Club Building (Near Post Office) Old JNU Campus, New Delhi - 110067 Tel: +91-11-26161796 Decision No. CIC/SG/A/2009/001990/5042 Appeal No. CIC/SG/A/2009/001990 Relevant Facts emerging from the Appeal: Appellant : Mr. Rajbir Singh S/o Shri Kashi Ram V + P Gadhi, Distt. Baghpat, U. P. Respondent 1 : Mr. Ravinder Kumar Public Information Officer Municipal Corporation of Delhi Central Establishment Department Town Hall, Delhi 110006. RTI application filed on : 18/02/2009 PIO replied : 17/03/2009, 18/06/2009 First appeal filed on : 17/04/2009 First Appellate Authority order : 20/05/2009 Second Appeal received on : 18/08/2009 The Appellant wanted following information related assets and liabilities of DHO Shahdara, North Zone, Mr. Ashok Rawat: S. No. Information Sought Reply of the PIO
1. Monthly salary Not given Information provided by the PIO (Shahdara North Zone) dated 25/05/2009.
2. Details of children with age, number of school goers children with details of their monthly school fee and other expenditures and name of the school. It did not cover under Section 2(f) of RTI Act, 2005.
3. Details of transportation if any, was availed by the children. As above. Information provided by the PIO (Town Hall) dated 18/06/2009.
4. Whether he was living in his own house or in Govt. accommodation. If he was living in rented accommodation then copy of the rent slip. The information sought by the Appellant through this point, being secret documents/information which could not be disclosed in the absence of a general or special order, under provisions of GIO (S.O.114) under rule (1) of rule 18 of CCS (Conduct) rules 1964 clause 110 of the Manual of office procedure, rule 11 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964 as the information sought covered under Section 8 (j) of the RTI Act, 2005.
5. Details of his immovable property with details of immovable property which was in the name of his wife and children. As above.
6. Details of immovable property which was purchased after going his service in MCD in Delhi. As above.
7. Details of property which was disclosed by him at the time of joining. Not give.
8. Details of anything more than Rs.10000/- which was purchased by him during his service, with date when the appropriate disclosure was made to the department & the same was duly assessed in his assessment of financial year. Not give.
9. Whether the Govt. vehicle was being utilized for personal use or not. Not give. First Appeal: Unsatisfactory and incomplete information received from the PIO. Order of the FAA: The FAA (Shahadra NorthZone) in its order directed the PIO/DHO (Shahadra North Zone) to give the reply of point no. 2 & 3 to the Appellant. Ground of the Second Appeal: Non-receipt of complete information from the PIO. Relevant Facts emerging during Hearing: The following were present: Appellant: Mr. Rajbir Singh; Respondent: Mr. S.C.Gupta, Officer Superintendent on behalf of Mr. Ravinder Kumar; The PIO Dy. Health Officer, Shahdara North Zone, Dr. Ashok Rawat had initially refused to give any information on 17/03/2009 contending that what was sought is not information as defined under Section 2(f) of the RTI Act. The reply was clearly wrong, the queries at no. 1,4,5,6,7,8 & 9 are clearly information as defined under Section 2(f) of the RTI Act. After the FAAs order PIO CED Mr. Ravinder Kumar replied to the Appellant on points 5,6 & 7 on 18/06/2009 that information could not be provided under Rule 11 of CCS Rules and also claiming exemption under Section 8(1) (j) of the RTI Act. He had also given no explanation how Section 8(1)(j) would apply. The Commission has already ruled on the matter of providing information on the assets held by a public servant in its decision no. CIC/SG/A/2009/001436/4247 dated 23 July 2009: The Commission can allow denial of information only based on the exemptions listed under Section 8 (1) of the act. The PIO has claimed that the information should not be disclosed since it is exempted from disclosure under Section 8 (1) (j). Under Section 8 (1) (j) information which has been exempted is defined as: "information which relates to personal information the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or interest, or which would cause unwarranted invasion of the privacy of the individual unless the Central Public Information Officer or the State Public Information Officer or the appellate authority, as the case may be, is satisfied that the larger public interest justifies the disclosure of such information:" To qualify for this exemption the information must satisfy the following criteria:
1. It must be personal information. Words in a law should normally be given the meanings given in common language. In common language we would ascribe the adjective 'personal' to an attribute which applies to an individual and not to an Institution or a Corporate. From this it flows that 'personal' cannot be related to Institutions, organisations or corporates. ( Hence we could state that Section 8 (1) (j) cannot be applied when the information concerns institutions, organisations or corporates.). The phrase 'disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or interest' means that the information must have some relationship to a Public activity. Various Public authorities in performing their functions routinely ask for 'personal' information from Citizens, and this is clearly a public activity. When a person applies for a job, or gives information about himself to a Public authority as an employee, or asks for a permission, licence or authorisation, all these are public activities. The information sought in this case by the appellant has certainly been obtained in the pursuit of a public activity. We can also look at this from another aspect. The State has no right to invade the privacy of an individual. There are some extraordinary situations where the State may be allowed to invade on the privacy of a Citizen. In those circumstances special provisos of the law apply, always with certain safeguards. Therefore it can be argued that where the State routinely obtains information from Citizens, this information is in relationship to a public activity and will not be an intrusion on privacy. Therefore we can state that disclosure of information such as assets of a Public servant, - which is routinely collected by the Public authority and routinely provided by the Public servants,- cannot be construed as an invasion on the privacy of an individual. There will only be a few exceptions to this rule which might relate to information which is obtained by a Public authority while using extraordinary powers such as in the case of a raid or phone- tapping. Any other exceptions would have to be specifically justified. Besides the Supreme Court has clearly ruled that even people who aspire to be public servants by getting elected have to declare their property details. If people who aspire to be public servants must declare their property details it is only logical that the details of assets of those who are public servants must be considered to be disclosable. Hence the exemption under Section 8(1) (j) cannot be applied in the instant case. Hence the information sought by the Appellant at query 1,4,5,6,7,8 & 9 would have to be provided. Decision: The Appeal is allowed. The PIO Mr. Ravinder Kumar will provide complete information after obtaining whatever assistance he needs form any other officer to the Appellant before 25 October 2009. The issue before the Commission is of not supplying the complete, required information by the PIO within 30 days as required by the law. From the facts before the Commission it is apparent that the then PIO Dr. Ashok Rawat is guilty of not furnishing information within the time specified under sub-section (1) of Section 7 by not replying within 30 days, as per the requirement of the RTI Act. It appears that the PIOs actions attract the penal provisions of Section 20 (1). A showcause notice is being issued to him, and he is directed give his reasons to the Commission to show cause why penalty should not be levied on him. He will present himself before the Commission at the above address on 06 November 2009 at 11.30am alongwith his written submissions showing cause why penalty should not be imposed on him as mandated under Section 20 (1). This decision is announced in open chamber. Notice of this decision be given free of cost to the parties. Any information in compliance with this Order will be provided free of cost as per Section 7(6) of RTI Act. Shailesh Gandhi Information Commissioner
06 October 2009 (In any correspondence on this decision, mention the complete decision number.)(GJ) Dr. Ashok Rawat Dy. Health Officer Civil Lines Zone, 16, Rajpur Road, Delhi