Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter arises from Suit No. 701-A/81 under Sections 8 and 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, concerning a contract dated 30 June 1976 between the parties that contained an arbitration clause. By order dated 12 April 1985 this court appointed Shri T. U. Mehta, Retd. Chief Justice, as sole arbitrator to adjudicate the claims in the suit except Claim No. 3. The arbitrator made an award on 16 July 1987 and caused it to be filed in the court. Notice of filing was accepted for the claimant on 4 December 1987 and was served on the respondent on 19 February 1988. The respondent filed objections to the award on 18 March 1988.

The parties' pleadings produced three issues for determination: (1) whether the award is liable to be set aside for reasons stated in the objections, (2) whether the objections were filed within the period of limitation and the effect if not, and (3) relief. Affidavit evidence was filed in support and resistance to the objections and counsel were heard.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Is the award liable to be set aside for any of the reasons set out in the objection petition?
  2. Have the objections been filed within the period of limitation? If not, what is its effect?
  3. What relief should be granted?

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent / Objector's Arguments

  • The objections challenge the award on general grounds of misconduct by the arbitrator, alleging perversity, lack of evidence base, and bias in favour of the claimant.
  • It was contended that the award of pre-reference interest on Claim No. 1 is unjustified because (a) there is no contractual stipulation for interest, (b) no written notice demanding interest was given, and (c) the arbitrator lacked jurisdiction to award interest with yearly rests.
  • Specific challenge to Claim No. 2 included an allegation of an apparent error in the travel expense award — the auditor's report covered travelling from July 1976 to December 1979, whereas the claimant's affidavit allegedly stated trips only up to March 1979; thus, some travel costs were said to be wrongly awarded.
  • It was also argued that the Rs. 30,000 awarded for technical notes was unjustified because no technical notes were submitted and the claimant had already been paid Rs. 30,000 for a feasibility report; therefore, further payment was not warranted.
  • Objections were made to the awards for foreign trips (claimed Rs. 60,000, awarded Rs. 37,920) and long-distance calls (claimed and awarded Rs. 20,000) on the ground that they were not supported by evidence.

Claimant's Arguments

  • The claimant sought refund of Rs. 15,000 (their contribution to the proposed joint venture) and claimed interest at 1.5% per mensem (18% p.a.) from 30 June 1976 until payment; the arbitrator awarded the principal refund and awarded interest at 12% p.a. with yearly rests from 13 November 1979 until the date of decree.
  • The claimant relied on documents, an auditor's report and affidavits to prove expenses included under Claim No. 2 (travel, acquisition of technical notes, foreign trips and long-distance calls), and the arbitrator accepted those materials in part, awarding amounts totaling Rs. 1,08,151.50 out of claimed Rs. 1,30,231.50.
  • The claimant treated a letter dated 13 November 1979 as a demand or notice relevant to claiming interest (this letter was relied upon by the arbitrator as a basis for awarding pre-reference interest).

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court addressed Issue No. 2 first and found that objections were filed within time: the respondent was served with notice of filing of the award on 19 February 1988 and the objections were received by the registry on 18 March 1988, so they were filed within the statutory period. Accordingly, Issue No. 2 was decided in favour of the objector (i.e., objections are in time).

Turning to Issue No. 1, the court analysed the objections to the arbitrator's award claim by claim.

Claim No. 1 — refund of Rs. 15,000 and interest:

  • The arbitrator found Rs. 15,000 refundable and awarded interest not at the claimed 1.5% per month but at 12% per annum with yearly rests from 13 November 1979 until the date of decree; the arbitrator relied on the claimant's letter dated 13 November 1979 and treated that letter as a notice demanding interest under Section 3(1)(b) of the Interest Act, 1978. The arbitrator also relied on the fact that an arbitrator is included in the definition of "court" for purposes of the Interest Act.
  • The court analysed the text of the 13 November 1979 letter. The court held that a plain reading shows the letter warns the respondent to proceed with the joint venture and threatens to hold them responsible for "all costs and damages" if they fail to proceed. The court concluded that the letter did not contain a clear written notice demanding interest within the meaning of Section 3(1)(b) of the Interest Act, 1978; "damages" in the letter could not fairly be read as a demand for interest.
  • Because the arbitrator treated that letter as a demand for interest, the court characterised that approach as a "mistake apparent on the face of the award." The court therefore held that the arbitrator's award of pre-reference interest on the Rs. 15,000 was unjustified and severable from the rest of the award, and set aside that portion of the award (i.e., the pre-reference interest). The court did not need to decide the separate contention about yearly rests, although it noted prima facie that Section 3(3)(c) of the Interest Act supported the object's contention on yearly rests.

Claim No. 2 — various expenses:

  • The arbitrator awarded Rs. 1,08,151.50 out of claimed Rs. 1,30,231.50 across four heads: (a) travel between Delhi and Shimla — claimed and awarded Rs. 20,231.50; (b) acquisition of technical notes from foreign collaborators — claimed and awarded Rs. 30,000; (c) foreign trips to U.S.A. — claimed Rs. 60,000, awarded Rs. 37,920; (d) long-distance calls — claimed and awarded Rs. 20,000.
  • On the travel timing objection (that affidavit said trips until March 1979 whereas the auditor's report covered travel up to December 1979), the court examined the affidavit, the auditor's report, and a tabulated statement prepared under the arbitrator's direction. The court observed the auditor's report is a consolidated report for July 1976 to December 1979 and that it was not indicated that amounts debited in a month were necessarily incurred in that month; bills might have been submitted later. The court held that if the objector disputed the total, the correct course was to cross-examine the claimant on that point; no cross-examination took place. The affidavit's averments about trips and expenses did not show that entries were fictitious. Thus no error apparent emerged to justify setting aside or modifying the award on this ground.
  • On the Rs. 30,000 award for technical notes, the court reviewed the arbitrator's reasoning (paras 22.3–22.10 in the award) and relied on evidence including Ex. 16 (a letter showing submission of an additional report based on technical information from foreign collaborators). The court found the arbitrator's conclusion — that the initial payment for the 1976 report did not cover the costs of subsequent reports — to be supported by the material and rejected the objection.
  • As to the awards for U.S. trips and long-distance calls, the court noted the arbitrator relied on the auditor's report, which remained unrebutted; accordingly, the court found no fault with the awards on these heads.
  • More broadly, the court emphasised that the arbitrator is the sole judge of facts and law for the reference. The court stated it does not sit as an appellate tribunal to reappraise evidence or reconsider the arbitrator's fact-finding or reasoning; absent perversity or a clear error apparent on the face of the award, the court will not disturb the arbitrator's findings. It concluded that the objections to Claim No. 2 failed and must be dismissed.

The court therefore severed and set aside only the arbitrator's award of pre-reference interest on Claim No. 1 as a mistake apparent on the face of the award; all other portions of the award were upheld.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court's final decision was to uphold the award except for the pre-reference interest portion on Claim No. 1, which was set aside as a mistake apparent on the face of the award. The operative rulings include:

  • AWARD UPHELD IN PART — The arbitrator's awards on Claim No. 2 (travel, acquisition of technical notes, foreign trips and long-distance calls) and the principal refund of Rs. 15,000 on Claim No. 1 were sustained and the award (except as to the pre-reference interest portion) was made rule of the court.
  • PRE-REFERENCE INTEREST SET ASIDE — The arbitrator's grant of interest on the Rs. 15,000 from 13 November 1979 (i.e., the award of pre-reference interest) was set aside because the letter relied on did not constitute a written demand for interest within the meaning of Section 3(1)(b) of the Interest Act, 1978.
  • POST-AWARD INTEREST — The claimant was nevertheless awarded interest at the rate of 12% per annum on the awarded amount from the date of award until payment (this is the court's direction in the result paragraph of the opinion).
  • DEREE AND COSTS — A decree in terms of the award (as modified) was passed, a decree sheet ordered to be drawn up, and the parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Implications: The practical consequences are limited to the parties: the monetary awards in favour of the claimant (except the pre-reference interest) stand and have been made rule of court; pre-reference interest based on the challenged notice was removed. The opinion does not purport to lay down any broader new legal precedent beyond applying statutory provisions (notably provisions of the Interest Act, 1978) to the facts of this award.

    International Engineering Consultancy v. Himachal Pradesh Mineral And Industrial Development Corporation Limited

    D.K. Jain, J.

    On a petition under Sections 8 and 20 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 in Suit No. 701-A/81, arising out contract dated 30th June, 1976 between the parties, containing an arbitration clause, this court vide order dated 12th April, 1985, appointed Shri T. U. Mehta, Retd. Chief Justice, as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate the claims set out in the suit, except Claim No. 3.

    2. The ld. arbitrator made his award on 16th July, 1987, issued notices to the parties and caused the award to be filed in this court.

    3. Notice of the filing of the award was given to the parties. Notice was accepted for the claimant on 4th December, 1987. It was served on the respondent on 19th February, 1988. The respondent filed the objections against the award on 18th March, 1988. These have been resisted of the claimant. On the pleadings of the parties following issues were framed :

    (1) Is the award liable to be set aside for any of the reasons set out in the objection petition ?

    (2) Have the objections been filed within the period of limitation ? if not, what is its effect ?

    (3) Relief.

    4. Evidence was directed to be led by way of affidavits. Affidavits in support and in resistance to the objections have been filed by the parties. I have heard ld. counsel for the parties.

    Issue No. 2

    5. It would be convenient to dispose of this issue first. It is common ground that the respondent was served with the notice of filing of the award on 19th February, 1988. The objections petition, as per endorsement of the registry, appears as received on 18th March, 1988. The objections, thus, were filed within Fairly, as such, no arguments were addressed on the issue. The issue is, accordingly, found in favour of the Objector.Issue No. 1

    6. There were two claims, in main, besides of interest and costs for adjudication by the ld. arbitrator, namely :

    (i) Claim No. 1 - for refund of Rs. 15, 000 paid by the claimant towards their contribution of the proposed joint venture along with interest at 1.5% per mensem for the period 30th June, 1976 till payment calculated upto 30th June, 1985 at Rs. 36, 000.

    7. It has been allowed in full along with interest at 12% per annum with yearly rests instead of interest at 1.5% per month as claimed but held unjustifiable.

    (ii) Claim No. 2 - falling under four heads mentioned below; allowed to the extent mentioned against each of them.

    |-----|-----------------------------|-------------|-------------| | S. | Nature of Expenditure | Amount | Amount | | No. | | Claimed | Awarded | |-----|-----------------------------|-------------|-------------| | | | Rs. | Rs. | |-----|-----------------------------|-------------|-------------| | (a) | Amount spent on travel | 20, 231.50 | 20, 231.50 | | | between Delhi to Shimla | | | | | | | | | (b) | Amount spent on acquisition | 30, 000.00 | 30, 000.00 | | | of technical notes from | | | | | foreign collaborator etc. | | | | | for submission of technical | | | | | report | | | | | | | | | (c) | Amount spent on foreign | 60, 000.00 | 37, 920.00 | | | trips to U.S.A. | | | | | | | | | (d) | Amount spent on long | 20, 000.00 | 20, 000.00 | | | distance calls | | | |-----|-----------------------------|-------------|-------------|

    8. In the objections filed, the grounds of attack generally taken are (1) misconduct by the arbitrator on the pleas that the award is perverse and based on no evidence and the arbitrator was biased towards the respondent and (2) that there are mistakes apparent 'on the face of the record'.

    9. On the general and vague pleas of misconduct or award being perverse, no arguments were addressed by the ld. counsel. The alleged plea of bias was faintly touched with reference to observations in the award made while rejecting the contentions put forth on behalf of the respondent. I have gone through the award, which is detailed and well reasoned and do not find anything to show that the ld. arbitrator was biased against the respondent. Nothing substantial was pointed out in this behalf.

    10. The real challenge to award on Claim No. 1 is to the award of interest for the period prior to the reference. It was urged that there being no stipulation in the contract to pay interest, no interest could be allowed unless a notice demanding interest was issued; and in any case the interest awarded with yearly rests is without jurisdiction.

    11. An arbitrator has to act according to law. It is well settled that pre-reference interest can be awarded by an arbitrator only (i) if there is an agreement to pay interest (ii) if there is a usage on custom having the force of law or (iii) under substantive law like Section 61 of the Sales of goods Act etc. or if a notice of demand for interest as contemplated in Section 3(1)(b) of the Interest Act, 1978 is given in writing.

    12. Admittedly, there is no stipulation in the agreement for payment of interest. No usage or custom in support is relied on or is indicated. The ld. arbitrator has allowed interest saying :

    "In view of the fact that this amount of Rs. 15, 000 it withheld and utilised by the respondent-corporation right from the month of June, 1976, the reasonable rate of interest should be calculated on the footing of long term deposits. It should, in my view be calculated @ 12% per annum with yearly rests. I, therefore, held that the claimants are entitled to interest on this amount of Rs. 15, 000 at the rate of 12 p.c. with yearly rests from 13th November, 1979 till the date of decree, if any, passed by the court on the basis of this award. So far as the interest from the date of decree to the date of payment is concerned, it is for the court to adjudge the same under Section 29 of the Arbitration Act. The claimants have claimed interest at the rate of 1.5% per month which comes to 18% p.c. per year. This rate of interest is not justified. Moreover, the claimants claim of interest from 30th June, 1976 is also not justified for the reasons stated above. The claimant shall, however, be entitled to interest at the rate of 12 p.c. with yearly rests from 13.11.1979 till the date on which the court passes the decree. Issue No. 14 is accordingly disposed of."

    13. Obviously having found that a sum of Rs. 15, 000 was refundable by the respondent to the claimant, the ld. arbitrator on the basis of letter dated 13th November, 1979 has allowed interest under Section 3 of the Interest Act, 1978.

    14. The relevant portion of Section 3 of the Interest Act, 1978 is extracted below :

    "3. Power of court to allow interest. (1) In any proceedings for the recovery of any debt or damages or in any proceedings in which a claim for interest in respect of any debt or damages already paid is made, the court may, if it thinks fit, allow interest to the person entitled to the debt or damages or to the person making such claim, as the case may be, at a rate not exceeding the current rate of interest, for the whole or part of the following period, that is to say :

    (a) if the proceedings relate to a debt payable by virtue of a written instrument at a certain time, then, from the date when the debt is payable to the date of institution of the proceedings;

    (b) if the proceedings do not relate to any such debt, then, from the date mentioned in this regard in a written notice given by the person entitled or the person making the claim to the person liable that interest will be claimed, to the date of institution of the proceedings :

    Provided that where the amount of the debt or damages has been repaid before the institution of the proceedings, interest shall not be allowed under this section for the period after such repayment.

    (2) .....

    (3) Nothing in this section;

    (a) ......

    (b) ......

    (c) shall empower the court to award interest upon interest".

    15. Thus, Section 3(1)(b) of the Interest Act, 1978 enables the court, if it so thinks fit, to award interest to the person entitled to the debt or damages from the date mentioned in this regard in a notice given by the person making the claim for interest to the person liable to pay upto the date of institution of the proceedings for recovery. By including "an arbitrator" in the definition of "Court" in Section 2(a) of the said Act, the same power has been conferred on the arbitrator.

    16. As noted above, while awarding interest, the ld. arbitrator has treated claimant's letter dated 13th November, 1979 as one of demand of interest. It was argued that in the said letter there is no mention of any demand of interest but of "damages" and, as such interest could not have been awarded. The relevant portion of the said letter is extracted below :

    "Our amount of Rs. 15, 000 is still lying with you in trust for joint venture.

    All other expenses incurred by us are additional.

    Kindly note that we have supplied you expensive technology obtained by us from Pl-Squared in collaboration with Cladan of U.S.A. who are world leaders in the field. I have already sent you in original references on Pl-Squared from CTI corporation dated September 23, 1977 their Bank report of 28th December, 1977 their letter of 30th December, 1977 along with references from Indian Investment Centre - Mr. Bajaj.

    You will be fully responsible for paying all costs and damages if you fail to proceed with the Joint Venture"

    17. A plain reading of the portion side lined above, taken as notice for demand of interest by the ld. Arbitrator would show that it is not so. What is sought to be conveyed in plain words is a warning to the respondent/objector to proceed with the joint venture, failing which they were threatened to be made responsible to pay "all costs and damages". The damages sought for were in relation to the respondent not proceeding with the joint venture. The "damages" for not proceeding with the joint venture, resulting in a breach of contract, could be multifarious. It is difficult to read a demand of interest or confine or construe the word "damages" as used to mean demand for interest within the meaning of Section 3(1)(b) of the Interest Act, as done by the ld. Arbitrator. Nothing be contrary was pointed out.

    18. This, in my view, is a mistake apparent on the fact of the award. The award of interest by the ld. Arbitrator is, therefore, liable to be set aside. The award to that extent is severable and is accordingly set aside.

    19. In view of the fact that award of interest on Rs. 15, 000 has been held to be unjustified, there is no necessity of dealing with the alternative contention of the ld. counsel for the objector about the grant of interest vide yearly rests, even though, prima facie, in the light of Section 3(3)(c) of the Interest Act, the contention appears to be well founded.

    20. Now coming to the claim No. 2, as noted above, the ld. arbitrator has awarded a sum of Rs. 1, 08, 151.50 out of the total claims of Rs. 1, 30, 231.50.

    21. In so far as the award of these amounts is concerned the finding in that behalf has been arrived at on the merits of the case by the ld. arbitrator, after considering the entire material placed before him in the form of affidavit and documents and as such cannot be disturbed.

    22. Mr. P. K. Aggarwal, ld. counsel for the objectors, however, contends that there is an error apparent on the face of the award in that the ld. arbitrator has relied on the auditor's report, according to which the sum of Rs. 20, 325 was incurred on travelling between Delhi to Shimla for the period July, 1976 to December, 1979, whereas in the affidavit on behalf of the claimant it had been stated that trips to Shimla had been made upto March, 1979. He maintains that the amount debited under the said head for the period of March, 1979 is not payable but has been wrongly awarded by ld. arbitrator.

    23. I have glanced through the affidavit, the auditor's report and Ex. 20, a summary of expenses; including of trips between Delhi to Shimla, prepared by the counsel for the claimant under direction of the ld. arbitrator. The auditor's report is a consolidated one giving details of expenses incurred on account of travelling, conveyance and trunk calls made to U.S.A. on account of Ceremic Capacitors project, period July, 1976 to December, 1979." The monthly expenses incurred, included all those heads of expenses. The ld. arbitrator had got prepared break-up of the said expenses under the three separate heads, namely expenses incurred for travel between Delhi to Shimla; expenses for air tickets between India and U.S.A.; and the expenses in India for meetings in Electronics Deptt. and trunk calls made to U.S.A. and on correspondence. According to this tabulated statement, for the bills submitted during July 1976 to October, 1979 (there being no expenses under the first head for the month of November and December) the total expenses comes to Rs. 20, 325.10. It is not indicated that the amounts debited in any particular month was actually incurred in that month. May be that the expenses incurred in any month were debited on submission of bills subsequently. A perusal of the said statement and the auditor's report shows that after March 1979 travelling expenses between Shimla and Delhi are debited only in May, 1979 (Rs. 1582) and June, 1979 (Rs. 1707).

    24. There is no indication that expenses debited in these two months were actually incurred then or in the earlier months. Auditor's report having come on record and taken as the basis for tabulation, it was for the Objector, if they disputed the total expenses under the head, to have cross examined the claimant on the point to have it clarified, as is now alleged, that the expenses under the head debited in a particular month related to that very month. As such, averment made in para 15(c) of the affidavit of Mr. Ishtpal Singh, on behalf of the claimant, to the effect that he made 15 trips in pursuance of the contract and also incurred expenses for stay in Shimla during the period of three years between March, 1976 and the end of March, 1979 cannot be construed to mean that the expenses debited in the subsequent months were in fact not incurred and are fictiously entered. It cannot, therefore, be said that there is an error apparent on the face of the record to justify its being set aside or modified.

    25. The award of Rs. 30, 000 for the expenses incurred by the claimants for obtaining technical notes from the foreign collaborators is faintly assailed firstly, on the ground that no technical notes were submitted and, therefore, there was no justification for awarding the said amount and secondly, the claimant was entitled to only one set of fee of Rs. 30, 000 for submitting the feasibility report and that amount was admittedly paid.

    26. I have perused paras 22.3 to 22.10 and find that the ld. arbitrator has relied on various documents and given detailed reasons to arrive at the conclusion that the payment of Rs. 30, 000 for the first report of 1976 does not cover the costs of subsequent reports. The ld. arbitrator has also made a reference to a letter Ex. 16 whereby the claimant had submitted additional report on technology which, admittedly, was based on the technical information obtained by the claimant from Pl-Squared and GTI Associates, the foreign collaborators, as desired by the respondent. In this view of the matter I do not find any merit in the contention of the ld. counsel and hereby reject the same.

    27. Regarding award of Rs. 37, 920 out of the total claim of Rs. 60, 000 for the expenses incurred by the claimant on trips to United States and a further sum of Rs. 20, 000 for the expenses incurred on long distance calls by the claimant, respondent/objector's luke warm objection is that the award is not based on any evidence. In my view the contention of the objector is stated to be rejected. The ld. arbitrator while awarding the aforesaid amounts has relied on the auditor's report, which report, as noted above, has gone unrebutted. In my opinion no fault can be found in the award of the aforesaid amounts.

    28. Further more the arbitrator is a sole Judge on facts and law. His findings on merits cannot be reviewed, and this court, not sitting in appeal, cannot reappraise the evidence or go into the process of reasoning of the arbitrator nor can it look into the sufficiency or otherwise of the reasons given. It cannot be said that in the present case findings of fact of the ld. arbitrator on the merits of the case are perverse. I have, therefore, no hesitation in dismissing the objections on the award on claim No. 2.

    29. In the result, the award, except that of interest on claim No. 1 which has been set aside, is made rule of the court. The claimant will also be entitled to interest at the rate of 12% per annum, on the awarded amount, from the date of award till payment. A decree in terms thereof is passed. Parties will bear their own costs. A decree sheet shall be drawn up accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    International Engine... v. Himachal Pradesh Min...
    (May 8, 1992)