Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 7 (iv-A) of the Court-Fees Act,
  • S. 7 (ix) of the Court-Fees Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 7 (iv-A) of the Court-Fees Act,
  • S. 7 (ix) of the Court-Fees Act

    B. Nemichand Sowcar Petitioner. v. N. Namberumal Chetty .

    The question raised is whether the view of the learned City Civil Judge that the proper Court-fee has been paid on the plaint, is right. It is assumed by the Judge, and is conceded here, that if the valuation for the purpose of Court-fee is determined, the same valuation has to be adopted for the purpose of jurisdiction. The material facts may be briefly stated. On the 28th June 1928 the 2nd defendant granted a mortgage for Rs. 4,000 in favour of the 1st, over two items of his properties. Thereafter, the former filed against the latter C. S. No. 488 of 1928 on the file of the High Court, contending that the mortgage was not fully supported by consideration. In September 1932 a decree was passed in that suit, granting redemption on payment of Rs. 1375 and interest thereon. During the pendency of the appeal that had been filed from that decree (O.S.A No. 93 of 1932), the 2nd defendant in February 1933 mortgaged certain properties including the two items already referred to, in favour of the plaintiff for Rs. 12,500 and subsequently in June 1933, agreed to convey to him one of the two items aforesaid for Rs. 12,000. The plaintiff then goes on to allege, that in July 1933 there was a tripartite agreement between himself and the 1st and 2nd defendants, by which the amount due under the mortgage of 1928 was fixed at Rs. 1850, the sum allowed by the redemption decree, as already stated, being Rs. 1,375. Two days later, contrary to this arrangement, the plaintiff complains that the 1st and 2nd defendant allowed by consent a decree to be passed for Rs. 4,000 in O.S.A No. 93 of 1932. The plaintiff has brought the present suit praying (1) that it may be declared that the consent decree is not binding upon him and (ii) that the property may be directed to be delivered to him on payment of Rs. 1850.

    For the defence Mr. Narasimha Ayyar contends that S. 7 (ix) of the Court-Fees Act applies, as the suit is in effect one to redeem the property; under that clause, the valuation of suits for redemption is according to the principal money expressed to be secured by the instrument of mortgage. The plaintiff has paid Court-fee in respect of Rs. 2,150 (Rs. 4,000 minus Rs. 1850); the defendants' contention is that Court-fee should be paid on the full amount of Rs. 4,000. That contention cannot, in my opinion prevail. A redemption decree had already been passed and it would be unreasonable therefore to hold that the plaintiff was bound to institute a second redemption suit. The object of the action is to get rid of the consent decree and the provision that is directly applicable is S. 7 (iv-A) of the Court-Fees Act, which (the unnecessary portions being omitted) reads thus:

    “In a suit for cancellation of a decree for money, according to the value of the subject-matter of the suit and such value shall be deemed to be, if the whole decree is sought to be cancelled, the amount for which the decree was passed; if a part of the decree is sought to be cancelled, such part of the amount.”

    In the present case, the decree sought to be cancelled is in respect of the excess over the agreed amount of Rs. 1850 and that excess is Rs. 2150. The relief as to possession is consequential upon the declaration. I must therefore hold that the proper Court-fees has been paid.

    That the contention raised for the defence is untenable, becomes evident if the position is slightly altered. Supposing the present suit has been filed by the 2nd defendant himself, impeaching the decree as having been obtained by the 1st defendant's fraud, can it be contended that it should be treated as a second redemption suit? Clearly not. The fact that the suit has been brought not by the original mortgagor but by his transferee, can make no difference.

    The lower Court's view is therefore right and the Civil Revision Petition is dismissed with costs.

    It is scarcely necessary to add that the only question decided by me is that relating to Court-fee and jurisdiction, no other question having been raised before me; further, nothing that I have said can have any possible bearing upon the application which, I understand, is likely to be made for the transfer of the suit to the original side of the High Court to be heard along with some connected action there pending.

    N. R. R.Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    B. Nemichand Sowcar Petitioner. v. N. Namberumal Chetty .
    (Feb 28, 1935)