Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • RIGHT TO INFORMATION ACT 2005
  • sub-section (1) of Section 6 and sub-sections (1) and (5) of Section 7
  • clauses (b) and (c) of section 4(1) of RTI Act). (iii) Information
  • provisions of Section 2(h) of Right to Information Act
  • Central and State Information Commission. Section 19
  • provisions of clauses (a), (c) and (i) of sub-section (1),
  • provisions of the Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950.
  • clauses (b) and (c) of section 4(1) of RTI Act). (ii)
  • SECTION 8 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT 2002
  • provisions of Section 2(h) of the R.T.I. Act.
  • R.T.I. Act." "24. Section 3 of the R.T.I. Act
  • Information Act, 2005 (in short, R.T.I. Act).
  • 19. Moreover, Section 4 of the R.T.I. Act
  • Authority u/s 2(h) of the R.T.I. Act.
  • Information Commission. Section 20
  • (j) of Section 2 of the R.T.I.Act
  • provisions of the R.T.I. Act. 15.
  • Section 2(f) of the R.T.I. Act
  • Section 7(5) of the R.T.I. Act
  • Public Authorities. Section 4
  • provisions of sub-section (6),
  • Section 9 of the R.T.I. Act.
  • clause (b) of sub-section (1)
  • constitution. Section 7(5)
  • Section 2(j)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • RIGHT TO INFORMATION ACT 2005
  • sub-section (1) of Section 6 and sub-sections (1) and (5) of Section 7
  • clauses (b) and (c) of section 4(1) of RTI Act). (iii) Information
  • provisions of Section 2(h) of Right to Information Act
  • Central and State Information Commission. Section 19
  • provisions of clauses (a), (c) and (i) of sub-section (1),
  • provisions of the Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950.
  • clauses (b) and (c) of section 4(1) of RTI Act). (ii)
  • SECTION 8 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT 2002
  • provisions of Section 2(h) of the R.T.I. Act.
  • R.T.I. Act." "24. Section 3 of the R.T.I. Act
  • Information Act, 2005 (in short, R.T.I. Act).
  • 19. Moreover, Section 4 of the R.T.I. Act
  • Authority u/s 2(h) of the R.T.I. Act.
  • Information Commission. Section 20
  • (j) of Section 2 of the R.T.I.Act
  • provisions of the R.T.I. Act. 15.
  • Section 2(f) of the R.T.I. Act
  • Section 7(5) of the R.T.I. Act
  • Public Authorities. Section 4
  • provisions of sub-section (6),
  • Section 9 of the R.T.I. Act.
  • clause (b) of sub-section (1)
  • constitution. Section 7(5)
  • Section 2(j)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a Society registered under the Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950, running two educational institutions with approximately 700 students, filed a writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 read with Article 19(1)(g) and Article 21 of the Constitution of India. The grievance arises from applications filed by respondent No.4 under the Right to Information Act, 2005 (RTI Act), which the petitioner claims are vague, voluminous, and unconnected to its activities, causing harassment. The petitioner contends it is not a Public Authority under Section 2(h) of the RTI Act and challenges the proviso to Section 7(5) of the RTI Act as ultra vires the Constitution. The petition seeks to quash the proviso to Section 7(5), declare the petitioner not a Public Authority under Section 2(h), and relieve it from responding to respondent No.4's RTI applications.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is a Public Authority within the meaning of Section 2(h) of the Right to Information Act, 2005.
  2. Whether the proviso to Section 7(5) of the RTI Act is arbitrary and ultra vires the Constitution.
  3. Whether the petitioner can be exempted from furnishing information to respondent No.4 under the RTI Act on grounds of harassment and burden.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Respondent No.4 has no connection with the petitioner's business or work activities.
  • The RTI application filed by respondent No.4 is intended solely to harass the petitioner's office bearers.
  • The petitioner is already subject to furnishing information to various statutory authorities, and additional RTI applications impose an undue burden.
  • The proviso to Section 7(5) of the RTI Act is ultra vires the Constitution as it imposes an onerous financial and administrative burden on the petitioner to supply voluminous records.
  • The RTI Act is being misused by persons like respondent No.4 for harassment rather than legitimate purposes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Central Board of Secondary Education and Another Vs. Aditya Bandopadhyay and others, 2011(8) SCC 497 Interpretation of RTI Act's purpose, scope, exemptions, and obligations of Public Authorities; emphasis on right to information as a fundamental right under Article 19(1)(a). Used extensively to explain the scheme of the RTI Act, the definition of Public Authority, the right to information, exemptions, and the balance between transparency and confidentiality.
State of U.P. Vs. Raj Narain Public's right to know and transparency in government transactions as part of freedom of speech. Supported the principle that citizens have a right to know public acts and transactions, reinforcing the importance of RTI.
Dinesh Trivedi Vs. Union of India, (1997) 4 SCC 306 Right to know subject to reasonable restrictions; the need to balance transparency with public security and administrative efficiency. Emphasized the need for a fine balance between the right to information and the potential chilling effect of indiscriminate disclosure on governance.
People's Union for Civil Liberties Vs. Union of India Right to information as part of freedom of speech under Article 19(1)(a), subject to reasonable restrictions. Reinforced that the right to information is a facet of fundamental freedoms but can be restricted in the interest of state security and other exceptions.
Chief Information Commissioner and Another Vs. State of Manipur and Another, AIR 2012 SC 864 Right to information is intrinsic to free speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a); importance of openness in governance. Used to underline the fundamental nature of the right and the societal value of transparency and judicial discretion favoring free speech.
Public Information Officer and another Vs. Manohar Parrikar and another, 2012(1) Bom.C.R. 558 Explanation of RTI Act provisions including rights of citizens, obligations of Public Information Officers, and procedural aspects under the Act. Clarified the statutory framework and procedural requirements of the RTI Act relevant to the case.
Board of Management of Bombay Properties of Indian Institute of Science Vs. Central Information Commission and others, 2011(1) Bom.C.R. 32 Locus standi of applicants under RTI Act; obligation to furnish information regardless of applicant's intention. Rejected the petitioner's argument questioning the intention of the applicant, affirming that intention is not a ground to refuse information.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted the fundamental right to information under Article 19(1)(a) and the comprehensive scheme of the RTI Act as elucidated by the Supreme Court and this Court in the cited precedents. It emphasized that the RTI Act aims to promote transparency and accountability in public authorities, while also balancing other public interests such as confidentiality and administrative efficiency.

The petitioner’s claim that it is not a Public Authority under Section 2(h) of the RTI Act was rejected on the ground that the petitioner must first deal with the RTI application filed by respondent No.4 under the statutory provisions before seeking judicial intervention. The Court observed that the writ jurisdiction should not be invoked prematurely, especially against a private individual, and that the petitioner’s decision on the RTI application is subject to judicial scrutiny under the Act.

The challenge to the proviso to Section 7(5), which prescribes fees for providing information except for persons below the poverty line, was found to be unsustainable. The Court held that the financial burden argument is weak since fees are to be paid by the applicant, not the Public Authority, and the exemption for below poverty line applicants is determined by the appropriate Government.

The Court further reiterated the obligations of Public Authorities under Section 4 of the RTI Act to maintain and disseminate records and rejected the petitioner's contention that supplying documents is an onerous task. The Court underscored that when the law mandates record preservation, furnishing copies cannot be considered burdensome.

Ultimately, the Court dismissed the petition as devoid of merit, emphasizing the importance of the RTI Act’s objectives and cautioning against misuse but affirming the statutory framework for addressing grievances.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed.

The Court held that the petitioner is not excused from responding to RTI applications on grounds of alleged harassment or burden without first complying with the statutory procedure. The proviso to Section 7(5) of the RTI Act is valid and not ultra vires the Constitution. The petitioner must address the RTI application filed by respondent No.4 in accordance with the Act, and any aggrieved party may seek judicial review subsequently.

This decision directly affects the parties by requiring the petitioner to comply with the RTI Act procedures and denies the relief sought. No new precedent altering the scope of the RTI Act or its constitutional validity was established.

    Sir Sayyed Education Society v. State Of Maharashtra Through The Secretary, For Education Department Others

    RavindraV.Ghuge, J.

    1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard finally by consent of the parties.

    2. The petitioner has preferred this writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 r/w 19(1)(g) and 21 of The Constitution of India. Grievance is that the petitioner, finds itself harassed by the applications filed by respondent No.4 under the Right to Information Act, 2005 (in short, R.T.I. Act).

    3. The petitioner is a Society registered under the provisions of the Bombay Public Trust Act, 1950. It has two educational institutions, imparting education. It is claimed that there are 700 students taking education in the Secondary and Higher Secondary school, run by the petitioner, at Sakali, Tal. Yawal, Dist. Jalgaon. Respondent No.4 is a person unconnected with the petitioner trust and any of its institutions.

    4. The petitioner submits that several persons have, as on date, moved applications before it under the R.T.I. Act. On 03/01/2011, respondent No.4 moved an application seeking vague and voluminous uncalled for information from the petitioner. Respondent No.4 has no connection with the information sought. The petitioner claims that it is not a Public Authority as per the provisions of Section 2(h) of the R.T.I. Act. The petitioner, therefore, finds itself unduly harassed and bothered on account of such applications.

    5. In the light of the above, the petitioner has put forth the following prayers :-

    "(A) By issuing appropriate writ, order, direction or any other appropriate order in the nature of writ, the Hon'ble High Court may be pleased to quash and set aside the provisions of Section 7(5) proviso of Right to Information Act, 2005;

    (B) By issuing appropriate writ, order, direction or any other appropriate order in the nature of writ, the Hon'ble High Court may be pleased to declare that the petitioner is not a Public Authority as per the provisions of Section 2(h) of Right to Information Act and hence not liable to provide any information ;

    (C) By issuing appropriate writ, order or direction or any other appropriate order in the nature of writ, the Hon'ble High Court may be pleased to declare that the petitioner is not accountable or answerable to the application made by respondent No.4 under the Right to Information Act ;"

    6. The petitioner has raised several grounds for our consideration, which can be summarized as follows :

    (a) Respondent No.4 has no concern with the business / work activity of the petitioner Institution.

    (b) Application, seeking information, has been moved by respondent No.4 with the sole intention of harassing its office bearers.

    (c) The petitioner has to furnish information to various authorities like Charity Commissioner, Registrar of Societies and Education Officer, Zilla Parishad. Applications filed by the persons like respondent No.4, caused an undue burden on the petitioner.

    (d) The proviso to Section 7(5) of the R.T.I. Act is ultra-vires the Constitution. The petitioner would be unduly burdened by expenditure in supplying voluminous record running into hundreds and thousands of pages to persons unconnected with its Organization.

    (e) Persons like respondent No.4 are utilizing the provisions of the r.t.i. act, more in abuse or misuse than in utility or for a good cause.

    7. We have heard Mr.Barde, appearing for the petitioner and the learned A.G.P. on behalf of respondent Nos.1 to 3 and Mr.B.L.Sagar Killarikar for respondent No.5. Respondent No.4, though served, is absent. We have, with the assistance of the learned Advocates, gone through the petition paper book.

    8. A long standing need of the Society in garnering information was satisfied by the introduction of the R.T.I. Act, 2005. The said Act gave a right to an individual to seek information under the Scheme of the Act. The statement of objects and reasons, the preamble, the relevant provisions of the r.t.i. act and its entire scheme have been considered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Central Board of Secondary Education and Another Vs. Aditya Bandopadhyay and others, reported at 2011(8) SCC 497. Paragraph Nos.12 to 25, 59, 62, 63, 66 and 67 of the said judgment are reproduced thus :-

    "12. To consider these questions, it is necessary to refer to the Statement of Objects and Reasons, the Preamble and the relevant provisions of the r.t.i. act. The R.T.I. Act was enacted in order to ensure smoother, greater and more effective access to information and provide an effective framework for effectuating the right to information recognized under Article 19 of the Constitution. The Preamble to the Act declares the object sought to be achieved by the R.T.I. Act thus :

    "An Act to provide for setting out the practical regime of right to information for citizens to secure access to information under the control of public authorities, in order to promote transparency and accountability in the working of every public authority, the constitution of a Central Information Commission and State Information Commissions and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto."

    "Whereas the Constitution of India has established democratic republic;"

    "And whereas democracy requires an informed citizenry and transparency of information which are vital to its functioning and also to contain corruption and to hold Governments and their instrumentalities accountable to the governed;"

    "And whereas revelation of information in actual practice is likely to conflict with other public interests including efficient operations of the Governments, optimum use of limited fiscal resources and the preservation of confidentiality of sensitive information;"

    "And whereas it is necessary to harmonise these conflicting interests while preserving the paramountcy of the democratic ideal."

    "13. Chapter II of the act containing sections 3 to 11 deals with the right to information and obligations of public authorities. Section 3 provides for the right to information and reads thus :

    "Subject to the provisions of this Act, all citizens shall have the right to information." This section makes it clear that the R.T.I. Act gives a right to a citizen to only access information, but not to seek any consequential relief based on such information."

    "14. Section 4 deals with the obligations of public authorities to maintain the records in the manner provided and publish and disseminate the information in the manner provided. Section 6 deals with requests for obtaining information. It provides that the applicant making a request for information shall not be required to give any reason for requesting the information or any personal details except those that may be necessary for contacting him."

    "15. Section 8 deals with exemption from disclosure of information and is extracted below in its entirety:

    "8. Exemption from disclosure of information -

    (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, there shall be no obligation to give any citizen, -

    (a) information, disclosure of which would prejudicially affect the sovereignty and integrity of India, the security, strategic, scientific or economic interests of the State, relation with foreign State or lead to incitement of an offence ;

    (b) information which has been expressly forbidden to be published by any court of law or tribunal or the disclosure of which may constitute contempt of court;

    (c) information, the disclosure of which would cause a breach of privilege of Parliament or the State Legislature;

    (d) information including commercial confidence, trade secrets or intellectual property, the disclosure of which would harm the competitive position of a third party, unless the competent authority is satisfied that larger public interest warrants the disclosure of such information;

    (e) information available to a person in his fiduciary relationship unless the competent authority is satisfied that the larger public interest warrants the disclosure of such information ;

    (f) information received in confidence from foreign Government;

    (g) information, the disclosure of which would endanger the life or physical safety of any person or identify the source of information or assistance given in confidence for law enforcement or security purposes;

    (h) information which would impede the process of investigation or apprehension or prosecution of offenders;

    (i) cabinet papers including records of deliberations of the Council of Ministers, Secretaries and other officers; Provided that the decisions of Council of Ministers, the reasons thereof, and the material on the basis of which the decisions were taken shall be made public after the decision has been taken, and the matter is complete, or over:

    Provided further that those matters which come under the exemptions specified in this section shall not be disclosed;

    (j) information which relates to personal information the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or interest, or which would cause unwarranted invasion of the privacy of the individual unless the Central Public Information Officer or the State Public Information Officer or the appellate authority, as the case may be, is satisfied that the larger public interest justifies the disclosure of such information :

    Provided that the information which cannot be denied to Parliament or a State Legislature shall not be denied to any person.

    (2) Notwithstanding anything in the Official Secrets Act, 1923 (19 of 1923) nor any of the exemptions permissible in accordance with sub-section (1), a public authority may allow access to information, if public interest in disclosure outweighs the harm to the protected interests.

    (3) Subject to the provisions of clauses (a), (c) and (i) of sub-section (1), any information relating to any occurrence, event or matter which has taken place, occurred or happened twenty years before the date on which any request is made under Section 6 shall be provided to any person making a request under that section:

    Provided that where any question arises as to the date from which the said period of twenty years has to be computed, the decision of the Central Government shall be final, subject to the usual appeals provided for in this Act." (emphasis supplied)

    "16. Section 9 provides that without prejudice to the provisions of section 8, a request for information may be rejected if such a request for providing access would involve an infringement of copyright. Section 10 deals with severability of exempted information and sub-section (1) thereof is extracted below:

    "10 Severability - (1) Where a request for access to information is rejected on the ground that it is in relation to information which is exempt from disclosure, then, notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, access may be provided to that part of the record which does not contain any information which is exempt from disclosure under this Act and which can reasonably be severed from any part that contains exempt information."

    "17. Section 11 deals with the third-party information and sub-section (1) thereof is extracted below:

    "11 Third-party information - (1) Where a Central Public Information Officer or a State Public Information Officer, as the case may be, intends to disclose any information or record, or part thereof on a request made under this Act, which relates to or has been supplied by a third party and has been treated as confidential by that third party, the Central Public Information Officer or State Public Information Officer, as the case may be, shall, within five days from the receipt of the request, give a written notice to such third party of the request and of the fact that the Central Public Information Officer or State Public Information Officer, as the case may be, intends to disclose the information or record, or part thereof, and invite the third party to make a submission in writing or orally, regarding whether the information should be disclosed, and such submission of the third party shall be kept in view while taking a decision about disclosure of information:

    Provided that except in the case of trade or commercial secrets protected by law, disclosure may be allowed if the public interest in disclosure outweighs in importance any possible harm or injury to the interests of such third party."

    "18. The definitions of "information", "public authority", "record and right to information" in clauses (f), (h), (i) and (j) of Section 2 of the R.T.I.Act are extracted below:

    "2.(f) 'information' means any material in any form, including records, documents, memos, e-mails, opinions, advices, press releases, circulars, orders, logbooks, contracts, reports, papers, samples, models, data material held in any electronic form and information relating to any private body which can be accessed by a public authority under any other law for the time being in force ;

    (h) 'public authority' means any authority or body or institution of self-government established or constituted -

    (a) by or under the Constitution;

    (b) by any other law made by Parliament;

    (c) by any other law made by State Legislature;

    (d) by notification issued or order made by the appropriate Government, and includes any -

    (i) body owned, controlled or substantially financed;

    (ii) non-government organization substantially financed, directly or indirectly by funds provided by the appropriate Government;

    (i) 'record' includes -

    (a) any document, manuscript and file;

    (b) any microfilm, microfiche and facsimile copy of a document;

    (c) any reproduction of image or images embodied in such microfilm (whether enlarged or not); and

    (d) any other material produced by a computer or any other device;

    (j) 'right to information means the right to information accessible under this Act which is held by or under the control of any public authority and includes the right to -

    (i) inspection of work, documents, records;

    (ii) taking notes, extracts or certified copies of documents or records;

    (iii) taking certified samples of material;

    (iv) obtaining information in the form of diskettes, floppies, tapes, video cassettes or in any other electronic mode or through printouts where such information is stored in a computer or in any other device."

    "19. Section 22 provides for the Act to have overriding effect and is extracted below:

    "22. Act to have overriding effect - The provisions of this Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in the Official Secrets Act, 1923 (19 of 1923), and any other law for the time being in force or in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law other than this Act."

    "20. It will also be useful to refer to a few decisions of this Court which considered the importance and scope of the right to information. In State of U.P. Vs. Raj Narain, this Court observed : (SCC p.453, para 74)

    "74. In a Government of responsibility like ours, where all the agents of the public must be responsible for their conduct, there can be but few secrets. The people of this country have a right to know every public act, everything that is done in a public way, by their public functionaries. They are entitled to know the particulars of every public transaction in all its bearing. The right to know, which is derived from the concept of freedom of speech, though not absolute, is a factor which should make one wary, when secrecy is claimed for transactions which can, at any rate, have no repercussion on public security."
    (emphasis supplied)

    "21. In Dinesh Trivedi Vs. Union of India, this Court held : (1997) 4 (SCC pp.313-14 paras 16-17)

    "16. In modern constitutional democracies, it is axiomatic that citizens have a right to know about the affairs of the Government, which having been elected by them, seeks to formulate sound policies of governance aimed at their welfare. However, like all other rights, even this right has recognized limitations; it is, by no means, absolute....."

    "17. Implicit in this assertion is the proposition that in transactions which have serious repercussions on public security, secrecy can legitimately be claimed because it would then be in the public interest that such matters are not publicly disclosed or disseminated."

    "22. In People's Union for Civil Liberties V. Union of India, this Court held that right to information is a facet of the freedom of "speech and expression" as contained in Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India and such a right is subject to any reasonable restriction in the interest of the security of the State and subject to exemptions and exceptions."

    "23. The definition of "information" in Section 2(f) of the R.T.I. Act refers to any material in any form which includes records, documents, opinions, papers among several other enumerated items. The term "record" is defined in Section 2(i) of the said Act as including any document, manuscript or file among others. When a candidate participates in an examination and writes his answers in an answer book and submits it to the examining body for evaluation and declaration of the result, the answer book is a document or record. When the answer book is evaluated by an examiner appointed by the examining body, the evaluated answer book becomes a record containing the "opinion" of the examiner. Therefore, the evaluated answer book is also an "information" under the R.T.I. Act."

    "24. Section 3 of the R.T.I. Act provides that subject to the provisions of this Act all the citizens shall have the right to information. The term "right to information" is defined in Section 2(j) as the right to information accessible under the Act which is held by or under the control of any public authority. Having regard to Section 3, the citizens have the right to access to all the information held by or under the control of any public authority except those excluded or exempted under the Act. The object of the Act is to empower the citizens to fight against corruption and hold the Government and their instrumentalities accountable to the citizens, by providing them access to information regarding functioning of every public authority."

    "25. Certain safeguards have been built into the Act so that the revelation of information will not conflict with other public interests which include efficient operation of the Governments, optimum use of limited fiscal resources and preservation of confidential and sensitive information. The R.T.I. Act provides access to information held by or under the control of public authorities and not in regard to information held by any private person. The Act provides for the following exclusions by way of exemptions and exceptions (under Sections 8, 9 and 24) in regard to information held by the public authorities :

    (i) Exclusion of the Act in entirety under Section 24 to intelligence and security organizations specified in the Second Schedule even though they may be "public authorities" (except in regard to information with reference to allegations of corruption and human rights violations).

    (ii) Exemption of the several categories of information enumerated in Section 8(1) of the Act which no public authority is under an obligation to give to any citizen, notwithstanding anything contained in the Act [however, in regard to the information exempted under clauses (d) and (e), the competent authority, and in regard to the information excluded under clause (j), the Central Public Information Officer /State Public Information Officer / the appellate authority, may direct disclosure of information, if larger public interest warrants or justifies the disclosure].

    (iii) If any request for providing access to information involves an infringement of a copyright subsisting in a person other than the State, the Central / State Public Information Officer may reject the request under Section 9 of the R.T.I. Act.

    "Having regard to the scheme of the R.T.I. Act, the right of the citizens to access any information held or under the control of any public authority, should be read in harmony with the exclusions/exemptions in the Act."

    "59. The effect of the provisions and scheme of the RTI Act is to divide 'information' into the three categories. They are :

    (i) Information which promotes transparency and accountability in the working of every public authority, disclosure of which may also help in containing or discouraging corruption (enumerated in clauses (b) and (c) of section 4(1) of RTI Act).

    (ii) Other information held by public authority (that is all information other than those falling under clauses (b) and (c) of section 4(1) of RTI Act).

    (iii) Information which is not held by or under the control of any public authority and which cannot be accessed by a public authority under any law for the time being in force. Information under the third category does not fall within the scope of rti act. section 3 of rti act gives every citizen, the right to 'information' held by or under the control of a public authority, which falls either under the first or second category. In regard to the information falling under the first category, there is also a special responsibility upon public authorities to suo -moto publish and disseminate such information so that they will be easily and readily accessible to the public without any need to access them by having recourse to section 6 of rti act. There is no such obligation to publish and disseminate the other information which falls under the second category."

    "62. When trying to ensure that the right to information does not conflict with several other public interests (which includes efficient operations of the governments, preservation of confidentiality of sensitive information, optimum use of limited fiscal resources, etc.), it is difficult to visualise and enumerate all types of information which require to be exempted from disclosure in public interest. The legislature has however made an attempt to do so. The enumeration of exemptions is more exhaustive than the enumeration of exemptions attempted in the earlier Act that is section 8 of Freedom to Information Act, 2002. The Courts and Information Commissions enforcing the provisions of RTI Act have to adopt a purposive construction, involving a reasonable and balanced approach which harmonises the two objects of the Act, while interpreting section 8 and the other provisions of the Act."

    "63. At this juncture, it is necessary to clear some misconceptions about the RTI Act. The RTI Act provides access to all information that is available and existing. This is clear from a combined reading of section 3 and the definitions of 'information' and 'right to information' under clauses (f) and (j) of section 2 of the Act. If a public authority has any information in the form of data or analysed data, or abstracts, or statistics, an applicant may access such information, subject to the exemptions in section 8 of the Act. But where the information sought is not a part of the record of a public authority, and where such information is not required to be maintained under any law or the rules or regulations of the public authority, the Act does not cast an obligation upon the public authority, to collect or collate such non-available information and then furnish it to an applicant. A public authority is also not required to furnish information which require drawing of inferences and/or making of assumptions. It is also not required to provide 'advice' or 'opinion' to an applicant, nor required to obtain and furnish any 'opinion' or 'advice' to an applicant. The reference to 'opinion' or 'advice' in the definition of 'information' in section 2(f) of the Act, only refers to such material available in the records of the public authority. Many public authorities have, as a public relation exercise, provide advice, guidance and opinion to the citizens. But that is purely voluntary and should not be confused with any obligation under the RTI Act."

    "66. The right to information is a cherished right. Information and right to information are intended to be formidable tools in the hands of responsible citizens to fight corruption and to bring in transparency and accountability. The provisions of RTI Act should be enforced strictly and all efforts should be made to bring to light the necessary information under clause (b) of section 4(1) of the Act which relates to securing transparency and accountability in the working of public authorities and in discouraging corruption. But in regard to other information,(that is information other than those enumerated in section 4(1)(b) and (c) of the Act), equal importance and emphasis are given to other public interests (like confidentiality of sensitive information, fidelity and fiduciary relationships, efficient operation of governments, etc.)."

    "67. Indiscriminate and impractical demands or directions under RTI Act for disclosure of all and sundry information (unrelated to transparency and accountability in the functioning of public authorities and eradication of corruption) would be counter-productive as it will adversely affect the efficiency of the administration and result in the executive getting bogged down with the non-productive work of collecting and furnishing information. The Act should not be allowed to be misused or abused, to become a tool to obstruct the national development and integration, or to destroy the peace, tranquility and harmony among its citizens. Nor should it be converted into a tool of oppression or intimidation of honest officials striving to do their duty. The nation does not want a scenario where 75% of the staff of public authorities spends 75% of their time in collecting and furnishing information to applicants instead of discharging their regular duties. The threat of penalties under the RTI Act and the pressure of the authorities under the RTI Act should not lead to employees of a public authorities prioritizing 'information furnishing', at the cost of their normal and regular duties."

    9. In the case of Chief Information Commissioner and Another Vs. State of Manipur and another, reported at AIR 2012, SC 864, it is held that :

    "11. It is, therefore, clear from the ratio in the above decisions of the Constitution Bench of this Court that the right to information, which is basically founded on the right to know, is an intrinsic part of the fundamental right to free speech and expression guaranteed under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution. The said Act was, thus, enacted to consolidate the fundamental right of free speech."

    "16. The exercise of judicial discretion in favour of free speech is not only peculiar to our jurisprudence, the same is a part of the jurisprudence in all the countries which are governed by rule of law with an independent judiciary. In this connection, if we may quote what Lord Acton said in one of his speeches: "Everything secret degenerates, even the administration of justice; nothing is safe that does not show how it can bear discussion and publicity."

    "17. It is, therefore, clear that a society which adopts openness as a value of overarching significance not only permits its citizens a wide range of freedom of expression, it also goes further in actually opening up the deliberative process of the Government itself to the sunlight of public scrutiny."

    "20. However, while considering the width and sweep of this right as well as its fundamental importance in a democratic republic, this Court is also conscious that such a right is subject to reasonable restrictions under Article 19(2) of the Constitution."

    "21. Thus note of caution has been sounded by this Court in Dinesh Trivedi, M.P. & Others v. Union of India & others -(1997) 4 SCC 306 where it has been held as follows:

    "...Sunlight is the best disinfectant. But it is equally important to be alive to the dangers that lie ahead. It is important to realize that undue popular pressure brought to bear on decision makers in Government can have frightening side-effects. If every action taken by the political or executive functionary is transformed into a public controversy and made subject to an enquiry to soothe popular sentiments, it will undoubtedly have a chilling effect on the independence of the decision maker who may find it safer not to take any decision. It will paralyse the entire system and bring it to a grinding halt. So we have two conflicting situations almost enigmatic and we think the answer is to maintain a fine balance which would serve public interest."

    "25. It is quite interesting to note that even though under Section 3 of the Act right of all citizens, to receive information, is statutorily recognised but Section 6 gives the said right to any person. Therefore, Section 6, in a sense, is wider in its ambit than Section 3."

    10. In the case of Public Information Officer and another Vs. Manohar Parrikar and another, reported at 2012(1) Bom.C.R. 558, it is held as under in paragraph No.12 :-

    "12. Section 3 of the RTI Act confers upon a citizen right to have an information. Indeed, it only recognizes the right which already exists in a citizen to have an information which is regarded as a fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) of The Constitution [See: (Central Public Information Officer Vs. Subhash Chandra Agarwal) 2010, DGLS (soft) 2314 : (2011) S.C.C. 496 and the (Hindu Urban Co-operative Bank Ltd., Vs. The State Information Commission) - Civil Writ Petition No.19224 of 2006 decided on 9th May, 2010 by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Coram : Mohinder Singh Sullar, J.]

    "section 4 of the rti act confers a corresponding obligation on the public authority to give information. section 5 of the rti act request the public authority to designate as many PIOs as may be necessary to provide the informations to the persons requesting for an information. Section 6 prescribes the manner in which a citizen is required to make a request for an information to the PIO. Section 7 casts an obligation on the PIO to give the information. Section 8, as noticed earlier, grants exemption from disclosure of certain information. Section 9 also empowers the PIO to refuse an information where the request for providing access would involve an infringement of a copyright subsisting in any person other than the State. Section 11 provides for a procedure to be followed where the disclosure of the information relates to a third party. Sections 12 to 17 contained in Chapter III make a provision for constitution of Central and State Information Commission, their members, terms and conditions of their service, their appointment and removal. Section 18 defines the power and functions of the Central and State Information Commission. Section 19 provides for an appeal against a decision of the PIO to the first Appellate Authority and a further appeal against a decision of the first Appellate Authority to the Information Commission. Section 20 provides for a penalty which can be imposed by the Information Commission on the PIO at the time of deciding any complaint or appeal under section 19 of the rti act."

    11. In the case of Board of Management of Bombay Properties of Indian Institute of Science Vs. Central Information Commission and others, 2011(1) Bom.C.R. 32, it is held that,

    "As per section 3 of the Act, subject to the provisions therein, all citizens shall have the right to information. Section 6(1) of the Act states that a person, who desires to obtain any information under the Act, shall make a request in writing or through electronic means specifying the particulars of the information sought by him/her. Sub-section (2) of section 6 of the Act states that an applicant making request for information shall not be required to give any reason for requesting the information or any other personal details except those that may be necessary for contacting him. It is thus clear that while entertaining an application for information made under the Act, the locus standi or the intention of the applicant cannot be questioned and is required to furnish all the information sought by him except what has been exempted under section 8 therein."

    12. Having considered the submissions of the petitioner and in the light of the observations of the Apex Court and our Court in the judgments referred above (supra), we are unable to accept the contentions of the petitioner for reasons more than one. Firstly, that the petitioner has rushed to this Court claiming a relief against a private individual respondent No.4. Respondent Nos.1 to 3 and 5 appear to have been arrayed so as to render the matter maintainable under the writ jurisdiction of this Court. Secondly, the petitioner needs to test its contention that it is not a public Authority u/s 2(h) of the R.T.I. Act.

    13. The petitioner needs to take a specific stand under the provisions of the Act while dealing with the application of respondent No.4. Instead of rushing to this Court, the petitioner should first deal with the application filed by respondent No.4, which is pending before it. It's decision will always be subject to judicial scrutiny under the Act.

    14. By this judgment, we are not expressing a view that any application, seeking any information, ought to be accepted by an Establishment and the information sought should be given to the applicant. Every authority has the scope to look into the application filed before it and decide the said application in accordance with the provisions of the r.t.i. act.

    15. Ultimately, the intent and object of the Act has to be achieved, in as much as, the petitioner cannot be excused from deciding the application filed by respondent No.4 merely on the ground of hardships. We are thus unable to accept the contention of the petitioner and entertain the prayers made in this petition.

    16. The petitioner has raised a challenge to the proviso below Section 7(5) of the R.T.I. Act terming it to be arbitrary and ultra-virus the constitution. Section 7(5) and the proviso there below read thus :

    "Where access to information is to be provided in the printed or in any electronic format, the applicant shall, subject to the provisions of sub-section (6), pay such fee as may be prescribed:

    Provided that the fee prescribed under sub-section (1) of Section 6 and sub-sections (1) and (5) of Section 7 shall be reasonable and no such fee shall be charged from the persons who are below poverty line as may be determined by the appropriate Government."

    Besides terming the said proviso to be arbitrary and ultra-vires, there has been no other submission put forth by the petitioner.

    17. The proviso to Section 7(5) pertains to the fee to be prescribed u/s 6(1) and section 7(1) and 7(5) of the Act. In all these situations, the applicant who demands documents, is required to pay the requisite charges. The only exception carved out is that no fee shall be charged from a person who is below poverty line.

    18. The contention of the petitioner that it is an onerous task and a financial burden to prepare copies of documents to be supplied to the applicant, clearly appears to be unsustainable since the charges are to be paid by the applicant. If the applicant makes a claim that he is below poverty line, the same has to be determined by the appropriate Government in view of the proviso to Section 7(5). As such, this argument appears to be highly feeble and we find that it does not deserve any consideration. The said contention and the challenge to the proviso to Section 7(5) at the behest of the petitioner in the above circumstances is, therefore, required to be turned down.

    19. Moreover, Section 4 of the R.T.I. Act casts certain obligations on Public Authorities. Section 4 reads as under :

    "4. Obligations of public authorities : 1. Every public authority shall-

    a. maintain all its records duly catalogued and indexed in a manner and the form which facilitates the right to information under this Act and ensure that all records that are appropriate to be computerised are, within a reasonable time and subject to availability of resources, computerised and connected through a network all over the country on different systems so that access to such records is facilitated;

    b. publish within one hundred and twenty days from the enactment of this Act,-

    i. the particulars of its organisation, functions and duties;

    ii. the powers and duties of its officers and employees;

    iii. the procedure followed in the decision making process, including channels of supervision and accountability;

    iv. the norms set by it for the discharge of its functions;

    v. the rules, regulations, instructions, manuals and records, held by it or under its control or used by its employees for discharging its functions;

    vi. a statement of the categories of documents that are held by it or under its control;

    vii. the particulars of any arrangement that exists for consultation with, or representation by, the members of the public in relation to the formulation of its policy or implementation thereof;

    viii. a statement of the boards, councils, committees and other bodies consisting of two or more persons constituted as its part or for the purpose of its advice, and as to whether meetings of those boards, councils, committees and other bodies are open to the public, or the minutes of such meetings are accessible for public; ix. a directory of its officers and employees;

    x. the monthly remuneration received by each of its officers and employees, including the system of compensation as provided in its regulations;

    xi. the budget allocated to each of its agency, indicating the particulars of all plans, proposed expenditures and reports on disbursements made; xii. the manner of execution of subsidy programmes, including the amounts allocated and the details of beneficiaries of such programmes;

    xiii. particulars of recipients of concessions, permits or authorisations granted by it;

    xiv. details in respect of the information, available to or held by it, reduced in an electronic form;

    xv. the particulars of facilities available to citizens for obtaining information, including the working hours of a library or reading room, if maintained for public use; xvi. the names, designations and other particulars of the Public Information Officers;

    xvii. such other information as may be prescribed and thereafter update these publications every year;

    c. publish all relevant facts while formulating important policies or announcing the decisions which affect public;

    d. provide reasons for its administrative or quasi-judicial decisions to affected persons."

    "2. It shall be a constant endeavour of every public authority to take steps in accordance with the requirements of clause (b) of sub-section (1) to provide as much information suo motu to the public at regular intervals through various means of communications, including internet, so that the public have minimum resort to the use of this Act to obtain information."

    "3. For the purposes of sub-section (1), every information shall be disseminated widely and in such form and manner which is easily accessible to the public."

    "4. All materials shall be disseminated taking into consideration the cost effectiveness, local language and the most effective method of communication in that local area and the information should be easily accessible, to the extent possible in electronic format with the Central Public Information Officer or State Public Information Officer, as the case may be, available free or at such cost of the medium or the print cost price as may be prescribed.

    Explanation.- For the purposes of sub-sections (3) and (4), "disseminated" means making known or communicated the information to the public through notice boards, newspapers, public announcements, media broadcasts, the internet or any other means, including inspection of offices of any public authority."

    20. Needless to state and as observed by the Hon'ble Apex Court in paragraph No.14 in the case of C.B.S.E. And another (supra), Public Authorities are under an obligation to maintain records and disseminate the information in the manner provided under Section 4 of The R.T.I. Act. The submission of the petitioner that it is an onerous task to supply documents, therefore, is required to be rejected. When the Law mandates preserving of documents, supplying copies thereof to an applicant, in our view, cannot be said to be an onerous task.

    21. In the light of the above, this petition is devoid of merits and therefore, stands dismissed. Rule is discharged with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sir Sayyed Education... v. State Of Maharashtra...
    (Feb 12, 2014)