Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Reference under Section 69, Presidency Small Cause Courts Act)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a reference made by the Chief Judge and Judges of the Madras Court of Small Causes (through their Registrar) under Section 69 of the Presidency Small Cause Courts Act. The reference seeks the High Court’s opinion on two questions of law drawn from Suit No. 2129 of 1924 in the Small Cause Court.

The plaintiff sued the British India Steam Navigation Company Ltd. for about Rs. 1,200 for slackage (loss in weight/value) in three consignments of white Java sugar carried from Calcutta to Madras on three voyages (SS Mantola, SS Tregonnel and SS Margha). On arrival at Madras several bags in each consignment were torn and restitched and material slackage was found. The defendants denied liability on two grounds: (1) inadequate packing in single gunnies, and (2) that the goods were "re-shipped or re-exported" within the meaning of the Bill of Lading, and a clause in the Bill exempted the carrier from responsibility for the condition or contents of such goods.

The trial Judge found the slackage proved and that packing in single gunnies was sufficient, but held that the goods were re-shipped or re-exported because they had been imported into Calcutta from Java and shipped to Madras in the same bags. The Full Bench application focused on the proper construction of the words “re-shipped or re-exported” in the Bill of Lading, and reasonable doubts as to their meaning led to the reference to the High Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the goods in question (white Java sugar imported into Calcutta from Java and then shipped by the plaintiff to Madras in the same bags) come under the category of “re-shipped or re-exported goods” within the meaning of the Bills of Lading.
  2. If so, whether the shipping company is protected from liability for loss or slackage in such consignments by the stipulation in the Bill of Lading that the company is “not responsible for the condition or contents of re-shipped or re-exported goods.”

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The slackage alleged in the plaint was proved at trial.
  • Packing in single gunnies was sufficient (the trial Judge found this to be so).
  • Implicitly, the plaintiff contended that the exclusion clause should not apply so as to excuse the carrier’s liability for the slackage found on arrival.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The sugar was packed in single gunnies (advanced as a denial of liability on a packing ground).
  • The goods had been re-shipped or re-exported and therefore the Bill of Lading’s clause excluding responsibility for the condition or contents of re-shipped or re-exported goods absolves the carrier from liability.
  • Before the Full Bench and trial court it was urged (by those contesting the plaintiff) that the clause relating to re-shipment or re-exportation must be confined to re-shipment occurring in the course of the voyage covered by the Bill of Lading (i.e., transhipment during the voyage) and should not apply to goods previously imported into a port and later shipped onward.

Evidence Relevant to Meaning

  • The Bill of Lading itself, particularly clauses: (a) “Shipped in good order and condition”; (b) a clause permitting the company to tranship, land, store, re-ship and forward at company’s expense but at shipper’s/consignee’s risk; and (c) an exclusion clause reading (among other things) “nor for condition or contents of re-shipped or re-exported goods.”
  • Witness evidence (Mr. A. Wright of Messrs Binny & Co.'s shipping department) stating that “re-exported goods” are goods unloaded from a ship and lying at the port for some time and then re-exported by the owner to another port.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Stuart v. The British and African Steam Navigation Co. ("the Ida") Transhipment at the shipper's risk extends the rights and liabilities under the Bill of Lading to the rest of the voyage; expenses are paid by the ship, risks remain the same. Used to illustrate what constitutes transhipment/re-shipment in the course of a voyage and to distinguish that concept from the separate clause excluding responsibility for "re-shipped or re-exported goods".
New Chinese Antimony Co. v. Ocean Steamship Co., Ltd. Where "weight, contents and value when shipped unknown" is inserted, the onus is on the plaintiffs to prove the quantity shipped; the Bill of Lading is not prima facie evidence of quantity in such cases. Supported the court's exposition that the insertion of such words means the shipowner declines to accept the shipper's declaration and places the burden on the shipper to prove quantity.
Lebeau v. General Steam Navigation Co. The insertion of "weight, contents and value unknown" removes the binding nature of the shipper's statement as to nature/contents; the parties are taken to agree to a modified Bill where carrier undertakes to carry the case whatever it contains. Used to explain the legal effect of the "weight, contents and value unknown" clause and to support the interpretation that the carrier's obligation is limited to carrying the package without accepting the shipper's stated contents as binding.
Stockton and Darlington Ry. Co. v. Barrett Exportation does not necessarily mean export to a foreign country; domestic shipments can be treated as "exported" goods. Supported the court's view that "exportation" can include domestic movements (e.g., goods shipped from one domestic port to another) and therefore the term "re-exported" need not be limited to export abroad.
Nelson Line (Liverpool), Ltd. v. Nelson (James) & Sons, Ltd. A shipowner can only contract out of the duties of a common carrier by clear and unambiguous language. The court acknowledged this principle and held that, on the facts and language of the Bill of Lading before it, the exclusion clause was sufficiently clear and unambiguous to operate as claimed by the carrier (subject to the court's caution about Lord Halsbury's dicta in that case).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a close textual analysis of the Bill of Lading (Ex. A-1) and the clauses relevant to carriage, transhipment, and the exclusion of liability. The reasoning proceeded in the following steps, relying on the wording of the Bill and the authorities cited:

  1. The court noted the opening statement "Shipped in good order and condition" and, referencing standard authority (Carver on Carriage by Sea, s.73), observed that this constitutes an admission by the shipowner that, so far as the shipowner and agents could judge, the goods were shipped in that condition.
  2. The Bill expressly permitted the company to tranship, land, store and re-ship goods at the company's expense but at the shipper's or consignee's risk — a provision the court recognized as referring to transhipment/re-shipment in the course of the voyage (for example, if the original ship was disabled).
  3. The court then turned to the exclusion clause which stated, among other things, "Weight, contents and value when shipped unknown" and that the company is "not to be responsible for any loss or damage ... nor for condition or contents of re-shipped or re-exported goods."
  4. Relying on cited authorities, the court explained the legal effect of "weight, contents and value when shipped unknown": it places onus on the shipper to prove quantity and removes the Bill as prima facie evidence of quantity; it also neutralizes the shipper's statement as to the nature of the goods so that the carrier undertakes to carry the package regardless of what it contains.
  5. The court focused on the precise phrase "condition or contents of re-shipped or re-exported goods" and analyzed whether "re-shipped or re-exported" must be read as limited to re-shipment occurring during the voyage covered by the Bill of Lading (i.e., transhipment in the carrier's course of performance). The defendants had advanced that limitation; the court rejected it.
  6. The court reasoned that the collocation of the exclusion clause and the nature of the terms preceding it indicate the clause relates to matters within the control or knowledge of the shipper (insufficiency of address or packing, internal or external), not to incidents of the voyage. Thus, the words "re-shipped or re-exported" were not to be referred back to the earlier clause about transhipment in the course of the voyage.
  7. The court observed that a shipowner cannot ordinarily "re-export" (that is a shipper's act) and that the ordinary meaning of re-exported goods (supported by witness A. Wright) includes goods unloaded at a port and later re-exported by the owner. The court also invoked Stockton and Darlington Ry. Co. v. Barrett to show that "exportation" need not mean to a foreign country — domestic movements can qualify.
  8. Taking these textual readings and authorities together, the court concluded that the exclusion clause covers goods that had been previously imported into Calcutta from Java and were later shipped to Madras in the same bags — i.e., such goods fell within the description "re-shipped or re-exported goods" as used in the Bill of Lading.
  9. The court was mindful of the principle that exclusion clauses must be clear and unambiguous to exempt a common carrier from liability (Nelson Line v. Nelson), but for the reasons stated the court found the Bill's language sufficiently clear and unambiguous to operate as an exemption in the present circumstances.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The High Court answered both questions in the affirmative:

  • First: The goods in question do come under the category of “re-shipped or re-exported goods” within the meaning of the Bill of Lading, given they were imported into Calcutta from Java and thereafter shipped to Madras in the same bags.
  • Second: The defendant shipping company is protected from liability for loss or slackage in such consignments by the stipulation in their Bill of Lading that they are not responsible for the condition or contents of re-shipped or re-exported goods.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that, on the facts and the construed terms of the Bill of Lading, the carrier (British India Steam Navigation Company Ltd.) is not liable to the plaintiff for the slackage claimed in the three consignments characterized as re-shipped or re-exported.
  • The opinion applies established principles and authorities to interpret the specific Bill of Lading before the court. The court did not purport to lay down a new general precedent beyond its textual application here; it emphasized that exclusion clauses must be clear and, on these facts, found the clause sufficiently clear to operate as claimed.

Answered in the affirmative.

    Haji Shakoor Gani Sait v. B.I.S.N. Co. Ltd.

    1. This is a reference by the Chief Judge and Judges of the Madras Court of Small Causes through their Registrar under Section 69 of the Presidency Small Cause Courts Act submitting, for the opinion of the High Court the following questions:

    The goods in question in this suit, namely, sugar, having been found to be imported into Calcutta from Java, and from there shipped by the plaintiff to Madras in the bags in which such sugar had come from Java under the Bills of Lading covering the carriage thereof from Calcutta to Madras, do such goods come under the category of “re-shipped or re-exported goods” within the meaning of the Bills of Lading in question?

    If such goods do come under such category in the clause in question in the Bill of Lading, is the shipping company protected from liability for loss or slackage in such consignments, by the stipulation in such Bill of Lading that they are “not responsible for the condition or contents of re-shipped or re-exported goods?

    2. The plaintiff in Suit No. 2129 of 1924 in the Small Cause Court sued the British India Steam Navigation Company Ltd., for Rs. 1,200 and odd for slackage in three consignments of sugar from Calcutta to Madras. The three consignments were: (1) on 15th December, 1922, 377 bags of white Java sugar per SS. “Mantola,” (2) on 20th December, 1922, 1630 bags of white Java sugar per SS. “Tregonnel,” and 5(3) on 10th February, 1923, 2380 bags of white Java sugar per SS. “Margha.” On arrival at Madras certain bags in all the consignments were found torn and restitched and there was a very considerable slackage on the value claimed in all the three consignments. The defendants denied liability on two grounds: (1) that the sugar was packed in single gunnies, and (2) that under the Bill of Lading the goods had been re-shipped or re-exported and that they were, therefore, not liable for their condition or contents. The learned Chief Judge who tried the case found the slackage alleged in the plaint was proved and that the packing in single gunnies was sufficient. He also held that the goods had been re-shipped or re-exported because they had been imported into Calcutta from Java and were re-shipped or re-exported to Madras in the same bags in which they had come from Java. In the Full Bench Application No. 231 of 1925 this latter was the only question argued and as the Full Bench of the Small Cause Court entertained reasonable doubts as to how these words should be construed the reference comes before us. The point urged before the Full Bench and apparently also before the learned trial Judge was that the clause in the Bill of Lading relating to re-shipment or re-exportation must be confined to the course of the voyage to which the contract evidenced by the Bill of Lading relates. It is, therefore, necessary in order to answer the questions that have been referred to us to refer somewhat in detail to the Bill of Lading, Ex. A-1. The opening words are:

    Shipped in good order and condition.

    3. Then follow:

    The said goods to be carried and delivered, subject to the terms and conditions of this Bill of Lading in the like good order and condition at the port of Madras to the consignee or their assigns.

    4. It may here be noted that the consignor and the consignee are the same person as the plaintiff carried on business in both Calcutta and Madras. As pointed out by Carver in his standard work on Carriage by Sea, S. 73, the general statement ‘in good order and condition’ amounts to an admission by the shipowner that so far as he and his agents have had the opportunity of judging, the goods were so shipped. The next observation to make is that the company is at liberty to tranship or land and store the goods either on shore or afloat and to re-ship and forward the same at the company's expense but at shipper's or consignee's risk. That is obviously a transhipment and re-shipment in the course of the voyage,] as for instance when the original ship in ‘which the goods are laden is disabled’ and unable to continue her voyage she is allowed to land the goods and re-ship and forward them at her expense but at the shipper's risk, As was said in Stuart v. The British and African Steam Navigation Co.(1) “the Ida” the transhipment at the shipper's risk only extends the rights and liabilities of the parties under the Bill of Lading to the rest of the voyage; with this, that any expense that is incurred must be paid by the ship, the risks remaining the same.

    5. So that as regards this transhipment and re-shipment it is a matter which the shipowner is entitled to undertake and over which the shipper has no control. The Bill of Lading is stated to be issued subject to the following further conditions:

    Weight, coatents and value when shipped unknown. The company is not to be responsible for any loss or damage or delay whatsoever directly or indirectly resulting from insufficiency of the address, or packing internal or external, nor for condition or contents of re-shipped or re-exported goods.

    6. Where weight, contents and value unknown is inserted, it has been held in New Chinese Antimony Co. v. Ocean Steamship Co., Ltd.(2), that the onus is on the plaintiffs, the shippers, to prove the quantity shipped, as the Bill of Lading is under these circumstances not even prima facie evidence of quantity. The effect of these words is that the shipowner declines to accept the declaration of the shipper and according to the learned Judges in Lebeau v. General Steam Navigation Co.(3), their insertion completely does away with the statement made by the shipper with respect to the nature of the goods and both parties must then be taken to agree to the Bill of Lading in a modified form by which there is no binding statement as to the contents of the package, but the carrier undertakes in his capacity as carrier to carry the case whatever it contains.

    7. However this may be we are primarily concerned with the words condition or contents of re-shipped or reexported goods.

    8. It was pressed upon us that contents must mean specie, that is to say, if the bags described as containing Java sugar in fact contain sand, the shipowner will not be responsible. Even if this is so, the exception as to condition might well be held to absolve the shipowner from liability because it is but reasonable to infer that the bags having been torn and restitched part of their contents had been abstracted or lost owing to the tearing and that, therefore, provided that these bags are re-shipped or re-exported goods, the shipowner would not be responsible for their external condition on account of the exception. But it appears to us that contents must in these instances also include the internal condition of the package and that where the shipowner states that the weight is unknown when shipped he cannot be responsible for the internal condition or contents of the package should it turn out to weigh less than the shipper is prepared to prove it weighed when he put the bags on board the ship. This paragraph of the Bill of Lading obviously refers to matters within the control of the shipper; insufficiency of address or packing, internal or external, are matters with which the shipowner has nothing to do. It is, therefore, reasonable to suppose that the following clause nor for condition or contents of re-shipped or re-exported goods has also to do with something in the goods themselves which is, so to speak, in the disposition of or within the knowledge of or under the control of the shipper and not the shipowner. The whole of this clause has nothing to do with the incidents of the voyage, and it seems to us that from the collocation of the clause there is no ground for referring the words “re-shipped or re-exported” to the preceding clause “to tranship, re-ship and forward.” It is also perfectly clear that a shipowner cannot ordinarily re-export. That must be a matter under the control of a shipper. We therefore think that the contention that this clause relates to re-shipment or re-exportation in the course of the voyage covered by the Bill of Lading and not to goods which had been previously re-shipped or re-exported, cannot be sustained. Exportation does not necessarily mean exportation to foreign country; see Stockton and Darlington Ry. Co. v. Barrett(4) where the House of Lords held that goods shipped from Stockton to London were exported goods. As to whether these goods are in fact re-shipped or re-exported, he clearly says that the sugar was laden on board the defendant's vessels in the same gunnies as they were shipped in Java. Mr. A. Wright who has experience in the shipping department of Messrs Binny & Co., says that re-exported goods are goods which are unloaded from a ship and lie at the port for some time and then the owner re-exports them to another port. (The italics are ours).

    9. The only other reference to re-shipped goods is in the last paragraph but one of the Bill of Lading which refers to action on the part of third parties, i.e, neither the shipper nor the shipowner; such as strikes, war, sanitary regulations, etc. When these prevent the ordinary discharge of cargo the shipowner may tranship or land or otherwise dispose of the goods and may re-ship thence to destination as soon as conveniently may be. One such very common occurrence is illustrated by the recentgstrike in the Port of Colombo where cods destined for Colombo were over-carried to Madras or Calcutta, re-shipped there and returned to Colombo when the conditions were favourable for landing. This is what is called over-carrying. The Bill of Lading concludes:

    The Company shall not be responsible for loss or damage of any kind which may result directly or indirectly from the above causes or any of them and the delivery by the company of packages externally in good condition as received shall be conclusive evidence of delivery of full weight and contents.

    10. The concluding words lend some weight to the argument for the plaintiffs that weight is different from contents. But as we have already pointed out, even if weight is to be excluded in the “condition or contents of re-shipped or re-exported goods,” which we very gravely doubt, for the reasons above given, the Company would not be responsible under this clause for the condition of such goods, nor, it seems to us, for the results or consequences of such condition. In “A Treatise on the Law of Bills of Lading” published in 1880 there is an interesting form of the Bill of Lading employed by the defendant company in those days. One of the clauses is as follows:

    This Bill of Lading is issued subject to the following conditions: Weight, contents and value when shipped unknown. Neither Company (that is to say neither B.I.S.N Co. Ltd., nor the Transhipping Co., the P. & O. Co., is to be responsible “for leakage or package or other consequences arising from the insufficiency of the address or package or for damage, leakage or breakage to re-exported goods.”

    11. We are not unmindful that a shipowner can only contract himself out of the performance of his duties as a common oarrier by clear and unambiguous language [Nelson Line (Liverpool), Ltd. v. Nelson (James) & Sons, Ltd.(5)]. In this case for the reasons stated we are of opinion that the language of the Bill of Lading is sufficiently clear and unambiguous though the attention of the shipowners may be drawn to the dicta of Lord Halsbury in the case cited.

    12. We are, therefore, of opinion that under the circumstances set out in question (1) the goods in question do come under the category of re-shipped or reexported goods within the meaning of the Bill of Lading. We are also of opinion with regard to the second question that the defendant company is protected from liability for loss or slackage in such consignments by the stipulation in their Bill of Lading that they are not responsible for the condition or contents of reshipped or re-exported goods. These are our answers to the questions submitted.

    13. Answered in the affirmative.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Haji Shakoor Gani Sait v. B.I.S.N. Co. Ltd.
    (Mar 21, 1927)