Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit (O.S. 207 of 1950) was instituted by Kunhiraman Nambiyar and another for partition of the scheduled properties and for recovery of the plaintiffs' 1/3 share together with future profits (claimed at Rs. 30 per year). The Trial Court originally dismissed the suit; the lower appellate court confirmed that dismissal. The High Court in S.A. No. 932 of 1956 set aside the decrees of the two courts below and passed a preliminary decree for partition, holding Kunhiraman Nambiyar entitled to a 1/3 share. That preliminary decree was silent on the plaintiffs' claim for future profits.

The respondents (legal representatives of Kunhiraman Nambiyar) filed R.I.A. 878 of 1962 in the Trial Court requesting a final decree. By order dated 29.9.1964 the Trial Court passed a final decree implementing valuation and allotment in accordance with the Commissioner's report, but did not address the respondents' request for profits from the date of the suit. Defendants 4 to 6 challenged the final decree by appealing (A. S. 134 of 1964) to the Sub Court, Kasaragod, on grounds of incorrect valuation and unfair division.

The respondents filed a memorandum of objections before the Sub Court asserting that the Trial Court should have awarded them their share of profits from the date of the plaint. The lower appellate court allowed the appeal and the memorandum of objections, remanded the final decree application to the Trial Court for disposal in accordance with its directions, and the Subordinate Judge directed that the plaintiffs were entitled to profits from the date of the suit and ordered the Trial Court to ascertain and fix the quantum and include it in a fresh final decree.

Defendants 4 to 6 filed the present Civil Miscellaneous Appeal challenging the appellate court's direction insofar as it awarded future profits to the plaintiffs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the lower appellate court had jurisdiction to adjudicate and award the claim for future profits in final decree proceedings of a partition suit when the preliminary decree was silent and contained no provision recognising an entitlement to future profits.
  2. Whether the principles and limitations of Order 20 Rule 12, Civil Procedure Code (CPC), which govern mesne profits in suits for recovery of possession, apply to partition suits so as to prevent a final decree court from awarding future profits unless the preliminary decree specifically directed an inquiry into such profits.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Defendants 4 to 6)

  • The lower appellate court lacked jurisdiction to decide the plaintiffs' claim for future profits at the final decree stage because the preliminary decree passed by the High Court did not contain any declaration or provision entitling the plaintiffs to such future profits; thus the claim was impliedly negatived by the silence of the preliminary decree.
  • Order 20 Rule 12, CPC (governing mesne profits in suits for recovery of possession) requires that when a court upholds a claim for mesne profits the preliminary decree must contain a specific provision recognising the right and directing an inquiry; the same principle, argued the appellants, should apply to partition suits.
  • Reliance was placed on Supreme Court authorities (Subbanna v. Subbanna and Madanappa v. Chandramma) and other decisions dealing with mesne profits and O.20 R.12 CPC to support the contention that the absence of a provision in the preliminary decree precludes adjudication on future profits at the final decree stage.

Respondents' Arguments (Plaintiffs / Legal Representatives of Kunhiraman Nambiyar)

  • Respondents had specifically prayed in their application for the final decree that they should be awarded their share of the properties with effect from the date of the suit (i.e., share of profits from the date of plaint), and this claim should be considered at the final decree stage.
  • Before the Sub Court in the appeal the respondents contended (via memorandum of objections) that the Trial Court should have awarded them their share of profits from the date of the plaint; the lower appellate court ultimately upheld that contention and directed inquiry and incorporation of such an award in the fresh final decree.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Subbanna v. Subbanna, AIR 1965 SC 1325 Whether O.20 R.12 CPC permits awarding mesne profits for a period exceeding three years from date of decree; construction of decrees awarding future mesne profits in suits for recovery of possession. The court observed that Subbanna concerned the temporal limit on mesne profits under O.20 R.12 and did not consider whether a final decree court could award future profits when the preliminary decree was silent; therefore the decision did not assist the appellant on the specific point before the court.
Madanappa v. Chandramma, AIR 1965 SC 1812 Whether it is open to a court to award future mesne profits to a party who had not claimed them in the suit (in the context of partition suits and mesne profits). The court noted Madanappa did not finally decide the exact question raised in the present appeal because in Madanappa the plaintiff had claimed mesne profits in the plaint; the Supreme Court had not ruled on whether a final decree court can award future profits in the absence of a provision in the preliminary decree.
Mohd Amin v. Vakil Ahmad, AIR 1952 SC 358 Earlier Supreme Court authority on award of future mesne profits (used in argument about requirement of claim in plaint). The opinion notes that Madanappa discussed Mohd Amin and expressed that Mohd Amin might require reconsideration on a suitable occasion, but Mohd Amin was not applied to resolve the specific point in the present case.
Gopalakrishna Pillai v. Meenakshi Ayal, AIR 1907 SC 155 Application of O.20 R.12 CPC; discretionary power of a court to direct an inquiry into future mesne profits even if not specifically prayed for in the plaint (in suits to which O.20 R.12 applies). The court observed this case did not touch the precise question before it (jurisdiction to award profits at final decree in partition suits when preliminary decree was silent); it only held that where O.20 R.12 applies the court may have discretionary power to direct inquiry into future mesne profits.
Basavayya v. Guravayya, AIR 1951 Mad. 938 (Full Bench) Whether a final decree court in a partition suit can direct inquiry into and award profits realised during pendency of suit even though the preliminary decree was silent; applicability (or non-applicability) of O.20 R.12 CPC to partition suits. The court followed and expressly accepted the dictum of the Full Bench: Basavayya held that profits accruing from the common properties pending a partition suit are not strictly "mesne profits" under O.20 R.12 CPC, that such profits form part of the corpus and are liable to be partitioned, and that a direction for inquiry into profits may be made at final decree even after a silent preliminary decree. The present court stated it was in respectful agreement with Basavayya.
Atchamma v. Rami Reddi, AIR 1958 A.P. 517 Follow-up authority about division of profits in partition suits consistent with Basavayya. The court recorded that Atchamma (and other Andhra Pradesh High Court decisions) followed the Full Bench decision in Basavayya; the present court relied on these followings as supportive authority.
Krishnamma v. Latchumanaidu, AIR 1958 A.P. 520 Another Andhra Pradesh High Court decision cited as following Basavayya. The court noted that Krishnamma followed the Basavayya rationale; it was cited as part of line of authorities supporting the proposition that final decree courts in partition suits can deal with profits even if preliminary decree was silent.
Satyanarayana v. Mallikarjuna, AIR 1960 A.P. 45 Andhra Pradesh High Court authority following Basavayya on profits in partition suits. The court mentioned this case as part of the Andhra Pradesh decisions that have adopted Basavayya's view; it supported the court's adoption of the same principle in the present opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed the appellant's contention that Order 20 Rule 12, CPC (which deals with mesne profits in suits for recovery of possession) should be applied analogously to partition suits so that a preliminary decree's silence on future profits would strip the final decree court of jurisdiction to adjudicate those profits.

The court reviewed the authorities relied upon by the appellant:

  • It observed that Subbanna v. Subbanna concerned the temporal limitation of mesne profits under O.20 R.12 and did not address whether a final decree court could award future profits in the absence of a provision in the preliminary decree; thus Subbanna did not assist the appellant on the specific point.
  • It found that Madanappa v. Chandramma did not decide the specific question either, because in that case the plaintiff had claimed mesne profits and the Supreme Court did not decide whether a final decree court can award future profits when the preliminary decree is silent; Madanappa merely suggested Mohd Amin might need reconsideration in due course.
  • Gopalakrishna Pillai v. Meenakshi Ayal was noted as not touching the precise question; it only held that where O.20 R.12 applies the court may have discretion to direct inquiry into future mesne profits.

Having found the cited Supreme Court decisions not decisive on the question before it, the court turned to a directly relevant authority: the Full Bench decision in Basavayya v. Guravayya (Madras). The Full Bench held that:

  • The claim of a plaintiff in a partition suit for his share of profits realised by the defendant during the pendency of the suit is not properly a claim for "mesne profits" within the scope of O.20 R.12 CPC.
  • The profits accruing from common properties pending a partition suit are part of the corpus (the subject-matter) and are liable to be partitioned; the right to an account of such profits is implicit in the right to share in the common properties.
  • There is nothing in O.20 R.18 CPC (the opinion mentions O.20 R.18 in relation) that prevents a final decree court from directing an inquiry into such profits even after a preliminary decree that is silent on the matter.

The court noted that the Madras Full Bench's view had been followed by the Andhra Pradesh High Court in several decisions (Atchamma, Krishnamma, Satyanarayana). The present court expressed respectful agreement with the Full Bench and the Andhra decisions. It reasoned that in a partition suit the court must divide not only the lands but also adjust equities arising from the parties' relation to the common property; therefore a sharer is entitled to an account of profits received by the person in possession, and such profits form part of the corpus available for division (the "hotchpot").

Concluding from the authorities and principle of partition law, the court held that it is a legitimate function of a final decree court in a partition suit to adjudicate claims for future profits even where the preliminary decree contains no express provision or direction on that point. Consequently, the lower appellate court was correct in holding that despite the preliminary decree's silence, it had jurisdiction to inquire into and award future profits at the final decree stage.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is DISMISSED. The court held that a final decree court in a partition suit has jurisdiction to adjudicate and award a sharer's claim for future profits arising during the pendency of the suit even though the preliminary decree is silent on that question. The lower appellate court's direction awarding profits to the plaintiffs was therefore correct and is upheld.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The appellate court's order directing inquiry into and award of the plaintiffs' share of profits from the date of the suit is sustained; the final decree must include the award as directed and the appeal is dismissed with costs in favour of the plaintiffs-respondents.
  • Broader principle recognised by the court: In partition suits profits accruing from the common properties during the pendency of the suit are part of the corpus subject to division (and not strictly "mesne profits" under O.20 R.12 CPC), and a final decree court may adjudicate such claims even if the preliminary decree contains no express provision for them. The court expressly followed the Full Bench decision in Basavayya v. Guravayya and related Andhra Pradesh decisions in arriving at this principle.

Costs: The appeal was dismissed with costs to the plaintiffs-respondents.

    Mariyumma v. Kunhambu Nair

    1. Defendants 4 to 6 in O.S. 207 of 1950 have preferred this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal. The aforesaid suit was instituted by one Kunhiraman Nambiyar and another for a partition of the plaint schedule properties and for recovery of the plaintiff's 1/3 share with future profits at the rate of Rs. 30/-per year. The suit had been originally dismissed by the Trial Court and though the said decree of the Trial Court was confirmed by the lower appellate court, the High court in S. A. No. 932 of 1956 set aside the decrees of the courts below and passed a preliminary decree for partition holding that Kunhiraman Nambiyar was entitled to a 1/3 share. This preliminary decree was, however, silent about the plaintiffs' claim for future profits and did not contain any provision relating thereto.

    2. The respondents herein who are the legal representatives of Kunhiraman Nambiyar filed R.I.A. 878 of 1962 in the Trial Court for passing a final decree. The Trial Court by order dated 29.9.1964 passed a final decree implementing the valuation and allotment suggested in the Commissioner's report which was accepted by it. Although in their application for final decree the respondents herein had specifically made a prayer that they should be awarded their share of the properties with effect from the date of suit, the Trial Court did not advert to this matter at all in its final judgment and consequently, the final decree passed by it did not also contain any provision relating to the aforesaid claim. Defendants 4 to 6 filed A. S.134 of 1964 in the Sub Court, Kasaragod, challenging the aforesaid final decree on the ground that the valuation of the properties and the division effected by the Trial Court were incorrect and unfair. Respondents herein who were respondents before the Sub Court in the aforesaid appeal filed a memorandum of objections contending that the Trial Court should have awarded them their share of the profits from the date of the plaint. The lower appellate court allowed the appeal as well as the memorandum of objections and remanded the final decree application to the Trial Court for fresh disposal in the light of the directions given by it. The Subordinate Judge overruled the contention taken before him by defendants 4 to 6 that the respondents are precluded from putting forward their claim for profits in the final decree proceedings on account of the absence of a provision in that regard in the preliminary decree. He held that the plaintiffs respondents are entitled to profits from the date of suit and directed the Trial Court to ascertain and fix the quantum thereof and incorporate it in the fresh final decree to be passed by it. Defendants 4 to 6 have come up to this court with this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal, challenging the aforesaid decision of the appellate court in so far as it has directed the award of profits to the plaintiffs.

    3. The only point raised before us by the learned counsel for the appellant is that the lower appellate court had no jurisdiction to adjudicate on the claim for future profits put forward by the plaintiff in the final decree proceedings when the preliminary decree did not contain any provision entitling the plaintiffs to such future profits. It is contended that eventhough a claim for future profits had been put forward by the plaintiff in the plaint such claim must be deemed to have been impliedly negatived when a preliminary decree was passed in the suit by the High Court which did not contain any declaration of the plaintiffs' right to future profits. It is further urged that under O.20 R.12 CPC in suits for recovery of possession of immovable property and for mesne profits, whenever the claim for mesne profits from the date of institution of the suit is upheld by the court the preliminary decree should contain a specific provision recognising such right and directing an inquiry as to the quantum of such profits and it is only in such event that a final decree can subsequently be passed in respect of the claim for future profits. The contention of the learned counsel for the appellant is that the same principle must apply to suits for partition also and that if the preliminary decree in a partition suit does not recognise a party's claim to mesne profits nor specifically directs an inquiry as to mesne profits from the date of institution of the suit the court would have absolutely no jurisdiction in the final decree proceedings to adjudicate upon the claim for future profits. In support of the above proposition reliance was sought to be placed by the learned counsel on the observations of the Supreme Court in the decisions reported in Subbanna v. Subbanna (AIR 1965 SC 1325); and Madanppa v. Chandramma (AIR 1965 SC 1812). In Subbanna v. Subbanna (AIR 1965 SC 1325) the question that arose for decision was whether it was competent to a court in decreeing a suit for recovery of possession with mesne profits to award future mesne profits to the decree holder for any period subsequent to the expiry of three years from the date of the decree. Their Lordships held that O.20, R.12 CPC. does not empower a court to direct an inquiry and pass a final decree with respect to mesne profits for a period exceeding three years from the date of the decree. It was further held that even if the decree did not expressly contain specific mention that the future profits awarded by it was limited to a period ending with the expiry or three years from its date the decree has to be construed in conformity with the provisions of O.20 R.12 CPC. and the direction regarding.mesne profits restricted by implication to the period of three years from the date of the decree. The question whether future profits can be awarded by a final decree in the absence of a provision in the preliminary decree recognising the plaintiffs' right to future profits did not come up for consideration before the Supreme Court in the above case and hence this decision is really of no assistance to the appellant.

    4. In Maddanappa v. Chandramma (AIR 1965 SC 1812) the point raised before the Supreme Court was whether it was open to a court to award future mesne profits to a party who had not claimed them in the suit. Relying on the observations contained in an earlier decision of the Supreme Court in Mohd Amin v. Vakil Ahmad (AlR. 1952 SC 358) it was contended before their Lordships that future mesne profits could not be awarded even in a suit for partition unless a claim in that behalf had been put forward in the plaint. Their Lordships held that it was not necessary to make any final pronouncement on the question since the plaintiff in the case before them had claimed in the plaint not only partition and separate possession of her half share but also mesne profits and the first defendant in her written-statement had also prayed for a similar decree in her favour. Their Lordships have, however, expressed the view that when a suitable occasion arises it may become necessary to reconsider the decision in Mohd Amin v. Vakil Ahmad (AIR 1952 SC 358) in so far as it concerns future mesne profits. Thus, in Madappana v. Chandramma (AIR 1965 SC 1812) also the question whether the final decree court can award future mesne profits in the absence of a provision in the preliminary decree did not come up for consideration before the Supreme Court, and we find nothing in the above judgment which would in any way lend support to the contention raised before us by the appellant's counsel. The appellant's counsel referred us to yet another decision of the Supreme Court dealing with O.20, R.12, C.P.C. reported in Gopalakrishna Pillai v. Meenakshi Ayal (AIR 1907 SC 155). But this decision also does not touch the question mooted before us by the appellant. All that has been held by their Lordships in this case is that in a suit to which the provisions of O.20, R.12, CPC. apply, the court has discretionary power to pass a decree directing an inquiry into future mesne profits even though it is not specifically prayed for in the plaint, and the observations in Mohd Amin v. Vakil Ahmad (AlR. 1952 SC 358) were explained and distinguished.

    5. Thus none of the cases relied on by the appellant throws any real light on the question raised before us regarding the jurisdiction of the court passing a final decree in a partition suit to award future profits in favour of a party in the absence of any provision in that behalf in the preliminary decree. This point has, however, been directly considered and decided by a Full Bench of the Madras High Court in the decision reported in Basavayya v. Guravayya (AIR 1951 Mad. 938 FB.). The case before the Full Bench arose out of a suit for partition of joint family properties wherein a preliminary decree had been passed which did not contain any specific provision relating to profits. At the final decree stage the plaintiff applied for an inquiry into the profits of the properties realised by the defendants subsequent to institution of suit and prayed that provision should be made in the final decree for payment of his share of such profits. The defendant opposed the application on the ground inter alia that the preliminary decree passed in the suit did not contain any direction for inquiry into future profits. The Trial Court having overruled this objection of the defendants they approached the High Court with a Civil Revision Petition questioning the jurisdiction of the Trial Court to conduct an enquiry regarding future profits in the final decree proceedings. The Full Bench held that the claim of a plaintiff suing for partition for his share of the profits accruing from the suit property pending the suit, is not, properly speaking a claim for "mesne profits" and O.20, R.12, CPC. has no application to such a case. It was further held that the profits accruing from the common properties pending a suit for partition, like the properties themselves, are liable to be partitioned under the final decree and that a right to an account of such profits being implicit in the right to share in the common properties, both rights have to be worked out and provided for in the final decree for partition. In this view, the Full Bench held that a direction for an inquiry into the profits of the common property received or realised by one of the parties during the pendency of the suit may be made even after the passing of the preliminary decree and that there is nothing in O.20, R.18 CPC. interdicting such procedure. The contention that in the absence of specific provision in the preliminary decree declaring the right of a party to future profits the final decree court has no jurisdiction to award future profits by the final decree was therefore, rejected by the Full Bench.

    6. The above Full Bench decision of the Madras High Court has been followed by the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Atchamma v. Rami Reddi (AIR 1958 A. P. 517); Krishnamma v. Latchumanaidu (AIR 1958 A. P. 520) and Satyanarayana v. Mallikarjuna (AIR 1960 A. P. 45).

    7. We are in respectful agreement with the dictum laid down by the Full Bench in Basavayya v. Guravayya (AIR 1951 Mad. 938 FB.) and also the aforesaid decisions of the Andhra Pradesh High Court. In a suit for partition, the court has not only to divide the common properties but also to adjust equities arising between the parties out of their relation to the common property sought to be divided. A sharer claiming partition has a clear right to an account of the profits received by the person in possession of the common property and to be awarded his share thereof not as mesne profits but as appurtenant to his right in his share of the lands. The profits accruing from the common properties forming the subject matter of the division during the pendency of the suit form part and parcel of the corpus itself and are as much in the hotchpot as the lands themselves. It is not correct to regard the claim for profits put forward in a suit for partition by a sharer of joint family property or of coownership property as a claim for mesne profits falling under O.20 R.12 CPC. In our view, it is part of the legitimate function of a court passing a final decree in a suit for partition and effectuating a division of properties pursuant to a preliminary decree to make a division of the profits that have accrued from such properties pending the suit as such profits really form part of the corpus available for division.

    8. Hence we are clearly of opinion that in a partition suit it is perfectly open to the court to adjudicate on the claim for future profits put forward by a sharer during the final decree stage even though there is no provision or direction contained in that behalf in the preliminary decree. The lower court was therefore right in holding that despite the preliminary decree being silent on the question of future profits, it had jurisdiction to inquire into the plaintiff's claim for future profits at the final decree stage and to pass a decree awarding future profits to the plaintiffs.

    9. The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal, therefore, fails and is dismissed with costs to the plaintiffs respondents.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mariyumma v. Kunhambu Nair
    (Jul 26, 1967)