Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Nirmala Devi And Others

    Pradeep Nandrajog, J.:— The two captioned appeals arise out of the same accident which took place on 3.3.1979 The insurance company prays that its liability should be held to be limited to the extent of Rs. 50,000. The claimants pray that the compensation be enhanced.

    2. As a result of the accident. Prakaram Chand aged 34 years received fatal injuries. He died. He left behind his wife, 4 minor children and mother. His mother died during pendency of the claim petition.

    3. After discussing the evidence on record pertaining to the accident and holding the driver of the offending vehicle guilty of rash and negligent driving, the Tribunal awarded a compensation of Rs. 1,72,800 to the claimants. The owner, driver and the insurance company have been held liable to pay under the award.

    4. Vide F.A.O No. 209 of 1994, the insurance company has challenged the award insofar it determines that insurance company is liable to satisfy the award.

    5. A defence was raised by the insurance company that policy in question was an ‘Act only policy’ and in view of the statutory provision contained in clause (b) of sub-section (2) of section 95 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, its liability is limited to the extent of Rs. 50.000 only.

    6. Learned Tribunal has not discussed the issue of limited liability of insurance company in the award. However, considering that insurance company admitted that offending vehicle was insured with it, learned Tribunal has directed the insurance company to satisfy the award.

    7. To establish that policy in question was an ‘Act only policy’, an insurance policy purported to be the true copy of the original policy was filed on record. The same is at page 209 of the record of the Tribunal.

    8. No official from the insurance company was summoned to prove that said policy was a true copy of the original policy. The alleged true copy does not bear the signature of the person under whose authority same has been issued.

    9. The alleged true copy of the original insurance policy has thus remained an unproved document.

    10. There is no presumption in law that policy of insurance issued by an insurance company is ‘Act only policy’. For if, insur ance company takes additional premium, it can cover additional risk, A contract of insurance is between insurance company and assured. Where, policy covers a third party risk, third party is beneficiary of the risk. Thus, obligation is that of insurance company to prove terms of its liability. Where insurance company alleges that its liability is limited, onus is on the insurance company to prove it.

    11. To similar effect are the observa tions of Kerala High Court in the decision reported as Ouseph v. Antony, 1990 ACJ 57 (Kerala). In the said case, it has been observed as follows:

    “(9) … The insurance company has not chosen to produce the policy nor to adduce any evidence to show that their liability is limited to the statutory liability… As the insurance company has not discharged its burden by either producing the policy or adducing any other evidence to that effect, insurance company is liable to pay the entire amount due under this award.”

    12. Since the insurance company has failed to prove that its liability was limited to the extent of statutory liability, I direct insurance company to satisfy the award. F.A.O No. 209 of 1994 is accordingly dismissed.

    13. In F.A.O No. 232 of 1994, the appellants who were the claimants before the Tribunal seek enhancement of the compensation awarded to them due to death of the deceased in the said road accident.

    14. Vide award dated 14.7.1994, total compensation granted to the appellants is Rs. 1.72,800.

    15. Since the only issue involved in this appeal relates to quantum of compensation. I shall only note such facts as are relevant for adjudication of said issue.

    16. Deceased was aged 34 years as on the date of the accident.

    17. He left behind his wife, 4 minor children aged 13 years, 11 years, 10 years and 4 years respectively and his mother.

    18. Deceased was employed as a tailor and was earning Rs. 1,200 per month at the time of the accident.

    19. Noting the testimony of the wife of the deceased and other surrounding evidence, learned Tribunal has determined the earnings of the deceased at the time of the accident as Rs. 1,200 per month.

    20. Relying upon the decision reported as Radha Kishan Sachdeva v. L.D Sharma, 1994 ACJ 109 (Delhi), learned Tribunal has taken last income of the deceased, i.e, Rs. 1,200 per month as the loss of dependence. Noting that deceased was aged 34 years at the time of the accident, multiplier of 12 has been applied by the Tribunal. Thus, total compensation has been determined by the Tribunal at Rs. 1,200 × 12 × 12 = Rs. 1,72,800.

    21. After perusing the award, I find that compensation assessed to the appellants is faulty on one count.

    22. In my view. Tribunal erred in ignoring the prospects of future increase in the income of the deceased. Tribunal failed to take note of the fact that wages increase from time to time to equalise fall in purchasing power of the rupee. Considering that the deceased was aged 34 years at the time of the accident, it could be expected that he would have worked for another 26 years.

    23. A perusal of the minimum wages notified under the Minimum Wages Act show that the minimum wages increased by nearly 150 per cent in 10 years. Take for instance, minimum wages for skilled workman as on 1.1.1980 were Rs. 320 per month. Same rose to Rs. 1,043 in the year 1990 and further rose to Rs. 2,843 in the year 2000. Meaning thereby that there has been an increase of 225 per cent from the year 1980-1990 and an increase of 172 per cent from the year 1990-2000.

    24. Noting that the minimum wages virtually doubles after every 10 years to neutralise increase in inflation, cost of living, purchasing power of rupee and the fact that deceased would have worked for another 26 years, it could reasonably be assumed that his earnings would have at least tripled by the time he would have left gainful employment. Thus, mean average income of the deceased comes to Rs. 2,400 per month. [Rs. 1,200 + Rs. 3,600 (3 times increase in income)/by 2 = Rs. 2,400].

    25. I note that the deceased was maintaining besides himself, his wife, 4 minor children, aged between 4 years and 13 years and mother. Noting the principle that lesser is the income, lesser is the presumed expenses on self and the second principle larger is the family, lesser is the presumed expenses on self, I consider deduction of ‘/5th towards the personal spending of the deceased as appropriate. Thus, loss of dependence comes to Rs. 1,920 per month.

    26. The Tribunal has rightly applied multiplier of 12. In so holding, I note the undermentioned judgments:

    (i) U.P State Road Trans. Corpn. v. Krishna Bala, 2006 ACJ 2114 (SC);

    (ii) Managing Director, Tamil Nadu State Trans. Corpn. Ltd. v. K.I Bindu, 2006 ACJ 423 (SC);

    (iii) Tamil Nadu State Trans. Corpn. Ltd. v. S. Rajapriya, 2005 ACJ 1441 (SC); and

    (iv) New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Kalpana, 2007 ACJ 825 (SC).

    27. Applying multiplier of 12, total loss of dependence comes to Rs. 1,920 × 12 × 12 = Rs. 2,76,480.

    28. The Tribunal has awarded no compensation under the head ‘non-pecuniary damages’. Considering that the accident in question relates to the year 1979, I award compensation in sum of Rs. 10,000 under the said head. Thus, total compensation comes to Rs. 2,86,480.

    29. Tribunal has awarded compensation in sum of Rs. 1,72,800. Therefore, compensation is enhanced by a further sum of Rs. 1,13,680.

    30. Noting that interest rates fluctuated between 13 per cent per annum to 5.5 per cent per annum between the years 1979 and 2007, 1 direct that enhanced compensation shall be paid together with interest at the rate of 8 per cent per annum from the date of claim petition till the date of realisation.

    31. Enhanced compensation shall be disbursed as follows:

    (a) Appellant No. 1 (widow) Rs. 93,680.

    (b) Appellant Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 5 (children) Rs. 5,000 (each).

    32. F.A.O No. 232 of 1994 is allowed in terms of paras 29, 30 and 31 above.

    33. F.A.O No. 209 of 1994 is dismissed.

    34. No costs.

    35. Orders accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Nirmala Devi And Others
    (May 10, 2007)