AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • (no specific act/article title mentioned)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • (no specific act/article title mentioned)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 3 entered government service as a Lower Division Assistant in 1949 and was confirmed in that post in 1953. He was later transferred to the Vidhan Sabha Sachivalaya, where Respondents 1 and 2 were also appointed as Lower Division Assistants after the 1953 competitive examination, making Respondent 3 their senior.

In 1977 the State Public Service Commission (PSC) conducted a selection process for confirmation to seven permanent posts of Section Officer. Six candidates—including Respondents 1 and 2—were found fit and promoted. Respondent 3 was considered but declared unfit; one post reserved for Scheduled Caste candidates remained vacant because no suitable candidate was available.

Respondent 3 repeatedly represented to the Government that his juniors had been promoted over him. Acting on these representations, the Government requested the PSC to convert the unfilled Scheduled Caste vacancy into a general category post. After agreeing, the PSC allowed Respondent 3 to be appointed Section Officer by notification dated 8 January 1983, with effect from 2 January 1982.

Respondent 3 then sought seniority over Respondents 1 and 2. His request was rejected on 17 June 1984. He challenged that rejection in a writ petition before the High Court, which allowed his claim, holding that he had been unfairly “left out” of the earlier selection and that, once promoted, he should regain seniority. The present Supreme Court order results from an appeal against that High Court decision; special leave was granted and the matter heard on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Respondent 3, who was earlier found unfit for promotion but later appointed after the dereservation of a post, is entitled to seniority over Respondents 1 and 2 who were promoted on merit in 1977.
  2. Whether the High Court erred, both factually and legally, in concluding that Respondent 3 had been “left out” of consideration and was therefore entitled to regain seniority once promoted.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court rejected the High Court’s conclusion on two principal grounds:

  • Factual error: Contrary to the High Court’s assumption, Respondent 3 was not “left out” of consideration in 1977. He was considered by the PSC and found unfit for promotion to Section Officer, whereas Respondents 1 and 2 were found fit and selected.
  • Legal misapplication: The High Court relied on a broad proposition that a person initially superseded regains seniority once promoted. The Supreme Court clarified that such a rule applies only where the senior was wrongly omitted from consideration. Here, Respondent 3’s non-selection was based on merit, so the rule does not operate.

The Court emphasized that Respondent 3 gained entry into the Section Officer cadre only after the Scheduled Caste vacancy was converted into a general vacancy, achieved through representations rather than competitive selection. Because his promotion did not stem from merit in the original selection, he could not disturb the established seniority of those who had been duly selected in 1977.

Accordingly, the Court found the High Court’s order “unsustainable” and concluded that Respondent 3 must rank below Respondents 1 and 2 in the seniority list.

Holding and Implications

The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s order and directed that Respondent 3’s writ petition be dismissed, with no order as to costs.

Implications are confined to the parties: Respondent 3 remains junior to Respondents 1 and 2 in the Section Officer cadre, and no broader legal precedent was articulated beyond clarifying that seniority cannot be claimed where initial supersession was merit-based.

    State Of U.P Through The Secretary, U.P Vidhan Sabha, Lucknow v. Onkar Nath Tandon And Others

    Order

    1. Special leave granted.

    2. Heard counsel on both sides. We do not think that the impugned order of the High Court can be sustained. The respondent 3 (the original petitioner in the writ petition before the High Court) joined service as Lower Division Assistant in 1949 and after a competitive examination conducted by the State Public Service Commission (for short ‘PSC’) he was confirmed as Lower Division Assistant in 1953. In the course of service he was transferred to the Vidhan Sabha Sachivalaya as Lower Division Assistant. Respondent 1 Onkar Nath and respondent 2 Krishna Das Rastogi were also selected after a competitive examination conducted in 1953 as Lower Division Assistants in the Vidhan Sabha Sachivalaya. The appointments of respondents 1 and 2 were, however, made after that of respondent 3 since the latter was already in service. Respondent 3 was, therefore, senior to respondents 1 and 2.

    3. In 1977 selection for confirmation to the post of Section Officer was held by the PSC against seven permanent posts. Out of those considered by the PSC six persons were found fit and they were appointed as Section Officers. Respondent 3 was found unfit and was rejected. One post which was reserved for Scheduled Caste candidates was not filled as no suitable candidate from that class was available.

    4. The respondent 3 made representations to the Government that his juniors were promoted as Section Officers. On the basis of these representations the Government wrote to the PSC to convert the vacant post reserved for Scheduled Caste candidates into a general category post. After initial hesitation the PSC agreed and the said post was converted into a general category post. The respondent 3 was appointed as Section Officer on the said post by Notification dated January 8, 1983 with effect from January 2, 1982. Respondent 3 then represented that he was senior to respondents 1 and 2 Onkar Nath and Krishna Das Rastogi. This representation was rejected by the order of June 17, 1984. Thereupon, respondent 3 filed a writ petition in the High Court challenging that order. The High Court allowed the writ petition on two grounds, namely, (1) that respondent 3 was left out and was not selected while his two juniors were duly selected by the PSC; and (ii) that even otherwise after the appointment of respondent 3 as Section Officer the injustice done to him was remedied and, therefore, under the settled law he was entitled to be considered senior to his juniors who were promoted earlier in point of time. We are afraid that the High Court went wrong on both the factual as well as the legal aspects. In the first place it is necessary to note that respondent 3 was considered along with others but was found unfit for the post of Section Officer. He was, therefore, left out and his juniors who were found fit were appointed on that post. Out of the seven posts which were vacant one belonged to the reserved category but since no suitable Scheduled Caste candidate was available that post was kept vacant. Taking advantage of that fact respondent 3 made representations on the basis of which the PSC was persuaded to convert the reserved category post to a general category post. It was only thereafter that respondent 3 was appointed on that post. In the circumstances, it cannot be said that respondent 3 could be treated on a par with candidates who had been selected by the PSC. In fact respondent 3 was not found to be fit and it was on that account that he was left out. He thereafter entered the cadre of Section Officers by getting the Scheduled Caste seat dereserved and without going through a competitive selection process. He cannot, therefore, be permitted to disturb the seniority of selected candidates. He can only rank below them. Therefore the decision of the authorities to treat him as junior to the other two candidates cannot be assailed. It appears from the High Court judgment that he gave the impression that his claim was overlooked when the PSC selected six candidates for the six general category seats. That is why the High Court observes in the judgment that he was ‘left out from consideration and not selected by the PSC’. This is not a case of candidate having been inadvertently omitted from consideration. He was considered and not found fit for being selected for the post of Section Officer. The High Court, therefore, proceeded on a wrong assumption that he was inadvertently left out from consideration by the PSC when it selected candidates for filling the six general category seats. The High Court then proceeds to observe:

    “It has been a settled rule of law and practice in Government Departments that whenever on a post a person is promoted from which he was earlier superseded, he would regain his seniority from the date he was superseded.”

    5. We are afraid that this broad statement of law is not accurate because if a junior supersedes a senior on merit basis his senior cannot claim seniority in the higher cadre on his being promoted at a subsequent date unless it is shown that he was left out from consideration on the earlier occasion when he ought to have been considered. The High Court perhaps made this broad statement on the factual premise that he was left out of consideration and, therefore, not selected by the PSC. This factual premise is not correct.

    6. In view of the above we are of the view that the benefit obtained by respondent 3 under the impugned order of the High Court is undeserved and based on a factual inaccuracy that he was left out of consideration when his juniors were considered for promotion as Section Officers. As pointed out earlier he was considered and found unfit by the PSC and it is on that account that his name was not entered in the select list and he did not secure promotion to the next higher post. His subsequent promotion was also arranged by persuading the PSC to dereserve the vacancy meant for Scheduled Caste candidates and treat it as one belonging to the general category. Thus his entry in the cadre of Section Officers was not on merit but on this exercise and therefore he cannot claim seniority over his juniors who were selected and appointed on merits to the next higher post. We are, therefore, of the opinion that the High Court was in error in allowing the writ petition of respondent 3 and in granting consequential benefits. We, therefore, set aside the impugned order and direct that the said writ petition will be treated as dismissed with no order as to costs throughout.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of U.P Through The Secretary, U.P Vidhan Sabha, Lucknow v. Onkar Nath Tandon And Others
    (Aug 17, 1992)