1. The revision petition is taken up with the consent of parties. It is against an order permitting re-calling of D.W.I, to give further evidence.
2. The first defendant in the suit was examined as D.W.I, on 8-3.1988 and 11.3.1988 On 14-3-1988 he filed an application to recall and re-examine himself with reference to a statement made by him in relation to Ex. A3 in the examination-in-chief and in the cross-examination. In the affidavit filed in support of the said application he had stated that at the fag end of the cross-examination, due to his old age he was tired and was unable to withstand the cross-examination and without knowing the implication and meaning of the question misunderstood the question and he had admitted that he obtained loan by presenting the document Ex. A3. He has stated further in his affidavit that a statement made by him in the cross-examination was made inadvertently and that had created an ambiguity in the deposition. It is to be noted that in the written statement filed by him in the suit he had denied the execution of the suit document. In the chief examination also he had denied the execution of the document.
3. The learned trial Judge while holding that the allegation of inadvertence and plea of ambiguity had not been proved but the interest of justice requires that the petition should be allowed and consequently allowed the petition.
4. It is contended by learned counsel for the petitioner that the learned Sub Judge had no jurisdiction under, O. 18 R. 17, C.P Code, to re-call a witness at the instance of the party in order to clear an ambiguity. Learned counsel submitted that though the court has power under O. 18, R. 17, to re-call any witness at any stage and to put questions to such witnesses, it cannot be done at the instance of the parties and the parties cannot be allowed to cross-examine or examine the witness in chief. Learned counsel further submitted that the learned Sub Judge having found that the allegation of inadvertence and plea of ambiguity were not proved, erred in ordering the petition in the interest of justice. It is pointed out by the learned counsel that the provisions of S. 151 C.P.C were not invoked by the party in the application and that the learned Judge has also not made the position clear while making the order.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied on a decision of the Allahabad High Court in Altaf Hussain… v. Nasreen Zahra…. A.I.R 1978 All. 515 Banerji, J. observed in that case that rule 17 under Order 18 provides the Court with a power which is necessary for proper conduct of a case and that if it appeared to a court that it was necessary to re-call and further examine a witness, it can always do so at any stage of the suit even at the stage of writing a judgment. It was also pointed out in that case that the power could be exercised by the Court on its own initiative and also at the instance of a party but it should be done only for removing the ambiguities and for clarifying statements made already and not for the purpose of filling up a lacuna in a party's case.
6. Learned counsel also relied upon the judgments of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Sultan Sahib Bin Omer v. Vijaychand Srimal A.I.R 1966 A.P 295 and T. Ramachandramurti v. K. Ramamurthi & others A.I.R 1980 A.P 265 for the same proposition.
7. Learned counsel for the respondent contended that the decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Sultan Sahib Bin Omer v. Vijaychandra Srimal was really in his favour as inasmuch as it had been held by Venkatesan, J. in that case that the power to recall a witness could be exercised by a court under S. 151 C.P.C, without invoking the provisions of Order 18 rule 17 C.P.C The following passage in the judgment of the learned judge is relied on by learned counsel for the respondent:—
“A close reading of this rule makes it obvious that the right under that rule to put questions at any stage of a suit, or recall any witness for that purpose, is given to the court. The Court can put questions to the witness re-called, and no cross-examination is ordinarily allowed upon the answer to the questions put by the Judge without leave. The right to act under this rule is not restricted to the Court on its own motion, but may be exercised, at the instance of a party. It cannot, therefore, be said that an opportunity to a party to recall any witness for the purposes of examining, cross-examining or reexamining is governed by Order 18 rule 17 C.P.C I, therefore, hold that if circumstances warrant, an opportunity to a party to recall a witness for examining cross-examining or re-examining can be granted by a court in the exercise of its inherent jurisdiction under S. 151 C.P.C”
According to learned counsel the decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court is to the effect that the power under rule 17 of Order 18 could not be exercised if the judgment is reserved in a case. Learned counsel submits that it runs counter to the decision of the Delhi High Court in Suresh Kumar v. Haldevraj wherein Jain J. has taken the view that even after the judgment has been reserved, a witness can be recalled by the Court and the same view has been taken by the Allahabad High Court in the decision relied on by the petitioner himself in Altaf Hussain v. Nasreen Zehra
Learned counsel for the respondent also invites my attention to a passage in Sircar's Commentaries on Evidence, p. 1315 of 13th Edn. wherein learned author has pointed out that in the interest of justice a witness could be recalled and re-examined and cross-examined.
10. I am of the view that the Court can exercise its power under S. 151 C.P.C and recall a witness if the circumstances of the case require the same. I am also of the view that such re-calling can be made at any stage of the suit even at the time when the judgment in the suit is about to be delivered,
11. The Court below has taken the view that the facts of the case and the interest of justice require recalling of the witness D.W.I In a revision under S. 115 C.P Code, I do not think it is possible to interfere with the decision of the court below. Though the court below has not given its detailed reasoning for sustaining its order on the ground of interest of justice, I do not think that the said order could be interfered with by this court as it is one within the jurisdiction of the learned Sub Judge.
12. The respondent has in his affidavit filed in support of his application for recalling himself, has stated that he is aged 65 years and at the fag end of the cross-examination due to his old age he was tired, unable, to withstand the cross-examination and without knowing the implications and meaning of the question misunderstood the question and stated that he had obtained the loan by using the document in dispute. The circumstances of the case do warrant an opportunity being given to the respondent to explain the admission made by him.
13. In these circumstances, I do not find any ground to interfere with the order of the learned Sub. Judge Hence, the revision petition is dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.
VCS/RR.