IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present: The Hon'ble Justice Samapti Chatterjee C.O. 3629 of 2015
GSP Projects Private Limited
Vs
Rockfield Paj Replications Pvt. Ltd.
For the Plaintiff/Petitioner : Mr. Aniruddha Chatterjee, Learned Advocate Mr. Srijib Chakraborty, Learned Advocate
For the Defendant/
Opposite Party : Mr. Malay Kumar Ghosh, Learned SeniorAdvocate Heard on : November 18, 2015
Judgment on : January 27, 2016.
Samapti Chatterjee, J.
1. The plaintiff/petitioner has filed the present revisional application assailing the Order No.153 dated 31stAugust, 2015 passed by the Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), 2ndCourt at Barasat in Title Suit No.67 of 2008 whereby the application under Order 18 Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code read with Section 151 dated 19thSeptember, 2014 filed on behalf of the principal defendant praying for adducing
1
further evidence was allowed on contest with cost of a sum of `10,000/- payable by the principal defendant to the plaintiff.
2. Mr. Chatterjee learned Advocate appearing for the plaintiff/petitioner contended that the principal defendant has already authorised one Mahendra Agarwal to represent the principal defendant in the instant suit and the said Mahendra Agarwal had already submitted his affidavit-in-chief and tendered his evidence along with some documents which were exhibited by the Learned Court below and the said Mahendra Agarwal has been cross-examined and discharged.
3. Mr. Chatterjee further contended that the evidence of the Mahendra Agarwal had already been closed on two occasions i.e. on 9th November, 2011 and 24thNovember, 2014 respectively.
4. Mr. Chatterjee further contended that there is no provision under Civil Procedure Code that once the witness has concluded his evidence then again by filing application under Order 18 Rule 17 same witness can pray for further evidence.
5. Mr. Chatterjee also vehemently urged that though the application is under Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code but the nomenclature is the same that the principal defendant is trying to
2
adduce further evidence by filing the present application which is barred by law.
6. Mr. Chatterjee drew my attention to the 3rdparagraph of 2nd page of the impugned order dated 31stAugust, 2015 which is quoted below :
"Having heard the submissions of the Ld. Advocates appearing on behalf of the parties concern and having consulted with the case record, it appears to me that both the Ld. Advocate for the plaintiff and the erstwhile Ld. Advocate for the principal defendant submitted before this Court that no further evidence would be adduced from the parties concern, whereupon the case record has been fixed for hearing of the final argument of the case vide, order dated 24.4.14 and subsequently on 24.7.14 fresh vakalatnama has been filed on behalf of the principal defendant and thereafter, on 19.9.4 the principal defendant filed the instant petition under section 151 of the C.P. Code praying for adducing further evidence when the present suit has already been posted for hearing of the final argument of the case, although no such argument has yet been commenced. Therefore, there is no doubt that the principal defendant brought the instant application at the belated stage of the litigation just before commencing of the final argument of the case.
3
Further, this is the settled principle of law that the recalling of witness could not be allowed for filling up the lacunae in the evidence."
7. Mr. Chatterjee further vehemently urged that all the 68 documents are very much within the knowledge and possession of the principal defendant from October, 2006, therefore, nothing new can be brought by the impugned application for adducing further evidence though admittedly evidence of the principal defendant has already concluded and the matter has been posted for argument.
8. Mr. Chatterjee also contended that by filing the application opposite party/defendant is trying to delay and frustrate the hearing of the suit as the plaintiff/petitioner has already deposited a huge amount of money amounting to (`4,80,00000/-) and pursuant to the Learned Court's order the same is lying in the Learned Trial Court since February, 2011. Therefore, this present application is nothing but a dilatory tactics to frustrate the hearing of the suit.
9. Mr. Chatterjee further contended that the plaintiff/petitioner has filed an application under Order 19 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Code for producing Arun Kumar Agarwal on behalf of the principal defendant for cross-examination by the plaintiff but the defendant did
4
not allow the said Arun Kumar Agarwal to be cross-examined on the ground that the defendant should not be allowed to bring another person to adduce evidence on his behalf as on behalf of the principal defendant evidence had already been adduced by one Mahendra Agarwal and his evidence has been concluded.
10. In conclusion Mr. Chatterjee contended that the revisional application should be allowed by quashing the impugned order.
11. Mr. Malay Kumar Ghosh, learned senior Counsel appearing for the plaintiff/opposite party submitted that the said application under Section 151 of the CPC was filed for adducing evidence by producing second witness and not the same witness.
12. Mr. Ghosh further vehemently urged that Order 18 Rule 17 does not preclude to bring further evidence through other witness.
13. Mr. Ghosh further contended that in the present application another witness was brought on behalf of the plaintiff, therefore, there is no bar to adduce further evidence by presenting different witness and not the same witness.
5
Mr. Ghosh also strongly relied on Section 9 and Section 60 of the Evidence Act. Section 9 and Section 60 of the Evidence Act are quoted below: -
"Section-9-Facts necessary to explain or introduce relevant facts- Facts necessary to explain or introduce a fact in issue or relevant fact, or which support or rebut an inference suggested by a fact in issue or relevant fact, or which establish the identity of anything or person whose identity is relevant, or fix the time or place at which any fact in issue or relevant fact happened or which show the relation of parties by whom any such fact was transacted, are relevant in so far as they are necessary for that purpose." Section-60-Oral evidence must be direct.-Oral evidence must, in all cases whatever, be direct; that is to say-
If it refers to a fact which could be seen, it must be the evidence of a witness who says he saw it;
If it refers to a fact which could be heard, it must be the evidence of a witness who says he heard it;
If it refers to a fact which could be perceived by any other sense or in any other manner, it must be the evidence of a witness who says he perceived it by that sense or in that manner;
6
If it refers to an opinion or to the grounds on which that opinion is held, it must be the evidence of the person who holds that opinion on those grounds;
Provided that the opinions of expe5rts expressed in any treatise commonly offered for sale, and the grounds on which such opinions are held, any be proved by the production of such treatises if the author is dead or cannot be found, or has become incapable of giving evidence, or cannot be called as a witness without an amount of delay or expense which the Court regards as unreasonable; Provided also that, if oral evidence refers to the existence or condition of any material thing other than a document, the Court may, if it thinks fit, require the production of such material thing for its inspection."
14. Mr. Ghosh further contended that pre-judging the issue before trial on evidence is not accepted in law.
15. Mr. Ghosh also strongly urged that without bringing the further evidence on record the present suit cannot be decided. Therefore, evidence of the second witness on behalf of the plaintiff is very much required and necessary for proper adjudication of the suit.
7
16. Considering the submissions advanced by the learned Advocates of the respective parties and after perusing the records I am of the view that to consider the controversy involved in this case Court should not be unmindful of certain relevant provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure. Order 7 Rule 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure postulates the obligation of the Plaintiff to produce all relevant documents to be relied upon by him along with the plaint at the time of it's presentation. Similarly, the defendant is under the obligation to file all his documents at the time of filling written statement under Order 8 Rule 1A of the Code of Civil Procedure. In this case such provision has not been complied with. Such provision is followed by the provision of Order XIII Rule 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Those provisions are also not complied with in the instant case. The intention of the legislature is to ensure that the other side is not taken by surprise for belated production of documents.
I have also considered the provisions of Order 18 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, whereby certain discretions are left to the Court to allow principal witness to come subsequently provided sufficient reason is shown to the satisfaction of the Court.
Order 18 Rule 17A of the Code of Civil Procedure has since been deleted, which is a corresponding provision of Order 41 Rule 27 of the of
8
Code of Civil Procedure is the requirement of the Court and not of the parties and as such the said application is heard along with the appeal itself because it is the requirement of the Court for effective pronouncement of judgment as per Order 41 Rule 27 (b) of the Code of Civil Procedure. The provision of Order 41 Rule 27 (a) of the Code of Civil Procedure is very significant as to when and how additional evidence would be entertained. It is to be established notwithstanding the exercise of due diligence, such evidence was not within the knowledge of the party or could not be produced by him within time. Now coming to the provision of Order 18 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure the intention of the Legislature is clear that certain discretion has been conferred on the Court. But such discretion is not unfettered one and certain conditions are to be fulfilled as indicated above to enable the Court to exercise such power to permit further evidence or additional evidence.
Reference can be made to the case reported in (2003) 1 Supreme Court Cases Page-49 para-21 (Salem Advocate Bar Association vs Union of India) which is quoted below :-
"Para-21- We find that in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, a provision similar to Rule 17-A did not exist. This provision, as already noted, was inserted in 1976. The effect of the deletion of this provision in 2002 is merely to restore status quo ante, that is to
9
say, the position which existed prior to the insertion of Rule 17-A in 1976. The remedy, if any, that was available to a litigant with regard to adducing additional evidence prior to 1976 would be available now and no more. It is quite evident that Rule 17-A has been deleted with a view that unnecessarily applications are not filed primarily with a view to prolong the trial." (emphasis supplied)
Therefore, having considered the facts in controversy involved in this matter in the light of the relevant provisions quoted above I am of the view that the Court cannot shut its eyes on the submission advanced by Mr. Chatterjee that all documents (approximately 70/80) documents) were within the possession of the defendant/opposite party from the year 2006. Therefore, this application is contrary to the provision as laid down by the legislation referred above.
I also cannot ignore the submission of Mr. Chatterjee that since the evidence of a party is closed therefore, without recalling the said evidence another witness for the self same defendant cannot be produced by the defendant to adduce further evidence.
17. With the above discussions I am of the view that the impugned order being no.153 dated 31stAugust, 2015 passed by the Learned Civil
10
Judge (Senior Division) 2ndCourt at Barasat being Title Suit No.67 of 2008 cannot be sustained in the eye of law.
18. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 31stAugust, 2015 is set aside and quashed.
19. I direct the Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division) 2ndCourt at Barasat, North 24-Parganas to hear out and decide the said application afresh in the light of the Order 18 Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code within one month from the date of communication of this Order without being influenced by the earlier Order being No.153 dated 31stAugust,
2015.
20. With this direction, this revisional application stands allowed.
21. No order as to costs.
22. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment if applied for, be supplied to the parties after fulfilling all the formalities. (Samapti Chatterjee, J)
11