave doubt. The Master has to base his findings on the evidence before him. He may examine witnesses if he likes. But I think that it is wrong to arrive at a general conclusion on something which is not based on evidence. As to the second ground, I am quite clear, in my mind, considering the pleadings, the nature of the case, and particularly the evidence, that the evidence of the defendant was absolutely necessary and material to his case. ??? reasons are given by the Taxing Master as to why he considered that the evidence of the defendant was ??? “essential.” The authorities clearly show that what ??? Court has to consider in the circumstances of the ??? was whether it was reasonable for the defendant ??? into the witness-box in support of his case. The Taxing Master has brushed aside the decisions to which ??? attention seems to have been drawn on the ground ??? in those cases the question was of an oral arrangement or oral contract, etc. I do not think that any case ??? stated that it is only when there is a question of ??? contract or arrangement being proved that a part ??? evidence is essential, otherwise he can allow a case proceed by relying on the documentary evidence and need not offer himself as a witness. But even supposing that is the true principle, the facts in this case ??? within that principle. For here also the defendant case depended on the oral instructions given from ??? to time by the plaintiff which went in support of the plea of justification in which he ultimately succeed and also for the purpose of explaining the meaning such instructions given in letters written by plaintiff.
There is a third ground taken in the Taxing Master judgment, and that is, that the defendant might ??? applied for expediting the suit or getting a ??? Page: 73??? fixed for hearing or for getting himself examined de bene esse. In Howes v. Barber (1852) 18 Q.B 588 the contention was that the party could have offered himself as ??? witness under an order made to the effect that the parties should be at liberty to examine any witness before issued were joined. The Court did not even take any notice of the argument and the contention was rejected. ??? case has gone the length of saying that a party is ??? to take any of the steps referred to by the Taxing Master before he is entitled to claim expenses of subsistence and detention as costs. In this particular case, much depended on the evidence before the Judge who heard ??? case and the credibility which had to be attached ??? such evidence. In point of fact, the evidence shows at the defendant made an attempt to expedite the suit. ??? M'Alpine v. Poles (1833) 1 Cro. & M. 795 the Master allowed the plaintiff ??? of witnesses brought from abroad. It was ??? that they might have been examined on ??? But Lord Lyndhurst C.B said (p. 796):—
It is frequently very desirable that a party should be able to have his witnesses examined viva voce. It appears to us, that the allowance of such witnesses is still a matter in the discretion of the Master, in each particular ??? just as it was before the late act.”
??? after conference with the Judges of the other ??? he said (p. 796):—
They agree with us in the opinion which we have formed, that the act of ??? makes no difference in this respect. We think that the matter is ??? discretion of the Master, subject to be reviewed by the Court; and we ??? that, in this particular instance, that discretion was properly ???…”
Then it is argued that the travelling expenses should ??? be allowed. In this case, the defendant wanted to ??? for Australia about the end of March, and the plaintiff took steps to prevent him from doing so. That ??? from the haste with which the writ of ??? was served on the defendant. In England the ??? is that a witness is entitled to be reimbursed the Page: 74sums which have been reasonably and actually paid a travelling expenses, such as going to, staying, and returning home, from the place of trial. The only ??? is whether the expenses were reasonably incurred. ??? own rule is contained in Order XVI, rule 2, Civil Procedure Code. I do not see, therefore, why the travelling expenses should not be allowed in this case.
The seventh objection contains six items amounting together to Rs. 82. The costs in question were incurred by the defendant in obtaining a certified copy of the judgment delivered by the trial Judge with a view to ??? an appeal. These have been disallowed on the ground that they become useless. I do not agree. It is ??? that the appeal in the case was filed by the plaintiff. But the defendant did intend to file an appeal ??? the decision of the learned trial Judge, and that is ??? from the fact that as soon as the appeal was filed ??? filed cross-objections. If, therefore, in order to filed ??? appeal, he obtains a certified copy of the judgment ??? in the meanwhile the opposite party files an appeal do not see why these costs should not be allowed. I think that the Taxing Master is wrong in disallowing these items.
The eighth and ninth objections are not pressed ??? to me to involve a question of mere quantum ??? have been properly considered by the Taxing Master.
In the result, the review must, therefore, be allow as to sixth and seventh objections, and the case sent ??? to the Taxing Master to re-tax the items contained those objections.
Attorneys for plaintiff: Messrs Crawford, Boyle Co.
Attorneys for defendant: Messrs Captain & ??? Review allowed.
B.K.D