IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 57 of 2016. .
Judgment reserved on: 1.4.2 . 01 P 6. Date of decision: April 7, 2016. Veepul Lakhanpal f …. .Pe H titioner. Versus
Smt. Pooja o …..Respondent. Coram
The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Tarlok Sintgh Chauhan, Judge. Whether approved for reportinrg?1Yes
For the Petitioner o : u Mr. Harsh Khanna, Advocate. For the Respon C dent : Mr. Anirudh Sharma, Advocate. Tarlok S h ingh Chauhan, Judge. g This petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India at t i he instance of the husband takes exception to the order passed by H learned Additional District Judge-1, Solan on 14.1.2016 whereby his application under Section 10 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short the 'Code') for staying the proceedings has come to be dismissed.
2. The facts giving rise to the present petition may be noticed. The proceedings pending before the learned trial Court (Additional District Judge-1, Solan) have been instituted by the respondent under Section 12 of the Hindu Marriage Act (for short 'Act') wherein the petitioner moved application under Section 10 of CPC on the ground that earlier petition instituted by the petitioner under Section 13 of the Act was already pending adjudication before the learned District Judge, Shimla. The respondent had not only put in appearance, but had also
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?Yes
1
raised similar plea regarding impotency of the petitioner and had further raised certain other contentions, which were similar to the one se P t out i . n the present petition.
3. It was further averred that the relief sough.t by the respondent in the impugned proceedings pending b ef H ore the Court at Solan had already been sought by her in the proce f edings under Section 13 of the Act pending before the learne o d District Judge, Shimla. Therefore, she could not be allow r ed t to set up same ground in two different proceedings pendin u g before the two Courts of competent jurisdiction on the same o cause of action. It was further averred that the findings in one petition would operate as resjudicata in another proceeding an d i C n case both the proceedings are allowed to continue, then ther h e is every likelihood of contradictory findings, being recorded by g the two Courts on the same matter. 4 i . The learned Court below dismissed the application by H holding that the provision of Section 10 of CPC would not be applicable to the present case as the necessary ingredients of the Section were not attracted in the present case. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have also
gone through the records of the case carefully.
5. Section 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure reads thus:
"10. Stay of suit. - No Court shall proceed with the trial of any suit in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim litigating undr the same title where such suit is pending in the same or any other Court in India having jurisdiction to grant the relief claimed, or in any Court beyond the limits of India established or continued by the Central Government and having like jurisdiction, or before the Supreme Court.
2
Explanation. - The pendency of a suit in a foreign Court does not preclude the Courts in India from trying a suit founded on the sam . e cause of action."
6. The object of Section 10 CPC is to prevent . CoPurts of concurrent jurisdiction from simultaneously trying tw H o parallel suits between the same parties in respect of the same m atter in issue. The fundamental test to attract Section 10 is, whetfher on final decision being reached in the previous suit, t heo same would operate as res-judicata in the subsequent su r it. Stection 10 applies only in cases where the whole of the subje u ct matter in both the suits is identical. The key words in Section o 10 are "the matter in issue is directly and substantially in is C sue" in the previous instituted suit. The words "directly and substantia lly in issue" are used in contradistinction to the words
"incidenta h lly or collaterally in issue". Therefore, Section 10 would apply o i nl g y if there is identity of the matter in issue in both the suits, meaning thereby, that the whole of subject matter in both the proceedings is
H identical. 7. The mere common grounds in the previous suit and subsequent suit would not attract the Section 10. The basic purpose and underlying object of Section 10 of the Code is to prevent the Courts
of concurrent jurisdiction from simultaneously entertaining and
adjudicating upon two parallel litigations in respect of the same cause of
action, the same subject matter and the same relief. This is to pin down
the plaintiff to one litigation so as to avoid the possibility of contradictory
verdicts given by two Courts in respect of the same relief and is aimed
to protect the defendant from multiplicity of proceeding(s).
8. It is not in dispute that the respondent in the proceedings instituted by the petitioner under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act
3
has only filed her reply and has not raised a counterclaim therein. It is further not in dispute that the grounds taken by her in the petitio . n instituted by her under Section 12 of the Act are quite similar to P those raised as a defence in the proceedings instituted by the petitio.ner under Section 13 of the Act. H
9. Section 23-A of the Act, confers f a right upon the respondent to seek a decree by way t of c ou o nter claim while filing reply to a petition seeking decree of r divorce or judicial separation or restitution of conjugal rights. The aforesaid section inter alia provides that in any proceedings o for di u vorce or judicial separation or restitution of conjugal rights, the respondent may not only oppose the relief sought on the aforesa id C ground, but may also make a counter claim for any relief und h er this Act on that ground and the Court may grant such a dec g ree. 1 i 0. Section 23-A only applies to the proceedings for the H following reliefs: (i) divorce; (ii) judicial separation and ;
(iii) restitution of conjugal rights. But this Section has no applicability insofar as the relief claimed by the respondent under Section 12 of the Act is concerned. Even otherwise, no decree of annulment of marriage can be passed in favour of the respondent by the Court on the ground of impotency in the proceedings instituted by the petitioner under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act at Shimla wherein the respondent has raised a specific plea of impotency. Such decree of annulment of marriage can only be passed in a substantive petition under Section 12 of the Act which is pending
4
before the Court at Solan. Thus, the scope, ambit and result of both the petitions are entirely different. Moreover, the grounds for filing of a . n application under Section 12 of the Act and the grounds for filin P g of an application under Section 13 of the Act are entirely different. .
11. The learned counsel for the petitioner wo H uld then argue that the petition filed by the respondent pendin f g before the learned Court at Solan be transferred to Shim t la by o exercising the power under Section 21-A of the Act. I am a r fraid that even this prayer of the petitioner cannot be acceded to.
12. Section 21- o A rea u ds thus: "21-A. Power to transfer petitions in certain cases.- (1) Where -
(a) C a petition under this Act has been presented to a District Court having jurisdiction by a party to marriage praying for a decree h for a judicial separation under Section 10 or for a decree of divorce under Section 13; and g
(b) another petition under this Act has been presented thereafter i
by the other party to the marriage praying for a decree for judicial separation under Section 10 or for a decree of divorce H
under Section 13 on any ground, whether in the same District Court or in a different District Court, in the same State or in a different State, the petitions shall be dealt with as specified in sub-section (2). (2) In a case where sub-section (1) applies, -
(a) If the petitions are presented to the same District Court, both the petitions shall be tried and heard together by that District Court;
(b) if the petitions are presented to different District Courts, the petition presented later shall be transferred to the District Court in which the earlier petition was presented and both the petitions shall be heard and disposed of together by the District Court in which the earlier petition was presented.
(3) In a case where Clause (b) of sub-section (2) applies, the Court or the Government, as the case may be, competent under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908), to transfer any suit or proceeding from the District Court in which the later petition has been presented to the District Court in which the earlier petition is pending, shall exercise its powers
5
to transfer such later petition as if it had been empowered so to under the said Code."
.
6