AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 6 of Act 19/06
  • S. 6 of Act 19
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 6 of Act 19/06
  • S. 6 of Act 19
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition challenges Ext. P5, an order dated 26-04-2007 passed by the Fee Regulatory Committee for Professional Colleges (the "Committee"). The petitioner contends that the Committee exceeded the powers conferred on it under S. 6 of Act 19 of 2006 by interfering with the management's power to fix fee structure.

The Government of Kerala constituted the Fee Regulatory Committee under S.6 of Act 19 of 2006. Pursuant to a communication dated 18-01-2007 (Ext. P1), the Committee directed managements to forward proposed fee structures for academic years 2007-08 to 2009-10, together with supporting documents and audited accounts for specified prior years. The petitioner submitted its proposal on 15-03-2007 proposing a fee of Rs. 3,20,000 per student per year and supplied projected income and expenditure, chartered accountant's report and audited financial statements.

The petitioner attended hearings on 10-04-2007 and 26-04-2007. The petitioner says no clarifications were sought at those hearings. The Committee issued Ext. P5 on 26-04-2007 fixing the fee at Rs. 1,30,000 per student per annum for the petitioner's institution for academic years 2007-08, 2008-09 and 2009-10. The petitioner challenged Ext. P5 by the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Fee Regulatory Committee, under S.6 of Act 19 of 2006, exceeded its powers by effectively fixing a fee structure instead of restricting its intervention to regulation of profiteering or charging of capitation fee.
  2. Whether the Committee, in making Ext. P5, properly identified and communicated any specific elements of profiteering or capitation fee in the petitioner's proposed fee structure so as to permit the petitioner to explain or rectify them.
  3. Whether the Committee lawfully disallowed particular expense items claimed by the petitioner (for example, depreciation on land, building, equipment and machinery; interest on borrowed capital; certain salary expenses; chapel and hospital expenses) without adequate reason or specific findings of profiteering.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Committee failed to apply the legal principles laid down by this Court (in Lisie Medical & Educational Institutions) and the Supreme Court authorities relied upon therein, which recognize that the fixing of fees is primarily the right of the institution except to the extent of regulating profiteering and capitation fee.
  • Ext. P5 demonstrates that the Committee attempted to fix a fee of its own rather than examine whether the petitioner's proposed fees contained any element of profiteering or capitation fee.
  • The Committee wrongly disallowed depreciation on land, buildings, equipment and machinery and ignored that part of the investment was borrowed capital carrying interest (an expense). Depreciation on equipment and machinery is a legitimate annual charge to be borne by users (students).
  • The Committee ignored actual salary payments (which exceed Medical Council norms) and did not give credit for salaries actually paid despite audited accounts and details being furnished.
  • The Committee disallowed expenses for the chapel while considering income from it, and took income from the hospital without allowing corresponding expenses; it also assumed without data a hypothetical net income of Rs. 200 per bed per day for the hospital and loaded it as income.
  • The Committee reduced the development reserve allowance from 15% (claimed by petitioner and stated to be reasonable by the Supreme Court) to 10% without justification, and appears to have aimed to make fees uniform (around Rs. 1,30,000) across institutions.
  • The petitioner asserts it furnished all documents requested and would have supplied explanations if specific queries had been posed in writing.

Respondent's (Committee's) Arguments

  • The Committee is not bound to accept the fee structure submitted by the management and, depending upon the facts of each case, may modify the fee structure fixed by institutions.
  • The Committee examined all materials furnished by the management and, after consideration, fixed an amount of Rs. 1,30,000 per student per annum for the petitioner's institution for the academic years 2007-08 to 2009-10.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lisie Medical & Educational Institutions v. State of Kerala, 2007 (1) KLT 409 : ILR 2007 (1) Ker. 81 Affirms that the fee has to be decided by the institutions themselves and such right cannot be arrogated by the State or Committee; committees may only regulate profiteering or capitation fee and, if needed, modify fees to the extent of removing profiteering/capitation. The Court placed reliance on this decision to hold that the Committee exceeded its powers by not specifically identifying elements of profiteering/capitation and effectively fixing fees; the Court directed the Committee to identify specific areas of concern in writing so the management can respond.
TMA Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka, (2002) 8 SCC 481 : AIR 2003 SC 355 Authority establishing principles regarding the right of educational institutions in fixing fees and the limited scope of State interference (as cited by this Court through Lisie Medical). The Court relied on this Supreme Court authority (as relied upon in Lisie) to frame the principle that committees cannot arrogate the right to fix fees beyond regulating profiteering/capitation.
Islamic Academy of Education v. State of Karnataka, (2003) 6 SCC 697 : AIR 2003 SC 3724 Further Supreme Court authority on the autonomy of educational institutions in fee fixation subject to prevention of profiteering and capitation fee. Referenced (via Lisie) as part of the line of Supreme Court decisions confirming the limited regulatory role of committees/government over fee fixation.
P.A. Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra, (2005) 6 SCC 537 : AIR 2005 SC 3226 Authority concerning the rights of private unaided institutions in matters of admission and related governance, referenced for the general principle of institutional autonomy in education (as cited in Lisie). Included among the Supreme Court authorities relied upon to support the proposition that committees may only examine fee structures for profiteering/capitation and not supplant the institutions' right to fix fees.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed Ext. P5 in its entirety and found no clear finding by the Committee identifying specific areas in which the petitioner's proposed fee structure contained elements of profiteering or capitation fee. The Court emphasized the principle, drawn from Lisie Medical & Educational Institutions (which itself relied on the Supreme Court authorities such as TMA Pai, Islamic Academy and Inamdar), that the right to fix fees vests primarily with the institution and that the Committee's power is confined to regulating profiteering and capitation fee.

The Court reasoned that where a Committee suspects profiteering or capitation, it must point out the specific components or anomalies to the management in clear terms so that the management can either explain or rectify them. This process should be in writing to narrow areas of disagreement and to demonstrate application of mind by both the Committee and the management.

On the facts, the Court observed several specific deficiencies in Ext. P5: no specific identification of profiteering/capitation; disallowance of depreciation on equipment and machinery without legal basis despite the petitioner's claim that such depreciation represents genuine annual costs; disregard of interest on borrowed capital and of actual salary expenses supported by audited figures; selective disallowance of chapel expenses while including chapel income; taking hospital income without corresponding expenses and assuming a hypothetical net income for hospital beds without data. The Court also noted that the Committee fixed student strength figures and fees in a manner that suggested an attempt at uniformity (e.g., comparison with Amala Institute figures), rather than individualized assessment.

The Court compared the fee fixed by the Committee (Rs. 1,30,000) with the petitioner's proposed fee (Rs. 3,20,000) and with terms of an agreement (Ext. P7) involving seat- and fee-sharing in which the average agreed fee worked out to more than Rs. 3 lakhs; the Court observed that the petitioner's proposed fee was lower than the amount appearing from Ext. P7 and that seat-sharing under the agreement does not affect expenditure to run the college.

Based on the above, the Court concluded that Ext. P5 was unsustainable in the absence of specific findings of profiteering/capitation and appropriate written communication of alleged anomalies to the petitioner, and therefore directed that Ext. P5 be set aside and the matter remitted to the Committee with directions as to procedure and timelines.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Ext. P5 order dated 26/04/2007 passed by the Fee Regulatory Committee is set aside.

Directions and immediate consequences (as ordered by the Court):

  • The Regulatory Committee is directed to point out in writing any areas in the petitioner's fee proposal that it considers to contain elements of profiteering or capitation fee. This communication must be made within one week from the date of receipt of a copy of the judgment.
  • The petitioner may furnish a reply within three days of receipt of that communication.
  • On receipt of the reply, the Committee shall fix a date for hearing and dispose of the matter within two weeks thereafter.
  • The writ petition is disposed of on the basis of these directions.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is to annul the Committee's fee fixation in Ext. P5 and to require a procedurally proper reconsideration focused specifically on identification and examination of any profiteering or capitation elements, with opportunities for the petitioner to respond.
  • The judgment reiterates and applies established principles from earlier decisions (as summarized above) concerning the limited scope of regulatory interference with institutional fee fixation. The Court did not purport to set a new precedent beyond applying those authorities to the present facts.

This summary is strictly confined to the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond the judgment text.

    Malankara Orthodox S.C.M College v. Fee Regulatory Committee

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    K.S Radhakrishnan, J.:— Ext. P5 order passed by the Fee Regulatory Committee for Professional Colleges dated 26-4-2007 is under challenge in this Writ Petition on the ground that the Regulatory Committee has exceeded the powers conferred on it under S. 6 of Act 19/06 in interfering with the power of the management in fixing the fee structure.

    2. Petitioner has sought for a declaration that petitioner is entitled to collect fees from the students based on the fee structure proposed by them before the committee. Government of Kerala has constituted the Fee Regulatory Committee under S. 6 of Act 19 of 2006. Powers conferred on the Regulatory Committee under the Act was the subject matter of the decision of this Court in Lisie Medical & Educational Institutions v. State of Kerala (2007 (1) KLT 409 : ILR 2007 (1) Ker. 81). This Court placing reliance on the decision of the Supreme Court in TMA Pai Foundation case ((2002) 8 SCC 481), TMA Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka ((2002) 8 SCC 481 : AIR 2003 SC 355), Islamic Academy's case ((2003) 6 SCC 697) Islamic Academy of Education v. State of Karnataka (2003 (3) KLT SN 88 (C. No. 118) SC : (2003) 6 SCC 697 : AIR 2003 SC 3724 : JT 2003 (7) SC 1) and Inamdar's case ((2005) 6 SCC 537) P.A Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra (2005 (4) KLT SN 3 (C. No. 3) (SC) : ILR 2005 (4) Ker. 629 : (2005) 6 SCC 537 : AIR 2005 SC 3226) held as follows:—

    “It is further clear that the fee has to be decided by the institutions themselves and such right of the institutions cannot be arrogated by the State. While, however, fixing the fee structure, the institutions cannot indulge into profiteering nor can charge capitation fee, even though the element of surplus income to cater to the future needs of the institutions can be definitely taken into account while fixing the fee. The Committees that may be constituted or the law that may be even made could only regulate the profiteering and charging of capitation fee. The Committees would themselves have every right to modify the fee structure fixed by the institutions and debar institutions by an order and if legislation is made to that effect by law, to reduce the fee in the event of its coming to a finding that the fee structure had a component of profiteering and/or capitation fee, but nothing beyond that. The fixation of fee structure is the right of an institution particularly when unaided. The right of the Committees that may be constituted or the Government to legislate, in our considered view, cannot go beyond examining the fee structure to find out therein the element of profiteering or charge of capitation fee, be it by monitoring committees or by legislation.”

    (emphasis added)

    3. Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that the Committee has failed to bear in mind the above findings rendered by this Court while issuing Ext. P5 order, but indulged in an exercise to fix fee by itself without examining the question whether in fact there was any element of profiteering and/or capitation fee in the fixation of fee structure by the petitioner management. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent on the other hand contended that the Committee is not bound to accept the fee structure submitted by the management and in appropriate cases it can modify the fee structure fixed by the institutions depending upon the facts of each case. Learned counsel submitted that the Committee has examined all the materials furnished by the management and after taking into consideration of all aspects of the matter, an amount of Rs. 1,30,000/- was fixed per student per annum for the petitioner's institution for the academic years 2007-2008, 2008-2009 and 2009-2010.

    4. Ext. P1 is a communication dated 18-1 -2007 sent by the Regulatory Committee to the petitioner stating that the fee structure for each institution will have to be fixed by the management taking into account the factors such as the infrastructure facilities available, the investment made, salaries paid to the teachers and staff, future plans for expansion and/or betterment of the institution etc. Management was directed to forward the fee structure or their proposal for the academic years 2007-08 to 2009-2010 to the Committee along with the relevant documents and books of accounts, the income and expenditure statement, audited accounts and balance sheet for the last three years, i.e, 2003-04 to 2005-06. Proforma of statement to be filed by the self financing institutions was also attached along with that letter. Petitioner responded to the said letter and forwarded the fee structure fixed by them vide letter dated 15-3-2007 in the format supplied by the Regulatory Committee. Along with the letter the details of the projected income and expenditure with notes and chartered accountants report and also the annual report for the year 2005-06 and audited financial statements for 2003-04 and 2004-05 were also forwarded. Fee proposed by the petitioner was Rs. 3.2 lakhs per student per year.

    5. Petitioner later received a letter dated 03/04/2007 directing the petitioner to present for a hearing at the Committee's office on 10/04/2007. Petitioner has stated that as directed, the petitioner's representative appeared on that date but no clarification was sought for and they were under the impression that the fee structure fixed by them would be accepted. Committee raised no objection in any of the items of fees included and details furnished. Later petitioner was asked to be present on 26-4-2007. No questions or clarifications were elucidated from them and on the same day itself a very detailed order Ext. P5 was passed which is under challenge in this Writ Petition.

    6. Senior counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that Ext. P5 order would clearly indicate that the attempt of the Regulatory Committee was to fix a fee structure of its own rather than accepting the fee structure submitted by the petitioner. Counsel submitted that there is no case for the Committee that the fee structure forwarded by the petitioner had any element of profiteering or was there any indication for charging any capitation fee. Learned counsel submitted that the Committee has committed a grave error in disallowing depreciation on land and building, equipments and machinery. Learned counsel submitted that the petitioner has no intention to shift the burden of the investments on the students. Learned counsel submitted that out of the total investments made, a portion of it is borrowed capital from banks and for that borrowed capital there is a cost in the form of interests which is the actual expenses incurred for procuring the capital, which is allowable deduction under the Income Tax Act, which factor was completely ignored by the Committee. Learned counsel submitted that over and above the land and building, the major item of depreciation reckoned by the management while fixing fee structure was depreciation on equipments and machinery. Those items wear out and will have to be replaced. Counsel submitted that wearing out is by usage and therefore that is the actual cost of wear and actual expenses incurred over a period and the yearly proportion has to be loaded on the person using it in the form of depreciation.

    7. Learned counsel also submitted that the salary expenses shown is as per Medical Council Norms and the actual salary paid is much more than the MCI Norms and the petitioner is entitled to get credit to the actual salary paid and salaries are paid after deducting TDS and the entire audited figures were given and the details furnished were not adverted to by the Committee. Further it is also submitted that there is a small church in the campus and the Committee has disallowed the expenses for the Chapel, but has conveniently considered the income from the Church, which is much more than the expenses. Further it is also submitted that the Committee has taken the income from the hospital, but disallowed the expenses for the same. Counsel submitted that the Regulatory Committee has disallowed the various items on the ground of profiteering but has not pointed out any element of it. Counsel submitted that the management had claimed development reserve at 15% which was observed to be reasonable by the Supreme Court, but the committee has allowed only 10%. Further on a hypothetical figure, without any data the Committee had assumed a net income of Rs. 200/- per bed per day for the hospital and loaded it to the income head. On the whole, counsel submitted that the matter requires a thorough re-examination by the Committee, after giving an opportunity of being heard to the petitioner on the various materials produced. Counsel also submitted that the petitioner would have clarified all the queries if there was any. Counsel also submitted that the attempt of the Committee was somehow or other to fix the fee somewhere around Rs. 1,30,0007/- to almost all the colleges. On that basis, for Amala Institute of Medical Science the Committee had taken the student strength at 500, at the same time the student strength of the petitioner's college was fixed at 300 with an idea to bring the fee structure uniform.

    8. We have gone through Ext. P5 order in its entirety, and in our view, there is no clear finding by the Regulatory Committee as to areas where there is an element of profiteering or there has been any attempt to charge capitation fee in the proposal made by the petitioner. Division Bench in Lisie Medical & Educational Institution's case has specifically held that the fee has to be decided by the institutions themselves and such right of the institutions cannot be arrogated by the Committee. However, while fixing the fee structure, the institutions cannot indulge in profiteering or charge capitation fee, even though the element of surplus income to cater to the future needs of the institutions can be definitely taken into account while fixing the fee. Committee has got the power only to regulate the profiteering and charging of capitation fee. In our view, if there was any element of profiteering or charging of capitation fee in the fee fixed by the management, the Committee ought to have pointed out the same to the management in clear terms so that the management could either explain the same or rectify the anomaly, if any pointed out. The Committee in our view, should point out the anomalies, if any in writing so that the area of disagreement could be narrowed down. Such a procedure, if followed, would show application of mind by the Committee as well as the management and a reasonable fee structure could be arrived at, taking into consideration the overall public interest.

    9. Petitioner has got a specific contention that they had furnished the entire details called for by the Committee and also was ready with all the relevant materials in case any clarification was necessitated, but no clarification or query was made by the Committee. Fee structure has to be fixed in respect of each college or institution independently considering individual statement and the fee structure may vary from institution to institutions depending upon the investment on land, building, equipment, machinery and other infrastructural facilities offered. Regulatory Committee, in our view, has completely ignored the claim for depreciation on equipments and machinery. Equipments and machinery would wear out by usage by students, necessarily they will have to be replaced. Expenses incurred over a period and the yearly proportion has definitely to be loaded on to the beneficiaries in the form of depreciation. On the other hand, Committee has concentrated more on the land and building which will remain an asset of the management for which depreciation at the rate of 1 % was provided. But the crucial issue, that is, depreciation in respect of equipments and machinery has been negatived without any legal basis. Further we also notice that the salary expenses was also not noticed by the Committee. Committee had also disallowed the expenses for Chapel and not considered the income from the chapel which according to the petitioner will be much more than the expenses. Committee had also taken the income from the hospital but disallowed the expenses for the same. Further on a hypothetical figure, without any data, the Committee has assumed a net income of Rs. 200/- per bed per day which was loaded on the income head. Further Committee has not pointed out any specific area of profiteering and capitation fee which was the only area where the Committee has power to interfere. Committee ought to have pointed out to the management the component of profiteering and/or capitation fee in the fixation of fee structure, the same was not done. On the whole, the Committee has fixed their own fee structure to make it around Rs. 1,30,000/- which in the facts and circumstances of the case cannot be sustained. We are informed that the Government had entered into an agreement with few Medical Colleges in the State for seat sharing and fees sharing. Ext. P7 is one of such agreements. Agreement would indicate that the average fee agreed to by the Government would be around Rs. 3,67,500/-. Agreement would indicate that the total revenue permissible under the agreement is Rs. 3,37,50,000/- plus Rs. 30,00,000/-, i.e, Rs. 3,67,50,000/-. Agreement would indicate that the average fee works out to more than Rs. 3 lakhs in the place of Rs. 1,38,000/- fixed by the Regulatory Committee so far as the petitioner is concerned. Petitioner has made a fee structure of Rs. 3,20,000/- which is lesser than the amount agreed to vide Ext. P7 agreement. True, as per the agreement there has been seat sharing between the Government and the Management, but that will have no bearing on the expenditure to run the Medical College.

    10. We are therefore inclined to set aside Ext. P5 order passed by the Committee dated 26/04/2007 and direct the Regulatory Committee to point out the areas if any where there is any element of profiteering or capitation fee in the fee structure submitted by the petitioner institution. Wherever clarification is required the same would be communicated to the petitioner in writing within a period of one week from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment, therefore Management would be in a better position to explain the same. Reply, if any may be furnished within 3 days of the receipt of the communication from the Committee. On receipt of the reply, Committee will fix a date for hearing and dispose of the matter within two weeks thereafter.

    11. Writ Petition is disposed of as above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Malankara Orthodox S.C.M College v. Fee Regulatory Committee
    (Aug 18, 2007)