Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Land Acquisition Act itself. S. 21 of the Land Acquisition Act
  • CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT
  • S. 3 (v) of the Land Acquisition Act,
  • S. 18 of the Land Acquisition Act
  • Land Acquisition Act Ss. 18 to 28
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Land Acquisition Act itself. S. 21 of the Land Acquisition Act
  • CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT
  • S. 3 (v) of the Land Acquisition Act,
  • S. 18 of the Land Acquisition Act
  • Land Acquisition Act Ss. 18 to 28
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

In land acquisition proceedings, the Collector made a reference under S. 18 of the Land Acquisition Act to the City Civil Court, Madras, for determination of a specific objection raised by the second respondent, Pattabhirama Reddiar, concerning the amount of compensation; the second respondent did not accept the award. Four petitioners, who had participated in earlier stages of the acquisition proceedings, did not file objections under S. 18 within the prescribed time. Instead, they applied in the City Civil Court under Order 1 Rule 10, Civil Procedure Code, and Section 151 C.P.C., seeking to be added as parties to the pending reference on the ground that the acquired land belonged to an undivided joint Hindu family and that they represented one branch while respondents 2 to 6 represented another branch.

The lower (City Civil) Court found that the petitioners had not established even prima facie that they formed part of a joint family with a common interest in the land. The lower Court also relied on the Andhra Pradesh High Court decision in Ibrahim Sahib v. Land Acquisition Officer (A.I.R. 1958 A.P. 226) to the effect that a person who did not apply to the Collector for a reference under S. 18 could not ventilate grievances against the award in the civil Court dealing with the reference. The City Civil Court rejected the petitioners' application. The petitioners then filed the present revision petition challenging that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Who are the "persons affected by the objection" under Part III (S. 18–28) of the Land Acquisition Act for purposes of a reference under S. 18?
  2. Whether persons who did not file an objection under S. 18 (but appeared earlier in acquisition proceedings) can be added as parties to the reference under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC and thereby ventilate their own grievances before the civil Court handling the S. 18 reference.
  3. Whether an objection raised by one person competent to represent others (for example, in the case of a joint and undivided interest) enures to the benefit of all those persons for purposes of the S. 18 reference.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners claimed that the acquired land belonged to an undivided joint Hindu family and that they represented one branch while respondents 2 to 6 represented another branch of that family.
  • They argued that, on that basis, they should be made parties to the pending reference under S. 18 and that Order 1 Rule 10, C.P.C., and Section 151 C.P.C. permitted the Court to add them as plaintiffs or defendants so as to enable complete adjudication of the questions involved.

Second Respondent's Position (as appearing in the opinion)

  • The second respondent, Pattabhirama Reddiar, had not accepted the award and had filed a written objection under S. 18 requesting reference to the civil Court as to the amount of compensation. (The opinion does not elaborate further on any detailed counter-arguments by the second respondent.)

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ibrahim Sahib v. Land Acquisition Officer, A.I.R. 1958 A.P. 226 Holds that a person who did not file an application to the Collector for reference under S. 18 is not entitled to ventilate his grievances against the award in the civil Court dealing with the S. 18 reference. The lower Court adopted this decision; the Court in the present opinion relied on the same principle to support the view that the petitioners, having not filed objections under S. 18, cannot be allowed to ventilate their own grievances by being added as non-applicant parties to the reference.
Narayana v. Annapuranamma, A.I.R. 1941 Mad. 753 = 63 L.W. 463 Establishes (1) that a party who raised no objection to the apportionment of compensation made by the Collector must be taken to have accepted the award in that respect; and (2) that under Ss. 18, 20 and 21 the Court can deal only with the objection referred to it and cannot go into a question raised for the first time by a party who had not raised any objection under S. 18. This Court's reasoning (and the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Ibrahim Sahib) followed the principles in this decision to confine the civil Court's jurisdiction to objections actually raised under S. 18 and to preclude new grounds from parties who did not object before the Collector.
State v. Narayana Pillai (Kerala High Court) Contains observations that where several persons have no separate and distinct interests (i.e., a joint and undivided interest), an objection by one competent person may be deemed to be made on behalf of all and therefore may enure to the benefit of all; but if each has a distinct and separate interest and no one is entitled to represent the others, the position differs. The opinion notes these observations and acknowledges that they were referred to the lower Court; however, because the lower Court found that the petitioners had not proved a joint family/common interest with respondents 2–6, those observations did not operate to entitle the petitioners to be added as parties in this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the statutory scheme in Part III (Ss. 18–28) of the Land Acquisition Act and explained that the jurisdiction exercised by the civil Court on a reference under S. 18 is a special jurisdiction strictly circumscribed by the Act's provisions. The Court set out the following key statutory points and their consequences as stated in the opinion:

  • S. 18: Grants to "a person interested" who has not accepted the award the right to state his grounds of objection and to make a written application within the prescribed time to the Collector to refer the matter to the civil Court.
  • S. 3(b): Defines "a person interested" to include all persons claiming an interest in the compensation (and easements) — but the Court emphasized that this definition is not coextensive with the phrase "person interested in the objection" used in Part III.
  • S. 19: Requires the Collector, when making a reference, to give particulars including names of persons he has reason to think are interested.
  • S. 20: Requires the Court to give notice of hearing to (a) the applicant, (b) all persons interested in the objection except those who have consented to receive payment, and (c) when relevant, the Collector; the Court read S. 20 as identifying who are "persons affected by the objection."
  • S. 21: Restricts the scope of the enquiry before the Special Tribunal to a consideration of the interests of the persons affected by the objection.
  • S. 53: Provides that provisions of the Civil Procedure Code apply to proceedings under the Act insofar as they are not inconsistent with the Act.

From these provisions the Court reasoned that "a person interested in the objection" must be construed with reference to the stand taken by that person before the Collector at the time of the award — specifically, whether the person filed a written objection under S. 18 within the prescribed time or otherwise supported the applicant's objection before the Collector. The Court emphasized that this phrase does not simply mean any person who has an interest in the land (as per S. 3(b)) nor does it include persons who later attempt to raise new grievances if they had not elected to object within the S. 18 time-frame.

The Court explained the consequence of this construction: if a person consented to receive the compensation awarded (i.e., raised no objection), that person is not a "person affected by the objection" and is not to be treated as a party whose interests the Court must consider on the S. 18 reference. The Court accepted and applied the reasoning of earlier authorities (including Narayana v. Annapuranamma and Ibrahim Sahib) to hold that the civil Court cannot entertain new grounds raised for the first time by persons who did not raise S. 18 objections.

Applying these principles to the facts, the Court noted that the lower Court had found that the petitioners failed to establish prima facie that they and respondents 2–6 constituted a joint family with a common interest. Because the petitioners had not filed written objections under S. 18 and had not otherwise taken a stand supporting the objection before the Collector, they could not be treated as persons affected by the objection for purposes of Part III. The Court therefore held that it would not be permissible to add the petitioners as parties or to take into account representations from persons who had not applied within the statutory time limit after the award.

Holding and Implications

The Court confirmed the decision of the lower Court and dismissed the revision petition; the petition was dismissed with costs payable to respondents 2 to 6.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioners are not entitled to be added as parties to the S. 18 reference and cannot ventilate their own grievances in the S. 18 reference because they did not file a written objection under S. 18 within the period prescribed by the statute and did not demonstrate a joint family/common interest on the facts.
  • Scope of proceedings under Part III: The decision reaffirms that the civil Court on a reference under S. 18 is limited to hearing objections that were properly raised before the Collector and the contentions of those persons who were "interested in the objection" by reason of the stand taken before the Collector. The Court did not purport to lay down any new legal principle but applied established authorities to the facts of the case.

Signed in the opinion: V.C.S (as reproduced in the provided text).

    Rajamannar v. State Of Madras

    In certain land acquisition proceedings reference was made by the Collector under S. 18 of the Land Acquisition Act to the City Civil Court, Madras, for determination of a specific objection, as to the amount oi compensation, taken before him by the second respondent Pattabhirama Reddiar, who did not accept the award. The petitioners, four in number, did not file objection to the award under S. 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, though they had appeared in the land acquisition proceedings at some anterior stage. The claim in an application filed by them under O. 1. R. 10, C. P. C, and S. 151 C.P C, before the City Civil Court that the acquired land belonged to an undivided joint Hindu family, that they represented one branch of it while respondents 2 to 6 represented another branch, and that consequently they should be made parties to the reference under S. 18 of the Land Acquisition Act pending, before the City Civil Court, Madras. The lower Court found that the petitioners had not proved even on prima facie grounds that they constituted members of a joint family interested in the land in dispute. Secondly, it adopted the decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Ibrahim Sahib v. Land Acquisition Officer A.I.R 1958 A.P 226. it which it was held that a person who had not filed an application to the Collector for reference under S. 18 of the Land Acquisition Act was not entitled to ventilate his own grievances against the award in the civil Court which deals with the reference. The lower Court rejected the application. Against this decision the present revision petition is filed by the petitioners.

    The scheme contained in Part III of the Land Acquisition Act Ss. 18 to 28 provides for the exercise of a special jurisdiction by the civil Court, and the scope of this jurisdiction is strictly circumscribed by the appropriate provisions contained in this Part. S. 18 gives the right to “a person interested” who has not accepted the award, to state the grounds of his objection, and make a written application within the prescribed time limit to the Collector, requiring him to refer the subject matter of his objection to the civil Court for decision. “A person interested” has been defined in S. 3 (b) of the Act as including all persons claiming an interest in the compensation and the term also includes a person who is interested in an easement affecting the land. In making the reference, the Collector is required to give the particulars mentioned in S. 19 of the Act and among the particulars are included the names of the persons whom he has reason to think are interested in such land. S. 20 requires the Court to give notice of the hearing of the objection (a) to the applicant, (b) to all persons interested in the objection except such (if any) of them as have consented without protest to receive payment of the compensation awarded and (c) if the objection is in regard to the area oi the land or to the amount of the compensation, to the Collector. S. 21 of the Act restricts the scope of the enquiry to a consideration of the interests of the persons affected by the objection. S. 23 lays down certain principles for determining the amount of compensation. S. 53 says that save in so far as the may be inconsistent with anything contained in this Act, the provisions of the Civil Procedure Code, shall apply to all proceedings before the Court under this Act. No doubt O. 1, R. 10 on which the petitioners have relied, permits the Court at any stage of the proceedings to add as plaintiff or defendant any person whose presence before the Court may be necessary, in order to enable the Court effectually and completely to adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved in the suit (S. 20 of the Land Acquisition Act specifically gives a list of persons on whom the Court is required to serve a notice before determining the objection). The jurisdiction of the civil Court under Part III of the Land Acquisition Act being a special jurisdiction, its powers must be spelt out from the terms of the Land Acquisition Act itself. S. 21 of the Land Acquisition Act specifically confines the scope of the enquiry before the Special Tribunal to a consideration of the interests of the persons affected by the objection. The question, therefore, for determination is who are the persons affected by the objection raised under S. 18 of the Act. On an a priori reasoning it may be held that all persons interested within the meaning of S. 3 (v) of the Land Acquisition Act, already referred to, would be affected by the objection, but a careful perusal of the sections in Part III of the Act, would show that that is not the meaning intended to be given to the terms “persons affected by the objection.” To find out who are the persons affected by the objection, one can look at S. 20 of the Act, which provides for the category of persons to whom notice of the hearing by the Court, is required to be given. They are : the applicant and all persons interested in the objection except such of them as have consented to receive payment of the compensation amount awarded. In other words, the persons interested in the objection are those who, besides the applicant, have taken a stand similar to his by supporting his objection before the Collector. S. 20 (c) indicates that if the objection is in regard to the area of the land or to the amount of the compensation, the Collector is deemed to be a person affected by the objection and the interests of the Governments represented by the Collector would also be within the scope of the enquiry. So the question whether a person is affected by the objection or not, has to be decided by the civil Court, that is, the Special Tribunal, with reference to the stand taken by him before the Collector, at the time of passing the award, or who has expressed his attitude to the award by filing a written objection before the Collector within the time prescribed in S. 18 of the Act. If, on the other hand, he is a person who has not expressed any objection, but has consented to receive the amount of compensation awarded, he will not be a person affected by the objection. As pointed out by the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Ibrahim Sahib v. Land Acquisition Officer, a person interested in the objection is not the same as a person interested in the land; nor does it refer to persons interested in the success of the objection. According to the Andhra Pradesh High Court the mere fact that a person is brought before the Court as a non-applicant party does not entitle him to ventilate his own grievances against the award when he himself has not filed an application to the Collector for a reference under S. 18 of the Act. For the above view, the Andhra Pradesh High Court followed the decision of this Court in Narayana v. Annapuranamma A.I.R 1941 Mad. 753 = 63 L.W 463. where it has been held that (1) a party who raised no objection to the apportionment of the compensation made by the Collector must be taken to have accepted the award in that respect and (2) under Ss. 18, 20 and 21 of the Act, all that the Court can deal with, is the objection, which has been referred to it and it cannot go into a question raised for the first time by a party who had not raised any objec tion under S. 18 of the Act. The above discussion would show that on a reference under S. 18, the Court is required to hear only (.1) an objection which had been raised before the Collector in accordance with the formalities prescribed in S. 18 and (2) the contentions of only such persons who are interested in the objection. The term “person interested in the objection” is not equivalent “to a person interested” within the meaning of S. 3 (b) of the Act, but has to be interpreted with reference to the stand taken by him in respect of the award, within the time limit prescribed in S. 18, when he is required to elect whether he has accepted the award or not.

    Before the lower Court, the decision of the Kerala High Court in State v. Narayana Pillai was referred to. There are certain observations in the course of the judgment, which appareatly were relied upon in the lower Court by the petitioner. For example, there is an observation at page 138 which says:

    “Where the award is in favour of several parsons having no separate and distinct interest in the property acquired, all of them may be said to be interested in the objection raised by one or more of them to the award made by the Land Acquisition Officer. In such a case the objection may be deemed to have been made on behalf of all. Similarly, if one of several persons having only a joint and undivided interest in the property acquired is competent to represent the interests of all of them, the objection by him to the award and tha consequent reference to the District Court would enure to the benefit of all of them. But the position will be entirely different if each of them has a distinct and seperate interest in the property acquired and no one of them is entitled in law to represent the others as in the present case.”

    These observations would appear to indicate that if at the stage of the award there area group of several persons having only a joint and undivided interest in the property acquired, in such a case the objection made by one person competent to represent the interests of all would enure to the benefit of all. The lower Court has found on the facts that the petitioners had not proved that they and respondents 2 to 6 who were before the Land Acquisition Officer, constituted a joint family with a common interest. The specific sections of the Land Acquisition Act in Part III circumscribe the scope of the enquiry and specify the persons who should be made parties to the enquiry. It is not permissible to go beyond the terms of these sections, and infer that a person who did not prefer his objection to the award within the time limit prescribed in S. 18, is a person interested in the objection within the meaning of S. 20 (b) of the Act, and therefore, a person affected by the objection within the meaning of S. 21 of the Act. It will not be permissible to take into account at the enquiry the representations of persons who have never applied after the passing of the award within the time limit fixed by the statute, stating whether they accepted the award or were objecting to it. I therefore confirm the decision of the lower Court and dismiss this petition with costs of respondents 2 to 6.

    V.C.S

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajamannar v. State Of Madras
    (Mar 18, 1964)