AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff sued to recover possession of an eight-anna share of taluks numbered 278 and 456. These taluks, together with taluk No. 96 and other estates, were joint property of two brothers, Raja Chunder Shikhuressur Roy and Raja Mohessur Roy, each entitled to one moiety. The plaintiff is a son of Raja Mohessur; the minor defendant is the sole surviving son of Raja Chunder Shikhuressur.

Raja Chunder Shikhuressur died on 29th Srabun 1272 (August 1865). Twenty-seven days before his death (2nd Srabun 1272) he executed a will which, by its 8th clause, purported to bequeath his one-half share in certain taluks to three nephews (the plaintiff and two uterine brothers) in equal shares subject to conditions including male-line succession and restrictions on alienation.

After the testator's death the plaintiff's father took possession as guardian of his three sons, but from Bysack 1273 B.S. Ranee Soudamini (on behalf of her minor son, the defendant) dispossessed him from the two taluks in dispute. Later the Court of Wards took charge of the minor's estate; initially the suit was brought against the manager appointed by the Court of Wards (Horo Gobind Bose), but by an order dated 28th May 1877 Ranee Soudamini was authorized to appear as guardian for the minor defendant and defended the suit thereafter.

Two of the three nephews named in the will, Kumar Jugodissur Roy and Kumar Sibessur Roy, died without male issue (Sibessur on 5th Kartick 1276 (October 1869); Jugodissur on 24th Maugh 1279 (February 1873)). The plaintiff claimed the entire eight annas share under the will. The lower Court overruled the defence and decreed for the plaintiff. On appeal the appellate court was asked to decide (1) whether the 8th clause of the will is genuine, and (2) if genuine, what the rights of the contending parties are under that clause concerning the disputed eight-anna share.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the 8th clause of the will produced in the suit (the will of Raja Chunder Shikhuressur) is genuine.
  2. If the clause is genuine, upon a correct construction of it, what are the rights of the contending parties under it in respect of the eight annas share of the two taluks which form the subject-matter of the suit?

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Allegations

  • The plaintiff alleged that by clause 8 of the will the testator bequeathed his eight-anna share of the taluks in claim (and a share of taluk No. 96) to the plaintiff and his two uterine brothers in equal shares.
  • The plaintiff contended that after the testator's death his father, as guardian, was allowed to take possession of the bequeathed eight annas, but that Ranee Soudamini dispossessed him on behalf of her minor son from Bysack 1273 B.S., and subsequently the share came into the possession of the Court of Wards.
  • Following the deaths of the two other nephews without male issue, the plaintiff claimed the whole eight annas share under the terms of the will.

Defendant's (Ranee Soudamini on behalf of the minor) Defence

  • The defence asserted that the 8th clause (and several other clauses) of the will are not genuine, alleging substitution by some of the deceased’s amlahs shortly before death for certain other clauses of the original will.
  • It was further argued that, even if clause 8 were genuine, the bequest is in many respects invalid; and that, at any rate, the plaintiff is entitled only to a life-interest in a one-third share of the eight annas purportedly bequeathed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jotendro Mchun Tagore v. Ganendro Mohun Tagore, 9 B. L. R., 377 (Tagore v. Tagore) Holds that a private individual cannot make property inheritable otherwise than the law directs; where a will attempts to exclude the legal course of inheritance and select heirs contrary to law, the attempted inheritance is void and the first taker takes at least for life. The court applied this principle to declare the clause in the will imposing male-line-only succession invalid; consequently the grantees (the three brothers) took for their lives rather than under the attempted invalid inheritable estate.
S. M. Soorjeemoney Dosse v. Denobundoo Mullick, 9 Moore's I. A., 123 Recognizes that a gift over to surviving brothers is not invalid under Hindu Law. The court relied on this authority to hold that the gift over provision (to surviving brothers) in the will was valid insofar as it gave the deceased brother's share to the surviving brothers, even though the further limitation to male descendants was void.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

On the question of the genuineness of the will, after considering the evidence the appellate court agreed with the lower Court's conclusion that the will produced was genuine.

The court then analysed the legal effect of clause 8. The bequest, on its face, gave the property to three nephews in equal shares and attempted to limit succession thereafter to male descendants only. The court held that such a condition (restricting succession to male descendants and excluding other heirs) was inconsistent with Hindu law and therefore invalid. The court relied principally on the observations in Jotendro Mchun Tagore v. Ganendro Mohun Tagore (Tagore v. Tagore) that a private person cannot create an inheritance inconsistent with legal rules of succession; where an attempted inheritable estate is void in part, the gift must be given effect so far as consistent with law — in particular, the first takers will have a life interest.

Applying that principle, the court concluded the three brothers each took a one-third share of the bequest for life. When one brother (Kumar Sibessur) died without male issue, the will's provision that his share should devolve on surviving brothers (and their male descendants) was considered. The specific limitation to male-line descendants was void, but the gift over to the surviving brothers was valid under Hindu law (supported by S. M. Soorjeemoney Dosse v. Denobundoo Mullick and the Judicial Committee's observations in Tagore). Accordingly Sibessur's life-share devolved on the surviving brothers.

Upon the subsequent death of Kumar Jugodissur without male issue, his share similarly devolved. The court noted some doubt whether Jugodissur's original share together with the share he had received on Sibessur's death both passed to the plaintiff; nevertheless, reading the legacy as a whole the court considered the testator intended the whole augmented share to pass to the sole surviving brother (the plaintiff). Thus the court found that the entire eight annas share of the two taluks had devolved upon the plaintiff, but only as a life-interest because the attempted hereditability in the will was void.

The appellate court therefore modified the lower Court's decree: it decreed possession of the disputed share to the plaintiff, but declared his right to be only a life-interest. The court did not disturb the lower Court's decree as to mesne profits. As to costs, the court ordered that, under the circumstances, each party should bear their own costs in this Court and in the lower Court.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appellate court held that the 8th clause of the will is genuine, and that under a correct construction it entitled the plaintiff to possession of the disputed eight annas share of the two taluks but only as a life-interest.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The plaintiff is decreed possession of the disputed eight-anna share, but his interest is limited to a life-interest; his interest will determine on his death and, thereafter, the share will revert to the legal heir of the testator.
  • The court left intact the lower Court's decision regarding mesne profits.
  • The court ordered that each party shall bear their own costs in this Court and in the lower Court.

The opinion applied established authorities to construe and limit the testamentary gift rather than creating a new legal principle; no new precedent was formulated by the court beyond its application of existing law to the facts.

    Tarokessur Roy, A Ward Of Court, By v. Shoshi Shikhuressur Roy

    1. The plaintiff brought his suit to recover possession of an eight-anna share of taluks numberd 278 and 456, under the following circumstances:

    These two taluks and another numbered 96, together with several other estates, etc., constituted the joint property of two brothers, Raja Chunder Shikhuressur Roy and Raja Mohessur Roy, each entitled to a moiety. The plaintiff is one of the sons of the latter, and the minor defendant is the sole surviving son of the former. When Raja Chunder Shikhuressur died, Raja Mohessur had five sons living, viz., the plaintiff, Kumar Jugodissur and Kumar Sibessur, being three uterine brothers by a deceased wife, and Bissessur and Kopessur by his then living wife. Chunder Shikhuressur died on the 29th Srabun 1272 (August 1865), leaving him surviving a widow, Ranee Soudamini, and only son, the minor defendant, by the aforesaid Ranee, and two daughters, whether by the aforesaid Eanee or not is not clear upon the evidence. He died at Rampure Bolia, the head-quarters of the district of Rajshahye, having come thither about ten or twelve days before his death, accompanied by only a few servants; not a single member of his family was about him at the time of his death. It is not disputed that 27 days before his death,-i. e., on the 2nd Srabun 1272,-he executed a will at his family residence at Taherpur, distant about eight or ten hours' journey from the headquarters.

    2. It is alleged that, by the 8th clause of this will, Raja Chunder Shikhuressur bequeathed his eight annas share of the taluks in claim, as well as of the taluk No. 96, to the plaintiff and his two uterine brothers. The clause in question is to the following effect:

    My brother's sons, Kumar Jugodissur Roy, Kumar Tarokessur Roy, and Kumar Sibessur Roy, shall receive, for defrayment of the expenses of their pious acts, the following out of the properties left by me, to wit: my one-half share in Pargannna Chungoo, recorded as No. 278 is the Collectorate of Zilla Rajshahye in Dihi Dolil, and others appertaining to Tuppa Byas, and recorded as No. 456; and in Mouza Dihi Govindpur in Pargana Sautool, recorded as No. 96 in the touji or rent-roll of the Collectorate of Zilla Dinagepore. The said three nephews shall hold possession of the above in equal shares, and shall pay the Government revenue of the same into the Collectorate. They shall have no right to alienate the same by gift or sale, but they, their sons, grandsons, and other descendants in the male line shall enjoy the same, and shall perform acts of piety as they respectively shall think fit for the spiritual welfare of our ancestors. If any of them die without leaving a male child (which God forbid), then his share shall devolve on the surviving nephews and their male descendants, and not on their other heirs.

    3. The plaintiff further alleged that, after the "3eath of his uncle his father was allowed to take possession of the eight annas share of all these three taluks as guardian of his three sons. But from the month of Bysack 1273 B. S., Ranee Soudamini, on behalf of her minor son, the defendant in this case dispossessed him from the aforesaid eight annas share of the two taluks claimed, in this suit; that, subsequently, when the whole estate of the minor defendant was taken charge of by the Court of Wards, the disputed share of the two taluks also came into their possession.

    4. The plaintiff's elder brother, Kumar Jugodissur Roy, and his younger brother, Sibessur Roy, having both died on the 24th Maugh 1279 B. S. (February 1873) and the 5th Kartick 1276 (October 1869) respectively, without leaving any male issue, the plaintiff claims the whole eight annas share under the terms of the will. The taluk No. 96 is not included in this suit, because it is alleged that, out of the share bequeathed by the will, he is in possession of four annas, the other four annas being in possession of the Court of Wards, not on behalf of the minor defendant, but on behalf of the widow of his elder brother Kumar Jugodissur Roy.

    5. According to the provisions of the Act relating to the Court of Wards, the suit was brought against the minor defendant represented by the manager appointed by the Court of Wards, viz., Horo Gobind Bose. But the Court of Wards, by an order dated the 28th May 1877, authorized Ranee Soudamini, the mother of the minor defendant, to appear as his guardian, instead of the aforesaid manager, and thenceforward the suit was defended by the Ranee on behalf of her minor son.

    6. Her defence was that the 8th clause and several other clauses of the will, upon which the plaintiff relies, are not genuine, but were substituted by, some of the amlahs of the deceased Baja shortly before his death in the place of certain other clauses -of the original genuine will. It was further stated in the defence that, supposing the clause in question is genuine, the bequest is in many respects invalid, and that, at any rate, the plaintiff is not entitled to more than a life-interest in a one-third share of the eight annas which the clause in question purports to bequeath.

    7. The lower Court, overruling the defence, decreed the plaintiff's suit. On appeal, all the points raised in the defence have been raised before us, and with reference to them two questions call for decision: First, whether the 8th clause of the will produced in this that of the Raja Chunder Shikhuressur, is genuine or not? and secondly, if it is genuine, upon a correct construction of it, what are the rights of the contending parties under it in respect of the eight annas share of the two taluks which form the subject-matter of this suit?

    8. (After considering the evidence, the learned Chief Justice continued.)

    9. On the whole, upon a careful consideration of the evidence we think that the conclusion of the lower Court upon the question of the genuineness of the will filed in this case is correct.

    10. The next question is, what are the rights of the contending parties under the 8th clause with reference to the taluks in suit. The gift in the first place is to the three brothers, including the plaintiff, and to their succeeding generation in the male line. There is this further condition that, should any of the brothers die without leaving a male child, then his share shall devolve on his surviving brother or brothers and their male descendants.

    11. We are of opinion that the condition imposed upon the gift, that its subject-matter should devolve on male descendants only, is invalid. In Jotendro Mchun Tagore v. Ganendro Mohun Tagore 9 B. L. R., 377, at pp. 394, 395 and 396 the Judicial Committee observe:-"It follows directly from this, that a private individual, who attempts by gifts or will to make property inheritable otherwise than the law directs, is assuming to legislate; and that the gift must fail, and the inheritance take place as the law directs." Further on they say:-"If, on the other hand, the gifts were to a man and his heirs to be selected from a line other than that specified by law, expressly excluding, the legal course of inheritance, as for instance, if an estate were granted to a man and his eldest nephew, and the eldest nephew of such eldest nephew, and so forth for ever, to take as his heirs, to the exclusion of all other heirs, and without any of the persons so taking having the power to dispose of the estate during his lifetime, here, inasmuch as an inheritance so described is not legal, such a gift cannot take effect, except in favour of such persons as could take under a gift to the extent to which the gift is consistent with the law. The first taker would in this case take for his lifetime, because the giver had at least that intention. He could not take more, because the language is inconsistent with his having any different inheritance from that which the gift attempts to confer, and that estate of inheritance which it confers is void."

    12. Applying the principle enunciated in these observations to the terms of the will in this case, it is clear that, under the bequest, the three brothers, including the plaintiff, received the taluks in equal shares for their respective lives, and that the course of succession which was subsequently indicated by the testator being contrary to Hindu law, the particular estate of inheritance which he attempted to create was void.

    13. Therefore, on the testator's death, a one-third share of the eight annas of the taluks in suit devolved upon the plaintiff, enjoyable by him for his life, and the remaining two-thirds in equal shares devolved upon his two brothers, enjoyable by them in equal shares for their respective lives.

    14. But then these brothers died, one after the other, without leaving any male issue. Kumar Sibessur died first on the 5th Kartick 1276 (October 1869), leaving him surviving the plaintiff and his elder brother Kumar Jugodissur. On the happening of such a contingency as this, the will provides that the share bequeathed to the deceased was to devolve upon the surviving brothers and their male descendants. This latter limitation being contrary to Hindu law, is void. But the gift over to the surviving brothers is not invalid according to Hindu Law: see S. M. Soorjeemoney Dosse v. Denobundoo Mullick 9 Moore's I. A., 123, at p. 134 and the observations of The Judicial Committee upon that case in Tagore v. Tagore 9 B. L. R., 377, see pp. 399, 400.

    15. For similar reasons, upon the death of Kumar Jugodissur without leaving any male issue, his original share (viz. 1/3) devolved upon the plaintiff. It is somewhat doubtful whether, along with Jugodissur's original share (vie. 1/3), the share received by him on the death of Sibessur also did not pass to the plaintiff. But having regard to the provisions relating to the legacy as a whole, we think that it was the intention of the testator that the whole augmented share should pass to the plaintiff, who was the sole surviving brother. The language used relating to this gift over to the surviving brother or brothers is not inconsistent with this intention.

    16. We, therefore, come to the conclusion that the whole eight annas share of the two taluks, the subject-matter of this suit, has devolved upon the plaintiff under the provisions of the will of Raja Chunder Shikhuressur. But we do not agree with the lower Court that the plaintiff's right thereto is absolute. His interest will determine with his death, and, upon the happening of that event, the disputed share of the taluks in question will revert to the legal heir of the testator.

    17. In modification of the decree of the lower Court, we decree the possession of the disputed share of the two taluks, which is the subject-matter of this suit, and declare that the plaintiff has therein only a life-interest. We do not interfere with the decree of the lower Court as to mesne profits, but, under the circumstances of the case, we think that each party should bear his own costs in this as well as in the lower Court.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tarokessur Roy, A Ward Of Court, By v. Shoshi Shikhuressur Roy
    (Sep 9, 1880)