Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Tribunal Opinion (TA No.46/2010) — 19 February 2010

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition was transferred from the Hon'ble Delhi High Court to the Armed Forces Tribunal upon its formation. The petitioner, a Territorial Army (TA) officer who received a direct commission on 05.04.1984 and served as Company Commander in 109 Infantry Battalion (Territorial Army), Maratha LI, retired on completion of 54 years of age on 30.09.2002. The petitioner claims approximately 18 years of reckonable service (having participated in counter-insurgency and other operations, and having been promoted to Captain and Major), and sought a writ of mandamus directing grant of superannuation pension effective 01.10.2002 with interest at 12% per annum. The petition challenged a PCDA(P) letter dated 10.01.2003 as being contrary to the relevant rules.

After administrative steps to obtain pension failed, the petitioner filed the writ petition in the Delhi High Court, which was subsequently transferred to this Tribunal for disposal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an officer of the Territorial Army is entitled to pensionary benefits (including treatment as a "late entrant" where applicable) on the same basis as corresponding Indian Army officers under the Government orders of 30.10.1987 and 03.02.1998 and the Pension Regulations for the Army, 1961.
  2. Whether the PCDA(P) letter dated 10.01.2003 (which declined pension benefits to the petitioner) is contrary to the applicable Government orders and Pension Regulations and, if so, should be set aside.
  3. Whether the respondents are obliged to compute and pay the petitioner's pensionary arrears with interest (claimed at 12% per annum) and to grant costs.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted entitlement to superannuation pension effective 01.10.2002, relying on Government orders dated 30.10.1987 and 03.02.1998 and on Pension Regulations for the Army, 1961 (notably Regulations nos. 15, 25 and 292), which he submitted make Territorial Army personnel subject to the same pension provisions as corresponding Indian Army personnel.
  • The petitioner claimed approximately 18 years of reckonable qualifying service and that his service satisfied the requirements for pension as per the cited government orders and regulations.
  • Having been refused pension by the relevant authorities, the petitioner sought judicial relief by way of a writ of mandamus and the payment of arrears with interest.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents contended that the Territorial Army is a part-time concept and cannot be treated at par with the regular Indian Army for pension purposes.
  • They asserted that the petitioner had not completed 18 years of service but only 16 years and 92 days of service in the regular Army calculation.
  • The respondents relied on a communication dated 16.04.2002 from the Additional Directorate General Territorial Army (General Staff Branch, Army Headquarters) indicating that Territorial Army officers have never been treated at par with regular commissioned officers and that the benefit of Regulation 15 (Pension Part-I, 1961, concerning late entrants) could not be extended to TA officers because that regulation applied only to regular commissioned officers.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lt. Col. I.K. Talwar v. Union of India & Others (T.A. No. 771/2009) Establishes that personnel of the Territorial Army, for pension purposes, shall be treated at par with Army officers. The Tribunal relied on this decision as a similar case where TA personnel were held to be entitled to parity with Army officers for pensionary benefits and used it to support the present ruling that TA personnel are governed by Army pension regulations for computing pension.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal engaged in a focused textual and regulatory analysis grounded in the Government orders and the Pension Regulations for the Army, 1961. The court's reasoning proceeded in the following steps:

  1. The Tribunal observed that the Government orders dated 30.10.1987 (implementing recommendations of the Fourth Central Pay Commission) and 03.02.1998 (implementing recommendations of the Fifth Central Pay Commission) explicitly included Territorial Army (TA) officers among the categories of "Armed Forces personnel" to be governed by the modified pension provisions. The court reproduced and relied upon the relevant portions of these orders to show that TA personnel were to be covered by the same pension regulations as corresponding Army personnel.
  2. The Tribunal highlighted Regulation 292 of the Pension Regulations for the Army, which provides that the grant of pensionary awards to members of the Territorial Army "shall be governed by the same general regulations as are applicable to the corresponding personnel of the Army except where they are inconsistent with the provisions of regulations in this chapter." The court treated this as reinforcing the applicability of Army pension regulations to TA members.
  3. The Tribunal noted that an earlier decision in Lt. Col. I.K. Talwar v. Union of India & Others (T.A. No. 771/2009) had held that Territorial Army personnel should be treated at par with Army officers for pension purposes; the court considered this authority a directly relevant precedent supporting the petitioner's claim.
  4. The Tribunal criticized the respondents (including CGDA (Pension) and the Defence Ministry) for a lack of proper application of mind and for failing to adhere to the Government orders. The court observed that subordinate officers are bound by Government decisions and cannot override them, expressing regret at the manner in which the case had been handled.
  5. On the basis of the Government orders, Regulation 292, and the cited precedent, the Tribunal concluded that the PCDA(P) order dated 10.01.2003 was not consistent with the applicable rules and Government decisions and therefore could not stand.
  6. As a remedy, the Tribunal set aside the order dated 10.01.2003, directed the respondents to compute the petitioner's pensionary arrears and release them, and directed payment of arrears with interest at 12% per annum. The Tribunal also ordered costs (Rs. 10,000) in favour of the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Tribunal allowed the petition, set aside the order dated 10.01.2003, and directed the respondents to compute and pay the petitioner's pensionary arrears together with interest at 12% per annum. The Tribunal also awarded costs of Rs. 10,000 to the petitioner.

Implications: The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioner is to receive the pension and arrears as directed by the Tribunal, with interest and costs. The opinion emphasizes that Government orders of 30.10.1987 and 03.02.1998 and Regulation 292 of the Pension Regulations for the Army govern the applicability of pension provisions to Territorial Army personnel. The Tribunal criticized departmental non-application of mind in implementing those orders. The opinion does not, within its text, purport to set out broader legal principles beyond applying the cited Government orders, Regulation 292, and the cited precedent to the petitioner's case; the decision's immediate consequence is the grant of pensionary benefits and arrears to the petitioner as ordered.

Disposition date and Bench: New Delhi, 19 February 2010. Bench: A.K. Mathur (Chairperson) and M.L. Naidu (Member).

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Maj S.D. Singh v. Union Of India & Others

    19.02.2010

    1. The present petition has been transferred from Honble Delhi High Court to this Tribunal on its formation.

    2. Petitioner by this writ petition has sought a writ of mandamus to grant superannuation with effect from 01.10.2002 TA No.46/2010 with interest 12% per annum to the petitioner who retired on completion of 54 years of age with unblemished qualifying service of about 18 years, as per Government letters dated 03.02.1998, 30.10.1987 and 08.07.1994 and Regulations no.15, 25 and 292 of Pension Regulations for Army, 1961 by quashing the PCDA(P) letter dated 10.01.2003 being contrary to the corresponding rules.

    3. Brief facts which are relevant for the disposal of present writ petition are that petitioner was selected by the Selection Board for Territorial Army and he was granted direct commission on 05.04.1984. He was appointed as Company Commander in 109 Infantry Battalion (Territorial Army) Maratha

    LI. He participated in counter insurgency and other operations/ field areas and got promotion to the rank of Captain and then to Major after undergoing compulsory courses and professional examination. It is said that petitioner had put in 18 years of reckonable service and superannuated on 30.09.2002 on completion of 54 years of age. Thereafter, petitioner made a request for grant of pension but that request for pension was not acceded by the Authorities. Therefore, he was driven to file the present writ petition. Petitioner in this connection submitted that TA No.46/2010 as per Government order dated 30.10.1987 which clarified that all the members of Territorial Army will be entitled to same benefits as made applicable to Indian Army and this matter has been further clarified by the Government order dated 03.02.1998. Ultimately, petitioner after going through all efforts failed to get any relief. Therefore, he filed the present writ petition before the Hon'ble Delhi High Court which has been transferred to this Tribunal on formation of Armed Forces Tribunal for disposal.

    4. A reply was filed by the respondents and respondents have taken the position that Territorial Army is a part time concept and it cannot be treated at par with Indian Army and in that connection, they pointed out that petitioner has not put in 18 years of service but he has put in 16 years 92 days service in regular Army. It is also pointed that matter was examined at all level and ultimately, Additional Directorate General Territorial Army, General Staff branch, Army Headquarters, L Block, New Delhi vide communication dated 16.04.2002 has informed the Group Headquarters of all Commands that Territorial Army officers have never been treated at par with regular commissioned officers and the benefit of provision of Regulation 15 of Pension Part-I, 1961 TA No.46/2010 for Army about late entrants cannot be extended to Territorial Army officers as this Regulation is only applicable to regular commissioned officers only.

    5. We have learned counsel for parties and perused the record.

    6. At the outset we express our great regret that the matter has been mishandled badly. The Government orders dated 30th October, 1987 and 03rd February, 1998 have been flouted with impunity. Either Authorities have not read it or they have not applied their mind at all. Subordinate officers are bound by the Government decisions and they cannot override them. In this connection, reference may be made to first order dated 30th October, 1987 which needs to be reproduced as a whole to show that how thoughtlessly matter has been examined. The order dated 30th October, 1987 reads as under :- No. 1(5)/87 D (Pension/Services) Government of India/Bharat Sarkar Ministry of Defence/Raksha Mantralaya New Delhi dated the 30th October 1987 The Chief of the Army Staff The Chief of the Naval Staff TA No.46/2010 The Chief of the Air Staff Sub: Implementation of the Government decisions on the recommendations of the Fourth Central Pay Commission regarding pensionary benefits for the Armed Forces officers and personnel below officer rank retiring or dying in harness on or after 01.01.1986. Sir, I am directed to refer to the Government decisions on the recommendations of the Fourth Central Pay Commission as notified vide Government of India, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Department of Pension & Pensioners Welfare Resolution No.2/13/87-PIC dated 18th March, 1987 and to convey the sanction of the President to the modifications, to the extent specified in this letter, in the rules/regulations concerning pensionary benefits of the Commissioned Officers (including MNS and Territorial Army Officers)and personnel below officer rank (including NCs (E) of the three Services, Defence Security Corps and the Territorial Army) (hereinafter collectively referred to as Armed Forces personnel) 1.2 The provisions of the pension regulations of the three services and various service instructions/Government orders, which are not affected by the provisions of this letter, will remain unchanged. Part-1 Date of effect and Definitions 2.1 The provisions of this letter shall apply to the Armed Forces personnel who were in services as on 01.01.1986 or joined/join servcie thereafter. Definitions

    3. Reckonable Emoluments:

    4. Average emoluments:

    5. Qualifying Service (a) The term Qualifying Service (QS) shall mean:--------(table) (b) Weightage for the purpose of calculation of pension of commissioned officers will be given below:----------- (table) Notes : (1) There will be no weightage for officers and personnel below officer rank who retire prematurely for permanent absorption in public sector undertakings and autonomous bodies. (2) There will be no weightage for officers and personnel below officer rank of the Territorial Army. (3) The above weightage shall not be reckoned for determining the minimum qualifying service specified for admissibility of Retiring/Service Pension i.e. 20 years for service officers (15 years for late entrants), 15 years for personnel below officer rank and 20 years for NCs(E). (4) Full pre-commissioned service rendered under the Central Government whether in a civil Deptt. or in the Armed Forces, shall be TA No.46/2010 taken into account for working out the qualifying service for earning pensionary benefits subject to fulfilment of other conditions. This will also be counted for determining the minimum qualifying service indicated in Note 3 above for earning Retiring/Service Pension. (5) In calculating the length of qualifying service, fraction of a year equal to three months and above but less than 6 months shall be treated as a completed one half year and reckoned as qualifying service. Part-II Retiring/Service pension/gratuity, invalid pension/gratuity, special pension/gratuity, ordinary family pension, retirement/death gratuity.

    6. Retiring/Service pension 6.1 OFFICERS (a) The minimum period of qualifying service (without weightage) actually rendered and required for earning retiring pension shall continue to be 20 years (15 years in the case of late entrants). (b) Retiring pension in respect of the Commissioned Officers of the three services, including MNS and TA officers, shall be calculated at 50% of the average of emoluments reckonable for pension as defined in paras 3 and 4 above. The amount so determined shall be subject to a maximum of Rs.4,500/- per month and shall be the retiring pension for 33 years of reckonable qualifying service as defined in para 5 above; for lesser years of reckonable qualifying service, this amount shall be proportionately reduced. .................. .................. ..................

    30. Pension regulation of the three services will be amended in due course.

    31. This issue with concurrence of the Finance Division of the Ministry vide their u.o. no. 286-Pension of 1987.

    32. Hindi version will follow. Yours faithfully Addl Secy to the Govt of India

    7. The order dated 30th October, 1987 was for the implementation of the recommendations of the Fourth Central Pay Commission and order dated 03rd February, 1998 was issued for implementation of the Government decision on the Fifth Central TA No.46/2010 Pay Commission. Relevant portion of order dated 03rd February, 1998 reads as under :- No. 1(6) 98 D (Pension/Services) Government of India/Bharat Sarkar Ministry of Defence/Raksha Mantralaya New Delhi dated the 3rd Feb 1998 The Chief of the Army Staff The Chief of the Naval Staff The Chief of the Air Staff SUB: IMPLEMENTATION OF THE GOVERNMENT DECISIONS ON THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE FIFTH CENTRAL PAY COMMISSION REGARDING PENSIONARY BENEFITS FRO THE ARMED FORCES OFFICERS AND PERSONNEL BELOW OFFICER RANK (PBOR) RETIRING OR DYING IN HARNESS ON OR AFTER 01.01.1996. Sir, ........................ 5(2) In case of TA personnel aggregate of qualifying embodied service shall count for service pension. Aggregate qualifying embodied service may be continuous or rendered in broken spells. For calculating the total embodied service, the breaks in embodied service due to disembodiment will be treated as condoned but the period of breaks itself will not be treated as qualifying service for pension. Where qualifying embodied service has been rendered in broken spells, five per cent cut will be imposed on the pension of those JCOs/OR who have completed 15 years or more of aggregate embodied service but have not completed 20 years of aggregate embodied service. .......... 5(b) Notes: (3) The above weightage will not be reckoned for determining the minimum qualifying service specified for admissibility of Service Pension i.e. 20 years for service officers (15 years for late entrants) and

    15 years for PBOR and 20 years for NCs(E). 6.1 (a) The minimum period of qualifying service (without weightage) actually rendered and required fro earning retiring pension will be 20 years. In the case of late entrants (i.e. an officer who is retired on reaching the prescribed age limit for compulsory retirement with atleast 15 years commissioned service qualifying for pension but whose total service is less than 20 years, the minimum period of qualifying service (without weightage) TA No.46/2010 actually rendered and required for earning retiring pension will continue to be

    15 years.

    8. These two orders make it explicitly clear that the persons from the Territorial Army will be governed by the necessary pensionary Regulations which are applicable to Army also. There are no two opinions in the matter and there is no room for doubt. The Government orders dated 30th October, 1987 for implementation of Fourth Central Pay Commission and 3rd February, 1998 for implementation of Fifth Central Pay Commission make it abundantly clear that that the persons working in the Territorial Army will be governed by the Indian Army Pensionary Regulations for the purposes of working out their pensions.

    9. It may be relevant to reproduce Regulation 292 of Pension Regulations for the Army for Territorial Army and same is reproduced as under:- The grant of pensionary awards to members of the territorial Army shall be governed by the same general regulations as are applicable to the corresponding personnel of the Army except where they are inconsistent with the provisions of regulations in this chapter. TA No.46/2010

    10. A similar case came before us i.e. Lt. Col. I.K. Talwar Vs. Union of India & Others (T.A. No. 771/2009) and we have also held that the personnel of the Territorial Army for the purposes of pension shall be treated at par with Army officer. We have been shown the minutes of the note sheet of the Defence Ministry and CGDA (pension). We regret to say that there is not at all proper application of mind in this case. They are all obsessed with same concept of late entrants and the personnel of the Territorial Army stands differently for the purposes of pension. But the intention of the Government and two orders which have been issued in pursuance of the implementation of Fourth Pay Commission and Fifth Pay Commission leaves no room for doubt.

    11. After going through the files we record our great displeasure the way in which the case has been dealt and total non application of mind and this is the complete derogation of the policy decision of the Government. Despite the fact that the Government has already decided on 30th October, 1987 and 03rd February, 1998 still there is a doubt lurking in the mind of CGDA (pension) and so much so the Defence Ministry who has issued this circular after consultation with the Department of Personnel TA No.46/2010 did not stick to that and wade away by the observations of CGDA (pension). At least Ministry should have themselves examined orders issued by them on 30th October, 1987 and 03rd February, 1998. Therefore, we are of the opinion that the order passed by the Government dated 10.01.2003 is set aside and respondents are directed to work out the arrears of pension of petitioner and release the same and pay the same with interest @ 12% per annum.

    12. Petition is allowed with a cost of Rs.10,000/- to be paid to the petitioner. A.K. MATHUR (Chairperson) M.L. NAIDU (Member) New Delhi February 19, 2010.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Maj S.D. Singh v. Union Of India & Others
    (Feb 19, 2010)