Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 19 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 139 of the DCS Act. 12. On comparison of Section 2(f) of the RTI Act and Section 139 of the DCS Act,
  • Section 2(f)
  • Delhi Cooperative Societies Act
  • provisions of Section 139 of the DCS, Act. Section 22
  • Section 2(f) of the RTI Act.
  • Section 8 of the RTI Act. Section 2(f) of the RTI Act
  • Section 139 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act,
  • Public Authorities. Section 139
  • Section 19 of the RTI Act, 2005
  • 7 Section 139 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 19 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Section 139 of the DCS Act. 12. On comparison of Section 2(f) of the RTI Act and Section 139 of the DCS Act,
  • Section 2(f)
  • Delhi Cooperative Societies Act
  • provisions of Section 139 of the DCS, Act. Section 22
  • Section 2(f) of the RTI Act.
  • Section 8 of the RTI Act. Section 2(f) of the RTI Act
  • Section 139 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act,
  • Public Authorities. Section 139
  • Section 19 of the RTI Act, 2005
  • 7 Section 139 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act,
Smart Summary

Case Summary — W.P.(C) 6532/2013

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Ms. Eliamma Sebastian, a member of Sangha Mitra CGHS since 1995, filed a series of RTI applications from about 2006 seeking audit reports, accounts and other documents relating to the Society. She alleged fraud, embezzlement and tampering with accounts by the Society and complained that neither the Society nor the Registrar of Cooperative Societies (RCS) took action. The Society countered that the petitioner had long-standing defaults in payment and was using RTI requests to harass it.

Procedurally, the petitioner first sought information from the Society's SPIO; after unsatisfactory responses she appealed to the First Appellate Authority, which directed the SPIO on 20.12.2007 to obtain and supply information. Thereafter the petitioner appealed under Section 19 of the RTI Act to the Central Information Commission (CIC) on 15.02.2008. The CIC held the appeal not maintainable on the ground that cooperative societies are not public authorities under the RTI Act and information must be accessed through the Registrar under Section 139 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act (DCS Act). The present writ petition challenges that CIC decision and asks whether the petitioner could directly seek information from the Society and whether the CIC was correct in dismissing her appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner could directly seek information from the cooperative society (Sangha Mitra CGHS) under the RTI Act or whether such information must be accessed through the Registrar of Cooperative Societies under Section 139 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act.
  2. Whether the Central Information Commission was correct in holding the petitioner's appeal not maintainable on the ground that cooperative societies are not public authorities to which the RTI Act directly applies.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner alleged misappropriation, tampering of account books and sought audit reports and documents pertaining to the Society's affairs by filing multiple RTI applications since 2006.
  • She contended that the Society and the RCS staff were colluding, causing harassment to members and obstructing access to information.
  • She pursued remedies under the RTI regime (filed appeal before the CIC under Section 19) after the SPIO and Society did not adequately furnish the requested information.

Respondents' / Society's Arguments

  • The Society alleged the petitioner had continuously defaulted in payments and that her numerous RTI applications were a guise to harass the Society and avoid recovery of outstanding dues.
  • The respondents argued that Section 139 of the DCS Act gives members a right to information from the cooperative society and remedies through the Registrar, and therefore information could not be accessed directly under Section 2(f) of the RTI Act from the Society.
  • They submitted that the DCS Act, being a special statute, prevails over the RTI Act (a general law) insofar as cooperative societies are concerned, and that the Registrar of Cooperative Societies is the public authority from whom information should be sought.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rejender Goel & Ors. v. Registrar of Cooperative Societies (CIC appeals; decision dated 30.06.2008) Used by the CIC to support the proposition that cooperative societies are not public authorities to whom the RTI Act directly applies; information held by societies is to be accessed indirectly through the Registrar. The CIC relied on this decision in holding the petitioner's appeal not maintainable; the High Court records this as the basis for the CIC's conclusion that appeals are covered by that ratio and therefore cannot be pursued before the Commission.
Thalappalam Service Cooperative Bank Ltd. & Ors. v. State of Kerala & Ors., (2013) 16 SCC 82 Explained when a cooperative society qualifies as a public authority; held that a cooperative society is a public authority only if it satisfies certain conditions; held the Registrar (RCS) to be a public authority and discussed the scope of information Registrar can provide. The Court relied on the Supreme Court's discussion to conclude that the Registrar can provide information under Section 2(f) and can also gather information from a society to the extent permitted by law; it reinforced the view that RCS is a public authority and that not all society-held information may be accessible unless within Registrar's statutory powers.
People's Union for Civil Liberties v. Union of India, (2004) 2 SCC 476 Recognised that the right to information is a facet of freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a), subject to reasonable restrictions. The Court used this principle to explain the purpose and intent behind the RTI Act and to frame how RTI's overriding effect should be interpreted, particularly in relation to other laws.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Raj Narain, (1975) 4 SCC 428 Observation that the right to know, derived from freedom of speech, is not absolute but should make one wary when secrecy is claimed for transactions that do not affect public security. The Court cited this observation to support the proposition that the right to information is not absolute and that secrecy claims must be scrutinized in light of public interest and security considerations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by comparing Section 2(f) of the RTI Act (definition of "information") with Section 139 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act (DCS Act) (right to information for members/creditors of a cooperative society). The analysis unfolded along the following steps, based strictly on the material in the opinion:

  1. Characterisation of the Society and the Registrar: the Society was identified as a private body which, as such, is not per se a "public authority" under the RTI Act. By contrast, the Registrar of Cooperative Societies (RCS) is a public authority for the purposes of the RTI Act and Section 2(f).
  2. Scope of Registrar's obligations: as a public authority, the RCS is bound to comply with the RTI Act and provide information within the ambit of Section 2(f), subject to exemptions in Section 8 of the RTI Act. The Court drew on Thalappalam to explain that the Registrar can gather information from a society to the extent the Cooperative Societies Act permits and that the Registrar is not obliged to disclose information falling under Section 8 exemptions.
  3. Meaning and operation of Section 139 DCS Act: Section 139 expressly permits a member or interested creditor to seek information and certified copies of documents from a cooperative society, and provides for an appeal to the Registrar with potential penalties for default. The Court observed there is no bar in Section 139 on seeking information directly from the society.
  4. Relationship between the RTI Act and the DCS Act: the Court examined Section 22 of the RTI Act (which gives the Act overriding effect over inconsistent laws) but concluded that Section 22 does not mean that another law which independently enables access to information about a private body (as envisaged by Section 139) is overridden in every respect. The RTI Act applies to public authorities; the existence of Section 139 does not exclude its operation where the Registrar holds information.
  5. Practical allocation of responsibility: the Court reasoned that information in the possession of the cooperative society is accessible to members under Section 139. Information that is not in the society's custody but is held by the Registrar must be provided by the Registrar under the RTI Act. The exemptions in the RTI Act (Section 8) continue to apply where relevant.

On that basis, the Court reconciled the respective statutes: members may seek information directly from the society under Section 139, and where information lies with the Registrar (a public authority), the petitioner is entitled to obtain it under the RTI Act, subject to applicable exemptions. The Court therefore did not accept the CIC's blanket conclusion that RTI could not be invoked in relation to cooperative societies; instead it clarified the appropriate routes depending on where the information is held.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is PARTLY ALLOWED.

Direct effect on the parties:

  • The Registrar of Cooperative Societies (RCS) is directed to consider the petitioner's RTI applications to the extent information is available in the RCS office.
  • For information not available with the RCS, the RCS must explicitly indicate in an order what material does not exist.
  • Once the RCS indicates that certain material is not in its custody, the petitioner remains at liberty to seek that information directly from the cooperative society under Section 139 of the DCS Act.

Broader implications (as articulated in the opinion):

  • The judgment reconciles the RTI Act and the DCS Act: the RTI Act applies to public authorities (including the RCS), while Section 139 of the DCS Act provides a distinct mechanism for members to obtain information from cooperative societies. Both statutes operate together, with RTI's exemptions applicable where relevant.
  • The Court did not accept a categorical bar on invoking RTI in matters concerning cooperative societies; rather it prescribed the correct procedural avenue depending on where the records are held.

The opinion did not purport to lay down a new, broader principle beyond the statutory reconciliation described above; its directions are limited to providing practical relief to the petitioner and clarifying the respective roles of the Society and the Registrar in furnishing information.

    Ms. Eliamma Sebastian Petitioner v. Ministry Of Home Affairs And Ors. S

    * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI Reserved on : 02.03.2016

    Pronounced on: 17.03.2016

    + W.P.(C) 6532/2013, C.M. NOS. 14204-14205/2013, 16799/2014 & 20303/2014

    MS. ELIAMMA SEBASTIAN ………Petitioner Through: Sh. Ramesh Singh, amicus curiae with the petitioner in person.

    Versus

    MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS AND ORS. ……..Respondents Through: Sh. Roshan Lal Goel, Advocate, for UOI/Respondent No.1.

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE DEEPA SHARMA

    MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT

    %

    1. The petitioner who appeared and represented herself in this writ petition is aggrieved by the order of the Chief Information Commissioner ("CIC") dated 16.07.2008 whereby the petitioner's appeal was held to be not maintainable. The CIC reasoned that Cooperative Societies are not public authorities to whom the RTI Act applies.

    2. The petitioner has been a member of the Sangha Mitra CGHS ("Society") since 1995. However, during the course of her membership, a number of disputes have arisen leading to several rounds of litigation. Amongst various allegations, she accused the Society of committing fraud, embezzlement and accounts-tampering; in this regard she had filed several RTI applications seeking audit reports and various other documents pertaining to the working of the Society as well as its accounts. She claims to

    1

    have been seeking these documents by filing RTI applications since 2006, for almost 10 years. She alleges that despite several representations in this regard to the Society and the Registrar of Cooperative Societies ("RCS") no action was taken and it is her case that the Society was committing further fraud.

    3. The Society, on the other hand, has alleged that the petitioner has been continuously defaulting with payment since the inception of her membership and has made numerous RTI applications as a guise to harass it. The Society claims that the petitioner has been filing RTI applications in order to create pressure on the Society so that they do not demand outstanding dues from her or take legal action against her.

    4. The first issue that arose between the petitioner and the Society was on account of cost which was to be recovered from the petitioner for the flat. The petitioner disputed the cost and the matter went to arbitration. During arbitration proceedings the petitioner was dispossessed of her flat. She approached this Court through Writ Petition (C) No. 7276/2002 in which directions were issued on 20.12.2002 for expediting her claim in arbitration. It was also observed that in case the arbitrator found that the petitioner was liable to pay the disputed amount of `1.84 lakh, the petitioner would pay it in reasonable instalments. The arbitration proceedings resulted in an award where the petitioner was held liable to pay the disputed amount of `1.84 lakh. On appeal, the Delhi Cooperative Tribunal (DCT), on 17.02.2005 upheld the arbitrator's award. She thereafter filed W.P.(C) 7887/2005 challenging the order of the DCT. On 22.07.2005, the petitioner agreed to pay the said amount of `1,84,760 on or before 22.07.2006. Owing to her

    2

    limited financial means, the Court took a lenient view and allowed the same while giving specific instructions that it was not to be taken as precedent. Despite the extension of time granted to her, the petitioner failed to pay the amount due. Due to failure of payment of money the Society was granted liberty to take action against her. She, thereafter moved two applications, one of which were dismissed on 23.11.2006 and another application for review and stay of payment of money due by her to the Society, was dismissed on 09.01.2007. During the hearing of the applications, the petitioner submitted that she would not press for extension of time and instead claimed damages from the Society for loss caused to her by the Society in different forms. She had also submitted that the Society had misappropriated amounts, which should also be investigated into and recovered. The Court, however, refused to investigate, inquire, and order payment of damages in those proceedings. This Court, on 09.01.2007, while dismissing the applications held as follows:

    "… Having heard the petitioner, who appears in person, we are of the considered opinion that the applications, which are filed by the petitioner before us are misconceived. We cannot investigate, inquire, and order for payment of damages in a proceeding of this nature. If she has suffered any damages, it is for her to take appropriate action in accordance with law. So far as the allegation of misappropriation is concerned this forum cannot entertain such a prayer as the same cannot be a prayer on a review application. She has to take action in accordance with law. "

    5. Subsequently an issue arose when the Society alleged that the petitioner had not been paying electricity, maintenance, water and ground rent charges since she got possession and an amount of `4,98,883 was outstanding against her as on 31.01.2008. A next round of litigation ensued

    3

    when the petitioner filed W.P.(C) 9007/2008 before this Court. The petition was filed for seeking to rake up the issue of electricity bills and ground rent charges. On 22.04.2010, the Petitioner, however, agreed to pay the amount outstanding towards electricity charges, water bills and ground rent. An order to that effect was passed by this Court, which also directed that once the bills had been settled, electricity and water to the petitioner's flat be restored. The petitioner paid this amount, but as far as the issue of cost of ` 1,84,760 was concerned, she had filed proceedings before the Supreme Court. In the meanwhile the petitioner also filed several applications before the management of the Society and thereafter before the Registrar of Cooperative Society demanding their audit report and other documents. She claimed that account books tampered with and excess amounts of funds were missing and misappropriated.

    6. The petitioner approached this Court again through W.P.(C) 4086/2011 claiming that the Society had failed to render proper accounts to her in so far as the issue of cost of construction was concerned. She also stated that there should not be any further recovery from her on various accounts whether it be electricity, water, ground rent or maintenance charges. The Court by its order-dated 03.06.2011 held that the issue regarding cost of construction could not be agitated repeatedly before this Court by filing different petitions. The Court, on the issue of other charges (water, electricity, maintenance and ground rent charges), held that they are in the nature of continuing charges. Thus, the Court passed the following order:

    4

    "As far as the other charges are concerned, they are in the nature of continuing charges. To the extent the petitioner has paid the amount, the Society is liable to adjust the same but this does not absolve the petitioner of making future payments. These are, by the very nature, charges which will have to be borne by the petitioner.

    We are conscious that the petitioner is in financial difficulty on account of the fact that she is without any job and does not have anyone to support her other than her brother and sister as claimed by her. However, if she has to continue to enjoy the flat she will have to bear the continuing charges as payable by other members of the Society. In case any interest has been imposed on her by the Society, the Society may consider the waiver of interest on account of the financial difficulties of the petitioner."

    7. The issue in the present writ petition stems from RTI applications that were filed by the petitioner before the SPIO. The petitioner had sought information from the SPIO regarding documents and accounts pertaining to the Society as well as minutes of the general body meeting of the Society. She had also sought information regarding charges payable to the DDA. Despite communication by the SPIO to the Society the latter gave no replies.

    8. The petitioner, aggrieved by the inaction of the Society, approached the First Appellate Authority who, on 20.12.2007 directed the SPIO to procure information sought by the petitioner from the Society by 04.01.2008 and further supply it to the petitioner by 08.01.2008. It was also directed that in case of failure on the part of the Society to furnish information sought from it, suitable action would be initiated against it in terms of provisions of Section 139 of the DCS Act. Subsequently, the Society on 01.04.2008, granted liberty to the petitioner to approach its office and inspect the records; in this regard a date and time was granted to her. As for the information

    5

    sought by her regarding charges payable to the DDA, the SPIO sent a letter, dated 09.01.2008 to the Society, which it subsequently replied to. In their reply the Society stated that the information sought by the petitioner was voluminous and that the petitioner was required to be specific as to the information sought by her. It also stated that once the petitioner deposited the amount towards photocopying the documents they would be able to provide her with the information. However, in the intervening period of 20.12.2007 and 01.04.2008, the petitioner filed an appeal under Section 19 of the RTI Act, 2005, before the CIC on 15.02.2008. The appeal before the CIC pertained to the order of the First Appellate Authority dated 20.12.2007 and the letter of reference from the SPIO dated 09.01.2008. In her appeal, the petitioner had contended that the staff of the RCS was colluding with Cooperative Societies (such as the present one; Sangha Mitra CGHS) and were inflicting a great deal of harassment on innocent members of such societies. The respondents, on the other hand, argued that the appellant had filed large number of RTI applications with no particular purpose. The respondents pointed out that under Section 139 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, the appellant as a member of the Cooperative Society, viz Sangha Mitra CGHS had all the right to receive information requested by her from the cooperative society including inspection of records and, in case she did not get any response from the Society she was entitled to appeal before the officers of the Registrar of Cooperative Societies.

    9. It was the respondent's submission that in view of Section 139 of the DCS Act, the appellant could not access information under Section 2(f) of the RTI Act. They further argued that the DCS Act, being a special Act

    6

    prevailed over the provisions of the RTI Act which is a general act; especially when the special act itself provided to a bona fide member of a cooperative society identical relief as provided under the RTI Act.

    10. The CIC observed that the Cooperative Society had given patient and direct replies to the appellant/ petitioner through the respondent. The Society had also given the petitioner the liberty to inspect its records as per a date and time mutually convenient to both the appellant and the Society. After analysing the facts and averments made before it through the course of the hearing, the CIC was of the opinion that the appeal was not maintainable due to the provisions of DCS Act and that Cooperative Societies are not public authorities to whom the RTI directly applies. It was observed by the CIC that information held by societies was to be retrieved indirectly from the Registrar who was public authority and who under the provisions of the DCS Act was competent to supply information. In its order the CIC held as follows

    "6. In view of the above and in view of the fact that the appeals herein are covered by the ration of the Commission's decision in Rejender Goel & Ors. vs. Registrar of Cooperative Societies; Appeal Nos. CIC/AT/A/2007/01525, 1526, CIC/AT/A/2008/00040, 41, 42, 99, 100 & 101; Date of Decision:

    30.06.2008, it is no more possible to pursue these appeals in the Commission. These appeals are clearly not maintainable because the Cooperative Societies are not public authorities to whom the RTI Act directly applies. The information held by such Societies is to be indirectly accessed under Section 2(f) of the RTI Act through a public authority, i.e. the Registrar of Cooperative Societies, who under the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act is competent to access information held by the Cooperative Societies. The ratio of the above-mentioned decision is that in the face of the presence of a self-contained disclosure-of-information

    7

    Section 139 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, a petitioner will have to access information held by the Cooperative Societies under the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act and not the RTI Act."

    11. The question that arises before this Court in this case is whether the petitioner could directly seek information from the Society and whether the Commission was correct in dismissing her appeal. The petitioner approached the CIC under Section 19 of the RTI Act, 2005 against the order of the First Appellate Authority and the SPIO - both of whom are officials of the Registrar of Cooperative Societies. However, the CIC refused to grant relief on the ground that in the case of Cooperative Societies, RTI Act applied indirectly, and all the information pertaining to the Society, which is held by the RCS would be available to her. In other words, the correct way to access information would be to approach the RCS under Section 139 of the DCS Act.

    12. On comparison of Section 2(f) of the RTI Act and Section 139 of the DCS Act, it is clear that the object of both is to provide information to an applicant. Some information can also be sought from a public authority under the RTI Act. The Society in question is a private body and not a public authority as defined under the RTI Act and is not obliged to furnish information. In this case it is the RCS who is a public authority as per Section 2(h) of the RTI Act as well as for the purpose of Section 2(f) would be the public authority from whom information could be accessed with respect to Cooperative Societies.

    13. As a public authority the RCS has been conferred with considerable statutory powers under the respective Acts under which he is functioning. Having said so, he is also duty bound to comply with the provisions of the

    8

    RTI Act and is required to provide information as provided for under Section 2(f) of the Act subject to the limitations enumerated under Section 8 of the RTI Act. Section 2(f) of the RTI Act reads as follows:

    (f) "information" means any material in any form, including records, documents, memos, e-mails, opinions, advices, press releases, circulars, orders, logbooks, contracts, reports, papers, samples, models, data material held in any electronic form and information relating to any private body which can be accessed by a public authority under any other law for the time being in force;

    14. Reliance is placed by the learned counsel for the respondent on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Thalappalam Service Cooperative Bank Ltd. & Ors. v. State of Kerala and Ors (2013) 16 SCC 82. In that case, an RTI application sought information from the appellant Cooperative Society. The Society refused to grant information on the ground that it was not involved in public activity and the information being sought was confidential in nature. The State Information Commission on being approached held that information had to be given. The High Court imposed a penalty. Both the Single Judge as well as the Division Bench held the Society to be a public authority under the administrative control of the Registrar. The Supreme Court through a detailed judgement discussed what classes of institutions and offices are public authority as well as the nature of information that could be divulged by such authority. It was held that a cooperative society was a public authority only if it satisfied the conditions enumerated in the Court's decision. However, the Court held the RCS to be a public authority. The Court then went on to discuss what information could be accessed from the Registrar. It was held as follows:

    9

    "52. … Information which he is expected to provide is the information enumerated in Section 2(f) of the RTI Act subject to the limitations provided under Section 8 of the Act. Registrar can also, to the extent law permits, gather information from a Society, on which he has supervisory or administrative control under the Cooperative Societies Act. Consequently, apart from the information as is available to him, under Section 2(f), he can also gather those information from the Society, to the extent permitted by law. Registrar is also not obliged to disclose those information if those information fall under Section 8(1)(j) of the Act. No provision has been brought to our knowledge indicating that, under the Cooperative Societies Act, a Registrar can call for the details of the bank accounts maintained by the citizens or members in a cooperative bank. Only those information which a Registrar of Cooperative Societies can have access under the Cooperative Societies Act from a Society could be said to be the information which is "held" or "under the control of public authority". Even those information, Registrar, as already indicated, is not legally obliged to provide if those information falls under the exempted category mentioned in Section 8(j) of the Act."

    15. Thus, it is apparent that the information which is sought with respect to the affairs of the Society is that which is contemplated under the DCS Act under Section 139, which is as follows:

    "Right to information.

    139. Any member or creditor having interest in the affairs of the co-operative society may seek information relating to any transaction of the co-operative society and for that purpose may be provided a certified copy of any document within thirty days from the date of receipt of application relating to such transaction on payment of such fee as may be specified.

    (2) Where a member or creditor having interest in affairs of a society seeking information prefers an appeal to the Registrar stating that the officer of the society without any reasonable

    10

    cause, has refused to receive his application for providing information or has not furnished information within the time specified under sub-section (1) or has refused the request for information or knowingly given incorrect information or obstructed in any manner in furnishing the information, the Registrar, after affording a reasonable opportunity of being heard to the officer of the society and the appellant, may either reject the appeal; or direct the officer of the society to furnish information within the period specified in the order or such extended period as may be allowed, and in case of default the Registrar may impose a penalty of two hundred and fifty rupees each day till the information is furnished, so however, the total amount of such penalty shall not exceed ten thousand rupees which shall be recoverable as arrears of land revenue in case of default in payment."

    On a reading of Section 139 it may be noticed there is no bar on seeking information directly from the Society. It states that any member who requires information relating to any transaction of the Society can move an application to the Society directly. This is also reaffirmed in Clause 2 of Section 139, which provides for appeal before the RCS as well as penalty in case of default.

    16. The next question that arises for consideration is the scope of Section 22 of the RTI Act and its applicability to the provisions of Section 139 of the DCS, Act. Section 22 states as follows:

    "22. Act to have overriding effect.—The provisions of this Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in the Official Secrets Act, 1923 (19 of 1923), and any other law for the time being in force or in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law other than this Act." Section 22 declares all laws, bye-laws, rules etc. which are inconsistent with the provisions of the RTI Act shall be overridden by its provisions. To gather

    11

    what is inconsistent with the provisions of the Act, it is essential to see what is the purpose and intent behind passing of this Act. In People's Union for Civil Liberties v. Union of India (2004) 2 SCC 476, the Supreme Court held that right of information is a facet of the freedom of "speech and expression" as contained in Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India and such a right is subject to any reasonable restriction in the interest of the security of the state and subject to exemptions and exceptions. In State of Uttar Pradesh v. Raj Narain - (1975) 4 SCC 428, the Supreme Court observed that "the right to know, which is derived from the concept of freedom of speech, though not absolute, is a factor which should make one wary, when secrecy is claimed for transactions which can, at any rate, have no repercussion on public security."

    17. The RTI Act is aimed at bringing within its ambit the practical regime of right to information for citizens to secure access to information under the control of public authorities, in order to promote transparency and accountability in the working of every public authority, the constitution of a Central Information Commission and State Information Commissions and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. This, however, in the Court's opinion does not necessarily mean that any other legislature, which aims to ensure access to information with respect to a private body (as per the RTI Act), is overridden by Section 22. The answer will have to be in the negative. The RTI is with respect to Public Authorities. Section 139 makes a separate distinct provision with respect to transactions of a cooperative society. The applicability of the RTI Act does not exclude the operation of the DCS Act, insofar as it enables access to information that is possessed by

    12

    a cooperative Society. The latter can clearly be sourced by the person concerned from the Society, in view of Section 139.

    18. In view of the above discussion this Court is of opinion that the information which is in the possession of the Cooperative Society is accessible to its members and those interested, in Section 139 of the DCS Act. The absolute nature of this obligation to furnish information to those entitled to apply and receive is reinforced by the consequences which are spelt out in Section 139 (2). However, information which the Society may not possess, but pertaining to it, in the form of records with the Registrar of Cooperative Societies, have to be provided by the latter, under the RTI Act, as there is no doubt that such official - who discharges statutory functions- is a "public authority". However, the grounds of exemption spelt out under the RTI Act too would be attracted, wherever applicable.

    19. In the light of the above findings, the applications of the Petitioner shall be considered by the RCS, to the extent the information is available with his office. In regard to the information not available, the RCS shall indicate clearly what material does not exist, in an order. It is then open to the Petitioner to seek such information under Section 139 of the DCS Act. The writ petition is partly allowed in the above terms.

    S. RAVINDRA BHAT

    (JUDGE)

    DEEPA SHARMA

    (JUDGE)

    MARCH 17, 2016

    13

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ms. Eliamma Sebastian Petitioner v. Ministry Of Home Affairs And Ors. S
    (Mar 17, 2016)