Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S.4 of Act 29 of 1958, hereinafter referred
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S.4 of Act 29 of 1958, hereinafter referred

    Chellappan v. Padmanabhan Nair

    1. This revision arises from an order in execution; and is filed by the judgment - debtor in O. S. No. 179/78 on the file of the Munsiff's Court, Palai. The suit was one for redemption of a mortgage and was resisted by the revision petitioner herein contending that the plaintiff is not entitled to redeem the mortgage. On the conclusion of the trial, a preliminary decree was passed for redemption of the mortgage. Thereafter the plaintiff applied for passing final decree and after hearing both parties, a final decree was also passed. When the decree - holder took steps in execution for recovery of possession of the property, the revision petitioner filed E. A. No. 197/82 claiming value of improvements and praying for issue of a commission to assess the value of improvements in the decree schedule property.

    2. This application was opposed mainly on the ground that the decree did not provide for value of improvements and the executing court cannot go behind the decree

    3. The executing court upholding the objection dismissed the said application.

    4. it is that order that is challenged in revision before this Court. Attacking this order the learned advocate appearing for the petitioners contended that under S.4 of Act 29 of 1958, hereinafter referred to the 'Act', a substantive right is conferred on the revision petitioner to claim compensation for value of improvements, on his eviction; that this is an independent right conferred on him and therefore even after passing a decree and even if the party had not raided this claim during trial, he is entitled to raise this claim in execution proceedings.

    5. I am unable to agree with the above contention of the counsel for the petitioner. There is nothing in this section or in any other provisions in the Act to show or indicate that a claim for compensation under S.4 can be raised in execution in spite of the fact that the said claim has not been raised or agitated during trial and the decree in question does not provide for value of improvements. S.4 and 5 of the Act have to be read together and when so read, it is crystal clear that in order to invoke the benefit of S.4(1) of the Act, the claim for compensation must have been adjudicated by a decree or order in a suit or other proceedings for eviction instituted against a tenant. It is only after the adjudication by a decree or order, the compensation becomes due and payable The second part of S.4 can be invoked only by a tenant to whom compensation is so due. The court shall ascertain value of improvements and fix compensation in accordance with S.7 to 16 of the Act. Under sub-s.(1) of S.5, if in a suit for eviction, a tenant establishes a claim for compensation due under S.4, a court shall have to ascertain the compensation in accordance with S.7 to 16 and pass a decree declaring the amount so found due. Under sub-s.(3) of S.5, the court has been given power to vary the decree passed under sub-s.(1) of S.5, in execution, for certain limited purposes in the manner and to the extent clearly indicated in the sub-section. On a careful reading of S.4 and 5, there can be no doubt, that the decree referred to in S.4(1) is the decree contemplated in sub-s.(1) of S.5 and the order referred to in S.4 (1) is the order mentioned in sub-s.(3) of S.5. While S.4 confers a substantive right, S.5 enumerates the procedure by which this right is adjudicated or secured by the courts.

    6. It is a well settled general principle that an executing court cannot go behind the decree and it is a fundamental principle of law that it is not the function of the executing court to go behind the decree or to decide matters which have already been concluded between the parties. In the instant case, the revision petitioner has claimed compensation for value of improvements on the trial side and Issue No.3 was raised in this regard. At the trial this issue was duly considered on the material on record and found against the revision petitioner. The finding is that there was no evidence to show that the revision petitioner effected any improvements in the suit property. This is therefore a case where the issue relating to improvements was duly adjudicated in the suit regarding the claim. This preliminary decree and judgment were not challenged by the revision petitioner. The mal decree was passed in accordance with the preliminary decree. This final decree also who not challenged by the revision petitioner. Therefore, as between the parties to the suit the matter has been finally concluded and the revision petitioner is bound by the decree which has declared that he is not entitled to any value of improvements.

    7. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the court below was right in dismissing the application filed by the revision petitioner. This revision therefore fails and is hereby dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chellappan v. Padmanabhan Nair
    (Feb 21, 1984)