Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • judicata.6. Order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC
  • Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC,
  • provisions of Rule 29 of Order 21
  • substance.8. Rule 29 of Order 21
  • Rule 29 of Order 21 of the CPC,
  • Rule 4 of Order 6 of the CPC.
  • Order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC.
  • 21, Rule 29 of the CPC
  • Rule 29 of Order 21,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • judicata.6. Order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC
  • Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC,
  • provisions of Rule 29 of Order 21
  • substance.8. Rule 29 of Order 21
  • Rule 29 of Order 21 of the CPC,
  • Rule 4 of Order 6 of the CPC.
  • Order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC.
  • 21, Rule 29 of the CPC
  • Rule 29 of Order 21,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Quazi Toufiqur Rahman, as plaintiff, instituted Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 (filed 27-3-1964) against Mst. Nurbanu Bibi for ejectment of the defendant as a tenant. The defendant filed a written statement on 30-9-1964 but the suit was decreed ex parte on 30-11-1965 for default. The defendant's application to set aside that ex parte decree (Misc. Case No. 4 of 1965) was allowed and the suit was restored, but thereafter the suit was again decreed ex parte on 14-11-1967. The defendant's subsequent application (Misc. Case No. 19 of 1967) to set aside the second ex parte decree was dismissed for default on 14-2-1968, and an application for revival was also dismissed, leaving the ex parte decree of 14-11-1967 effective.

The decree-holder (petitioner) initiated execution in Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969 on 5-6-1969. While the execution proceeding was pending, the judgment-debtor (Mst. Nurbanu Bibi) filed Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 in the same court seeking a declaration that the petitioner is not entitled to obstruct her possession and alleging that Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969 was for execution of an allegedly fraudulent decree. In Title Suit No. 141/69 she also sought an injunction under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC; that injunction application was refused on 18-8-1971 and an ensuing Misc. Appeal was rejected on 20-3-1972.

Thereafter, on 12-9-1972, the plaintiff in Title Suit No. 141/69 filed an application under Order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC in the same suit seeking a stay of the execution proceedings (Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969) until disposal of Title Suit No. 141/69. The learned Sadar Munsiff, by order dated 20-11-1974, granted a stay of the execution proceedings pending disposal of Title Suit No. 141 of 1969. The petitioner challenged that stay order by this revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution read with Section 115 CPC, seeking quashment of the order dated 20-11-1974.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the learned Munsiff had jurisdiction to pass the impugned order staying execution under Order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC in Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 (a suit rather than an execution proceeding).
  2. Whether the discretion conferred by Order 21, Rule 29 was exercised judicially and properly in granting the stay, or whether the stay was granted mechanically/without proper application of mind (amounting to abuse of process or constructive error).
  3. Whether the plaintiff in Title Suit No. 141/69 had made out sufficiently cogent grounds (for example, particularized allegations of fraud or collusion in accordance with pleading rules) to justify depriving the decree-holder of the fruits of a valid decree by way of stay.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The learned Munsiff lacked jurisdiction to pass the impugned order under Order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC in Title Suit No. 141/69 because Order 21 applies to execution cases only and therefore the impugned order could not have been passed in a suit.
  • Even assuming jurisdiction, the learned Munsiff failed to exercise the jurisdiction conferred by Rule 29 judicially; the discretion was exercised mechanically and the impugned order suffered from constructive res judicata / improper exercise of discretion.

Opposite Party's (Plaintiff in Title Suit No. 141/69) Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The plaintiff filed Title Suit No. 141/69 seeking a declaration that the defendant (petitioner) is not entitled to interfere with her possession and characterized the execution in Title Execution Case No. 13/69 as being for execution of an allegedly fraudulent decree.
  • She sought interim relief by application under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC (which was refused) and later applied under Order 21, Rule 29 for a stay of execution pending disposal of Title Suit No. 141/69 (the stay was granted by the learned Munsiff on 20-11-1974).
  • The opinion records that no particulars of fraud or collusion are specifically stated in the plaint of Title Suit No. 141/69.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeds in successive, focused steps that apply the text of Rule 29 of Order 21 and articulate limiting principles for its exercise:

  1. Interpretation of Rule 29: The court notes Rule 29 of Order 21 permits a Court to stay execution of a decree where a suit is pending in any Court against the holder of the decree (by the person against whom the decree was passed), and thus concludes that the learned Munsiff did have jurisdiction to stay the execution in the circumstances of Title Suit No. 141/69. The petitioner's first submission (lack of jurisdiction) is therefore rejected as without substance.
  2. Judicial exercise of discretion: The court emphasizes that the discretion under Rule 29 must be exercised judicially and not mechanically or as a matter of course. Rule 29 allows stays “on such terms as to security or otherwise,” but the discretion is not unfettered and must be carefully applied.
  3. Protection of decree-holder's rights: The court explains the policy behind cautious exercise of Rule 29 — a party who has obtained a lawful decree should not be deprived of its fruits except for “good and cogent reasons.” As long as a decree stands and is not set aside by a competent court it remains effective, and a stay should not be lightly granted.
  4. Particularized pleading where fraud alleged: The court states that if a subsequent suit seeks to set aside an earlier decree on grounds such as fraud or collusion, the allegations should be carefully examined and the pleading should comply with Rule 4 of Order 6 CPC (i.e., particulars should be provided). A simple subsequent suit without particularized pleadings is not, by itself, sufficient to warrant depriving a decree-holder of the decree's fruits.
  5. Application to the facts: The court examines the factual background: the defendant in Title Suit No. 52/64 had repeatedly defaulted leading to ex parte decrees (first set aside, then re-decreed, and the second ex parte decree remained valid after dismissal of revival), the execution case was filed and the judgment-debtor did appear and sought time to file objections, and the plaintiff subsequently filed Title Suit No. 141/69. The court finds Title Suit No. 141/69 does not allege particulars of fraud or collusion in the plaint and instead raises questions of title or possession in a manner the court views as intended to delay and deprive the decree-holder of the decree’s fruits.
  6. Conclusion on exercise of discretion: Given the absence of specific, cogent allegations (particularly of fraud) and the defendant’s previous conduct (defaults, attempts to revive and then further litigation), the court concludes the learned Munsiff did not exercise his discretion under Rule 29 judicially. Instead, the Munsiff acted mechanically and allowed the opposite party to use the process of law for delay. Therefore the stay order was improperly granted.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The impugned order dated 20-11-1974 passed by the learned Sadar Munsiff staying Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969 pending disposal of Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 is quashed; the revision petition is allowed and the Rule is made absolute.

Direct Implications for the Parties:

  • The specific stay order granted by the learned Munsiff was set aside by this Court's order.
  • The petition was allowed and the Rule made absolute by the Court. The Court made no order as to costs.

Broader Implications / Precedential Effect: The opinion does not set out or claim to lay down any new legal precedent beyond the application of established principles governing Rule 29 of Order 21 (i.e., that jurisdiction exists but must be exercised judicially and a decree-holder should not be deprived of the fruits of a decree except for cogent reasons). The opinion reiterates that stays under Rule 29 require careful, not mechanical, exercise of discretion and that pleading requirements (for fraud or collusion) must be observed before suspending execution of a decree.

Order as Recorded in the Opinion: "The impugned order passed by the learned Munsiff is quashed. The petition is allowed and the Rule is made absolute. I, however, make no order as to costs. Petition allowed."

    Quazi Toufiqur Rahman v. Mst. Nurbanu Bibi Opposite Party.

    1. By this petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India read with Section 115 of the CPC, the petitioner has prayed quashing the order dated 20-11-1974 passed by the learned Sadar Munsiff Gauhati in Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 by which the execution of the Decree in Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 has been stayed till decision of the Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 pending in the Court.

    2. The facts leading to this revision petition may be briefly stated as follows:—

    Petitioner Quazi Toufiqur Rahman filed as plaintiff Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 on 27-3-1964 against opposite party Mst. Nurbanu Bibi as defendant. Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 was filed for ejectment of the defendant-opposite party as a tenant in respect of the suit land. The defendant-opposite party filed written statement in Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 on 30-9-1964 but the suit was decreed ex parte on 30-11-1965 for default of the defendant-opposite party. An application for setting aside the ex parte decree was filed by the defendant-opposite party and that petition was registered as Misc. Case No. 4 of 1965 and in due course the Misc. Case was allowed and the ex parte decree was set aside and the Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 was restored to file. Thereafter Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 was decreed ex parte on 14-11-1967 for the second time. The defendant-opposite party filed another application for setting aside the ex parte decree which was numbered as Misc. Case No. 19 of 1967. But the said Misc. Case was again dismissed for default on 14-2-1968 and the application for revival of the petition was also dismissed. Consequently the ex parte decree dated 14-11-1967 in Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 for ejectment of the defendant-opposite party as a tenant has stood effective. Thereafter the decree holder-petitioner put the decree in Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 into execution in Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969 against the judgment-debtor/opposite party. During the pendency of the Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969 the judgment-debtor opposite party Mst. Nurbanu Bibi has filed Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 against the decree-holder petitioner Quazi Toufiqur Rahman for a declaration that defendant Quazi Toufiqur Rahman is not entitled to obstruct and/or interfere with the possession of the plaintiff Musstt. Nurbanu Bibi in respect of the suit land in Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969 which is for execution of the fraudulent decree in Title Suit No. 52 of 1964. In Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 the plaintiff-opposite party Mustt. Nurbanu Bibi also filed an application under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC, praying for restraining the defendant-petitioner Quazi Toufiqur Rahman from proceeding with Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969. The application for injunction was rejected by the Court by order dated 18-8-1971 passed in Title Suit No. 141 of 1969. Against the order dated 18-8-1971 rejecting the application for injunction the plaintiff-opposite party preferred a Misc. Appeal before the learned Assistant District Judge who rejected the Misc. Appeal by order dated 20-3-1972.

    3. The plaintiff-opposite party thus having failed to restrain the defendant-petitioner from executing the decree in Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 in Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969 filed an application under order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC on 12-9-1972 in Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 for staying the execution case (Title Execution case No. 13/69) till disposal of the suit. The learned Munsiff by his order dated 20-11-1974 has stayed Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969 pending disposal of Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 and the present revision petitioner is directed against this order dated 20-11-1974.

    4. Mr. B. Sarma, the learned counsel for the defendant-petitioner firstly submits that the learned Munsiff has no jurisdiction to pass the impugned order under Order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC, inasmuch as Order 21, applies to execution case only and therefore the impugned order could not have been passed in Title Suit No. 141 of 1969.

    5. The learned counsel for the petitioner next submits that even if the Court has jurisdiction to pass the impugned order under Rule 29 of Order 21 of the CPC, the learned Munsiff has failed to exercise that jurisdiction judicially and the impugned order was hit by constructive res judicata.

    6. Order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC reads as follows:—

    “Stay of execution pending suit between decree-holder and judgment-debtor. Where a suit is pending in any Court against the holder of a decree of such Court, on the part of the person against whom the decree was passed, the Court may, on such terms as to security or otherwise, as it thinks fit, stay execution of the decree until the pending suit has been decided”.

    7. In Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 which was decreed by the Sadar Munsiff on 14-11-1967, the decree-holder is Quazi Toufiqur Rahman and the judgment-debtor is Mustt. Nurbanu Bibi. The judgment-debtor Mustt. Nurbanu Bibi has filed Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 in the court of the Sadar Munsiff against Quazi Toufiqur Rahman and that suit is pending. That being the position, in view of the language of Rule 29 of Order 21, the Court may on such terms as to security or otherwise, as it thinks fit, stay execution of the decree in Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 pending disposal of Title Suit No. 141 of 1969, if the Court is satisfied that in view of the facts and circumstances of the case and for the ends of justice such a stay order is required to be passed. Hence I find that the first submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the learned Munsiff had no jurisdiction to pass the impugned order, has no substance.

    8. Rule 29 of Order 21 states that the Court may stay execution on such terms as to security or otherwise as it thinks fit. But the discretion conferred on the Court by Rule 29, shall be exercised judicially and not mechanically as a matter of course.

    9. While exercising the discretion conferred under Rule 29 of Order 21, the Court should duly consider that a party who has obtained a lawful decree is not deprived of the fruits of that decree except for good and cogent reasons. So long as the decree is not set aside by a competent court it stands good and effective and it should not be lightly dealt with so as to deprive the holder of the lawful decree of its fruits. If the judgment-debtor bring a suit for setting aside an earlier decree on ground of fraud and/or collusion or that the decree was not binding on him for some legal grounds, the allegations made in such a suit should be carefully examined by the Court before exercising the discretion conferred under Rule 29. If the subsequent suit is brought for setting aside the earlier decree on ground of fraud and/or collusion etc. Court should also see whether the pleading of the party concerned has complied with the requirements of Rule 4 of Order 6 of the CPC. A party should not be deprived of the fruits of the decree obtained by him from a competent court merely because a suit has subsequently been filed for setting aside that decree. A decree passed by a competent court should be allowed to be executed and unless a strong case is made out on cogent grounds no stay should be granted. Even if stay is granted it must be on such terms as to security etc., so that the earlier decree is not made ineffective due to lapse of time.

    10. In the instant case, as observed hereinabove, the opposite party who was the defendant in Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 filed written statement on 30-9-1964. The suit was allowed to be decreed ex parte on 30-11-1965 for default. Then the ex parte decree was set aside at her instance but again the suit was allowed to be decreed ex parte on 14-11-1967. Thereafter also an application was filed for setting aside the ex parte decree but that application was allowed to be dismissed for default on 14-2-1968. An application for revival of that petition was also dismissed. As a result the ex parte decree dated 14-11-1967 stood valid. The Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969 for executing the decree in Title Suit No. 52 of 1964 was filed on 5-6-1969 and the judgment-debtor appeared in Title Execution Case No. 13 of 1969 on 10-7-1969 and she applied for time to file objection. Thereafter she has filed Title Suit No. 141 of 1969 on 1-9-1969. The plaintiff in Title Suit No. 141/69 has prayed for a declaration that the defendant is not entitled to obstruct and/or interfere with her possession in respect of the suit land in Title Execution Case No. 13/69 which is for the execution of the alleged fraudulent decree in Title Suit No. 52/64. In Title Suit No. 141/69 the plaintiff's case is not that she wants a declaration that the decree in Title Suit No. 52/64 was obtained by fraud and collusion or undue influence or such other ground and therefore the decree was vitiated and not binding on her. On the other hand some question of title of the plaintiff in Title Suit No. 52/64 has been raised and in that way she has sought for a declaration that her possession may not be interfered with in the Title Execution Case No. 13/69. In the plaint of Title Suit No. 141/69 no particulars of fraud or collusion etc., have been specifically stated. The conduct of the opposite party in Title Suit No. 52/64 and the pleading in Title Suit No. 141/69 are eloquent enough that the opposite party's main intention is to deprive the petitioner of the fruits of the decree lawfully obtained in Title Suit No. 52/64.

    11. The decree against the opposite party in Title Suit No. 52/64 was passed as a tenant under the petitioner. If really it was the case of the opposite party that the petitioner had no title to the suit land she could have easily agitated those matters in Title Suit No. 52/64 denying the tenancy and if the tenancy had been denied and not proved the plaintiff in Title Suit No. 52/64 could not have got a decree if the defendant therein had taken care to contest the suit. But the conduct of the opposite party as defendant in Title Suit No. 52/64 is such that she has only been trying to make abuse of the process of law by delaying tactics and she is found to have adopted the same thing in Title Suit No. 141/69 inasmuch as she first filed an application under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC, which was rejected; then went on appeal which was also rejected and thereafter she has filed this application under Order 21, Rule 29 of the CPC. Considering the entire facts and circumstances of the case I find the opposite party has not been able to make out a just cause for stay of Title Execution Case No. 13/69.

    12. The learned Munsiff in staying the Title Execution Case No. 13/69 did not properly apply his mind to the provisions of Rule 29 of Order 21 vis-a-vis the facts and circumstances of the case and failed to exercise the discretion under Rule 29 judicially but has acted mechanically as a matter of course allowing the opposite party to abuse the process of law.

    13. The discretion of the Court under Rule 29 cannot be exercised so as to allow a party to abuse the process of law.

    14. It is thus found that in passing the impugned order of stay the learned Munsiff failed to exercise his jurisdiction properly and judicially. Thus I find that there is substance in the second submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner.

    15. In the circumstances the impugned order passed by the learned Munsiff is quashed. The petition is allowed and the Rule is made absolute. I, however, make no order as to costs.

    16. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Quazi Toufiqur Rahman v. Mst. Nurbanu Bibi Opposite Party.
    (Jun 30, 1975)