AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Bihar and Orissa Mining Settlement Act, 1920 and Jharia Water Supply Act, 1914.
  • S. 2(6) of the Bihar Shops and Establishments Act, 1953 (hereinafter referred
  • rule 7 of the Payment of Gratuity (Bihar) Rules, 1972 (hereinafter referred
  • S. 2(6) of the 1953 Act, the provision of the Payment of Gratuity Act
  • PAYMENT OF GRATUITY ACT 1972
  • provisions of Bihar Shops and Establishment Act
  • Area Development Authority Act, 1986,
  • S. 2(6) of the 1953 Act.
  • rule 10 of the Rules
  • SECTION 4 INTEREST ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Bihar and Orissa Mining Settlement Act, 1920 and Jharia Water Supply Act, 1914.
  • S. 2(6) of the Bihar Shops and Establishments Act, 1953 (hereinafter referred
  • rule 7 of the Payment of Gratuity (Bihar) Rules, 1972 (hereinafter referred
  • S. 2(6) of the 1953 Act, the provision of the Payment of Gratuity Act
  • PAYMENT OF GRATUITY ACT 1972
  • provisions of Bihar Shops and Establishment Act
  • Area Development Authority Act, 1986,
  • S. 2(6) of the 1953 Act.
  • rule 10 of the Rules
  • SECTION 4 INTEREST ACT
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of Court Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner in this writ application is the Mineral Area Development Authority (the petitioner authority), which succeeded two earlier boards (Jharia Mines Board of Health and Jharia Water Board) and retained their employees when it took over those functions. The respondent workman (respondent 3) was appointed in 1953 at a monthly salary of Rs. 500 and continued in service; by the date of his retirement he was drawing more than Rs. 1,000 per month. The Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (the Act) came into force on 16 September 1972.

After retirement, the workman filed an application under rule 10 of the Payment of Gratuity (Bihar) Rules, 1972 before the controlling authority (Deputy Labour Commissioner, Bokaro Steel City), registered as PG Case No. 4 of 1993, seeking gratuity. The petitioner submitted written statements and a supplementary rejoinder, denying applicability of the Act and asserting that gratuity computed under Bihar Rules had been offered and that the establishment was not within the meaning of S. 2(6) of the Bihar Shops and Establishments Act, 1953 (the 1953 Act). The controlling authority, after allowing an amendment by the applicant (to include dearness allowance) and hearing the parties, held that the workman was an employee within S. 2(e) of the Act, satisfied S. 4's conditions, and directed payment of Rs. 40,064 with 10% interest from the date of the order (order made Annexure 5). The petitioner challenged that order by way of the present writ petition.

The petitioner also sought to offset the gratuity by claiming amounts due from the workman (it had stated before the controlling authority that Rs. 28,943 was due as gratuity under the petitioner's rules and that penal rent of Rs. 4,62,579 for a post-retirement quarter occupation should be adjusted against any gratuity).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an employee who had been employed for more than five years on wages below the statutory limit at the commencement of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, but who was drawing wages in excess of that statutory limit at the time of retirement, falls within the definition of "employee" under Section 2(e) of the Act and is thus entitled to gratuity under Section 4.
  2. Whether the petitioner authority is an "establishment" to which the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 applies (specifically via Section 1(3)(b) of the Act), as opposed to being outside that Act under the Bihar Shops and Establishments Act, 1953.
  3. Whether the claim was barred by delay (the rules prescribe a 90-day limitation under rule 10), given that the application was filed many years after the retirement (approximately nine years), and whether the controlling authority could condone that delay.
  4. Whether the petitioner's adherence to Bihar rules for payment of gratuity precluded enforcement of the Central Act's provisions in this case.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Petitioner) — Principal Contentions

  • The petitioner is not an establishment within the meaning of S. 2(6) of the 1953 Act; therefore the Payment of Gratuity Act does not apply to it.
  • An employee who has already retired cannot be treated as an "employee" within Section 2(e) of the Act for the purpose of claiming gratuity.
  • Because the respondent was drawing a salary in excess of the prescribed statutory limit at the time of his retirement, he is not entitled to gratuity under the Act.
  • The application before the controlling authority was filed well beyond the 90-day limitation under rule 10 (it was filed after about nine years), and therefore the claim should have been rejected as barred by limitation.
  • The petitioner had adopted the Bihar Rules for gratuity calculation and payment; hence, the central Act should not be applied to the petitioner or its employees for gratuity purposes.

Respondent (Workman) — Principal Contentions

  • The respondent is an "employee" within the meaning of Section 2(e) of the Payment of Gratuity Act and satisfies the requirements of Section 4 for entitlement to gratuity (continuous service for not less than five years).
  • After retirement he had re-employment and continued to occupy a quarter allocated to him; charging penal rent for that quarter was illegal and arbitrary.
  • The application before the controlling authority was amended to include dearness allowance which was part of salary during service; that amendment was accepted by the controlling authority.
  • The controlling authority correctly found entitlement and directed payment of Rs. 40,064 with interest; any delay in filing was condoned by the controlling authority and, given the welfare nature of the Act, technical pleas of limitation should not defeat a rightful claim.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Good Year India, Ltd. v. K.G. Devessar, 1985 (2) L.L.N. 822 (Supreme Court) Held that an employee who was within the statutory wage limit earlier but drew wages in excess of the limit at retirement is still entitled to gratuity; management's similar submission was rejected. The court relied on this Supreme Court decision to reject the petitioner's contention that an employee drawing more than the statutory limit at retirement is thereby excluded from gratuity.
Vasant Industrial and Engineering Works v. Narayan Damodar Desai, 1980 (1) L.L.N. 109 (Bombay High Court, Division Bench) Explained that the definition of "employee" in Section 2(e) must be read with the Explanation which provides that gratuity is to be computed for the period when wages were within the specified limit; later higher wages do not deny entitlement. The court cited the Bombay High Court's clear interpretation of the Explanation to support the position that prior service on wages below the threshold confers entitlement even if wages later exceeded the threshold.
Jogendralal Mahakar v. Regional Labour Commissioner (Central) and Appellate Authority, 1977 L. & I.C. 1308 (Calcutta High Court) Rejected the proposition that long-serving employees should be deprived of gratuity merely because they were drawing wages over the statutory limit when the Act commenced; the Explanation supports inclusion. The court relied on this authority to underscore that denying gratuity to those who rendered long prior service would be unjust and that the Explanation brings such employees within the Act's purview.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a statutory interpretation of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 in light of the facts. It began by examining Section 1(3) (the applicability clause) and Section 1(3)(b) in particular, observing that the petitioner authority falls within the purview of establishments contemplated by S. 1(3)(b) (shops and establishments in which ten or more persons are/were employed). Because the Act is a self-contained code, the court held it unnecessary to rely on or determine the meaning of "establishment" under the Bihar Shops and Establishments Act, 1953.

Turning to entitlement, the court considered Section 4 (which requires continuous service of not less than five years) together with Section 2(e) (the definition of "employee") and the Explanation thereto. The Explanation expressly provides that where a person has been employed for not less than five years on wages not exceeding the specified amount and is later employed on higher wages, gratuity shall be determined with reference to the wages during the qualifying period. The court found that the respondent was appointed in 1953 on a wage of Rs. 500, had rendered continuous service for the qualifying period, and thus satisfied Section 4 and the definition in Section 2(e) (read with the Explanation).

The court rejected the petitioner's submission that the respondent's later higher wages at the time of retirement disqualified him. The court relied on the statutory text and on prior authorities (including the Supreme Court in Good Year India and relevant High Court decisions) that interpret the Explanation to protect employees who initially served on wages within the prescribed threshold.

As to delay/limitation, the court emphasized the welfare character of the Act and noted that technical pleas of limitation should not defeat a legitimate claim. The controlling authority had considered the delay and condoned it after reviewing the materials. The court declined to interfere with that factual and discretionary finding made by the authority in exercise of its jurisdiction under the Rules.

Having considered the statutory provisions, the Explanation, the controlling authority's order, and persuasive precedents, the court concluded that the controlling authority's finding of entitlement was lawful and without error.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Writ dismissed.

The court held that:

  • The petitioner authority is an establishment within the meaning of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (via Section 1(3)(b)), so the Act applies.
  • The respondent workman qualified as an "employee" under Section 2(e) read with the Explanation and satisfied Section 4's requirement of continuous service for not less than five years; therefore he was entitled to gratuity determined in accordance with the Act.
  • The controlling authority's order directing payment of Rs. 40,064 with 10% interest was not shown to be illegal; the authority's condonation of delay was not interfered with.
  • The writ petition was dismissed and the petitioner was ordered to pay costs of Rs. 5,000 to the workman.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the controlling authority's direction for payment of gratuity (Rs. 40,064 plus interest) stands and the petitioner must pay costs of Rs. 5,000 to the employee.
  • The court applied existing statutory interpretation and precedent to resolve the dispute; it did not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond those applications. No new legal precedent was stated as emanating from this judgment beyond its application of the Act and existing authorities.

Writ dismissed with costs of Rs. 5,000 payable by the petitioner to the concerned workman.

    Mineral Area Development Authority v. State Of Bihar And Others

    1. In this writ application filed by the petitioner, namely, Mineral Area Development Authority, a very short but interesting question arises as to whether an employee, respondent 3 who was originally drawing a salary of less than Rs. 1,000 per month continuously for more than five years on the date of commencement of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as the Act), but subsequently drawing more than the statutory limit per month on the day of his retirement, will be deemed to be an employee within the meaning of S. 2(e) of the Act.

    2. The fact of this case is not in dispute. The respondent workman was previously appointed in the Jharia Mines Board of Health and Jharia Water Board constituted under the provisions of the Bihar and Orissa Mining Settlement Act, 1920 and Jharia Water Supply Act, 1914. By subsequent legislation, namely, Bihar Coal Mining Area Development Authority Act, 1986, the aforesaid two Boards were replaced. Subsequently by amendment the name of the Bihar Coal Mining Development Authority was changed to the Mineral Area Development Authority. All the employees of the aforesaid Jharia Mines Board of Health and Jharia Water Board have been retained in service at the time of taking over by the petitioner authority. The concerned workman was appointed in the year 1953 at the monthly salary of Rs. 500 only and referred as head clerk with effect from 30 June, 1985 and his salary was subsequently increased and at the time of retirement he was getting more than Rs. 1000 per month. Since the employer failed to pay the gratuity even after complying with rule 7 of the Payment of Gratuity (Bihar) Rules, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as the rules), the concerned workman filed an application in terms of rule 10 of the Rules before the respondent controlling authority, namely, Deputy Labour Commissioner, Bokaro Steel City, some time in the year 1993, which was registered as PG case No. 4 of 1993. The petitioner authority has appeared before the respondent controlling officer and filed written statement stating, inter alia, therein that the concerned respondent workman is entitled to a sum of Rs. 28,943 only as gratuity according to the Rules followed by the petitioner authority and, accordingly, directed the concerned respondent to receive the payment and further to pay a sum of Rs. 4,62,579.00 as penal rent of the quarter which was in his occupation after retirement. It is further alleged that after adjustment of the said amount, there is no due to the concerned respondent on account of gratuity. A supplementary rejoinder was also filed stating therein that the provision of the Act is not applicable to the petitioner as it is not an establishment within the meaning of S. 2(6) of the Bihar Shops and Establishments Act, 1953 (hereinafter referred to as the 1953 Act).

    3. In this case a counter-affidavit has been filed on behalf of the concerned employee stating, inter alia, therein that he is an employee within the meaning of S. 2(e) of the Act and fulfils all the requirements as envisaged under S. 4 of the Act for payment of gratuity. It is further stated that after retirement he was given re-employment and in that capacity he was occupying the quarter which was allotted to him when he was in regular service of the petitioner authority. It is further alleged that his son, who was also a clerk under the petitioner, was allotted quarter in the very beginning, who had refused to accept the same since he was living with his father and after the retirement of his father the quarter was allotted to him. In the premises it is submitted that the action of the petitioner and its officials charging the penal rent of the quarter is wholly illegal, arbitrary and uncalled for. The petition filed under rule 10 of the Rules was subsequently amended by the concerned workman since the amount of salary mentioned in the original petition did not include the dearness allowance which was being paid to the employee during the service and, accordingly, the said amendment was accepted by the respondent controlling authority. The respondent controlling authority after hearing the parties and going through the materials on record after having held that the applicant, namely, respondent 3 is an employee within the meaning of S. 2(e) of the Act and having fulfilled the conditions as required under S. 4 of the Act for payment of gratuity, has directed the petitioner authority to pay a sum of Rs. 40,064.00 along with an interest at the rate of 10 per cent per annum from the date of order, copy of the said order is made Annexure 5 to this writ application. The petitioner being aggrieved by the order passed by the respondent controlling authority has filed the instant writ application for the relief as mentioned above.

    4. Sri SB. Gododia, senior counsel for the petitioner, has assailed the order under challenge in this writ application firstly on the ground that the petitioner being not an establishment within the meaning of S. 2(6) of the 1953 Act, the provision of the Payment of Gratuity Act will not apply in the case of the petitioner. It is further submitted that the employee, who has already retired, cannot be deemed to be an employee within the meaning of S. 2(e) of the Act. It is then submitted that the respondent workman was drawing the salary more than the prescribed limit under the statute at the time of his retirement, he is not entitled for the gratuity under the Act. It is further submitted that the limitation prescribed for filing application under rule 10 of the Rules is 90 days whereas the concerned respondent has filed the application before the controlling authority after lapse of nine years and on this ground alone the claim of the respondent workman could not have been entertained by the respondent controlling authority. Lastly it is submitted that the petitioner authority having accepted the Bihar Rules and in terms thereof the gratuity amounts are being paid to its employees the provision of the Act will not apply for the purpose of paying gratuity to its employees. While developing his argument on the first point regarding the applicability of the provisions of the Act he submits that the concerned respondent at the time of retirement was getting more than 1000 rupees and, as such, he cannot claim the gratuity under the provisions of the Act being not an employee within the meaning of S. 2(e) thereof. Before appreciating the argument of Sri Gododia some relevant provision of the Act has to be referred to. In this connections S. 1(3) and its various sub-clauses read as follows.

    “(3) It shall apply to—

    (a) every factory, mine, oil-field, plantation, port and Railway company,

    (b) every shop or establishment within the meaning of any law for the time being in force in relation to shops and establishment in a State, in which ten or more persons are employed, or were employed, on any day of the preceding twelve months;

    (c) such other establishments or class of establishments, in which ten or more employees are employed or were employed, on any day of the preceding twelve months, as the Central Government may, by notification, specify in this behalf”.

    Sub-section (3)(a) of S. 1 of the Act is also relevant which is as follows:

    “A shop or establishment to which this Act has become applicable shall continue to be governed by this Act notwithstanding that the number of persons employed therein at any time after it has become so applicable falls below ten”.

    Mere reading of the aforesaid provisions of the Act it can safely be held that the petitioner authority is an establishment within the meaning of the Act. It is true that the establishment has not been defined separately in the Act but the petitioner will definitely come within the purview of S. 1(3)(b) of the Act, as quoted above. Accordingly, it is unnecessary to consider the provisions of Bihar Shops and Establishment Act for the purpose of determining as to whether the petitioner authority is an establishment within the meaning of S. 2(6) of the 1953 Act. The Act is a complete code in itself and, as such, it is not necessary to examine the provisions of the 1953 Act in order to ascertain the status of the petitioner authority. Accordingly, the submission of Sri Gododia is wholly misconceived and rejected as such. Section 4 of (he Act envisaged that gratuity shall be payable to the employees on termination of their employment after having rendered continuous service for not less than five years. Section 2(e) of the Act defines the employee and the explanation appended thereto as under:

    “‘employee’ means any person (other than an apprentice) employed on wages not exceeding two thousand and five hundred rupees per mensem, or such higher amount as the Central Government may, having regard to the general level of wages, by notification, specify in any establishment, factory, mine, oil field, plantation, port, railway company or shop, to do any skilled, semi-skilled, or unskilled, manual, supervisory, technical or clerical work, whether the terms of such employment are express or implied and whether or not such person is employee in a managerial or administrative capacity, but does not include any such person who holds a post under the Central Government or a State Government and is governed by any other Act or by any rules providing for payment of gratuity.

    Explanation.— In the case of an employee, who, having been employed for a period of not less than five years on wages not exceeding the amount for the time being specified by or under Cl. (e) is employed at any time thereafter on wages exceeding that amount, gratuity in respect of the period during which such employee was employed on wages not exceeding that amount shall be determined on the basis of the wages received by him during that period”.

    As has been stated above, at the time of appointment the concerned workman was getting Rs. 500 only. It is also admitted that the petitioner was getting more than 1,000 rupees by way of salary at the time of retirement. This Act came into force with effect from 16 September, 1972. Reading S. 4 along with Cl. (o) of S. 2 read with the explanation appended thereto, it is amply clear that the concerned employee fulfils all the requirements as envisaged under S. 4 and is an employee within the meaning of S. 2(e) and; as such, he is entitled to gratuity in accordance with the provisions of the Act. It may be mentioned here that the limit of Rs. 1,000 as mentioned in S. 2(e) was increased to Rs. 1,600, which was subsequently increased to Rs. 2,500 by the amending Act of 1984. Merely because the concerned employee was drawing more than the prescribed limit at the time of retirement he cannot be deprived of the gratuity amount. He will be deemed to be an employee under the Act when admittedly he was drawing less than the prescribed limit when the Act came into force. In that view of the matter, the submission of Sri Gododia to the effect that the concerned employee is not entitled for the gratuity amount under the Act since he was drawing more than the statutory limit has to be rejected outright. Somewhat a similar question came for adjudication before the Supreme Court in the case of Good Year India, Ltd. v. K.G Devessar reported in 1985 (2) L.L.N 822, when the Court has rejected the similar submission of the management and held that the employee, who was getting the salary within the statutory limit but subsequently more than the statutory limit at the time of his retirement he shall be entitled for payment of gratuity under the provisions, of the Act. The similar question has been answered by a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of Vasant Industrial and Engineering Works v. Narayan Damodar Desai reported in 1980 (1) L.L.N 109, in Para. 11, at page 113, in the following terms:

    “Now, the question is whether merely because the main part of the definition of employee refers only to a person employed on wages not exceeding Rs. 1,000 per mensem, the employee in the instant case should be held to be excluded from the benefits under the Act. The definition of employee in the main part of Cl. (e) of S. 2 must be read along with the explanation. The explanation in this case is really in the nature of a substantive provision providing for computation of gratuity in case of persons who were initially employed on wages not exceeding Rs. 1,000. The explanation makes it very clear in unambiguous language that notwithstanding the fact that a person who had been in employment for more than five years on wages not exceeding Rs. 1,000 per month draws wages which exceed Rs. 1,000 per month at any time thereafter, his claim for gratuity is to be determined on the basis of the wages received by him during the period when he was drawing less than Rs. 1000 per month. The intention of the Legislature in enacting the explanation obviously was to make it clear that the fact that at the time when any one of events referred to in S. 4(1) occurs, the employee is drawing wages exceeding Rs. 1,000 will not deprive him of the benefits under the Act if it is shown that earlier for a period of five years, the employee concerned was employed on wages not exceeding Rs. 1,000. Having regard to the definition of employee, it becomes, therefore, clear that the wages drawn by an employee at the time of either retirement, resignation, superannuation, death or disablement being in excess of Rs. 1,000 per month will not alone be the determining factor for deciding whether the claim for gratuity should be rejected. Even in such a case the Legislature has created an entitlement in favour of an employee if he is able to show that he was employed for a period of not less than five years on wages not exceeding Rs. 1,000”.

    Reference may also be made to the case of Jogendralal Mahakar v. Regional Labour Commissioner (Central) and Appellate Authority reported in 1977 L. & I.C 1308, wherein a Bench of the Calcutta High Court has held that it would be wholly unjust to hold that the employee who has rendered such along years of service at the commencement of the Act would be deprived of the benefits of gratuity simply on the ground that when the Act came into force the employee was drawing a salary of more than the statutory limit per month. The explanation appended to S. 2(e) of the Act clearly go to show that the case of such employee, who was even drawing more than the prescribed limit at the time of retirement, will come under the purview of the definition of the employee, as quoted above. The last submission of Sri Gododia to the effect that the application filed by the concerned employee after the statutory period prescribed under the rules could not have been entertained by the respondent controlling authority is also without any substance. This has to be kept in mind that the Act being a welfare legislation, the rightful claim of the employee cannot be defeated on the ground of technicality, such as, limitation. That apart, the respondent controlling authority has considered this aspect of the matter in detail and after having satisfied on the material on record, has condoned the delay. This Court in exercise of its power under Art. 226 cannot interfere with the findings of the respondent authority.

    5. After having heard the learned counsel for the parties and going through the material on record including the order under challenge, I am of the view that there is no illegality in the order passed by the respondent controlling authority and, accordingly, this writ application is dismissed with cost of Rs. 5,000 payable by the petitioner authority to the concerned workman.

    Writ dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mineral Area Development Authority v. State Of Bihar And Others
    (Jul 17, 1997)