IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,
SHIMLA.
RSA No. 481 of 2005 Reserved on: 16.11.2015 Decided on: 18.11.2015 . ______________________________________________________ Khem Singh. …Appellant . . P
Versus Y.R. Sharma. …Re H spondent.
_______________________________________________ f ___ ____________ Coram:
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Sharma, Ju dg o e.
Whether approved for reportin r g?1t Yes For the Appellant : M u r. Rajneesh K. Lal, Advocate. For the Respondent: o Mr. Neeraj Gupta, Advocate. ____________________________________________________________
Justice R a C jiv Sharma, Judge. h This Regular Second Appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 7.6.2005 rendered by the
ig District Judge, Solan in Civil Appeal No. 72-S/13 of 2004. H
2. "Key facts" necessary for the adjudication of this appeal are that respondent-plaintiff (hereinafter referred to as the "plaintiff" for convenience sake) filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction against the appellant-defendant (hereinafter referred to as the
"defendant" for convenience sake). Plaintiff was one of the
1
2
co-owners of the suit land. He purchased 8 biswas of land from Khasra No. 153/57 vide sale deed No. 264 dated 18.3.1991. Defendant has no right, title or interest in the .
suit land. He has threatened to interfere in the suit lan . d. P3. Suit was contested by the defendant. It was denied that plaintiff was owner in possession o H f the suit
land. Plaintiff did not possess any part f of Khasra No.
153/57. The suit land was part an d o parcel of Khasra No. 47.
4. Issues were frame r d bty the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Solan. Civil J u udge (Senior Division) decreed the suit on 21.9.2004 o . Defendant preferred an appeal before the District C Judge, Solan against the judgment and decree dated 21. 9.2004. He dismissed the same on 7.6.2005. Henc h e, the present appeal. It was admitted on the g following substantial questions of law: i
1. Whether the courts below were justified in rejecting the H
application for appointment of Local Commissioner when in the facts and circumstances of the case, boundary dispute could only be determined by appointment of Local Commissioner and adjudication of the dispute in accordance with High Court Rules and Orders Vol.I Chapter-I which procedure has not been followed?
2. Whether the discretion exercised in rejecting the application for additional evidence and not adjudicating and determining the exact location of the plot has vitiated the findings more particularly when it was found that the
3
original Musabi and torn Momi copy thereof had not been produced and demarcation could be carried out with the Aks tatima in respect of Khasra numbers 57 and 47 which could have been located?
3. Whether production of additional evidence was necessary . for satisfactorily pronouncing the judgment and judicial discretion has not been exercised while rejecting th P e same? .
5. Mr. Rajnish K. Lal, on the b as H is of the substantial questions of law frame o d, h f as vehemently argued that the boundary t dis pute could only be determined by appointing L r ocal Commissioner. He has lastly contended that a u pplication under order 41 rule 27 has been rejected i o n an illegal manner. 6. Mr. Neeraj Gupta has supported the judgments and decrees passed by both the courts below.
h7. I
C have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the records carefully.
ig
8. Since all the substantial questions of law are H
interconnected and interlinked the same are taken up together for determination to avoid repetition of discussion of evidence. 9. PW-1 Yudhishter Raj Sharma has deposed that he has purchased the suit land on 13.3.1991 from Surmi
and Jeet Ram vide sale deed No.264. He has proved copy
4
of sale deed Ex.P-1, copy of Jamabandi for the year 1991-
92 Ex.P-2 and tatima mark 'A'. Defendant has no concern over the suit land. He had engaged labourers to remove .
the bushes. Defendant forced his labourers to leave th P e spot. He has proved copy of demarcation report mark . 'B'. He has denied in his cross-examination that K ha H sra No.57 is part of Khasra No. 47. f
10. PW-2 Ashok Kumar has proved Latha and has also prepared Aksh from Latha t q uao Khasra No.153/57, 152/57, 56, 47, 38 and 48. r
11. PW-3 Y.R. Sh u arma has led his evidence by filing an affidavit. He h o as produced Aksh Sajra Ex.P-4, copy of Jamabandi for the year 1991-92 Ex.P-5 and copy of Jamabandi f C or the year 1996-97 Ex.P-6.
12. Defendant has led his evidence by filing an
g affidhavit. According to him, Naib Tehsildar Parma Nand i
had undertaken the demarcation.
H
13. DW-2 Nand Lal has also led his evidence by filing affidavit. According to him, on 15.5.1983 at the time of demarcation, Jeet Ram, Surmi and Krishan Das Bhatia were present on the spot. In his cross-examination, he has
admitted that he has not seen the revenue record at the
time of demarcation. He did not know which Khasra
5
number exists below Khasra No.153/57. He did not know which Khasra number is in existence over Khasra No.47.
14. PW-3 Prem Dutt has deposed that he could not .
produce the record since the same was destroyed. P
15. It is evident from the revenue record produ . ced by the parties that Khasra Nos. 57 and 47 are H separately owned and possessed by the parties. f T here is no contemporaneous evidence placed on record to suggest that any part of Khasra No. 153 t /5 7 oforms part of Khasra No.47. r
16. Mr. Rajnish K. Lal has vehemently argued that the courts below have unot taken into consideration the demarcation C reporot conducted by Parma Nand. Fact of the matter is that defendant has not produced Parma Nand, who h has conducted the demarcation. Even from report it is g not discernible that Khasra No.153/57 was part of Khasra i
No. 47.
H
17. Mr. Rajnish K. Lal has also contended that an application under order 41 rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure has been wrongly rejected. Defendant wanted to produce on record Aksh Sajra Kistwar and to summon the
record pertaining to demarcation proceedings. It was not a
case of boundary dispute, as argued by Mr. Rajnish K. Lal.
6
Moreover, there was no encroachment found as per demarcation report dated 15.5.1983. The purpose of application under order 41 rule 27 is not to fill up the .
lacunae in the case. The purpose of application unde P r order 26 rule 9 CPC is to ascertain the position on . the spot. H
18. The courts below have correctly f ap preciated the oral as well as documentary evidenc e l o ed by the parties and there is no need to interfere with the well reasoned judgments and decrees passe r d byt both the courts below.
19. The substantial questions of law are answered accordingly. ou20. In view of the analysis and discussion made hereinabo ve C , there is no merit in the present appeal and the s h ame is dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, also g stands disposed of. There shall, however, be no order as to i
costs.
H
(Justice Rajiv Sharma), Judge. 18.11.2015 *awasthi*