Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 7 of the Orissa Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (For Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Act, 1971
  • Section 2(b) of the Orissa Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (For Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Act, 1971
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Section 7 of the Orissa Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (For Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Act, 1971
  • Section 2(b) of the Orissa Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (For Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Act, 1971
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal concerned the applicability of the “carry-forward” rule for a roster-reserved promotional post for Scheduled Caste candidates in government service in the State of Orissa. The appellant, a Scheduled Caste employee, was working as Typist-cum-Despatcher in the office of the Principal Secretariat Institute, Bhubaneswar, and the dispute related to promotion to the post of Head Typist.

A Head Typist post reserved for Scheduled Caste candidates fell vacant in 1982; as no Scheduled Caste candidate was available, a general category candidate was promoted. The post next became available only on 30-8-1988. Although the 1988 roster position was earmarked for a general category candidate, the Departmental Promotion Committee treated it as reserved for Scheduled Caste by applying the carry-forward rule and selected the appellant for promotion.

Respondent 1 (general category) challenged the appellant’s promotion by filing OA No. 348 of 1989 before the Orissa Administrative Tribunal. By judgment dated 5-8-1991, the Tribunal allowed the petition, holding that a carry-forward vacancy could be continued for three financial years and that promotion after three years was illegal. The Tribunal directed that Respondent 1 be considered for promotion to Head Typist. The appellant then filed the present appeal against the Tribunal’s judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under the Orissa Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (For Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Act, 1971 and its carry-forward provision for “three years of recruitment,” the reserved vacancy from 1982 could be carried forward and applied when the next promotion/recruitment occurred in 1988.
  2. How the expression “recruitment year” should be construed for the purpose of applying the carry-forward rule in the context of promotions where no recruitment occurs in the intervening period.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant relied on the Supreme Court decision in Harish Chandra Ram v. Mukh Ram Dubey (1994 Supp (2) SCC 490; (1994) 27 ATC 844), which construed “recruitment year” as the year in which recruitment actually takes place, not each of the successive years during which a vacancy exists.

Respondent's/Tribunal's Position (as reflected in the impugned order)

  • The Tribunal held that a carry-forward vacancy could continue only for three financial years and that, after the lapse of three years, it could not be carried forward; consequently, it treated the appellant’s promotion after three years as illegal and directed consideration of Respondent 1 for the post.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Harish Chandra Ram v. Mukh Ram Dubey 1994 Supp (2) SCC 490, (1994) 27 ATC 844 Construction of the expression “recruitment year” as the year in which recruitment takes place, not each of the successive years in which a vacancy exists. Treated as the governing authority on interpreting “recruitment year” for carry-forward purposes; the Court applied it to conclude that 1988 was the relevant next recruitment year after 1982 since no recruitment occurred in between.
Arati Ray Choudhury v. Union of India (1974) 1 SCC 87 Cited by the Tribunal (reliance noted), but not addressing the specific situation or construing “recruitment year.” Distinguished: the Supreme Court stated that it was not required in that case to consider a situation like the present one and it did not construe “recruitment year,” making it not determinative for the issue at hand.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the statutory framework governing reservation in Orissa, namely the Orissa Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (For Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Act, 1971 and the rules framed under it. It noted that Section 7 provides for carrying forward a vacancy for “three years of recruitment,” and that “recruitment year” is defined in Section 2(b). The Court recorded that prior to 1987 it meant the financial year during which recruitment is actually made, and that an amendment in 1987 replaced “financial year” with “calendar year.”

On the facts, the Court emphasized that after the 1982 promotion of a general category candidate (due to non-availability of a Scheduled Caste candidate), the Head Typist post became available again only in 1988, and there was no recruitment by promotion to that post in the intervening period. Therefore, the Court treated 1988 as the next “recruitment year” after 1982 for purposes of carry-forward.

Applying the carry-forward rule in that context, the Court held that the vacancy available in 1988 had to be assigned to the Scheduled Caste candidate, and that the Departmental Promotion Committee had acted correctly in selecting the appellant. The Tribunal’s approach—treating the carry-forward as limited by the lapse of three financial years regardless of whether recruitment occurred—was found erroneous.

The Court also addressed the Tribunal’s reliance on Arati Ray Choudhury v. Union of India (1974) 1 SCC 87, observing that that decision did not involve the present type of situation and did not construe the expression “recruitment year.” Instead, the Court relied on the more recent decision in Harish Chandra Ram v. Mukh Ram Dubey to resolve the interpretive question.

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED: The Supreme Court held that the Tribunal erred in setting aside the appellant’s promotion to the post of Head Typist, set aside the Tribunal’s judgment dated 5-8-1991, and dismissed Respondent 1’s petition (OA No. 348 of 1989).

The appellant, who had been reverted pursuant to the Tribunal’s judgment, was directed to be restored to his original position. No order as to costs was made. The direct implication was reinstatement of the appellant’s promotion and termination of Respondent 1’s challenge; the opinion applied existing principles on construing “recruitment year” for carry-forward and does not state that it laid down any new broader rule beyond that application.

    Jogendra Sethi v. Rabindranath Behura And Others

    Order

    1. Leave granted.

    2. We have heard learned counsel for the parties.

    3. The question which arises for consideration in this appeal relates to the applicability of the carry-forward rule in relation to the post reserved for Scheduled Caste candidates in government service in the State of Orissa. The appellant belongs to a Scheduled Caste. He was employed as Typist-cum-Despatcher in the office of the Principal Secretariat Institute, Bhubaneswar, Orissa. The matter relates to the promotion to the post of Head Typist. One post of Head Typist which was reserved for Scheduled Caste candidate as per the roster fell vacant in the year 1982. Since no Scheduled Caste candidate was available, a candidate belonging to a general category was promoted. Thereafter the post became available only on 30-8-1988. That post was earmarked for a general category under the roster but by application of carry-forward rule it was treated as reserved for Scheduled Caste and the appellant was selected for promotion on the said post by the Departmental Promotion Committee. Respondent 1 who belongs to the general category filed a petition (OA No. 348 of 1989) before the Orissa Administrative Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”) assailing the said promotion of the appellant. The said petition was allowed by the tribunal by judgment dated 5-8-1991. The tribunal has held that the carry-forward vacancy could be continued for three financial years whereafter it cannot be carried forward. According to the tribunal the appointment of the appellant on the post of Head Typist after the lapse of three years was illegal. The tribunal directed that Respondent 1 be considered for promotion to the post of Head Typist.

    4. Feeling aggrieved by the said judgment of the tribunal the appellant filed this appeal.

    5. Shri Venkataramani, the learned counsel for the appellant, has invited our attention to the recent decision of this Court in Harish Chandra Ram v. Mukh Ram Dubey 1994 Supp (2) SCC 490, (1994) 27 ATC 844 wherein this Court has construed the expression “recruitment year” as the year in which the recruitment takes place but not for each of the three successive years in which the vacancy exists.

    6. Provision with regard to reservation of posts for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in Orissa is made in the Orissa Reservation of Vacancies in Posts and Services (For Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Act, 1971 and the rules framed thereunder. In Section 7 of the said Act provision is made for carrying forward vacancy for “three years of recruitment”. The expression “recruitment year” is defined in Section 2(b) of the Act. Prior to 1987 it meant the financial year during which the recruitment is actually made. By the amendment of 1987 the word “financial year” was replaced by “calendar year”.

    7. In the present case after the promotion of a candidate from general category in 1982 the post of Head Typist became available for promotion only in 1988 and there was no recruitment by promotion on that post in between. Therefore, the next recruitment year after 1982 was 1988. Having regard to the carry-forward rule the post of Head Typist which became available for promotion in 1988 had to be assigned to the Scheduled Caste candidate and the Departmental Promotion Committee did so rightly. The tribunal was in error in holding that the said post could not be assigned to a Scheduled Caste as per the carry-forward rule.

    8. In Arati Ray Choudhury v. Union of India (1974) 1 SCC 87 on which reliance has been placed by the tribunal, this Court was not required to consider a situation like in the present case and the court has not construed the expression “recruitment year”. This question has been considered in the recent decision in Harish Chandra Ram v. Mukh Ram Dubey 1994 Supp (2) SCC 490, (1994) 27 ATC 844.

    9. The tribunal was, therefore, in error in setting aside the promotion of the appellant to the post of Head Typist. The appeal is, therefore, allowed, the judgment of the tribunal dated 5-8-1991 is set aside and the petition filed by Respondent 1 is dismissed. The appellant who was reverted in pursuance of the tribunal's judgment will be restored to the original position. No order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jogendra Sethi v. Rabindranath Behura And Others
    (Nov 10, 1994)