BY THE COURT: (per Hon'ble the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The applicant, Meghalaya Editors and Publishers Association has moved this application seeking leave to file appropriate intervening application in a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) Petition [WP(C) No.127 of 2015] that was disposed of on 17.03.2016. The applicant has moved this application with reference to a provision made in the order dated 17.03.2016 for considering revival of the said PIL petition on an appropriate miscellaneous application, if and when required.
The applicant-association seeks to state its grievance in regard to one of the directions issued in the said PIL petition on 27.05.2015, whereby restrictions were put over publication of any statement by the banned organization or any other organization, which might have the effect of disturbing the even tempo of public life and cause violation of fundamental rights of the citizens. It has been indicated in the instant application that on being aggrieved of the restriction so put by this Court in the order dated 27.05.2015, the applicant filed a petition for Special Leave to Appeal [SLP] before the Hon'ble Supreme Court, which was, however, withdrawn on 18.09.2015 while seeking liberty to move this Court for appropriate relief. It is noticed that in the aforesaid detailed order dated 27.05.2015, a Full Bench of this Court took note of the then obtaining scenario, where the
2
functioning of even essential services was being disrupted in the State of Meghalaya because of regular calls of bandh in the name of banned organization or other organizations. This Court referred to the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Communist Party of India (M) v. Bharat Kumar and others: (1998) 1 SCC 201 as also to the decisions of various High Courts; and in view of the submissions made by the Advocate General and the Director General of police, issued several directions, essentially aimed at restoring the rule of law and removing the fear psyche of the common citizens. The part of directions issued by this Court read as under: -
"In view of the present obtaining scenario, consequent upon call of bandh in the State of Meghalaya, the prayer of the Director General of Police Shri Mehta deserves consideration. Hence, we direct that the statements of HNLC or any organization which may disturb the even tempo of day-to-day public life and cause violation of Fundamental rights of citizens in particular under Article 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India relating to strike, Bandh, Hartal, Road Blockade and holding of Rallies with unlawful design shall not be issued by any of the print and electronic media. In case of violation of this order, the Court may not only proceed under the Contempt of Courts Act, but it is also directed that the State Government shall register criminal cases under appropriate provisions of the law. It may not be out of place to direct the Secretary/Director of Information and Publicity of Government of Meghalaya, to ensure wide publicity of this order in print and electronic media so that the common citizens are encouraged to return to their normal life and get a strength of courage to pursue their regular avocation without any element of fear. We also direct that the State Government shall authorize the local administration to take the assistance of Para-Military Forces which are positioned in Shillong in sufficient strength for holding Flag March to dispel the fear from the mind of common citizens, and also for use depending upon the of law and order situation in the city of Shillong as well as across the State of Meghalaya. We also direct the State Government of Meghalaya and the CEO/In- charge of Municipal Corporation, Shillong, to issue notice to all such shops and business establishments, in particular, the medical shops and hotels and also to taxi owners, as to why their licences not be cancelled for staying away from their lawful avocation and for keeping their establishments closed despite repeated Press Release/Communique of assurance issued by the State Government that they shall be provided adequate protection on their place of occupation/business. Further, all the Central and State Government organizations situated in the State of Meghalaya are also issued notice with direction to file affidavits regarding the position of attendance of staff today or thereafter, namely, the date of call of bandh given by the outfit HNLC."
It is also noticed that this Court monitored the implementation of directions so issued in the order dated 27.05.2015 for some time but ultimately, after being informed that the directions had been substantially
3
complied with, the monitoring was closed on 10.12.2015. The said PIL petition, of course, remained pending even after 10.12.2015 for dealing with other peripheral issues, but was finally disposed of on 17.03.2016 while providing for its re-opening or further directions in the following: -
"The learned Amicus Curiae, however, submits that even though monitoring of the order dated 27.05.2015 was closed in the order dated 10.12.2015 at the given stage but then, for the peculiar nature of the issue addressed and looking to the requirements of public, the aspects relating to monitoring and implementation of the order dated 27.05.2015 and other directions issued in this matter may be kept open for revival/further orders, if and when required. The learned senior Government Advocate has, in all fairness, candidly supported these suggestions of the Amicus Curiae. Taking note of the submissions so made, and while providing that this petition may be considered for revival on appropriate Miscellaneous Application and/or any further direction may be issued in the matter, if and when required, as at present, the proceedings in this petition stand closed; and this petition stands disposed of."
The applicant seeks to suggest grievance against the part of the directions in the order dated 27.05.2015 that prevents publication of any such statement by the banned organization or any other organization, which might disturb the even tempo of public life and violate the fundamental rights of the citizens. However, it is an admitted position that the applicant approached the Supreme Court with the same grievance by way of SLP (C) No.16777 of 2015 but, on 18.09.2015, withdrew from the petition, while seeking to reserve the liberty to move this Court; and the petition before the Hon'ble Supreme Court was dismissed as withdrawn.
Noticeable it is that after withdrawing from the SLP on 18.09.2015, the applicant did not move this Court anytime earlier though the said PIL petition was regularly taken up by this Court and several orders were passed including those dated 30.09.2015, 02.11.2015, 18.11.2015, 26.11.2015 before the monitoring of the order dated 27.05.2015 was closed on 10.12.2015. The said PIL petition remained pending even after 10.12.2015, albeit for dealing with other peripheral issues, before it was disposed of on 17.03.2016. As noticed, for all this time when the PIL petition was being regularly dealt with by this Court and even until its disposal on 17.03.2016, the applicant-association did not move any application; and, in fact, the instant application has been moved nearly two months after closure of the matter.
4
It is also noticed from the order dated 17.03.2016 that a provision for revival of the petition has been made for the purpose of monitoring and implementation of the directions issued by this Court but not for the purpose of challenging any part of the order dated 27.05.2015, that has attained finality long back.
The learned counsel for the applicant-association, though initially attempted to argue on the application but upon our expressing reservations on this highly belated and rather unwarranted application in the disposed of matter, the learned counsel has, in all fairness, sought permission to withdraw and has filed an application in that regard.
Although the learned counsel for the applicant-association has frankly sought permission to withdraw after our expressing reservations, but, in the totally of the circumstances of the case, we are impelled to impose costs on the applicant-association for this undeserving application while granting permission to withdraw. To this, the learned counsel for the applicant prays that only nominal costs be imposed.
Having regards to the circumstances, we permit the applicant to withdraw and this application [MC (WP(C)] No.78 of 2016] stands dismissed as withdrawn with costs in the sum of Rs.2,000/- [two thousand only] that shall be deposited by the applicant with the Director of Social Welfare, Government of Meghalaya for the benefits of the inmates of Juvenile Home within thirty days. It shall be required of the applicant to produce the receipt of such deposit in the Registry of this Court within sixty days.
JUDGE CHIEF JUSTICE
Lam Item No.2