1. The payment into Court of assets realized and the application for rateable distribution were made on the same day, and the officer distributing the assets should have ascertained which act was prior in point of time. He distributed the assets on the footing that the application was prior.
2. The plaintiffs who now challenge his action must show that it was wrongful, since there can be no presumption as to the order of events.
3. The second point argued was that owing to an irregularity in the proceedings the application for execution made by defendant 1 was not legally subsisting at the date of distribution. A valid application within S. 73 had been made and was on the file of the Court at the date of distribution, and we think that the requirements of the section had been fulfilled. The third point is whether the decrees were against the same judgment-debtor. The appellants obtained a decree for money against defendants 3 and 4 personally and respondents obtained a similar decree against; defendant 3. It has been held by this Court that the individuals must be the same: Srinivasaiyengar v. Kanthimathi Ammal(1), and the precise point was decided by the Calcutta High Court: Debohi Nundun Sen v. Hart(2). It has been pointed out that if the fund in Court is the property of the same person who is judgment-debtor under both decrees, he may be regarded as the same debtor in respect of that fund: Nimbaji Tulsiram v. Vadia Venati(3) and Grant v. Subramaniam(4); but if the fund is the joint property of two persons their respective rights thereto cannot be ascertained without an inquiry which is beyond the scope of S. 73 Debohil Nundun Sen v. Hart].
4. It is however admitted here that the joint debtors were entitled to the fund in equal shares, and in the argument on this part of the case the plaintiffs did not claim more than half of the fund paid to defendant 1; and therefore the inquiry mentioned in Deboki Nundun Sen v. Hart is unnecessary. We are therefore of opinion that defendant 1 must account to the plaintiffs for their share of half of the fund in which defendant 1 was not entitled to participate. The appeal is allowed to this extent and there will be a decree for plaintiffs for Rs. 1,118 with interest at six per cent, from 23rd July 1913 till payment with proportionate costs of both parties throughout.
S.N/R.K
5. Appeal partly allowed.