Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rules 4 and 7 of the Contempt of Court Rules
  • Rules 4, 6 and 7 of the Contempt Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rules 4 and 7 of the Contempt of Court Rules
  • Rules 4, 6 and 7 of the Contempt Rules
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Patherya, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This contempt application was instituted by the petitioner alleging violation of an order dated 28 April, 2010. The background given in the opinion, stated only as found in the record, is as follows:

  • Title Suit No. 2 of 1980 was filed by Haran Chandra Das (the petitioner's predecessor-in-interest) and was decreed on contest in December 1985. An appeal was filed but dismissed for default; a miscellaneous case was also dismissed on contest.
  • A writ petition was filed seeking correction of the record of rights; an order by Altamas Kabir, J. directed the Block Land & Land Reforms Officer (BL & LRO), Ranaghat II, Nadia, to correct the record of rights; no corrective step was taken and a contempt application was filed but later lapsed.
  • In November 2009 it was noticed that members of the Ranaghat II Panchayet Samity and Baidyapur II Gram Panchayet were surveying the decreed plots for a Sajal Dhara water project. The petitioner made a representation dated 11 January, 2010; for non-consideration W.P. 24088 (W) of 2009 was filed.
  • By order dated 28 April, 2010 this Court directed respondent No. 5 to consider and dispose of the petitioner's representation after giving an opportunity of hearing to all parties and to pass a reasoned order; meanwhile no step was to be taken in respect of the project undertaken.
  • The petitioner alleged that, despite the order and despite being decree-holder's representatives, the BL & LRO registered the decreed plots in favour of third parties and that project work (including erection of structures and boundary walls) continued under the Sajal Dhara Scheme.
  • The alleged contemnors/respondents produced letters (including from BL & LRO to Assistant Engineer, PHE Directorate) instructing stoppage of construction; the parties dispute whether there was compliance and whether any construction shown in photographs was on the subject plots.
  • The petitioner initiated the present contempt proceedings alleging violation of the 28 April, 2010 order; the respondents deny contempt and assert that the representation was disposed of after hearings on 25 May, 2010, 10 June, 2010 and finally 25 June, 2010.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there was a contemptuous violation of the High Court's order dated 28 April, 2010 restraining steps on the project and directing consideration and disposal of the petitioner's representation.
  2. Whether the contempt petition complied with the Contempt of Court Rules of the Calcutta High Court (specifically Rules 4, 6 and 7) and thus whether it was maintainable.
  3. Whether, on the material before the Court (photographs, letters, hearing record), the alleged contemnors in fact failed to comply with the 28 April, 2010 order so as to attract contempt proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The order dated 28 April, 2010 directed respondent No.5 to consider and dispose of the representation dated 11 January, 2010 after hearing and by passing a reasoned order; meanwhile no step in respect of the project was to be taken.
  • Despite the order, work on the Sajal Dhara project continued: photographs show erection of structures and construction of boundary walls, indicating violation.
  • The BL & LRO had registered the decreed plots in favour of third parties despite the decree and prior orders; no step was taken to bring the petitioner on record in the Record of Rights.
  • Non-communication of the adjudicating authority's decision (even if an oral pronouncement was made) amounted to violation of the order which required communication of the decision.

Respondents' Arguments (Alleged Contemnors)

  • There was no violation of the order dated 28 April, 2010. The representation dated 11 January, 2010 was considered and disposed of after hearings: notice issued on 17 May, 2010, hearing on 25 May, 2010, adjourned to 10 June, 2010 and then to 25 June, 2010 when the order was passed.
  • The order was read out and explained to the parties and they were directed to obtain certified copies; the process complied with the Court's directions.
  • Letters from the BL & LRO to the Assistant Engineer, PHE Directorate instructed stopping of construction; contractors informed that work had stopped (including earlier stoppage from around 24 April, 2010) and later communications confirm stoppage in compliance with the Court's order.
  • Any photograph evidence does not establish that the construction shown was on the petitioner's subject plots; the petitioner failed to identify the plots shown.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through a step-by-step factual and legal analysis constrained to the material before it:

  1. Scope of the 28 April, 2010 order: The order directed respondent No.5 (the adjudicating authority) to consider and dispose of the representation dated 11 January, 2010 after giving hearing to all parties and by passing a reasoned order within three weeks from receipt; the decree of December 1985 and the order of January 1994 were to be considered; the decision was to be communicated within one week and, in the interim, no step was to be taken in respect of the alleged project.
  2. Communication and proceedings chronology: The 28 April, 2010 order was communicated to the alleged adjudicating authority by letter dated 3 May, 2010 and received on 4 May, 2010; notice of hearing was issued on 17 May, 2010 for the hearing fixed on 25 May, 2010; the matter was adjourned to 10 June, 2010 and finally to 25 June, 2010 when the adjudicating authority passed its order. The adjudicating authority directed parties to obtain certified copies; whether a formal written communication was issued to the petitioner was disputed.
  3. Evidence of continued work and identification of subject plots: The petitioner relied on photographs showing construction activity. The respondents produced letters instructing stoppage and communications from contractors stating work had stopped. The Court observed that while photographs disclose construction, there was no proof in the record that the construction was on the subject plots; the plots were not identified in the photographic material or otherwise.
  4. Procedural compliance for contempt proceedings: The Court analysed the form and content of the contempt petition under the Calcutta High Court Contempt of Court Rules. It found non-compliance with Rules 4 and 7 (and referred to Rules 4, 6 and 7 collectively) because the cause title and the prayer did not distinctly state the contumacious acts alleged, and the petition did not set out full particulars of the materials on which it was grounded. The acts of contempt were levelled generally against all respondents and not particularized against specific persons.
  5. Burden to show specific contraventions: The Court stressed that to sustain contempt, the petitioner must specify which respondent committed which contumacious act. The only potential act identified (non-communication of the decision by the adjudicating authority) could not be sustained because the petitioner was not definite about against whom to proceed, and the record showed hearings and an oral pronouncement with direction to obtain certified copies.
  6. Conclusion of analysis: On the material before it, the Court was not satisfied that (a) the photographs established that the construction was on the petitioner's declared plots, or (b) that any respondent was specifically shown to have disobeyed the Court's interim direction. Separately, the contempt petition's procedural defects under the Contempt Rules rendered it untenable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The contempt application is dismissed for non-compliance with Rules 4, 6 and 7 of the Contempt of Court Rules of the Calcutta High Court.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The direct effect is dismissal of the present contempt application for procedural non-compliance and for failure to attribute specific contumacious acts to particular respondents with adequate particulars and materials.
  • The Court directed that if a copy of the order dated 25 June, 2010 has not been supplied to the petitioner, the adjudicating authority (alleged contemnor/respondent No.1) must communicate that order to the petitioner within one week of receipt of the Court's order; the petitioner is thereby entitled to take steps in accordance with law following receipt.
  • The opinion contains no reasoning that purports to lay down any new precedent beyond resolving the present application on the procedural and evidentiary basis stated; the decision operates as a disposition of this application only.

This summary strictly reflects only the matters contained in the provided opinion and does not add information beyond the text of the opinion.

    Narayan Chandra Das v. Sri Anjan Ghosh & Ors.

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Patherya, J.:— In this contempt application the petitioner has alleged violation of order dated 28th April, 2010.

    Counsel for the petitioner submits that by order dated 28 April, 2010 the respondent No. 5 was directed to consider and dispose of the petitioner's representation after giving an opportunity of hearing to all parties and by passing a reasoned order. The decree passed on 23rd December, 1985 and the order passed by the High Court on 5 January, 1994 was directed to be considered. In the meantime, no step was to be taken in respect of the project undertaken. Title Suit No. 2 of 1980 was filed by one Haran Chandra Das, the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioner which suit was decreed on contest and although an appeal was filed the same was dismissed for default. The misc. case filed was also dismissed on contest. Inspite of the aforesaid no step was taken by the State to divest the said plots of land and include the name of the petitioner, although it was decreed that the said plots belonged to the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioner, in the record of rights. Accordingly a writ petition was filed and an order was passed by Altamas Kabir, J. directing the BL & LRO, Ranaghat II, Nadia to correct the record of rights but no step was taken and a contempt application was filed, the said contempt application has however lapsed. In November, 2009 it was noticed that some members of the Ranaghat II Panchayet Samity and the Baidyapur II Gram Panchayet were surveying the decreed plots for the purposes of setting up a water project under the Sajal Dhara Prokolpa. A representation was made and for non-consideration of such representation W.P 24088 (W) of 2009 was filed and order dated 28 April, 2010 was passed.

    In spite of the representation of the legal heirs and representatives of Haran Chandra Das, the decree-holder, the BL & LRO registered the said decreed plots in favour of third parties. Such third parties filed a suit, which was dismissed and the appeal filed was also dismissed on 21st April, 2010. In April 2010 the Sajal Dhara Scheme came into effect. By letter dated 12.12.2009 the order dated 5 January, 2009 was sent to the office of the Block Land & Land Reforms Officer, Ranaghat II, Nadia. The said was received by the BL & LRO on 14.12.2009 In spite thereof a no objection was taken from Bimal Kumar Moulik and the other purported owners of the said plots for the Sajal Dhara Scheme, in January, 2010 by the Panchayet Samity. The order was passed on 28 April, 2010 by this Court and from the photographs it will appear that steps were taken to continue with the project work by erecting structure and construction of boundary wall and all persons involved in the project work of Sajal Dhara have violated the order dated 28 April, 2010 and are guilty of contempt.

    In the opposition filed to the Rule by Anjan Ghosh the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1 on 20 June, 2012, letters have been annexed from the Block Land & Land Reforms Officer, Ranaghat, Nadia to the Assistant Engineer, PHE Directorate, Krishnanagar, Nadia whereby directions were given to stop all construction work over the three plots in question. In spite of receipt of the said letters and communication of the High Court's order there has been no compliance thereof. Therefore all the respondents be held guilty of contempt.

    Counsel for the alleged contemnor/respondents submits that there has been no violation of the order dated 28 April, 2010. The work undertaken was in respect of Sajal Dhara Scheme. The representation is dated 11 January, 2010. On receipt of the said order a notice of hearing was issued on 17 May, 2010 fixing the date of hearing on 25 May, 2010. The said notice was served on not only the petitioner, who received the same but also on other interested parties. On 25 May, 2010 the parties were represented at hearing. The matter was then adjourned till 10 June, 2010 on which date after hearing once again the matter was adjourned till 25 June, 2010 when the order was passed. Thus the representation dated 11 January, 2010 has been disposed of in compliance with the order dated 28 April, 2010. Not only was the order read out and explained to the parties but the parties were also directed to obtain certified copies.

    As the order dated 28 April, 2010 directed disposal of the representation dated 11 January, 2010 and the said representation has been disposed of the question of violating the order dated 28 April, 2010 does not arise.

    The contempt application has also not been filed as per the Contempt Rules framed by the Calcutta High Court. Rules 4 and 7 specifically require that the cause title and the prayer should distinctly state the contumacious act alleged. In the instant case such allegation has not been distinctly set out in either the prayer or the cause title of contempt application and therefore the contempt application is not in proper form and warrants dismissal.

    In reply, counsel for the petitioner submits that the communication made by the office of the BL & LRO is not in connection with the Sajal Dhara Scheme but is in respect of arsenic water treatment. Although in the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1 by letters dated 12 May, 2010 and 5 December, 2011 the project manager has informed of stoppage of work, but from the photographs which has been annexed to the affidavit-in-reply it will appear that work continued in respect of the said project. The order dated 25 June, 2010 has been passed by the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1. It has been specifically pleaded that all documents as required by the adjudicating authority was submitted. On the date when such documents was submitted, the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1 was posted at Kalyani and the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 4 took charge in his place. Therefore the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1 could not have taken a decision as per order dated 28 April, 2010 and a duty was cast on the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 4 to take such decision. It has been admitted by the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1 that on 25 June, 2010 the representation was disposed of but no formal communication was made as the order was read out and explained to the parties with a request to take certified copies thereof. As the order dated 28 April, 2010 directed communication of the decision, non-communication thereof is in violation of the said order.

    Having considered the submissions of the parties all that the petitioner sought in W.P 24088 (W) of 2009 was consideration and disposal of his representation dated 11 January, 2010. By order dated 28 April, 2010 the respondent No. 5, namely, the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1 was directed to consider and dispose of the said representation after giving an opportunity of hearing to all parties and by passing a reasoned order within three weeks from the date of receipt of the order. The decree of December 1985 and the order of January 1994 were also directed to be considered. The decision taken was to be communicated within one week and in the meantime no step was to be taken in respect of the alleged project undertaken.

    By letter dated 3 May, 2010, the order dated 28 April, 2010 was communicated to the office of the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1 and the same was received on 4.5.2010 Thereafter on 17 May, 2010 a notice of hearing was issued to not only the writ petitioner but to all interested parties. By the said notice the date of hearing was fixed on 25 May, 2010 at 12 noon in the office of the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1. The said notice was received by the petitioner will appear from the hazira filed by the petitioner on 25 May, 2010 through his authorized lawyer Mr. Bikash Chandra Das, advocate. The vakalatnama was also filed on the same day. It was within a fortnight that the notice was issued and on the last day of three weeks the hearing fixed. It was at the hearing as will appear from the order-sheet dated 25 May, 2010 that it was submitted that the plaint of T.S 2 of 1980 was necessary and 15 days' time was needed to obtain certified copy thereof. Accordingly an adjournment was granted till 10 June, 2010. Further time was sought on 10 June, 2010 by the petitioner's advocate and such time was also allowed till 25 June, 2010. After hearing the parties on 25 June, 2010 the order was passed and it may be true that the decision was not communicated but the parties were directed to obtain certified copies.

    Prior to filing of the contempt application no notice was issued by the petitioner to the alleged contemnor/respondents alleging violation of the said order and therefore, in fact no opportunity was given to the alleged contemnor/respondents to communicate the decision. The main thrust of the petitioner's argument is in respect of the interim order passed which restrained continuance of the project undertaken. According to the petitioner the work was continued in violation of the order. After receipt of the order dated 28 April, 2010 by letters dated 4 May, 2010 and 7 May, 2010 the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1 informed the Assistant Engineer, PHE Directorate to ask its contractors to stop work and it was informed by the contractors of the PHE Department that work had stopped due to local problem since 24 April, 2010. This was prior to the order dated 28 April, 2010. From the letter dated 5.12.2011 of the contractor to the PHE Department the work was stopped as per the Court's order and the said communication was also sent to the office of the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1. From the photographs disclosed construction is evident but whether such construction was in the plots of land belonging to the petitioner one is not aware. Even assuming that such construction was made in the plots of land of the petitioner, it is necessary to see whether the parties against whom contempt has been alleged have in fact violated the said order. The alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1 informed the Assistant Engineer, PHE Department of the order dated 28 April, 2010 and he in turn informed the contractor who informed the Assistant Engineer, PHE Department that there has been compliance with the order dated 28 April, 2010 as the work was stopped.

    Till date the Record of right has not been corrected by bringing the petitioner on record. A no-objection was obtained by the authorities from the Mouliks on 25.1.2010 From the letters disclosed it appears that work in the subject plot has been stopped, while the photographs show otherwise. There is no proof that the construction shown is in the subject plots, nor is there anything to identify the subject plot. In the absence of identification of the subject plots it cannot be held that there has been violation of the order dated 28.4.2010 One is not aware if the project was undertaken in the subject plots.

    The petitioner has also not taken any step to correct the Record of rights. The Contempt of Court Rules of the Calcutta High Court specifically provides in Rules 4, 6 and 7 that the contumacious conduct complained of must be stated in the cause title (Rule 4) and also in the prayer portion (Rule 7). The petition must also contain full particulars of the materials on which the petition is grounded.

    In the petition there has been no compliance of Rules 4 and 7 of the Contempt of Court Rules of this Court. The acts of contempt has been levelled against all the respondents and against no particular respondent. Although it was submitted in the course of hearing that without the knowledge of the Sub-Divisional Officer, the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 2 no work can be undertaken, but no such allegation has been levelled against him.

    There is no specific act of contempt attributed to any of the alleged contemnor/respondents and the only act of violation against the alleged contemnor/respondent Nos. 1 and 5 that could have been sustained is with regard to non-communication of its decision by the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1 or 5. But here again the petitioner is not sure against whom he wants to proceed, therefore this act can also not be sustained and is rejected.

    Accordingly for non-compliance of Rules 4, 6 and 7 of the Contempt Rules of this High Court, this application is dismissed.

    In the event no copy of the order dated 25.6.2010 has been given to the petitioner, let such Order be communicated by the alleged contemnor/respondent No. 1, the adjudicating authority within a week of receipt of this Order and the petitioner will be entitled to take steps in accordance with law.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Narayan Chandra Das v. Sri Anjan Ghosh & Ors.
    (May 3, 2013)