Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Case Summary: W.P.(C) 198/2016 & CM No.813/2016 (for stay) — Sunita Arora v. Delhi University & Ors.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition challenged (a) the Minutes of the General Body Meeting (GBM) dated 28th November, 2015 of respondent no.2 (DUWA) recording the decision to hold elections to the Executive Committee of DUWA, and (b) the Notification dated 2nd January, 2016 issued by the Returning Officer appointed in that GBM which announced the election result. The petitioner sought a mandamus directing DUWA to hold a de novo election and also sought to restrain respondent no.1 (University of Delhi) from interfering with DUWA's elections, alleging that the University had unlawfully interfered in DUWA affairs.

The petition first came up before the Court on 8th January, 2016 and again on 11th January, 2016; notice had not been issued. On 15th January, 2016, after hearing counsel, the Court dismissed the petition but granted the petitioner liberty to pursue remedy by way of a civil suit in respect of the affairs of DUWA, and awarded no costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable against respondent no.2 DUWA (and/or respondent no.1 University) in view of precedents holding that bodies like DUTA are not State/instrumentalities under Article 12 and are private bodies against which writ does not ordinarily lie.
  2. Whether the petitioner has the necessary cause of action / locus standi to challenge the election when she was not a candidate in the said election.
  3. Whether the actions alleged (appointment of Returning Officer by the Vice Chancellor; alleged interference by the University; alleged improper agenda/notice and minutes) amount to unlawful interference justifying relief in writ jurisdiction.
  4. Whether, if an election is to be challenged, the appropriate remedy is an election petition or a civil suit rather than a writ petition (in absence of statutory provision for an election petition).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The University interfered with DUWA's election process by causing the Vice Chancellor to appoint the Returning Officer, which the VC was not authorized to do, vitiating the election process.
  • The election was held wrongly and arbitrarily (including allegation that the acting VC's wife took over as President and issued an additional agenda with insufficient notice), and therefore the writ petition is maintainable.
  • The petitioner, as a member of the outgoing Executive Committee, asserted an entitlement to refuse to hand over charge to an allegedly illegally constituted Executive Committee.
  • When pressed on remedy, counsel for the petitioner indicated she would accept a direction restraining respondent no.1 University from interfering in future with DUWA's affairs.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Relying on the Division Bench decision in S.D. Siddiqui v. University of Delhi (2006), it was contended that DUWA is identically placed as DUTA and therefore is not a State or instrumentality under Article 12; DUTA was held to be a private body and no writ lies against it.
  • The writ petition is not maintainable; if an election is to be challenged, an election petition must be filed where the statute or rules so provide, otherwise a civil suit is the proper remedy (paragraph 30 of S.D. Siddiqui).
  • The petitioner could not have been a candidate because she had been a member of the Executive Committee for two consecutive terms (contention made by respondent's senior counsel).
  • There is no distinction in powers between the Vice Chancellor and the acting Vice Chancellor under the University Ordinance and Statutes (countering petitioner’s contention about acting VC versus VC).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S.D. Siddiqui v. University of Delhi, 2006 (3) AD (Delhi) 290 Held that DUTA is not a State or instrumentality under Article 12, does not perform a public function and is a private body; therefore writ does not lie against DUTA. Paragraph 30: election challenges must proceed by election petition (if provided) or civil suit. The Court recorded and applied the principle to the present matter, observing that respondent no.2 DUWA is identically placed as DUTA and that writ remedy may not be available; paragraph 30 informed the Court's view about the proper forum to challenge elections.
Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University v. Smit Rajput, MANU/DE/1356/2015 Where cause of action disappears during pendency of appeal, the writ petition should proceed no further; constitutional court should not decide issues in vacuum. The Court relied on this decision to stress the need for a continuing cause of action and to support dismissal where petitioner lacks a cause of action to maintain the writ.
Shipping Corporation of India Ltd. v. Machado Brothers, (2004) 11 SCC 168 Principle about cause of action and conduct of proceedings relied upon by the Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University decision. Referred to as authority supporting the proposition that a matter should not be decided in vacuum when cause of action disappears; used indirectly to support dismissal.
Arnit Das v. State of Bihar, (2001) 7 SCC 657 Authorities concerning the ambit of judicial review and the need for a live cause of action (cited in context). Referred to as supporting the proposition that the Court should not decide issues in vacuum; cited in the same context as other authorities.
Ram Das Athawale v. Union of India, MANU/SC/0212/2010 Authority cited in support of the principle that constitutional courts should not proceed in vacuum. Referred to as additional supporting authority for the Court's approach to cause of action and closure of petitions lacking a live controversy.
Bhushan Ramlal Kahsyap v. S.D.O., MANU/MP/0496/1996 Held that to have locus to invoke certiorari, a person must be an aggrieved person; relied on Jasbhai Desai and Calcutta Gas authorities. The Court applied the reasoning to hold that a person not being a candidate in an election is not an aggrieved person entitled to challenge the election in writ jurisdiction.
Jasbhai Motibhai Desai v. Roshan Kumar Haji Bashir Ahmad, AIR 1976 SC 578 Authority relied upon for locus standi principle in certiorari context (as cited by Bhushan Ramlal Kahsyap). Used through the Madhya Pradesh decision to support the requirement that only an aggrieved person who has suffered a legal grievance ordinarily can invoke Article 226.
Calcutta Gas Co. v. State of West Bengal, AIR 1962 SC 1044 Held that rights enforceable under Article 226 are ordinarily personal or individual rights of the petitioner. Applied to support the conclusion that the petitioner must show personal/individual legal grievance to have locus to challenge the election by writ.
Thammanna v. K. Veera Reddy, (1980) 4 SCC 62 In election petition context, a respondent who neither joins issue nor makes common cause with the petitioner is not a person aggrieved to prefer an appeal. Referred to by the Court as analogous authority illustrating that persons who have not contested or participated have no right to challenge election results in the relevant fora.
Dr. P.P. Rastogi v. Meerut University, MANU/UP/0648/1997 Division Bench held permitting individual members to seek review of orders in a petition filed by a Committee would cause confusion and problems. Applied to support the proposition that individual members of an outgoing committee do not have a right to agitate election results and that allowing such challenges could cause multiplicity of proceedings.
Committee of Management, Sri Kachcha Baba Inter College v. Regional Committee Pancham Mandal, MANU/UP/2165/2007 Single Judge following the above holding that members of a society have no right to agitate election results. Used to reinforce the Court's view that individual members cannot challenge election results in the manner proposed by the petitioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through a structured analysis focused on maintainability and locus standi:

  1. The Court first recorded the respondents' reliance on S.D. Siddiqui (DUTA) to contend that bodies like DUWA are private associations and not amenable to writ relief under Article 12; the senior counsel for respondent no.1 asserted that DUWA is identically placed and therefore the writ petition is not maintainable.
  2. The petitioner’s counsel argued that the earlier decision addressed only DUTA's status and that, irrespective of status, the University had unlawfully interfered with DUWA's election process (appointment of Returning Officer by the VC, insufficient notice, irregular minutes), thereby making the writ maintainable. The petitioner contended the VC was unauthorized to appoint the Returning Officer and that the election was vitiated.
  3. The Court enquired whether the petitioner had been a candidate in the election; counsel admitted she had not. The respondent claimed she could not have been a candidate due to an alleged two-term incumbency; the petitioner disputed that, saying she had served only one term and had been eligible but chose not to contest.
  4. Turning to principle, the Court emphasized that a writ petition must be founded on a cause of action (rejecting the petitioner’s assertion that a writ can be filed without a cause of action). The Court relied on authorities (including Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University and supporting Supreme Court decisions) to hold that courts should not decide matters in vacuum where no live cause of action exists.
  5. On locus standi, the Court held that ordinarily only a person who is an aggrieved person — a candidate denied participation or a candidate whose result is challenged — would have a cause of action to contest the election by way of writ. The Court noted that the position could be different only if the governing statute or rules expressly vested such a right in others.
  6. The Court applied supporting precedents (Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh decisions and Supreme Court authorities) to conclude that non-candidates and ordinary members of a committee do not have the requisite personal legal grievance to maintain such challenges in writ jurisdiction, as permitting each outgoing member to challenge would result in multiplicity and indefinite delay.
  7. The Court addressed specific factual contentions: the Memorandum of Association of DUWA provided for the Vice Chancellor to be ex officio patron and the VC's wife to be ex officio President (with an exception only if the VC were a woman). The petitioner argued this applied to the VC only and not an acting VC; the University’s counsel stated there is no distinction between VC and acting VC in the Ordinance and Statutes. The petitioner also alleged that the minutes did not correctly record the GBM and that the acting VC’s wife issued an additional agenda with insufficient notice. The Court observed that entering into such internal matters of DUWA would intrude into the arena of DUWA's affairs, and the petitioner had not pressed the writ petition in that respect in view of the authorities.
  8. Given the absence of a live cause of action and the petitioner not being a candidate, the Court concluded the writ petition was not maintainable and therefore dismissed it. The Court nonetheless granted the petitioner liberty to pursue civil suit remedies relating to DUWA's affairs.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is DISMISSED. The Court granted the petitioner liberty to avail of a suit remedy with respect to the affairs of respondent no.2 DUWA. No costs were imposed.

Implications:

  • The immediate effect is that the writ petition challenging the GBM minutes, the Returning Officer’s notification and the election result stands dismissed; the petitioner may pursue relief, if any, by filing a civil suit (or other appropriate forum) rather than by a writ in the High Court, unless statute/rules provide a specific election petition mechanism.
  • The decision reaffirms the principles that (a) writ jurisdiction ordinarily protects personal or individual rights of aggrieved persons, (b) non-candidates and ordinary members of elected bodies generally lack locus to challenge elections by writ, and (c) courts should not decide matters in vacuum absent a live cause of action. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent; it applies and follows existing authorities cited within the opinion.

Judge: Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J. — Order dated January 15, 2016.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sunita Arora Petitioner v. Delhi University & Ors. S

    $~12 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

    + W.P.(C) 198/2016 & CM No.813/2016 (for stay) SUNITA ARORA ..... Petitioner

    Through: Ms. Roma Bhagat with Mr. Pankaj Sinha & Ms. Nupur Grover, Advs.

    Versus

    DELHI UNIVERSITY & ORS ..... Respondents

    Through: Mr. Sudhir Nandrajog, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Mohinder J.S. Rupal & Ms.

    Simran Jeet, Advs. for University of Delhi.

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW

    O R D E R

    % 15.01.2016

    1. The petition impugns (a) the Minutes of the General Body Meeting (GBM) dated 28thNovember, 2015 of the respondent no.2 (DUWA) containing the decision to hold the election to the Executive Committee of the respondent no.2 DUWA; as well as, (b) the Notification dated 2nd January, 2016 of the Returning Officer appointed in the aforesaid GBM for holding the elections, announcing the result of the election. Axiomatically, mandamus is also sought to the respondent no.2 to DUWA to hold de novo election.

    2. It is also inter alia the pleading of the petitioner that the respondent

    1

    no.1 Delhi University has interfered with the affairs of the respondent no.2 DUWA and axiomatically relief of restraining the respondent no. 1 University from interfering with the elections of DUWA is also claimed.

    3. Though the petition came up first before this Court on 8thJanuary, 2016 and thereafter on 11thJanuary, 2016 but was adjourned and notice has not been issued as yet. The order dated 11thJanuary, 2016 records the contention of the senior counsel for the respondent no.1 University appearing on advance notice that the writ petition is not maintainable in view of the law laid down by the Division Bench of this Court in S.D. Siddiqui Vs. University of Delhi 2006 (3) AD (Delhi) 290 that Delhi University Teachers Association (DUTA) is not a State or an instrumentality of the State under Article 12 of the Constitution of India and does not perform any public function and is a purely private body working for the welfare of teachers of the university and affiliated colleges and hence no writ lies against DUTA.

    4. The senior counsel for the respondent no.1 University today also contends that the respondent no.2 DUWA is identically placed as DUTA and thus what has been held qua DUTA would equally apply to the respondent no.2 DUWA.

    5. The counsel for the petitioner on the aspect of maintainability of the

    2

    writ petition contends that the judgment aforesaid is a judgment only on the aspect of DUTA being not a State. It is contended that in the present proceeding it is the case of the petitioner that the respondent no.1 University has unreasonably, arbitrarily and unauthorizedly interfered with the process of election of DUTA and thus a writ petition is maintainable. It is argued that the Returning Officer of the election was appointed by the Vice Chancellor (VC) of the respondent no.1 University and which the VC was not authorized to do and the same has vitiated the entire election process. It is even otherwise contended that since the elections have been held wrongly and in an arbitrary manner, the petition would be maintainable.

    6. I have enquired from the counsel for the petitioner whether the petitioner was a candidate in the said election.

    7. The answer is in the negative.

    8. The senior counsel for the respondent no.1 University states that the petitioner could not have been a candidate having been a member of the Executive Committee of the respondent no.2 DUWA for the past two consecutive terms.

    9. The counsel for the petitioner controverts that the petitioner was the member of the Executive Committee of the respondent no.2 DUWA for two

    3

    consecutive terms. It is stated that the petitioner was a member of the Executive Committee for one term only and though was eligible to contest the election to the Executive Committee this year also but chose not to.

    10. I have in the circumstances enquired from the counsel for the petitioner as to what is the cause of action of the petitioner to maintain this petition, even if the same was to be maintainable.

    11. The counsel for the petitioner states that this is not a suit, for the petitioner to have a cause of action.

    12. I am afraid that is not the position in law. It would be preposterous to say that a writ petition can be filed without a cause of action. In fact, the Division Bench of this Court in Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University Vs. Smit Rajput MANU/DE/1356/2015 while relying on the judgment of Supreme Court in Shipping Corporation of India Ltd. Vs. Machado Brothers (2004) 11 SCC 168 has held that where the cause of action with which a writ petition is filed disappears during the pendency of appeal, the same is to proceed no further. The Constitutional Court should not proceed to decide the issues in vacuum and should close the writ petition. Reference can be made to Arnit Das Vs. State of Bihar (2001) 7 SCC 657 and Ram Das Athawale Vs. Union of India MANU/SC/0212/2010.

    4

    13. In my view, the petitioner, without being a candidate in the election which was admittedly due, cannot challenge the same especially when it is not in dispute that the election was due. Only a candidate desirous of participating in the elections and wrongfully denied such participation or a candidate who has contested in the election and the result whereof is claimed to be vitiated, would in my opinion in such circumstances have cause of action to challenge the result of the election. The position may be different if the statute or the Rules and Regulations of the body / society vest such a right.

    14. The High Court of Madhya Pradesh, in Bhushan Ramlal Kahsyap Vs. S.D.O. MANU/MP/0496/1996, relying on Jasbhai Motibhai Desai Vs. Roshan Kumar Haji Bashir Ahmad AIR 1976 SC 578 held that in order to have locus standi to invoke certiorari jurisdiction, the person must be an aggrieved person and relying on Calcutta Gas Co. Vs. State of West Bengal AIR 1962 SC 1044 held that the right which can be enforced under Article 226 shall ordinarily be a personal or individual right of petitioner. Applying the said principles it was held that person aggrieved must be the person who has suffered a legal grievance, a man against whom decision has been pronounced which has wrongfully deprived him from something. Further

    5

    applying the said principles and finding that the petitioner therein was not a candidate in the election, it was held that the petitioner was not a person aggrieved to maintain a petition against the order of the Election Tribunal.

    15. Supreme Court in Thammanna Vs. K. Veera Reddy (1980) 4 SCC 62, though in the context of election petition under the Representation of Peoples Act, 1951 held that a respondent to an election petition, who neither joins issue with the contesting party nor do anything tangible to show that he had made a common cause with the election petitioner was not a person aggrieved to prefer an appeal against the decision of the High Court in the election petition. The contention that since an election petition is in the nature of a representative action on behalf of whole body of the electors, he had a right to appeal, was negatived.

    16. The counsel for the petitioner then states that the petitioner as the member of the outgoing Executive Committee is entitled to refuse to handover the charge to an illegally constituted Executive Committee.

    17. I am afraid the petitioner is not entitled to do so. The petitioner could have challenged the election only if had been an aspirant thereto and not otherwise. None can be permitted to perpetuate his / her term of elected office by contending that the result of the next election is vitiated - without

    6

    participating in that election. If the same were to be permitted, it would vest a right in each and every member of outgoing elected body to challenge the election and may lead to multiple challenges indefinitely delaying the taking over of reigns by the newly elected body. A Division Bench of the High Court of Allahabad in Dr. P.P. Rastogi Vs. Meerut University MANU/UP/0648/1997 also held that to permit individual members of Committee of Management to seek review of the order in a petition filed by the Committee of Management would create a lot of problems because any individual member or several members may file applications at any time resulting in confusion. Following the same, a learned Single Judge of the High Court of Allahabad in Committee of Management, Sri Kachcha Baba Inter College Vs. Regional Committee Pancham Mandal MANU/UP/2165/2007 held that members of society have no right to agitate the result of elections.

    18. At this stage, some further arguments have taken place and the senior counsel for the respondent no.1 University has also drawn attention to paragraph 30 of S.D. Siddiqui supra where it has been held that if one wishes to challenge an election, he has to file an election petition if that is provided under the relevant statute or Rules, and if there is no such provision in any

    7

    statute or Rule for election petition, then one has to file a civil suit for this purpose and not a writ petition.

    19. Faced therewith the counsel for the petitioner states that the petitioner would be satisfied with a direction to the respondent no.1 University not to interfere in future with the affairs of respondent no.2 DUWA.

    20. In this view of the matter, need is not felt to record certain other arguments earlier made by the counsel for the petitioner or to deal therewith.

    21. On being asked as to what is the interference of respondent no.1 University, the counsel for the petitioner states that on 25thNovember, 2015 the wife of the acting VC of the respondent no.1 University took over as the President of the respondent no.2 DUWA and in her capacity as President, issued an additional agenda item for the GBM, with respect to elections scheduled on 28thDecember, 2015 and which did not satisfy the requirement of the minimum notice to be given of the election.

    22. However, I find that the Memorandum of Association of the respondent no.2 DUWA provides for the VC to be the ex officio patron of the Association and the wife of the VC of the respondent no.1 University to be the ex officio President of the respondent no.2 DUWA and only in the event of the VC at the relevant time being a woman, provides for the President to

    8

    be elected from amongst the members of respondent no.2 DUWA.

    23. The counsel for the petitioner states that the provision is with respect to VC and not with respect to acting VC.

    On enquiry whether in the University Ordinance and Statutes there is any difference between powers of the VC and the acting VC while the counsel for the petitioner is unable to answer, the counsel for the respondent No.1 University states that there is no distinction.

    24. The counsel for the petitioner then contends that the Minutes of the GBM do not truly record what transpired at the GBM.

    25. However this again amounts to entering into the arena of affairs of respondent no.2 DUWA and qua which the counsel for the petitioner has not pressed the writ petition in view of the judgment supra.

    26. The petition is thus dismissed with liberty however to the petitioner to avail of the suit remedy with respect to the affairs of the respondent no.2

    DUWA.

    No costs.

    RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW, J.

    JANUARY 15, 2016

    'gsr/bs'

    9

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sunita Arora Petitioner v. Delhi University & Ors. S
    (Jan 15, 2016)