Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Lt. Col. Jb Chetri v. Uoi & Ors.

    Arguments heard.

    2. This is an OA, under Section 14 of the Armed Forces Tribunal Act 2007, for having : (a) the respondents order dated 23.09.2013 rejecting the Statutory Complaint made by the petitioner against his non- empanelment for promotion by No. 3 Selection Board held in December, 2011 quashed and (b) the CRs (Confidential Reports) for the periods respectively from May 2006 to Dec 2006, Jan 2007 to Dec 2007 and Jan 2008 to May 2008 set aside. Direction requiring the respondents to consider him as a fresh case in No. 3 Selection Board for promotion to the rank of Colonel without loss of seniority has also been sought for. OA 222/2014

    3. The background facts, not in dispute, may be summed up as under:-

    (i) On 6th Dec 1997, the petitioner was commissioned into 15th Battalion, Assam Regiment of the Indian Army. During the period from Mar 2006 to May 2008, while remaining posted as GSO- 2(Ops) at HQs 11 Inf. Div. he had earned three CRs. All the three Reports were initiated by Col SS Tinaiker.

    (ii) The petitioners promotion to the rank of Col had to be considered by No. 3 Selection Board in accordance with policy contained in Para 108 of the Regulations for the Army, 1987 (Revised Edition), Army HQ letter No. 31525/P/MS 5B dated 06 May 87 and IHQ of MoD(Army) letter No. 04502/MS Policy dated 31.12.2008.

    (iii) In Dec 2011, the petitioner was considered as a fresh case by No. 3 Selection Board and was not empanelled. Being aggrieved, he preferred a Non-statutory Complaint, wherein he had sought review of all the CRs in the reckonable profile. However, on examination, the Chief of the Army Staff found that only Initiating Officers assessment as to his professional competence to handle Higher Appointments, reflected at para 24(e) of the CR covering period from Jan 2007 to Dec 2007, deserved interference on the ground of inconsistency. He, accordingly, directed expunction of the inconsistent figurative assessment as recorded in the para (above).

    (iv) In Jun 2012, the petitioner was considered afresh by No. 3 Selection Board as Special Review in view of the partial redress OA 222/2014 granted upon his Non-statutory Complaint but was again not recommended for promotion.

    (v) On 12 Jun 2013, the petitioner submitted the Statutory Complaint against his non-empanelment. In this complaint, he had also prayed for setting aside of all the three CRs characterising the same as subjective as well as inconsistent with his overall profile.

    4. According to the petitioner, the partial redress granted to him by the Chief of the Army Staff was suggestive of the inference that Col SS Tinaiker had initiated the CR for the period from Jan 2007 to Dec 2007 with a biased and prejudiced mind and therefore the same deserves to be quashed as not based on an objective assessment of his performance. He has further averred that the other two CRs in question are also liable to be expunged in their entirety as the subjective, biased and prejudiced assessments made by the IO had certainly influenced the process of assessment of his performance during the relevant periods by the RO and the SRO.

    5. In the counter, while explaining the procedure prescribed in the policy documents and relevant guidelines laid down for the promotion, the respondents have submitted that the petitioner was not empanelled on account of his overall profile and comparative batch merit. OA 222/2014

    6. Col SS Tinaiker, against whom bias is imputed has not been impleaded as one of the respondents. Further bias is, in fact, a condition of mind, which sways judgments and renders the judge unable to exercise impartiality in a particular case.(See State of W.B. v. Shivananda Pathak, (1998) 5 SCC 513). However, the test is as to whether there is a mere apprehension of bias or there is a real danger of bias and it is on this score that the surrounding circumstances must and ought to be collated and necessary conclusion drawn therefrom. In the event, however, the conclusion is otherwise that there is existing a real danger of bias, administrative action cannot be sustained. If on the other hand allegations pertain to rather fanciful apprehension in administrative action, question of declaring them to be unsustainable on the basis therefore, would not arise. {State of Punjab vs. V.K.Khanna (2001) 2 SCC 330 referred to}.

    7. Coming to the facts of the case, it may be observed that the CR, in respect of which a limited redress was granted by way of expunction of para 24(e) was not the first CR initiated by Col SS Tinaiker. Moreover, the respective assessments made by the ROs and SROs were not only in conformity with his overall performance both before and after the relevant periods but also did not suffer from any material divergence. In this view of the matter, the contention that all the three CRs impugned here were tainted OA 222/2014 with bias, inconsistency and subjectivity deserves to be rejected as being apparently misconceived.

    8. This apart, contents of the Personal Performance Sheet as well as the Comparative Chart clearly reflect that in the Special Review (Afresh), the First Review and Final Review Boards, the petitioners non-empanelment was based on his overall profile and the comparative batch merit. Having gone through the corresponding records in the light of the rival contentions, we are convinced that the petitioners overall profile was comparatively much weaker than the last officer recommended for promotion by each one of the Boards. As such, his grievance against the non-empanelment has no merit or substance.

    9. For these reasons, the OA stands dismissed with no order as to costs. (R.C.MISHRA) MEMBER(J) (S.K. SINGH) MEMBER (A) New Delhi 23.01.2015

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lt. Col. Jb Chetri v. Uoi & Ors.
    (Jan 23, 2015)