AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition challenges the order dated 02.03.2015 passed below Exhibit 54 by the trial court in Regular Civil Suit No.107 of 2012. The trial court rejected the defendant's application under Section 65 of the Evidence Act seeking permission to lead secondary evidence. The rejection was based on the grounds that the contents regarding the loss of the original document were vague and the photostat copy of the document was not authenticated.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in rejecting the application under Section 65 of the Evidence Act for permission to lead secondary evidence without permitting the party to enter the witness box and be subjected to cross-examination.
  2. Whether the requirements for leading secondary evidence—proof of existence and loss of the original document—can be established without allowing oral evidence and cross-examination.
  3. Whether the admissibility of the photostat copy as secondary evidence can be determined before the evidence is led and tested through cross-examination.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments

  • Reliance on the decision in Bank of Baroda, Bombay vs. Shree Moti Industries, 2009(1) Mh.L.J. 282, paragraphs 25 to 27, which holds that to lead secondary evidence, there must be proof of the existence and loss of the original document.
  • Submission that the trial court correctly held the document was not authenticated, in conformity with the cited precedent.

Court's Observations

  • The court emphasized that the application under Section 65 can only be properly considered if the party is permitted to give oral evidence and be cross-examined.
  • The veracity of statements regarding loss and existence of the original document must be tested through cross-examination to avoid miscarriage of justice.
  • Admissibility of the photostat copy and its marking as an exhibit can only be decided after evidence is led.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bank of Baroda, Bombay vs. Shree Moti Industries, 2009(1) Mh.L.J. 282 Requirements to lead secondary evidence: proof of existence and loss of original document. The court upheld the principle but held that these requirements cannot be established without oral evidence and cross-examination, thus the trial court erred in rejecting the application without permitting such evidence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the application under Section 65 of the Evidence Act by emphasizing that the mere filing of an application alleging loss of original documents and producing a photostat copy is insufficient without allowing the party to give oral evidence and be cross-examined. The court reasoned that the two essential elements—proof of existence and loss of the original—cannot be conclusively established without testing the veracity of the statements through cross-examination. The trial court's refusal to permit the party to enter the witness box and examine witnesses was therefore erroneous. The court further clarified that questions regarding the admissibility of the photostat copy as secondary evidence must be decided after evidence is led and tested in court. Consequently, the application should have been kept pending rather than rejected outright.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed. The order dated 02.03.2015 passed below Exhibit 54 by the trial court is quashed and set aside. The trial court is directed to permit the parties to enter the witness box and/or examine witnesses who shall be subjected to cross-examination. The application under Section 65 shall thereafter be decided on its own merits in accordance with law. All questions regarding the admissibility of such secondary evidence are kept open. The trial court is further directed to decide the suit expeditiously.

This decision directly affects the parties by reinstating the opportunity to present and test secondary evidence through oral testimony and cross-examination. No new precedent beyond the application of established principles was created.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Suresh S/O Shrikrishna Pandharipande v. Parag S/O Padmakar Pandharipande

    wp3426.15.J.odt 1/4

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.

    WRIT PETITION NO.3426 OF 2015

    Shri Suresh s/o Shrikrishna Pandharipande, Aged about 72 years,

    Occu. Retired, R/o Plot No.60, Ambazari Layout, Nagpur. ....... PETITIONER

    ...V E R S U S...

    Parag s/o Padmakar Pandharipande, Aged about 47 years,

    Occu. Service, R/o Plot No.483, Professor Colony, Hanuman Nagar, Nagpur. ....... RESPONDENT

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Shri R.A. Gupte, Advocate for Petitioner.

    Shri Amol Mardikar, Advocate for Respondent.

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    CORAM: R.K. DESHPANDE, J.

    DATE: 14 th SEPTEMBER, 2015.

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    1] Rule, made returnable forthwith. Heard finally by consent of the learned counsels appearing for the parties.

    2] The challenge in this petition is to the order dated 02.03.2015 passed below Exhibit 54 by the trial court in Regular Civil Suit No.107 of 2012. The trial court has rejected the application filed by the defendant under Section 65 of the Evidence Act for grant of permission to lead secondary evidence. The rejection is on the ground

    1

    that the contents regarding loss of original document pleaded in the application are vague, the photostat copy of the document sought to be produced is not authenticated.

    3] Shri Mardikar, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent - original plaintiff has relied upon the decision of this Court in case of Bank of Baroda, Bombay vs. Shree Moti Industries, Bombay and others reported in 2009(1) Mh.L.J. 282, more particularly, paragraphs 25 to 27 therein. The court has held that if anybody wants to lead secondary evidence, two things are required to be proved; (i) there must be evidence of the existence of the original documents, and (ii) there must be evidence of their loss. He submits that the trial court has held that the document is not authenticated and this view is in conformity with the aforestated decision.

    4] The proposition laid down in the said decision cannot be disputed. However, in the present case, the court is required to consider the application under Section 65 of the Evidence Act for grant of permission to lead secondary evidence, and the contents of the application can be established only if the party is permitted to enter the witness box, and is subjected to cross-examination. The veracity of the statements made by the party seeking permission to lead secondary evidence has to be tested on the cross-examination by the other side.

    2

    Otherwise there would be miscarriage of justice. The two things contemplated by the aforestated decision can not be proved unless party concerned is permitted to enter the witness box and/or examine the witnesses who are also subjected to cross-examination by adversarials. As and when photostat copy of the document is tendered in evidence, its admissibility in evidence or whether it can be marked as an Exhibit can be decided. Similarly, it is after the evidence is led, the court can consider the question as to whether the evidence so led is admissible in law as secondary evidence. The matter can be tested thereafter in the light of the guidelines laid down by this Court in the judgment cited supra. Till then the application has to be kept pending. The court has committed an error in refusing to grant permission to the party to enter the witness box, and/or examine the witnesses in support of the claim made in such application. The order impugned cannot therefore, be sustained.

    5] In the result, the writ petition is allowed. The order dated 02.03.2015 passed below Exhibit 54 by the trial court in Regular Civil Suit No.107 of 2012, is hereby quashed and set aside. The trial court shall permit the parties to enter the witness box, and/or to examine witnesses who shall be subjected to cross-examination, and thereafter the application at exhibit 54 shall be decided on its own merits in accordance with law. All questions regarding admissibility of such

    3

    evidence are kept open. The trial court to decide the suit expeditiously. No costs.

    JUDGE

    NSN

    4

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Suresh S/O Shrikrishna Pandharipande v. Parag S/O Padmakar Pandharipande
    (Sep 14, 2015)