Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges

    Punch Cowrie Mull v. Chunnoo Lall

    Appeal from a decree passed by Mr. Justice Kennedy in the Original Civil Jurisdiction of the High Court, dismissing the plaintiff's suit.

    The facts of this case are as follows:—One Hoolasseeloll ??? a shawl merchant and bill discounter, died in December 1826 without issue. By his will be directed the business to be ??? on by his executors, to whom he gave ten annas of the profits beneficially, and the remaining six annas he disposed of as follows:—“Six (6) annas of my own, the profit that shall accrue ??? year the same you will disburse for Dharrum as follows: Particulars, two (2) annas profit to Sri Munderjee of Calcutta of the Tairopuntee Jainee Amnyas, which you will appropriate for the expenses of its Poojairees and Tailoohas and repairs and for Articles for Poojabs. The mooktears to apply the same are the brethren of the Tairopuntee Amnya. Two (2) aunas you ??? appropriate for the expenses of Sri Seckorjee's Mundeers, Poojairees, Tailoohas, Nowbutkhannah, repairs, gomastah, and articles for Poojahs. Two (2) annas at Ferozabad, & c., to the sa-dharamee brethren, such brethren as go there on ??? you will give to them in a suitable manner and will expend ??? this in the matters of the sa-dharamee. If there be ??? then you will write such against my name in my six ??? puttee. If there be profit in the six (6) annas you will appropriate the same for the aforesaid expenses.” The testator went ??? give several bequests of the same kind and then continued:— “??? the sums for pious acts that I have directed to be applied different persons, if any of them shall not apply any sum shall keep back any, all the Tairopuntee Amuya brethren of all towns have the power to cause the same to be applied or to ??? an account thereof.” The testator made one Hursahoy Baboo a gomastah named Luckmee Chand, executors of his will, who ??? out probate and entered into possession of the property in the ginning of 1827. Luckmee Chand died first, whereupon Hursahoy took possession of the whole property. Hursahoy died leaving will of which he made executor his only child Inder Chund, ??? proved it and entered into possession of Hursahoy's ??? Inder Chund died in 1871, leaving two sons and a widow; on the sons died in 1873, the other is the principal defendant in ??? case, Chunnoo Lall. Hoolasseeloll also directed in his will ??? in case the business should be discontinued, certain sums ??? go to his executors and others, and “the whole of ??? remainder shall be for the purpose of dharrum, mooktears ??? the application whereof are the Calcutta Tairopuntee ??? Punch brethren. You will apply the same with their ??? but should the business cease and delay intervene in the ??? of the money, then you will vest this money for ??? in Company's paper or place to credit in the hands of some ??? pectable shroff with the advice of the Punch brethren.”

    The plaintiffs alleged that various payments had been ??? to the Calcutta Punch brethren from time to time by ??? and Inder Chund, and that the business had been ??? in 1876, by a decree of the High Court. The grounds on ??? they sued and the relief claimed are set out in the ??? paragraphs of the plaint:—

    “1.—The plaintiffs are the persons who constitute the ??? Tairopuntee Amnya Punch brethren, the said body being a ??? ??? is vested the management and control of the temples, ??? and worship of the Degumbery sect of Jains, which body forms the committee for the management of ??? Jain charities as well in Calcutta as in all other towns ??? in India.

    2.—The only other Tairopuntee Amnya Punch in the ??? of Bengal is the Punch of and at Ferozabad, near Agra, ??? North-Western Provinces of India, but all the Jain temple charities in India are under the management of the Calcutta Punch, and by the usages and customs of the Jains ??? of one Punch becomes, on going to any town where ??? is a Punch, entitled, by virtue of his being a member of Punch at one place, to become and act as a member of the ??? of any and every town to which he may happen to go.”

    ??? The plaintiffs are desirous, as such members as aforesaid ??? said Calcutta Tairopuntee Amnya Punch brethren, of ??? the will of the said Hoolasseeloll construed by this ??? Court, and of having the rights of the plaintiffs as such ??? thereunder ascertained and declared,” and of having the ??? dedicated to the said religious purposes and pious uses ??? and secured; and they prayed accordingly.

    Barason and Jackson, for the Plaintiffs.

    Paul (Advocate General), for the Defendants.

    The case was set down far settlement of issues, at the hearing, which the following judgment was delivered by

    Kennedy, J.:— ??? not know that I have ever met a document much more ??? to understand than the will produced in this case; in ??? the interpreters who have had the duty of preparing the ??? annexed to the plaint, seem in some portions of it to abandoned the task as hopeless, and marked the passages as ???. As matters stand, however, I feel myself relieved ??? the necessity of trying to ascertain the meaning of this ??? for, in my opinion, the plaintiffs have no such interest as ??? them to maintain a suit.

    The plaint sets out in the two first paragraphs the alleged position of the plaintiffs. [The learned Judge here read the ??? and second paragraphs of the plaint set out in the statement the case, ante.] I may observe that I think, if there were no objections to the suit, it would be difficult to maintain it ??? uncertain and ambiguous a description of the character in ??? the plaintiffs sue, and of the nature and constitution of the to which they belong; and this is something more than ??? technical objection, for if the account in the second paragraph true, every member of every Punch in India is, in fact, a ??? of the Punch here, and ought to be joined in order to bind as well as for other reasons.

    I asked Mr. Branson if he thought himself able to ??? that the property in this case was debutter, and he ??? relinquished that contention, which, indeed, I think on the ??? of the will, would have been wholly untenable. We ??? have not the plaintiffs in the position of sebait, and they ??? claim, and it is clear that on the terms of the will they not ??? claim, property in the subject matter of the suit. All claim or could claim is a right of management. Well, I ??? that it is a little new to me to find a suit for property ??? by a mere manager without some special power. The ??? law does confer such power in the case of a sebait, (if in ??? he be a mere manager,) but then the property is vested ??? deity, and the sebait merely represents him. Here, the ??? not being debutter, it is not vested in any one, and only claim is to have the right of management, which alleged to have been vested in them under the provisions ??? XX of 1863. It seems to me that this in itself is a ??? objection to the present frame of this suit—King of ??? Mahado, 4 Rus., 225.

    There is, however, a further difficulty which seems to ??? it was that which was most strongly pressed by ??? Advocate-General, and I did not hear any answer to it ??? Branson, save a faint suggestion as to the possible different Indian Law. It is this: the plaintiffs sue, not in their individual right but as the persons constituting the ??? Punch. They do not allege that they were the persons constituted it at the time of the testator's death; and ??? more than fifty years ago, it is in the highest degree ??? that any of them were. They sue, therefore, it would in their individual but in their supposed corporate ??? is no allegation that they have been legally ??? it is improbable that they have been. Well, in Lloyd ???, 6 Vesey, 773, the Lord Chancellor distinctly held Court ought not to permit persons to sue in a corporate who do not fulfil it. That is a statement of the law ??? in Westminster Hall, thence of the Supreme ??? derivatively of this Court. The present case does not in any of the classes in which native laws are reserved; did, nothing has been suggested to me to show that ??? is different in this respect.

    ??? strong point was that every mode of procedure ??? with difficulties, that he was unable to find an course. I think it possible that there may be none. Provisions of the will are so confused and absurd that it is ??? there may be no person in a position to put them but Mr. Justice Norman, in the case of the Sikh ??? Calcutta, has held, and in my opinion rightly held, that ??? of Act XX of 1863 apply to religious endowments ??? towns, and to persons who are de facto trustees, ??? were a correct view of the case, the defendants or ??? might (if any liability attaches on them, and if any religious endowments created by the will) be sued ??? under the 14th section; but in that case preliminary ??? the 18th section would be necessary. If these can ??? as not religious but charitable gifts, possibly the General could sue; but when I am asked to take the ??? of a trade for upwards of fifty years in order to carry ??? define the trusts of an unintelligible will, I confess that, ??? were not either inconsistent with my judicial duties to ??? adviser of the plaintiffs and to point out to them a ??? of procedure, if any such exists, I should not feel ??? anxious to give them any advice in the matter. My ??? to decide upon their present suit, and this seems untenable; and even if they are able to get over these ??? of form, I think they will probably find others of substance lying behind with which, however, I have at ??? nothing to do. I must dismiss this suit with costs. If I allowed it to stand I should have thought myself bound to allow the greater portion of the costs of the plaint, nearly two pages of which are taken up by setting out in extenso a ??? decree of this Court, from the suit number at the top the certificate of the Assistant Registrar at the bottom, decree being only material as showing that in fact the ??? left by the testator had been discontinued; a statement ??? might have been made in three lines.

    The plaintiffs appealed.

    Branson and Jackson, for Appellants.

    Paul, (Advocate-General,) for Respondents.

    The judgment of the High Court (1) is as follows:—

    In this case the plaintiffs brought a suit, in which they ??? to have the will of one Hoolaseeloll construed, and the right the plaintiffs, as members of a certain “Punch” under the ??? declared; and they also prayed to have certain property ??? had been dedicated by the will to religious purposes, ascertain and secured. The learned Judge in the Court below has dismissed the suit, (without settling any issues, and without going evidence,) as we understand, upon four grounds: (1) that plaintiffs do not shew in what right they sue; (2) that the plaintiff are not a corporation, and cannot therefore claim to hold ??? by succession; (3) that the Advocate-General is not a party the suit; and (4) that no leave of the Court to bring the has been obtained under section 18 of Act XX of 1863.

    The right in which the plaintiffs sue is, in our opinion sufficiently shewn. They describe themselves as the performing, for the time being, the Tairopuntee Amunya ??? brethren, and as such, they claim to have, on behalf of ??? and others, the general management and control of the endowments belonging to the Degumbers sect of Jains. They show that the bequests, which they seek to enforce, are ??? which the testator directed to be applied under the management and direction of this very same Punch, to certain ??? connected with the worship of this sect. So far, therefore, there appears to us to be no objection to the frame of the suit; of course when the issues are properly settled, the plaintiffs will have to prove this part of their case.

    The next objection to the suit, in our opinion, also fails; we do not consider the object of the suit to be to assert any personal rights of ownership in the plaintiffs whatsoever. If any part of the plaint is ambiguous in this respect, all doubt as to this might have been removed when framing the issues. What the plaintiffs substantially seek is to have the trusts of the will, in which they are interested, (not beneficially, but as the representatives of their sect,) ascertained, and the performance of these trusts secured.

    Nor do we consider that the practice of this Court requires that the Advocate General should be a party to a suit of this description. We have enquired into the matter, and far as we have been able to discover, this is not necessary. For example, in 1861, we find a person named Nolbanridoff filing a will on behalf of himself and all the other Armenian inhabitants of New Naukchewan in Rupia, to enforce certain bequests to the institutions of that city; and he only alleged, as his title to bring the suit, that he was one of the inhabitants. In that case a scheme was drawn up and a decree made, without any concurrence of the Advocate General.

    The last objection is no doubt supported by the authority of Mr. Justice Norman; but, having carefully considered the Act XX of 1863, we are unable to agree in the view that it was intended to apply to such a suit as this. The first thirteen sections of the Act clearly do not apply; and, although the language of section 14, which empowers any person interested in a religious endowment to sue a trustee, is general in its terms, yet we do not consider that the Legislature had in its contemplation to interfere with the procedure of the Supreme Court in reference to trusts concerning property which could not, under any circumstances come under the direct control of Government. Such a suit ??? the present is not brought under Act XX of 1863, but under ??? Ordinary Original Jurisdiction of this Court, inherited from the Supreme Court, and conferred upon the Supreme Court by its Charter; a jurisdiction similar in its general features to that of the Lord Chancellor in England. (See Attorney General v. Brodie, 4 Moore's Ind. App., 190.)

    At the same time, whilst we believe that this is the correct view of the Law, as it stands at present, we cannot help thinking it extremely desirable that suits of this kind to enforce trusts which are of a public character should only be brought either by the consent of the Advocate General, or by the leave of the Court; such suits are very often vexatious, and open to abuse; and we consider that a procedure similar to that which is provided by Act XX of 1863 for suits to which that Act extends, might usefully be applied to all suits of this nature. This, of course, could only be effected by Legislative interference. We think that the learend Judge was wrong to dismiss the suit upon the grounds stated by him. The decree will, therefore, be set aside, and the suit remanded to be heard upon its merits. The costs of the appeal will be costs in the cause.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Punch Cowrie Mull v. Chunnoo Lall
    (Apr 1, 1878)